Decisions by Judge 2007 to Present

Judge Peter Eckerstrom
Please click on the case number in the "Decision" column to view the complete decision.
Case Number Case Title Role Decision
ASC CV-08-0224-PR  LAURA SEISINGER v. SCOTT SIEBEL, M.D.  Participating ASC CV-08-0224-PR
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 12-2604 violate the separation of powers doctrine in article III of the Arizona Constitution?
2 CA-CR 2008-0405  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS HUMBERTO SOTO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0405
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Does A.R.S. § 13-4033(C), a statute precluding defendants from directly appealing their convictions when their voluntary conduct in failing to appear has delayed sentencing, violate article II, § 24, of the Arizona Constitution, which provides criminal defendants “the right to appeal in all cases?” 2. Does a defendant waive his right to appeal by his voluntary conduct in failing to appear for sentencing in the absence of any direct advisory that his failure to appear would result in a loss of appeal rights?


2 CA-CR 2009-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID CHARLES HENRY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0035
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Do federal or Arizona prohibitions against ex post facto laws prevent the state from (1) applying its sex-offender registration and monitoring statutes, A.R.S. §§ 13-3821 to -3829, to a person convicted of armed rape in 1974 and (2) subsequently convicting him based on his failure to comply with a registration requirement created after 1974?


2 CA-CR 2011-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE FRANK McPHERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0126
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: (1) When the defendant possessed seven separate images of child pornography on one DVD, did the imposition of seven consecutive, ten-year terms of imprisonment violate constitutional or statutory prohibitions against multiple punishments?

(2) Did the mandatory consecutive sentences required here by A.R.S. § 13-705 amount to cruel and unusual punishment prohibited by article II, § 15 of the Arizona Constitution?

(3) Does § 13-705 violate constitutional guarantees of equal protection by punishing the possession of child pornography more severely than other dangerous crimes against children that are committed directly against children?


2 CA-CR 2011-0169  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NELSON E. NOTTINGHAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0169
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: What effect, if any, does Perry v. New Hampshire, ___U.S.___, 132 S. Ct. (2012), have in modifying Arizona Supreme Court jurisprudence addressing (1) whether a defendant is entitled to a Dessureault hearing when the suggestive pretrial identification procedure occurs at a court proceeding and therefore is not arranged by police, and (2) whether a defendant remains entitled to an identification instruction under such circumstances even if not entitled to a Dessureault hearing?


2 CA-CR 2012-0006  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADY WHITMAN JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0006
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Is a criminal defendant’s notice of appeal timely if it is filed within twenty days of the filing of the minute entry that contains the judgment and sentence? 2) When determining the constitutionality of a traffic stop, may a court consider any observed traffic violation as a basis for the stop, or may the court instead consider only those violations that were cited or relied upon by the police officer who performed the stop?


2 CA-CR 2012-0305  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN BETZA VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0305
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in denying Vasquez’s motion to sever his trial from that of his codefendant? 2) Did the trial court err in admitting statements made by a non-testifying co-defendant, thereby violating the Confrontation Clause?


2 CA-CV 2013-0075  IN RE ESTATE OF RICHARD R. SNURE  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0075
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Was Garbareno’s right to notice under the Fourteenth Amendment violated when the estate mailed a notice of claim denial to Garbareno by certified mail, the notice was returned as undeliverable, and the estate took no further steps to notify Garbareno? 2) Did the estate’s sending of the notice by certified mail fulfill the requirements of A.R.S. § 14-3806(A)? 3) If the notice sent by the estate was deficient for any of these reasons, what is Garbareno’s remedy?


2 CA-CR 2008-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL HERRERA III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0273
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Whether this court erred in remanding this matter to the trial court for the limited purpose of determining the admissibility of other-act evidence under Rule 404(c), Ariz. R. Evid.

2) Whether, following remand, the trial court abused its discretion in finding the other-act evidence admissible to establish an aberrant sexual propensity under Rule 404(c), Ariz. R. Evid.

3) Whether the trial court fundamentally erred in giving an instruction that explained the use of sexual propensity evidence.

4) Whether the trial court abused its discretion in precluding evidence of the victim’s prior sexual conduct pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-1421.

5) Whether the state’s expert witness’s testimony improperly invaded the province of the jury and improperly vouched for the victim, denying Herrera a fair trial.


2 CA-CR 2008-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEAN WILLIAM ZINSMEYER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0369
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: In defendant’s appeal from his convictions and sentences for theft of a means of transportation and third-degree burglary, both stemming from his theft of a truck: 1) Did the trial court err in denying his motion to suppress statements he had made to investigating officers after he had stated “I think I need a lawyer” and had asked officers if he needed a lawyer? 2) Did the prosecutor commit misconduct during opening statement and closing argument by commenting about the quality of the police department’s investigation? 3) When the state concedes the trial court relied on two improper aggravating factors at sentencing and the only proper aggravating factor the court fell under the catch-all provision in former A.R.S. § 13-702(C)(24), did the imposition of an aggravated sentence violate the rule announced in State v. Schmidt, 220 Ariz. 563, 208 P.3d 214 (2009)? 4) Does unlawful entry into a truck not used or adapted for residential purposes constitute third-degree burglary under A.R.S. § 13-1506? 5) Is § 13-1506 unconstitutionally vague? 6) Did the trial court err at sentencing in entering a premature criminal restitution order requiring defendant to pay attorney fees and an indigent assessment fee?


2 CA-CR 2012-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HEULON COLSTON BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0124
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: (1) When the defendant made both pre- and post-arrest statements while hospitalized and on medication, did the trial court err by refusing to suppress those statements on either Fifth or Sixth Amendment grounds?

(2) Did the court err by refusing to provide the jury with duress, “voluntary act,” and “missing witness” instructions?

(3) Was the defendant’s conviction under Arizona’s felony-murder statute unconstitutional and in violation of due process because neither he nor the other participants in the home invasion were directly involved in the killing that occurred?


2 CA-CR 2013-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD JOHN BRUGGEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0041
** Constitutionality decision
2 CA-CR 2013-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESGARDO JAVIER NEVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0065
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion to suppress evidence based on a police stop of the defendant’s vehicle for lack of a license plate when the officer failed to see a properly displayed temporary license until he had approached the vehicle on foot, at which point he observed evidence of driving under the influence? Did police violate the defendant’s right to counsel by denying his request for an attorney to read to him a warrant they had obtained to draw his blood?


2 CA-CR 2013-0102-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG MICHAEL STEFANOVICH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0102-PR
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Do previous convictions for driving under the influence within the previous eighty-four months qualify under A.R.S. § 28-1383(A)(2) when those convictions fell outside the sixty-month window in effect at the time of the defendant’s previous convictions and that sixty-month window had elapsed before the statutory amendment changing the window from sixty months to eighty-four months?

2. Did the trial court err in rejecting defendant’s post-conviction-relief claim that his decision to admit previous convictions was not voluntary because he allegedly had not been informed that admitting his previous convictions could result in an enhanced prison term and that the state was required to prove the fact of those convictions?


2 CA-CR 2013-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID J. WALLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0315
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in denying defendant’s motion to suppress his pretrial statements made prior to and following Miranda advisements on a theory the deputies had conducted a two-stage custodial interrogation prohibited under Missouri v. Seibert, 542 U.S. 600 (2004)?

2. Was it reversible error for the trial court to instruct the jury that it was not required to reach a unanimous verdict on which form of assault, as described by A.R.S. § 13-1203, led to its finding defendant guilty of aggravated assault pursuant to A.R.S. § 13–1204(A)(2)?


2 CA-CV 2007-0143  CAIN; BAHR; HOLCOMB; AZ ASSOC. OF SCHOOL BUSINESS OFFICIALS; ...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0143
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Do the Arizona Scholarship for Pupils with Disabilities Statute and the Arizona Displaced Pupils Grant Statute violate the Arizona Constitution by providing for state funds to be applied to the cost of tuition and fees for certain categories of students at private, sectarian and nonsectarian, primary and secondary schools at the direction of the students' legal guardians?


2 CA-CV 2011-0080  BAKER v. UNIVERSITY PHYSICIANS HEALTHCARE, WITTMAN, ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0080
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding A.R.S. § 12-2604 did not permit a specialist in internal medicine with subspecialties in oncology and hematology to testify as to the standard of care for a specialist in pediatrics with a subspecialty in pediatric hematology/oncology? If not, does § 12-2604 violate the Anti-Abrogation, Equal Protection, or Due Process clauses of the Arizona Constitution?


2 CA-CV 2011-0088  DOWNING v. DOWNING  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0088
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining A.R.S. § 25-530 precluded it from including appellee’s disability benefits, awarded pursuant to U.S.C. title 38, chapter 11, in its calculation of appellant’s spousal maintenance award? Does A.R.S. § 25-530 violate the Equal Protection clause?


2 CA-IC 2006-0025  MONT POLANCO v. ICA; PIMA COUNTY   Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0025
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does the requirement of A.R.S. § 23-1061(H) that a workers’ compensation claim “shall not be reopened because of increased subjective pain if the pain is not accompanied by a change in objective physical findings” violate article XVIII, § 8 of the Arizona Constitution by limiting the means by which an employee can meet the obligation to prove a “new, additional or previously undiscovered temporary or permanent condition” arose out of and in the course of employment?


2 CA-CR 2010-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID JAMES YONKMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0338
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in refusing to suppress the defendant’s statements to police? 2. Did the court err in admitting other-act evidence of which the defendant had been charged and acquitted? And, if the evidence had been admitted properly, was the defendant entitled to inform the jury of the acquittal? 3. Was it error to admit prior consistent statements of the victim and an alleged former victim when there was no allegation the statements had been made before the motive to fabricate arose? If error, was it harmless because the statements were contained in the victims’ testimony?


2 CA-CR 2010-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES DARRELL JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0380
Issues Summary: 1. Was there sufficient evidence supporting the jury’s finding the murder was committed in an especially cruel, heinous, or depraved manner? 2. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in precluding Johnson from presenting diminished capacity evidence pursuant to State v. Mott, 187 Ariz. 536, 931 P.2d 1046 (1997), and A.R.S. § 13-502, when that evidence was relevant to rebut the state’s allegation of aggravating factors?


2 CA-CR 2011-0214  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME RENE ESPINOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0214
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court abused its discretion in dismissing with prejudice an indictment alleging defendant’s failure to register as a sex offender on the ground that the order first requiring him to register had been void.


2 CA-CR 2011-0244  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY ALAN NUCKOLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0244
Issues Summary: When a trial court has imposed a reasonable deadline for submitting restitution requests and supporting documentation, and when a crime victim subsequently fails to comply with this deadline, may the court then deny the victim’s request based on its untimeliness?


2 CA-CR 2011-0252-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0252-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in dismissing with prejudice defendant’s second proceeding for post-conviction relief when counsel failed to timely file a petition through no fault of the defendant?


2 CA-CR 2011-0264  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROHAN LIVINGSTON BUTLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0264
Issues Summary: 1. Did sufficient evidence exist to convict the defendant of possessing a deadly weapon during a felony drug offense? 2. When a duplicitous indictment alleges three weapons offenses in one count, and when the defendant neither objects to the indictment before trial nor seeks any curative measures during trial, does the defendant suffer prejudice entitling him to relief under fundamental error review? 3. Did the trial court err by admitting a document from an out-of-state sheriff’s department showing the defendant had possessed a large amount of currency within the dates of his alleged drug-trafficking conspiracy? 4. Does an appeal rejecting a codefendant’s argument under Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), establish the law of the case for a defendant bringing a subsequent appeal? If not, has the appellant here established a Batson violation?


2 CA-CR 2011-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM PETER MORAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0346
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in finding reasonable suspicion for the defendant’s traffic stop or probable cause for his arrest for suspected driving under the influence of an intoxicant (DUI)? (2) Did the defendant’s two DUI convictions from Nevada for offenses committed in 2005 support his convictions for aggravated DUI pursuant to A.R.S. § 28-1383(A)(2)?


2 CA-CR 2012-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUILLERMO E. COONEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0061
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in admitting evidence of time spent incarcerated to prove Cooney’s prior DUI convictions occurred within the statutory time period necessary to establish aggravated DUI? 2) Did the use of Cooney’s two prior DUI convictions as elements of aggravated DUI violate double jeopardy?


2 CA-CR 2012-0094  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDALL SHANNON GRAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0094
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in denying appellant’s motion for a judgment of acquittal in reliance on the admissions of appellant’s counsel during opening statements?


2 CA-CR 2012-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY CONNUE SERRANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0215
Issues Summary: (1) Was the trial court authorized to enter a discretionary sex offender registration order more than two weeks after pronouncing the defendant’s judgment and sentence? (2) Does this court have jurisdiction over the defendant’s appeal?


2 CA-CR 2012-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL FRANCISCO INZUNZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0273
Issues Summary: (1) Did the emergency aid exception justify the warrantless entry into and search of the defendant’s apartment where a missing, intellectually disabled adult was last seen? (2) Did the trial court err in precluding evidence of a prior sexual assault committed against the victim? (3) Did the defendant’s prior conviction in Washington for assault with a deadly weapon support the enhanced sentences imposed here?


2 CA-CR 2012-0358  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHILOE DOMINIQUE ESPINOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0358
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in barring the retrial of the defendant for aggravated robbery when a previous jury had convicted her of an improper lesser-included offense, had rendered no verdict on the aggravated robbery count, and the state had not sought the declaration of a mistrial on that count?


2 CA-CR 2012-0405  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CHARLES GLISSENDORF  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0405
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion to dismiss a child molestation charge filed ten years after the victim first reported the offense to the police? (2) Was the defendant entitled to a jury instruction derived from State v. Willits, 96 Ariz. 184, 393 P.2d 274 (1964), due to the state’s destruction of a video recording that documented the victim’s initial allegation of child molestation? (3) Did the trial court commit reversible error in admitting evidence pursuant to Rule 404(c), Ariz. R. Evid., to show the defendant had an aberrant sexual propensity to commit the charged offenses?


2 CA-CR 2012-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARVIN WHIT WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0411
Issues Summary: Does sufficient evidence support the defendant’s conviction for attempted robbery, given that he was acquitted of other related charges?


2 CA-CR 2012-0479  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYNERIAL RAY KINDRED  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0479
Issues Summary: 1) Does inserting a pry bar partially into a door jamb constitute “entry” as defined by A.R.S. § 13-1501(3) for the purpose of determining whether defendant committed second-degree burglary? 2) When the defendant forced entry into an apartment, and there was some evidence suggesting the apartment was visibly empty and unoccupied, was there sufficient evidence the defendant intended to commit a felony upon entry?


2 CA-CR 2012-0505  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS J. TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0505
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in using a verdict form that treated manslaughter upon sudden quarrel or heat of passion as a lesser-included offense of second-degree murder? 2) Did the trial court err in finding the presence of a child as an aggravating factor?


2 CA-CR 2012-0513  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND ANTHONY HALL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0513
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in concluding that a set-aside of a conviction pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-907 necessarily includes the restoration of a person’s right to possession of firearms?


2 CA-CR 2013-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR CASTILLO MENDOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0083
Issues Summary: 1) Did sufficient evidence support the defendant’s conviction for child molestation when the facts established that he “humped” the victim when they were both clothed, and the victim was under a blanket and did not feel the defendant’s genitals? 2) Did the trial court err in instructing the jury on (a) the elements of child molestation or (b) the defense of lack of sexual motivation?


2 CA-CR 2013-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VAUGHN MILES DENZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0120-PR
Issues Summary: 1) Did counsel render ineffective assistance by failing to consult with a medical expert when medical causation was central to liability? 2) Did the trial court err in finding precluded Denz's claim of actual innocence?


2 CA-CR 2013-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONE ALEX GILL  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0156
Issues Summary: When the defendant admitted to investigating police officers that he had been drinking and driving the truck involved in the recent accident near his house, did the doctrine of corpus delicti prevent him from being convicted of aggravated driving under the influence or criminal damage?


2 CA-CR 2013-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REUBEN RENEE COTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0185
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in conducting a supplemental closing argument in the defendant’s absence without a personal waiver of his right to be present? 2. Did the court err in entering a criminal restitution order at sentencing for (a) the unpaid balance of the court-ordered restitution and (b) other fees and assessments?


2 CA-CR 2013-0507  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR JACQUES ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0507
2 CA-CV 2011-0012  SANTEE v. MESA AIRLINES, INC.; AMERICA WEST AIRLINES, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0012
Issues Summary: Is a notice of appeal premature and invalid when it is filed before a trial court rules on a motion for sanctions made pursuant to Rule 68(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P.?


2 CA-CV 2011-0020  In re the ESTATE OF FRANCES B. LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0020
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion under Rules 16(a) and (f), Ariz. R. Civ. P., in sanctioning an out-of-state appellant—specifically, in dismissing his complaint, entering a default judgment against him, and setting aside his objection to the informal probate of a will—on the grounds that (1) the appellant failed to personally attend a pretrial conference and (2) the appellant failed to file a timely reply to appellees’ counterclaims?


2 CA-CV 2011-0027  RICHARD ANDERSON v. VALLEY UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT #22  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0027
Issues Summary: May a teacher appeal a disciplinary decision of a school district’s governing board beyond the superior court?


2 CA-CV 2011-0134  PATTERSON v. THE ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0134
2 CA-CV 2012-0060  MAHAR v. ACUNA, II  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0060
Issues Summary: In this protective order proceeding, did the trial court abuse its discretion by prohibiting the defendant from possessing firearms in the absence of any showing that he posed a threat to the physical safety of the plaintiff or any other person?


2 CA-CV 2012-0063  COHEN v. LOVITT & TOUCHE, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0063
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in determining Arizona public policy categorically bars insurance coverage of restitutionary payments?

2. Did the trial court err in determining payments made in the settlement of a class action were restitutionary in nature?


2 CA-CV 2012-0090  CHAMPLIN; STOPINSKI, SKIPTON AND ASSOC. v. BANK OF AMERICA  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0090
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by refusing to set aside the entry of default, pursuant to Rule 55(c), Ariz. R. Civ. P., even if a copy of the application for the entry of default had not been mailed in a timely fashion?


2 CA-CV 2012-0152  WYCKOFF v. MOGOLLON HEALTH ALLIANCE  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0152
Issues Summary: 1. Does this court have jurisdiction to consider the trial court’s vacation of a default judgment? 2. Did plaintiff’s failure to timely serve her complaint cause her action to abate? 3. Did the trial court err in finding the default judgment was void, rather than voidable? 4. Under the discovery rule, when does a cause of action for a mold related illness accrue?


2 CA-CV 2013-0008  PINAL COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE v. PINAL COUNTY EMPLOYEE MERIT COMMISSION; JAMES  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0008
2 CA-CV 2013-0053  TIMMONS v. ROSS DRESS FOR LESS, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0053
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in granting defendant retail store's motion for summary judgment on the basis that it was not the owner or controller of the premises where plaintiff fell? 2) Did the trial court err in denying plaintiff's motion to amend her complaint?


2 CA-CV 2013-0059  LIBBY v. LICHTE  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0059
2 CA-CV 2013-0089  STANT v. CITY OF MARICOPA EMPLOYEE MERIT BOARD, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0089
Issues Summary: 1. Does this court have jurisdiction over a discharged law enforcement officer’s appeal under A.R.S. § 38-1004 from the decision of a city or its merit board? 2. If so, does the record here support the decision of the city or board?


2 CA-CV 2013-0105  LOPEZ v. FOOD CITY  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0105
Issues Summary: Should this court apply Rule 9(b)(2)(B) of the amended Rules of Civil Appellate Procedure, effective as of January 1, 2014, to our consideration of jurisdiction over this appeal?


2 CA-CV 2013-0113  MUNGER CHADWICK v. FARWEST DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF THE SOUTHWEST, LLC, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0113
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding that a law firm was eligible for an award of attorney fees when representing itself?


2 CA-CV 2013-0143  SVENDSEN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0143
Issues Summary: (1) When the suspension of a driver’s license has been appealed to the superior court pursuant to our implied consent statute, A.R.S. § 28-1321, does the Arizona Department of Transportation have a statutory right to appeal the superior court’s decision? (2) If so, did the administrative law judge err in sustaining the suspension here?


2 CA-CV 2013-0145  CANYON COMMUNITY BANK v. ALDERSON, ALDERSON FAMILY TRUST  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0145
2 CA-CV 2014-0019  MYRICK v. MALONEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2014-0019
Issues Summary: (1) In this domestic-relations proceeding, did the trial court abuse its discretion by declining to award the appellant her attorney fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-324(A), given the significant disparity in the parties’ incomes? (2) Are attorney fees available in a final judgment pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-403.08?


2 CA-IC 2011-0014  GARY D. HACKWORTH v. ATLAS COPCO NORTH AMERICA and LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE GROUP  Author 2 CA-IC 2011-0014
Issues Summary: When an injured worker’s claim for compensation raises a question of medical causation, is a physician’s testimony regarding the possibility of idiopathic causes sufficient to create a conflict in the evidence and rebut the testimony of another physician establishing industrial causation to a reasonable medical probability?


2 CA-IC 2013-0005  PALOMINAS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DIST. & AZ SCHOOL ALLIANCE v. SPECIAL FUND & MARTHA M. VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-IC 2013-0005
2 CA-SA 2012-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABIGAIL ALETA ALLIN  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0034
2 CA-SA 2012-0060  ELIZABETH W. v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0060
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge have the authority to order a patient undergoing involuntary, court-ordered treatment to submit to drug testing when the patient admitted she had used marijuana in violation of her treatment plan?


2 CA-SA 2012-0076  CALISTO MARIKO WELLS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0076
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in ordering a defendant to disclose to the state recordings of interviews with police witnesses, conducted without the prosecutor's knowledge, when he intended to use the material solely for impeachment?


2 CA-SA 2013-0053  STEVEN LANE FULLER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2013-0053
Issues Summary: 1. Did the state violate the requirement in A.R.S. § 36-3706 that a person alleged to be an SVP must have a trial within 120 days?

2. If the requirement was violated, was Fuller sufficiently prejudiced by the violation to require dismissal of the SVP proceeding?


2 CA-SA 2014-0015  KEENAN REED-KALIHER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2014-0015
Issues Summary: When the petitioner was on probation for possession of a narcotic drug for sale, did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying his motion to modify the terms of that probation to allow him to use marijuana pursuant to Arizona's Medical Marijuana Act?


2 CA-CR 2006-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIGINIO AGUILAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0226
Issues Summary: Whether the state’s request to use an undisclosed scientific report and to have an undisclosed witness testify during Aguilar’s first trial created manifest necessity requiring a mistrial, so that double jeopardy did not bar his retrial.


2 CA-CR 2010-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE RAYMOND ALVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0310
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by excluding third-party culpability evidence concerning a landscaper present in the yard prior to the burglary when the defendant’s DNA was found in the residence after the burglary?


2 CA-CR 2011-0028  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEE PALMER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0028
Issues Summary: Was testimony regarding a question about the location of defendant’s backpack, asked by an unavailable witness, inadmissible hearsay?


2 CA-CR 2011-0076  STATE OF ARIZONA v. XAVIER HIPOLITO ESTRELLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0076
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by denying a motion to suppress evidence obtained from a search of a vehicle driven by Estrella and owned by his employer, following the warrantless placement and monitoring of a GPS tracking device on the vehicle?


2 CA-CR 2011-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CURTIS T. BUNTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0164
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 13-4505 require a trial court to permit the state's expert to conduct an additional examination of a defendant in a competency proceeding?


2 CA-CR 2011-0384  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARAMA AZIZI MWANDISHI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0384
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by failing to grant the defendant’s motion for a judgment of acquittal in which he argued the state presented evidence only that he had caused a “typical fracture,” asserting that is not sufficient proof of serious physical injury to permit a finding of aggravated assault pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 13-1204(A)(1) and 13-105(39)?


2 CA-CR 2012-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REY DAVID VILLEGAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0200-PR
Issues Summary: Where the state, the court, and defendant all erroneously believed he would be eligible for earned release credits against a prison term imposed at sentencing, as reflected in his plea agreement, did the trial court abuse its discretion in finding the plea voluntary, notwithstanding the error, or in fashioning resentencing relief, pursuant to Rule 32, Ariz. R. Crim. P., designed to afford defendant “the benefit of his plea bargain as he understood it”?


2 CA-CR 2012-0296-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE DEJESUS VILLEGAS-ROJAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0296-PR
Issues Summary: Is the name or exact identity of the victim a necessary element of endangerment, as set forth in A.R.S. § 13-1201(A)?


2 CA-CR 2012-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELINO PAOLO BUCCHERI-BIANCA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0315
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err by granting the state’s motion to preclude evidence that a victim had applied for a “U-Visa,” issued to noncitizen victims of certain crimes that provides temporary authorization to enter and remain in the United States? 2. Did the prosecutor commit misconduct during his closing argument by asserting repeatedly that the victims had no motive to lie, despite alleged evidence of motive which the prosecution successfully had moved the trial court to exclude? 3. Did the trial court err by denying defendant’s motion to preclude generalized expert testimony regarding child sex abuse victims, not rooted in the facts of the case, on grounds her expertise was based on novel scientific theories, was unhelpful to the trier of fact, and impermissibly bolstered the credibility of the victims?


2 CA-CR 2012-0377  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO PENA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0377
Issues Summary: Did the state present sufficient evidence that each of the victim’s separately charged injuries caused “temporary but substantial disfigurement” to support the defendant’s multiple convictions for aggravated assault under A.R.S. § 13-1204(A)(3)?


2 CA-CR 2013-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERONICA SANCHEZ-EQUIHUA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0003
Issues Summary: Was defendant's constitutional right to compulsory process violated when: her codefendants signed plea agreements stating they had no exculpatory information, the state acknowledged it might seek to withdraw the codefendants' plea agreements if they provided exculpatory testimony, and the codefendants then refused to testify based on a fear of reinstated charges? Did the trial court err by failing to compel the codefendants' testimony?


2 CA-CR 2013-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO ANDRES ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0157
2 CA-CR 2013-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PIERRE BANDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0199-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining defendant had waived a statute of limitations defense by pleading guilty and in rejecting defendant’s claim counsel had been ineffective in failing to raise that defense prior to the guilty plea?


2 CA-CR 2013-0233-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND JOHN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0233-PR
Issues Summary: Does the federal Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 16901-16962, preempt Arizona’s jurisdiction to enforce state registration requirements on tribal lands?

Did the trial court err in finding the state could impose upon a member of the Navajo Nation a duty to register as a sex offender based on his residence on tribal land in Arizona?


2 CA-CR 2014-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE ROY VERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0154-PR
Issues Summary: Whether a trial court’s order granting relief, pursuant to Miller v. Alabama, ___ U.S. ___, 132 S. Ct. 2455 (2012), to a juvenile sentenced to life imprisonment without release for twenty five-years, should be vacated in light of the legislature’s recent action affording such juveniles an opportunity for parole.


2 CA-CV 2011-0072  IN RE THE ESTATE OF FRED N. KIRKES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0072
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by invalidating a beneficiary designation of more than fifty percent of an individual retirement account, reasoning that appellee was entitled to fifty percent as her share of community property?


2 CA-CV 2011-0108  KAZ CONSTRUCTION, INC v. SIERRA COBRE ESTATES, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0108
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining a trust beneficiary was without authority to execute a deed of trust conveying the trust res to appellants and, therefore, it was invalid? Did the court err in determining further that appellee had a valid first-position mechanic’s lien on the property?


2 CA-CV 2011-0126  FETTERS v. STEWART TITLE & TRUST OF PHOENIX, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0126
2 CA-CV 2011-0140  GRUBB v. DO IT BEST CORPORATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0140
Issues Summary: Does a cooperative qualify as a seller for purposes of product liability when a member store ordered the product directly from the vendor in a drop-ship order, but the vendor sent the bill to the cooperative?


2 CA-CV 2011-0166  CATALINA FOOTHILLS UNIF. SCH. DISTR. NO. 16 v. LA PALOMA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0166
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in certifying a “partial judgment” for appeal pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., when the partial judgment does not dispose of any claim or party? If so, does this court nevertheless have jurisdiction over the appeal from that partial judgment, which incorporates an order of immediate possession, as an interlocutory judgment under A.R.S. § 12-2101(A)(6)?


2 CA-CV 2011-0193  TA ROBINSON EQUIPMENT CO. v. JCB, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0193
2 CA-CV 2011-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COOPERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0197
Issues Summary: In a prosecution for both driving under the influence of an intoxicating liquor pursuant to A.R.S. § 28-1381(A)(1) and for driving with an alcohol concentration of .08 or more pursuant to § 28-1381(A)(2): (1) Whether a presumption of intoxication under § 28-1381(G) is raised in an (A)(1) case whenever the state introduces evidence of breath-test results or only when the state requests a jury instruction regarding the presumption; (2) Whether Guthrie v. Jones, 202 Ariz. 273, 43 P.3d 601 (App. 2002), or Rule 402, Ariz. R. Evid., requires a defendant to introduce evidence of his own partition ratio in an (A)(1) case to challenge the results of a breath test, or whether it is sufficient to show the variability of partition ratios in the population generally; (3) Whether evidence of certain physiological variables to challenge breath-test results—breathing patterns, hematocrit, and breath or body temperature—are relevant and admissible in both (A)(1) and (A)(2) cases.


2 CA-CV 2012-0040  MM&A PRODUCTIONS, L.L.C. V. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION, YAVAPAI-APACHE NATIONS CLIFF CASTLE CASINO, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0040
2 CA-CV 2012-0093  ARIZONA MEDICAL BUILDINGS, LLC, TRUITT v. CHASM INVESTMENTS, LLC, TRUITT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0093
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in determining only one of the quitclaim deeds at issue effectively transferred property?

2) Did the trial court err in determining a contract did not exist for the sale of appellant’s medical practice?

3) Did the trial court err in not granting judgment as a matter of law pursuant to Rule 50, Ariz. R. Civ. P., or vacating the verdict pursuant to Rule 59(a)(8), Ariz. R. Civ. P., on appellant’s wrongful filing of a lis pendens claim?

4) Did the trial court give an erroneous jury instruction on appellant’s lis pendens claim?

5) Did the trial court err in denying appellant attorney fees pursuant to contract or A.R.S. § 12-341.01?

6) Did the trial court abuse its discretion by not admitting the affidavits of a witness offered for impeachment?

7) Did the trial court err by awarding damages on appellee’s quiet title claims, and by quieting title to personal property?

8) Did the trial court abuse its discretion by not offsetting appellant’s costs of maintaining the real property against appellee’s award of damages?

9) Did the trial court err in denying appellee attorney fees pursuant to contract or § 12-341.01?


2 CA-CV 2012-0114  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF KASSA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0114
Issues Summary: Is a special order after judgment sufficient to vest the Court of Appeals with jurisdiction when it does not resolve all issues raised in the post-decree petition or contain certification of finality pursuant to Rule 78(B), Ariz. R. Fam. Law P.?


2 CA-CV 2012-0167  JOHNSON, JR., dba BUTCH JOHNSON FARMS v. BINKLEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0167
2 CA-CV 2012-0175  GLOBAL MUSIC SUPPLY, LLC v. PRESTINI INTERNATIONAL, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0175
2 CA-CV 2013-0023  DELONG v. MERRILL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0023
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred by failing to apply the standards of Rule 36(c), Ariz. R. Civ. P., to a party’s motion to file late responses to requests for admission and by granting summary judgment as a sanction for the party’s failure to provide timely responses.


2 CA-CV 2013-0024  YANNI, THOMPSON, GUNDERSON, SAYEGH v. TUCKER PLUMBING, INC., BREWER ENTERPRISES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0024
Issues Summary: Are subcontractors of new home construction subject to suit by homeowners for breach of the implied warranty of workmanship and habitability absent contractual privity with the homeowners?


2 CA-CV 2013-0051  MM&A PRODUCTIONS, LLC v. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0051
Issues Summary: Can the doctrine of apparent authority be applied in a contract action to conclude an Indian Nation’s employee waived the Nation’s sovereign immunity?

Did the trial court err by not allowing further discovery or an evidentiary hearing before ruling it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over appellant’s contract action?


2 CA-CV 2013-0065  PI'IKEA, LLC v. WILLIAMSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0065
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment for plaintiff who had brought an action on a guarantee when the defendant guarantors asserted the lender had a duty to mitigate its damages by permitting a trustee sale to occur, or to take some other recourse, years earlier when the subject property still had sufficient value to cover the debt?

2. Did the guarantors' express waiver of protections under A.R.S. § 47-3605 and "any similar or analogous other statutory or common law" duty preclude their defense that the lender had a duty to mitigate damages before the property lost significant value?


2 CA-CV 2013-0069  SOUTHWEST NON-PROFIT HOUSING CORPORATION v. NOWAK, KNIFFEN, MARTELL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0069
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting defendant appraiser’s motion to dismiss a negligence claim based on lack of duty to plaintiff property seller who claimed a negligently prepared appraisal resulted in a lower sale price for its property?

2. In two similar, consolidated cases, did the trial court err by granting defendant appraisers’ motions for summary judgment based on lack of duty to, and reliance by, plaintiff property seller?


2 CA-CV 2013-0100  POTTERS CLAY REALTY, ET AL. v. KUMMER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0100
2 CA-CV 2014-0001  KONDAUR CAPITAL CORP. v. WHITE; BABEU  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0001
Issues Summary: On appeal from a declaratory judgment action concerning the procurement and enforcement of writs of restitution:

1) Does the Appellant have standing to seek appellate review of issues that were resolved in its favor?

2) Does any exception to the mootness doctrine apply to Appellant’s claims?


2 CA-CV 2014-0029  BOYLE v. FORD MOTOR COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0029
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by imposing sanctions under Rule 68, Ariz. R. Civ. P., when the offer of judgment provided for dismissal of all claims with prejudice, rather than entry of judgment, but the offerees failed to object to the form of offer until after the jury entered its verdict and sanctions were imposed?


2 CA-IC 2013-0001  JULIE MUNOZ v. SONIC RESTAURANTS #10 and HARTFORD ACCIDENT & INDEMNITY/GALLAGHER BASSETT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0001
Issues Summary: Did the ALJ properly conclude that Munoz’s concurrent earnings from her horse training business must be excluded from her average monthly wage calculation because her business was not covered employment under the Workers’ Compensation Act?


2 CA-IC 2013-0015  JOHAHNS B. ANDERSON v. PINNACLE PEAK and SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0015
2 CA-JV 2013-0029  BENNIGNO R. v. ADES, S.R. and L.R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0029
Issues Summary: (1) Does the principle of res judicata bar the Arizona Department of Economic Security (ADES) from re-litigating in a proceeding on its second motion to terminate a parent’s rights, the issue of whether termination of the parent’s rights was in a child’s best interest, after the court determined, following a hearing on ADES’s first motion to terminate the parent’s rights, that ADES had not sustained its burden of establishing best interests? Did the juvenile court err in this case by denying the appellant father’s motion for summary judgment based on res judicata under such circumstances?

(2) Did the appellant father waive the right to question in a severance proceeding the reasonableness and propriety of services provided by ADES throughout the dependency, when the father did not request additional services during that time or object to the juvenile court’s periodic reasonable-efforts findings?

(3) Waiver notwithstanding, does the record support the juvenile court’s determination that ADES had made a diligent effort to provide reunification services, and that termination of the father’s rights was in the children’s best interests?


2 CA-SA 2011-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMENEZ; LLINAS; MEDINA; ROGERS; SIRNIO; TANNER   Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0098
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by precluding the state from introducing the results of blood alcohol testing in a DUI case after the state failed to produce the results by the time of a rescheduled case management conference?


2 CA-SA 2012-0006  SUSAN SCHEERER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0006
Issues Summary: In granting the state relief in its appeal from a sentence imposed on petitioner in justice court, did the respondent judge err by ordering that no credit be given against a jail term ordered on resentencing for any period of time appellant spent in an unauthorized home detention program as ordered by the justice court?


2 CA-SA 2012-0032  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEL AGUSTIN LOPEZ   Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0032
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in concluding defendant’s previous conviction for aggravated assault on a police officer was not, based on the elements of the offense, necessarily a violent crime and therefore that the defendant was eligible for probation under A.R.S. § 13-901.01?


2 CA-SA 2012-0044  MIKEL LO, M.D. and MIKEL W. LO, M.D, INC. v. MILLS  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0044
Issues Summary: In plaintiff’s medical malpractice action, did the respondent judge err in determining that plaintiff’s designated standard-of-care expert met the requirements of A.R.S. § 12-2604(A)(1)?


2 CA-SA 2012-0052  ARTURO DURAZO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0052
2 CA-SA 2012-0070  ROOSEVELT ARTHUR WILLIAMS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0070
Issues Summary: After a hearing conducted in accordance with A.R.S. § 13-753(G), did the respondent judge err or abuse his discretion in ruling that Williams had failed to establish, by clear and convincing evidence, an intellectual disability that renders him ineligible for the death penalty in his pending prosecution for murder?


2 CA-SA 2013-0057  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEBBIE LYNN COPELAND  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0057
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse her discretion in granting a motion to set aside a conviction for attempted aggravated assault, when A.R.S. § 13-907(D) precludes such relief for convictions “[i]nvolving a dangerous offense” as defined in A.R.S. § 13-105(13)?


2 CA-CR 2002-0153  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN WAYNE TALMADGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2002-0153
2 CA-CR 2002-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AUDRA JEAN TALMADGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2002-0155
2 CA-CR 2004-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MALIK CORNELL PRIOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2004-0059
2 CA-CR 2005-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LUGO PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0083
2 CA-CR 2005-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK FILLMORE CHISHOLM  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0139
2 CA-CR 2005-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREG CANTUA ORTEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0233
2 CA-CR 2005-0272  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EDWARD COX  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0272
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in refusing to give defendant’s requested jury instruction defining prohibited possession even though an identical instruction had been approved in dicta in State v. Tyler, 149 Ariz. 312, 316-17, 718 P.2d 214, 218-19 (App. 1986)?


2 CA-CR 2005-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MANUEL BRACAMONTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0275
2 CA-CR 2005-0333  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NEREA GOITI ANDICOECHEA  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0333
2 CA-CR 2005-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMBER LYNN TRUDELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0371
2 CA-CR 2005-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACKIE EUGENE DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0379
2 CA-CR 2005-0433  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN BRADLEY RADY  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0433
2 CA-CR 2006-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEARNED O'NEIL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0042
2 CA-CR 2006-0053  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS VALENZUELA CARRILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0053
2 CA-CR 2006-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENIE VARELA VALENCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0067
2 CA-CR 2006-0123  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH BENITEZ LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0123
2 CA-CR 2006-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY BRIAN ABEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0131
2 CA-CR 2006-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN RAY MILLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0137
Issues Summary: In a prosecution for armed robbery, did the trial court err when it admitted, and found relevant, testimony that, after the defendant’s arrest, there had been a cessation of robberies involving the same modus operandi?


2 CA-CR 2006-0143  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIM DALE CALHOUN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0143
2 CA-CR 2006-0149-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISAURA CRUZ CHIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0149-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0151-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PATRICK WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0151-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENE GREG SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0155
2 CA-CR 2006-0161-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO ALBERTO ALTAMIRANO, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0161-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0171  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER JOHN PRADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0171
2 CA-CR 2006-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY EUGENE RHODES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0185
2 CA-CR 2006-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICIA A. BARNES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0191
Issues Summary: Does an officer transform a lawful warrantless strip search into an intrusion beyond the body’s surface that requires a warrant when he or she handles an object protruding from, and extending into, an arrestee’s body cavity?


2 CA-CR 2006-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY BARAJAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0193
2 CA-CR 2006-0195-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTRON MOROTO FAIRCHILD  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0195-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0199  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO DE LA OSSA MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0199
2 CA-CR 2006-0201  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON JAMERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0201
2 CA-CR 2006-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PRENTISS COGHILL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0215
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court commit reversible error in admitting evidence that defendant possessed adult pornography based on its finding the evidence was relevant under Rule 404(b), Ariz. R. Evid., to show the defendant’s intent, knowledge, and opportunity to download child pornography?

2. Did the trial court err in allowing the jury to view portions of the child pornography found in defendant’s residence despite his offer to stipulate that the material was child pornography?

3. Did the trial court violate defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to retain counsel of his choice when it denied the application of defendant’s father, an Illinois attorney, to appear pro hac vice?

4. To be guilty of a dangerous crime against children under A.R.S. § 13-604.01, must a defendant have known that the children depicted in child pornography the defendant possessed were under the age of fifteen?

5. Did the trial court violate Rule 15 of the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure and commit fundamental error by allowing the state, in making its pretrial disclosure, to provide Coghill with copies of his computer hard drives rather than producing the original hard drives?


2 CA-CR 2006-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HERSHEL ROBERTS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0233
2 CA-CR 2006-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT BRION URIAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0241
2 CA-CR 2006-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY JOSEPH DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0251  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0251
Issues Summary: 1) Is the evidence supporting a bigamy conviction necessarily insufficient if the accused never recorded the license of the later marriage?

2) Are the spouses of a person convicted of bigamy “victims” as defined by Arizona law?

3) May a court order a criminal defendant to pay restitution following a restitution hearing attended by neither the defendant nor his counsel?


2 CA-CR 2006-0257  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA EDWARD SYMONETTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0257
2 CA-CR 2006-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO FIERRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0265
2 CA-CR 2006-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANE GERALD McMILLIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0267
2 CA-CR 2006-0277  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ALLEN LYMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0277
2 CA-CR 2006-0295-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WARREN FRANK STAFFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0295-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0299-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH G. HEIRONIMUS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0299-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0311-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD A. POTTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0311-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN SWARTFIGUER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0331  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM JAMES NIELSON CORBETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0331
2 CA-CR 2006-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AGUSTIN CARRENO BUERAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0341
2 CA-CR 2006-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANSON RYDELL NORRIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0347
Issues Summary: Did the elements of the offense of possessing marijuana for distribution in violation of 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1) strictly conform to the elements of any comparable Arizona felony so that the defendant’s federal conviction qualified as a “historical prior felony conviction” for purposes of sentence enhancement?


2 CA-CR 2006-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ARMANDO GOMEZ   Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0351
2 CA-CR 2006-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ALDANA GUEVARA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRACY MARK DUTCHER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0371
2 CA-CR 2006-0379-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0379-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WEALTHY DAVID THOMAS, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0389
2 CA-CR 2006-0401  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ANGEL VALDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0401
2 CA-CR 2006-0403  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALAN DOOGAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0403
2 CA-CR 2006-0411-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW ERICH MANZANEDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0411-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0427  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID YULO MARTINEZ, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0427
2 CA-CR 2006-0433-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KURT WOODBURN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0433-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0437  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN SCHULTZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0437
2 CA-CR 2007-0005-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN MICHAEL FERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0005-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEANTONIO MORENO TERAN, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0013
2 CA-CR 2007-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG LANCE ENGLISH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0023
2 CA-CR 2007-0032-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN PATRICK HOLDEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0032-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DONALD MALY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0038
2 CA-CR 2007-0043-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PABLO MORENO GONZALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0043-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0055  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH JOHN FALCONE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0055
2 CA-CR 2007-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER MASSINGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0083
2 CA-CR 2007-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOREECE HADORN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0085
2 CA-CR 2007-0095-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY CHARLES RHOME  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0095-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0097-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN G. WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0097-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0101  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CORRALES RIVERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0101
2 CA-CR 2007-0103  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MOISES ZELAYA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0103
2 CA-CR 2007-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUCINDA MARIE PIERCE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0107
2 CA-CR 2007-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANE ROBERT ESTILLORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0109
2 CA-CR 2007-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0125-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANDY SALCIDO DURAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0125-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL MENDOZA CARRASCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0135  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER DALE CLARK  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0135
2 CA-CR 2007-0141-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINO FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0141-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0147-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THUC TRI NGUYEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0147-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0151-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER EARL YOUNG  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0151-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER WALLISER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0155
2 CA-CR 2007-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM HALEY FLYTHE, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0157
Issues Summary: Can a defendant’s renewal of a motion to sever trials pursuant to Rule 13.4(c), Ariz. R. Crim. P., preserve the severance issue on appeal for his codefendant when the codefendant did not join in the renewal of that motion or renew his own?


2 CA-CR 2007-0161  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JESUS ALCALA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0161
2 CA-CR 2007-0171  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL RAY BUSKE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0171
2 CA-CR 2007-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY STEPHEN PARENTEAU, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0177
2 CA-CR 2007-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE DALE TRUJILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0185
2 CA-CR 2007-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTOINETTE JEANNE NEWCOMB  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0193
2 CA-CR 2007-0195  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO JIMENEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0195
2 CA-CR 2007-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC DALE JERMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0197
2 CA-CR 2007-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LYNN TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0217  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARNEST LEE BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0217
2 CA-CR 2007-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYON EUGENE MIMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0236
2 CA-CR 2007-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERT JOHN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0237
2 CA-CR 2007-0239  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUADALUPE YOLANDA GOMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0239
2 CA-CR 2007-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRYSTAL LEE EISENSEE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0241
2 CA-CR 2007-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL RICHARD STATON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN KEITH WADE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0263
2 CA-CR 2007-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OMAR NAVARRO AMAVISCA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0267
2 CA-CR 2007-0279  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND ANTHONY BROEKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0279
2 CA-CR 2007-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN LUKE DOITCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ASCENSION GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0293
2 CA-CR 2007-0307  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO VASQUEZ CELAYA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0307
2 CA-CR 2007-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT SANCHEZ ESCOBEDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0311
2 CA-CR 2007-0313-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEON TIMBERLAKE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0313-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0315-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC ALAN MULKEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0315-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0317  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANG LE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0317
Issues Summary: May a defendant raise ineffective assistance of counsel claims in a motion to vacate judgment pursuant to Rule 24.2(a)(3), Ariz. R. Crim. P.?


2 CA-CR 2007-0321  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT SPENCER DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0321
2 CA-CR 2007-0337-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMAS SILVAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0337-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOBB LUIS ORNELAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0339
2 CA-CR 2007-0367  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL MIRANDA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0367
2 CA-CR 2007-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT LEEROY SLOVER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0379
Issues Summary: Do the victim’s attorney fees incurred to have private counsel assist the state in prosecuting the criminal case against the defendant directly flow from the defendant’s criminal conduct so as to constitute proper restitution to the victim?


2 CA-CR 2007-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LYNN WESTMILLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0415-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN WAYNE McMULLEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0415-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELIZABETH MICHELLE HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0003
2 CA-CR 2008-0011-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER ANDREW RAMON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0011-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MOON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0015
2 CA-CR 2008-0021-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JARED MICHAEL WAGONER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0021-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE GENE SARTIN, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0025
2 CA-CR 2008-0027  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RENARD REED, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0027
2 CA-CR 2008-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN DURAZO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0031
2 CA-CR 2008-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN DWAYNE SZPYRKA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0035
Issues Summary: Was the statement “I got nothin’ to say” an unambiguous invocation of a suspect’s Fifth Amendment right to remain silent, obliging the detective to cease questioning immediately?


2 CA-CR 2008-0049  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALOME CABALLERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0049
2 CA-CR 2008-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT MICHAEL HOLLENBACK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0065-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNEST JAMES GRIMM  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0065-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0083
2 CA-CR 2008-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKEL THOMAS DILLON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0091
2 CA-CR 2008-0095-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE D.L. CROCKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0095-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENA ARLIEN BREWER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0107
2 CA-CR 2008-0117  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RENE BENITEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0117
2 CA-CR 2008-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH GLENN HUNTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0123  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS GREGORIO ORNELAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0123
2 CA-CR 2008-0129  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNIE RAY KENNEDY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0129
2 CA-CR 2008-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD DAVID HAYNES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0137
2 CA-CR 2008-0141  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS M. BORREGO, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0141
2 CA-CR 2008-0145  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CARLOS MENDEZ-BAUTISTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0145
2 CA-CR 2008-0147  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EVA MARIE BACINSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0147
2 CA-CR 2008-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS JAMES CRETENS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0155
2 CA-CR 2008-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY DEVON MOORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0158
2 CA-CR 2008-0159-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONDRE KAMONIE BELLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0159-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAUN JERMAINE BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0167
2 CA-CR 2008-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MULHOLLAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GROVER LEE HODGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0185
2 CA-CR 2008-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE HURSEY, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0191
2 CA-CR 2008-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN GILBERTO REYNOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0193
2 CA-CR 2008-0194  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES SCOTT TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0194
2 CA-CR 2008-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHYRON LEE THOMAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0205  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIE THOMAS MACHADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0205
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court commit reversible error in precluding evidence that suggested a third party committed the murder with which the appellant was charged? 2. Did the court err in precluding on hearsay grounds certain out-of-court statements the appellant had made to police? 3. Was the appellant entitled to present the results of a polygraph test that suggested he did not shoot the victim? 4. Did the trial court err in instructing the jury on issues of eyewitness identification and reasonable doubt?


2 CA-CR 2008-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WESLEY HOWARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0209
2 CA-CR 2008-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES EARL HUTCHISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0213
2 CA-CR 2008-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY BARAJAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0225  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD JOE GONZALEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0225
2 CA-CR 2008-0229-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL A. FULLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0229-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0241-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUNIES A. JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0241-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0249  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA DIANNE BRINK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0249
2 CA-CR 2008-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE LYNN PERSHING  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0253
2 CA-CR 2008-0267-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM E. MORGAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0267-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KNYCEAULAS BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0269
2 CA-CR 2008-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMISON SCOTT WILLETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0278
2 CA-CR 2008-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN BARRAZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY ALFREDO TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMMY JAMES WARE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0293
2 CA-CR 2008-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID PAUL WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0300
2 CA-CR 2008-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON JARED BECK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0303-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH GABRIEL LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0311
2 CA-CR 2008-0321  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON DOUGLAS BLESSIE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0321
2 CA-CR 2008-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY JAYE WADE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKAL OMAR RASUL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0329
2 CA-CR 2008-0331  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STERLING DEVON MOORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0331
2 CA-CR 2008-0337  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RICARDO TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0337
2 CA-CR 2008-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMIAH MARCE FORTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0339
Issues Summary: When a defendant’s probation is revoked and he is sentenced for a felony offense, does a trial court err by conducting the disposition hearing with the defendant appearing only through an interactive audiovisual device and unable to communicate confidentially with counsel?


2 CA-CR 2008-0352  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MAGADAN VALLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0352
2 CA-CR 2008-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MALIK CORNELL PRIOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0377  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS LEE EDDINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0377
Issues Summary: 1. In a homicide case investigated by the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, did the trial court err, pursuant to Rule 18.4(b), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and A.R.S. § 21-211(2), in refusing to strike a venireman who was then employed as a Pima County Sheriff’s deputy, provided security at the superior court, knew up to half of the state’s witnesses from the sheriff’s department, and knew that the defendant was being held in custody?

2. Do the court’s jury instructions require reversal of the defendant’s conviction?


2 CA-CR 2008-0395-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO ALBERTO ALTAMIRANO, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0395-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0397  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TAMMY IRENE SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0397
2 CA-CR 2008-0407  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GALAREKA HARRISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0407
2 CA-CR 2008-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MUSGROVE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0409
2 CA-CR 2008-0413  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH M. COOPER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0413
2 CA-CR 2008-0417  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEOBARDO ARGIMIRO GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0417
2 CA-CR 2009-0005-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARRON SHAWN BOSSARDET  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0005-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0009  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ARNOLD GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0009
2 CA-CR 2009-0011  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN LEE KANANEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0011
2 CA-CR 2009-0017-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO GAMA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0017-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRUCE TYRONE STOCKER, JR.   Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0031
2 CA-CR 2009-0043  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JENNIFER SUE JEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0043
2 CA-CR 2009-0059-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANSON HOANG LEE LAVENTURE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0059-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0065-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL MARISCAL CARDENAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0065-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0066  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADLEY WILLIAM KENNEDY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0066
2 CA-CR 2009-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN TROY ECKHARDT  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0083
2 CA-CR 2009-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANYELLE DESHAWN CLAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0091
2 CA-CR 2009-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM ALCANTAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0109
2 CA-CR 2009-0111  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY LEE HINDEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0111
Issues Summary: Does the definition of fenced commercial yard in A.R.S. § 13-1501(4) require the property to be currently used for business purposes?


2 CA-CR 2009-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODRICK WADE HIGH-ELK  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0121-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT FISHER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0121-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0127  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RICHARD SATTERFIELD  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0127
2 CA-CR 2009-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBIN DIANE TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0131
2 CA-CR 2009-0133-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN JOSEPH COX  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0133-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL HUDG FRANCIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0139
2 CA-CR 2009-0153-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY LEE SABIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0153-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO LUIS MANKEL   Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0155
2 CA-CR 2009-0169  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WAYNE McCORMICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0169
2 CA-CR 2009-0195  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDY ALEXANDER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0195
2 CA-CR 2009-0199  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT GRADILLES YSLAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0199
2 CA-CR 2009-0203-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IBAN ANTONIO MORALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0203-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0205  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN GEORGE PONSART JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0205
Issues Summary: Pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-4033, does this court have jurisdiction to consider a pleading defendant’s appeal from a sentence that has been imposed after a contested probation violation proceeding?


2 CA-CR 2009-0207-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. R.L. ANTHONY ST. CLAIR  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0207-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH WIEBER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0223  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOMINIC WILLIAM DOMINGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0223
2 CA-CR 2009-0237-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA NARCHO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0237-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDRES EFREN ESTRADA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0247  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PRENTISS COGHILL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0247
2 CA-CR 2009-0261  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN LEON CORRAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0261
2 CA-CR 2009-0269-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WHITT MULHOLLAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0269-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0274-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEANTONIO MORENO TERAN, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0274-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0309  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY STEVE SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0309
2 CA-CR 2009-0313-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANFORD LAMAR FERRELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0313-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0317-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY NIDEZ VALENCIA, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0317-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0325  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID LLOYD  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0325
2 CA-CR 2009-0337-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID AUGUSTINE HIGDON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0337-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO ROLANDO LOZANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0343
2 CA-CR 2009-0345-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRY WAYNE MAHURIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0345-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JAMES BANN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DELLA LISA VERMUELE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0395
Issues Summary: Does a defendant forfeit appellate review of those claims that do not become apparent until pronouncement of sentence when she neither objects to the trial court’s pronouncement of sentence nor raises the issue in a post-judgment motion?


2 CA-CR 2009-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAREN SCOTT DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0399
Issues Summary: 1. When the trial court acknowledged that the jury’s verdict “could have gone either way,” did the court abuse its discretion by denying the defendant’s motion for a new trial based on the verdict being contrary to the weight of the evidence, pursuant to Rule 24.1(c)(1), Ariz. R. Crim. P.?

2. Did the trial court commit reversible error in limiting defense counsel’s closing argument to eight minutes when the defendant raised no objection until after he had been found guilty?

3. Did the trial court abuse its discretion by requiring the defendant to register as a sex offender when he was convicted of one count of public sexual indecency, a misdemeanor offense?


2 CA-CR 2009-0409-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK ALLISON GRAY, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0409-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ENRIQUE ORTEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0005  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL PETER GODOY  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0005
2 CA-CR 2010-0007  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0007
2 CA-CR 2010-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH GERARD JONES, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0013
2 CA-CR 2010-0033-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY LEE MITCHELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0033-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WILLIAM CLINGER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0038
2 CA-CR 2010-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS HUMBERTO GONZALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0041
2 CA-CR 2010-0055-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON P. AGREGAARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0055-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0065-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS RAMON CUEVAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0065-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0073  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SELENA ALICIA CORONADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0073
2 CA-CR 2010-0085-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTHA E. MARQUEZ CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0085-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LANDO ONASSIS AHUMADA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0093
Issues Summary: Pursuant to a consensual pat-down search, does the Fourth Amendment authorize a law enforcement officer to seize an object from a suspect’s pocket that the officer has probable cause to believe is drugs based on the object’s plain feel and the totality of the circumstances?


2 CA-CR 2010-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUCAS TYLER MORSE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0099
2 CA-CR 2010-0101-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DONALD MALY  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0101-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0103-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO DE LA OSSA MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0103-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ALLEN LYMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0145-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAYTON LEE HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0145-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0147-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON RAY TYLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0147-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0153-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO ESCARCEGA RUIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0153-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0155-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY BERNARD ENGEBRETSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0155-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD KELLY YOUNG  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0164
2 CA-CR 2010-0173  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON LAMONT WILMORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0173
2 CA-CR 2010-0179  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS M. BLANCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0179
2 CA-CR 2010-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL REYES VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0185
2 CA-CR 2010-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HESAM MOHAJERIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0193
Issues Summary: 1) Does A.R.S. § 13-4051 allow a petitioner to seek a notation of clearance on his criminal records on the ground that he is factually innocent? 2) Does A.R.S. § 12-2101(B) give this court jurisdiction over an appeal from a ruling on a petition for clearance, or may such a ruling only be reviewed by special action?


2 CA-CR 2010-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0207
2 CA-CR 2010-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JU'JUAN MARQUETTE GIBSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0209
2 CA-CR 2010-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY JAMES SIMMONS   Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0213
2 CA-CR 2010-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON MARTIN OCHOA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0215
2 CA-CR 2010-0217-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA MONTENEGRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0217-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ENRIQUE BALLESTEROS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0241
2 CA-CR 2010-0243  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERTO NAHUM NUNEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0243
2 CA-CR 2010-0249-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM EDWARD FOX  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0249-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0251-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0251-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0261  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DINAUSH NATHANIEL LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0261
2 CA-CR 2010-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LEE SANTY, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0267
2 CA-CR 2010-0277  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ALLEN RICE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0277
2 CA-CR 2010-0301  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONTY L. HELMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0301
2 CA-CR 2010-0305  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JESUS PALLANES  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0305
2 CA-CR 2010-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL VILLANUEVA LUGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0306
2 CA-CR 2010-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEL PRICE HAGGARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0314-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RANDALL HALSTEAD  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0314-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0315-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN JOSEPH ESTRADA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0315-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0317-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON JOSE GARCIA, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0317-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0327-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LEWANDOWSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0327-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0329-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR A. AVENDANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0329-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0333-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY ALAN KLEVENOW  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0333-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DURELL LEE CLIFTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0334
2 CA-CR 2010-0335-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRACEY LEANNE THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0335-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0353-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LORENZO SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0353-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL ARTURO GUZMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0365
2 CA-CR 2010-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JONATHON CARLSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0382
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in suppressing the defendant’s statements made during a custodial interrogation when detectives never provided the advisory required by Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966), and the defendant’s own attempted recitation of that advisory did not specify that he had the right to the presence of an attorney both before and during any questioning?


2 CA-CR 2010-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC MARK SUTHERLAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0396  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KYLE EVAN SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0396
Issues Summary: Is a defendant who has one prior felony conviction that is not a historical prior felony conviction ineligible for probation under A.R.S. § 13-703 when convicted of a subsequent felony offense?


2 CA-CR 2010-0402  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINALD DAVID TENNYSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0402
2 CA-CR 2010-0403-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM WHITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0403-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0407-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY JAYE WADE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0407-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY LOUIS MUSGROVE  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0007-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNOLDO HENRY PETERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0007-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY JAMES WRIGHT  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0034
2 CA-CR 2011-0037-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY LEE BAILEY, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0037-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IVAN SHAWN SAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0046
2 CA-CR 2011-0048  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FLORENCIO ROMAN-LIZARRAGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0048
2 CA-CR 2011-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN LAMAR BOOKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNY ALLEN HALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0056
2 CA-CR 2011-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWIN MICHAEL LYBARGER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0070
2 CA-CR 2011-0072-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN FRANCISCO MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0072-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0084-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH MICHAEL GODDARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0084-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court properly designate petitioner’s convictions dangerous crimes against children when he had been convicted of attempted sexual conduct with a minor who was under twelve years of age under former A.R.S. § 13-604.01?


2 CA-CR 2011-0090  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN SHALOM HUNTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0090
2 CA-CR 2011-0096-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0096-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0104  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY LYNN SEXTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0104
2 CA-CR 2011-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERROLD DEAN BROMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0106
Issues Summary: Is a petition to revoke probation or an allegation within the petition unlawfully “duplicitous” when it alleges the probationer possessed ten images of child pornography and the state then offers forty images of child pornography to prove the violation, without specifying which particular image or images establish the violation?


2 CA-CR 2011-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ALCANTAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0142-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BURRELL RICO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0142-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARC MARTIN LEYBA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICIO ENRIQUE MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0148
2 CA-CR 2011-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH MCBILES  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0152
2 CA-CR 2011-0154  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MICHAEL LONA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0154
2 CA-CR 2011-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREA MARGARITA TAPIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0156
2 CA-CR 2011-0162-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL FELTON CRAGO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0162-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0186-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT TADEO GARZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0186-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0188-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON JOSEPH BISHOP  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0188-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0204-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ILEANA KRYSTAL LINN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0204-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH LAMONTE FLUELLEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0208
2 CA-CR 2011-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE FLORES MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0224  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUREL DION ROBERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0224
2 CA-CR 2011-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL WILLIAM CROOKS II  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0226
2 CA-CR 2011-0236-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW ALAN CLACK  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0236-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0238-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY PATRICK KELLY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0238-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACOB MAGALLANES  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0246
2 CA-CR 2011-0260-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH THOMAS JESSUP  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0260-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID SCOTT PAULSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0278
2 CA-CR 2011-0290-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANKIE LEE RODRIGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0290-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0308-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CARRASCO GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0308-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0318-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EUGENE VICKREY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0318-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0322  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BYRON LEE HAGANS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0322
2 CA-CR 2011-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM EDWARD WRIGHT  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0328
2 CA-CR 2011-0338-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN LEON CORRAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0338-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0344  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TONY NIXON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0344
2 CA-CR 2011-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JESUS ALCALA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0358-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0358-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0362  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR LORETO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0362
2 CA-CR 2011-0366  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON WADE SMILEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0366
2 CA-CR 2011-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONTANA L. SCOTT  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0388
2 CA-CR 2011-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KATHLEEN ELIZABETH METZNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0398
2 CA-CR 2012-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT C. ECHOLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARQUIS JAMES HALL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0024
2 CA-CR 2012-0030-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LONGINO E. VALDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0030-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0034-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT MENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0034-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEANNINE LYNN CLARK  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0056
2 CA-CR 2012-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO M. SALLINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0058
2 CA-CR 2012-0086-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD STEVE MENDIVIL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0086-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0108-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN MICHAEL SPARKS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0108-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0110-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD ALLEN WEBB  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0110-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0114-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MINH MY THAI  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0114-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0118  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALAN CLAYTON DAVOLT, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0118
2 CA-CR 2012-0128  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY FLYNN WALKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0128
2 CA-CR 2012-0136-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES KEVIN FRAZIER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0136-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0146-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EVARISTO COTA-PARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0146-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0148-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN MICHAEL GALAVIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0148-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0159  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICARWIA JOSEPHINE HUDSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0159
2 CA-CR 2012-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE FRANCIS CURTIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0164
2 CA-CR 2012-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PIERRE MANTANO HOLNESS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0166
2 CA-CR 2012-0170-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MENDEZ, also known as VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0170-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0174-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO VARGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0174-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0180  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID SCOTT SELBY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0180
2 CA-CR 2012-0192-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. D RYAN JONES  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0192-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0196-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC THORIN PEELER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0196-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIANNE MARI LANE  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0210
2 CA-CR 2012-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH MICHAEL POWERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0213
2 CA-CR 2012-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS IRENE MONCADA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0222-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH DALTON LYNCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0222-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0234  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HARRY EMERSON RAMSEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0234
2 CA-CR 2012-0242-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS DONOVAN HILAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0242-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0248-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL SHANE LLOYD  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0248-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0250-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT STANFORD III  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0250-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0256
2 CA-CR 2012-0266-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ADAM MEDINA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0266-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONAVAN ANTHONY JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0269
2 CA-CR 2012-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SIOBHAN LYNN PARCELLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0282-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARSHALL LEE PATRICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0282-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0290-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO VIRGEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0290-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WHITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0318-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALFREDO PERALTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0318-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0322-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ALBERTO CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0322-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0324-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMETRIO ACOSTA URTUSUASTEGUI  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0324-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0328-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN JON PURKERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0328-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALLACE ALBERT BEGAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PATRICK CHAVEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0334
2 CA-CR 2012-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GERMAN MENDEZ, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0335
2 CA-CR 2012-0348-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EUGENE YODER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0348-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0353  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MICHAEL BARCELO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0353
2 CA-CR 2012-0356  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH NELSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0356
2 CA-CR 2012-0360-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS aka GLEN ALLEN HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0360-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0364-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LUIS TORRES-PAIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0364-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0368-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GALAREKA HARRISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0368-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0370-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LUIS GASTELUM-RABAGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0370-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0386-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESTEBAN PEREZ-VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0386-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0406-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH WIEBER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0406-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0412-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0412-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0418-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK OWENS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0418-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0420  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODGER D. FRANKLIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0420
2 CA-CR 2012-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES A. ROGERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0431  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN OSHEA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0431
2 CA-CR 2012-0451  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK K.C. HERTEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0451
2 CA-CR 2012-0457  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW EDWARD FOSTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0457
2 CA-CR 2012-0463  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LEE PETERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0463
2 CA-CR 2012-0466-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN G. WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0466-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0468-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ROY MALONE   Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0468-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0483  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM LEON CORRAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0483
2 CA-CR 2012-0490-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEC J. HOLTZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0490-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0492-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PONSART JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0492-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0495  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON BRICE ARNOLDI  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0495
2 CA-CR 2012-0507  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADIYIA SUNDIATA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0507
2 CA-CR 2012-0508-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL WADE LANDRITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0508-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0012  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON BRICE ARNOLDI  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0012
2 CA-CR 2013-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD FINCK  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0039
2 CA-CR 2013-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SARA GOLDEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0040
2 CA-CR 2013-0052-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO ESTRADA, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0052-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0064-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EVA LYNN MAYFIELD  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0064-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0070-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHAD LEE BUMPUS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0070-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0073-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT C. GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0073-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN MERCADO VALDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL GONZALES MALDONADO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0099
2 CA-CR 2013-0100-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID WAYNE TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0100-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS JAMES GALLARDO JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY LYNN WATSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0149
2 CA-CR 2013-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS BLACKWATER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KATHARINE McMURRAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0189
2 CA-CR 2013-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIRAM MERAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0191
2 CA-CR 2013-0197-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ABEL CABRERA-SOMOSA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0197-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEAN FRANKLYN SOARES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0221-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT L. CONRAD  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0221-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0225-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIPOLITO CHAVEZ MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0225-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0227-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS MAX BOLDT  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0227-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0231-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMITRI SHEPHERD  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0231-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL RUBEN PENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0241
2 CA-CR 2013-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN KYLE SHEETS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0249  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COLIN GEORGE GALIPO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0249
2 CA-CR 2013-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL CHRIS BOLTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT KENNETH CAMERON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0265
2 CA-CR 2013-0291  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD HAROLD STEWART, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0291
2 CA-CR 2013-0299  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW ABRAHAM SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0299
2 CA-CR 2013-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO FRANCISCO MONTES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0303-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK NORIKI KASIC  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMARI EUGENE CARTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0313
2 CA-CR 2013-0317  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY GLEN LAW  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0317
2 CA-CR 2013-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK GUNNAR WHITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0319
2 CA-CR 2013-0327-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY HULL  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0327-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0347-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP JOHN CORTEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0347-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0349-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERALD CHARLES SOUCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0349-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0351-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHARON ANN MCCOWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0351-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NIKISHA ALANA CALLISTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER SAMANIEGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0365
2 CA-CR 2013-0379-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES LOYD WHITE, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0379-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0407-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ADAM APALATEGUI  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0407-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0415  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ADAN AGUAYO-RUIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0415
2 CA-CR 2013-0417-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL TYRELLANDRE MCWILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0417-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0435  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE BORJON NAVARRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0435
2 CA-CR 2013-0441-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FLORENCIO ROMAN-LIZARRAGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0441-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0445-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN NATHAN JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0445-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0459-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN MICHAEL GRIZZLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0459-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0461-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLTON J. LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0461-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0467-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GREG LAPOINTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0467-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0475-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM ARTHUR BORJA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0475-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0477-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIO CESAR MORALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0477-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0481  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL SKYE BURTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0481
2 CA-CR 2013-0501-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARITY MARIE HILL  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0501-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0503-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN STEPHEN BRANNOCK  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0503-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0517-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0517-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0519  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD EUGENE POETHIG  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0519
2 CA-CR 2013-0525-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER WALTON HOPTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0525-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0537-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS RAMON AGUIAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0537-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0541-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX CRAIG JOHNSTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0541-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0543-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0543-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0557-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH DUANE MYERS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0557-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0559-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO LOPEZ-ZAMARRIPA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0559-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0565-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE FERNANDO MCCORMICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0565-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0045-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JAIME SILVA-ACOSTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0045-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0047-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WONTREL LAWAN SELLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0047-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0075-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELANIE ANNE MOYES  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0075-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0079-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAN MILTON ALFONSO  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0079-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ERIC STOKES, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0095-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM DUTCHER  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0095-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. QUINN WYATT BISHOP  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD CONNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0123-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANT REY DECKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0123-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0125-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM WESTLEY DUNCAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0125-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0127-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY BERNARD WALFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0127-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DEAN DeYOUNG  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0163-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARMAN NICHOLAS KING  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0163-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL RENE LOPEZ-VIDAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0217-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN L. DUDLEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0217-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALVADORE SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLY BURTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0261-PR
2 CA-CV 2006-0041  YOST v. YOST  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0041
2 CA-CV 2006-0069  KIM v.MANSOORI  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0069
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion when it granted summary judgment on a claim for attorney fees prior to judgment on the merits and certified the judgment as final pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., 16 A.R.S., Pt. 2?


2 CA-CV 2006-0108  TUCSON GASTROENTEROLOGY v. SIDI, M.D.  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0108
2 CA-CV 2006-0159  LA CANADA HILLS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v. FLORENCE KITE  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0159
Issues Summary: In an action where a partnership seeks to enforce its rights under the partnership agreement after one limited partner’s breach of the agreement, which statute of limitations applies, the one governing partnership accounting actions that allows four years from the time the partners wind up their affairs together for a plaintiff to bring an action, or the statute governing breach of contract actions that gives a plaintiff six years from the time of the breach


2 CA-CV 2006-0167  BEISE v. CAPPSCO INTERNATIONAL and PRO-TECH AVIATION, LTD.  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0167
2 CA-CV 2006-0169  McGEE v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0169
2 CA-CV 2006-0181  DYKES v. GRANDE PROPERTIES and THERMO-TEMP ROOFING  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0181
2 CA-CV 2006-0191  POTTER v. WHEELAND, D.O.; DR. CHANG  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0191
2 CA-CV 2006-0193  HARRIS, WILSON, ANGEL TEAM HOME CARE v. COCHISE HEALTH SYSTEMS  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0193
Issues Summary: 1. Is a party who has voluntarily dismissed its amended complaint with prejudice an aggrieved party for purposes of establishing appellate court jurisdiction? 2. Can a party raise arguments on appeal that were not raised before the trial court if application of a legal principle would dispose of an action on appeal and correctly explain the law but the issue has not been briefed or argued below? 3. Does a party meet the requirements of A.R.S. § 12-821.01 for individualized notice of a claim when it does nothing more than list the party’s name as the statutory agent for a public entity also named as a defendant?


2 CA-CV 2006-0229  JENKINS v. SEDILLO, ULIBERRY, ARIZ. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS   Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0229
2 CA-CV 2007-0009  BERETTA v. TUCSON TRAP & SKEET CLUB  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0009
2 CA-CV 2007-0017  SMITH v. HUBER  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0017
2 CA-CV 2007-0023  GARY BLUEMKE v. UNIV. OF ARIZONA POLICE PENSION BOARD  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0023
2 CA-CV 2007-0043  DENISE PECK v. DAVID WATERMAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0043
2 CA-CV 2007-0107  MICHAEL REDHAIR v. KINERK, BEAL, SCHMIDT, DYER & SETHI, P.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0107
Issues Summary: 1. Does the one-year statute of limitations governing actions for breach of an employment contract apply to only those contracts defined by the Arizona Employment Protection Act? 2. Does the one-year statute of limitations of either A.R.S. § 12-541(3) or § 12-541(5) apply to a statutory action for unpaid wages, in which a trial court may award treble damages?


2 CA-CV 2007-0109  MARIA HENNING v. MONTECINI HOSPITALITY, ET AL.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0109
Issues Summary: Does the seller of a bar have a continuing duty of care in dispensing alcohol at that bar when the sale has not closed but the seller has contractually relinquished the right to control, operate, and profit from the bar to the buyer and when the bar is serving alcohol pursuant to the new operator’s liquor license?

Can a seller of a bar be held liable for the negligent training of bar employees when the employees’ allegedly negligent conduct occurs after the seller no longer employs them, when they are employed by the purchaser and new operator of the bar?


2 CA-CV 2007-0113  CATHERINE ANN RODRIGUEZ v. RICHARD RAYMOND RODRIGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0113
2 CA-CV 2007-0129  EVA ANGELINA ENCINAS TREJO v. LAMBERTO ARMENTA TREJO  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0129
2 CA-CV 2007-0131  LORENZO SANCHEZ, SR. ET AL v. OLD PUEBLO ANESTHESIA, PC, ET AL.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0131
Issues Summary: When a plaintiff invokes the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur in a medical malpractice action alleging negligence by either a surgeon or anesthesiologist or both, must the plaintiff comply with A.R.S. §§ 12-2603 and 12-2604 by obtaining a preliminary expert opinion affidavit on the relevant standards of care from both an anesthesiologist and a surgeon, or does the res ipsa doctrine create an exception to the requirements of those statutes?


2 CA-CV 2007-0139  HORNBECK v. LUSK  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0139
Issues Summary: When a litigant in justice court seeks a peremptory change of judge pursuant to Rule 10.2, Ariz. R. Crim. P., is “the presiding judge” to whom the case must be transferred for reassignment under Rule 10.5, Ariz. R. Crim. P., the justice of the peace of that particular precinct or the presiding justice of the peace for the county in which the precinct is located?


2 CA-CV 2007-0149  PINAL COUNTY v. AIRE H. DeJONG and MILKY WAY DAIRY  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0149
2 CA-CV 2007-0170  LORENZO SANCHEZ, SR. and BERTHA SANCHEZ v. TUCSON ORTHOPAEDIC INSTITUTE; LEVI  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0170
Issues Summary: Was summary judgment properly granted in favor of the defendants in a res ipsa loquitur case when the plaintiff failed to establish that the defendant surgeon had exclusive control over the injury-causing instrumentality?


2 CA-CV 2008-0013  ROBERT L. BOUCONI v. RANDALL NEIS  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0013
2 CA-CV 2008-0023  SWAIN CHAPMAN v. THE WESTERNER  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0023
Issues Summary: In an action involving the purchase of one partner’s interest in a limited partnership, where the parties agreed to base the purchase on an appraisal of the partnership’s primary asset, did the trial court err when it concluded, as a matter of law, that the appraiser’s first opinion of value is entitled to the same finality given final arbitration awards?


2 CA-CV 2008-0039  RALPH A. PENA, JR. v. ADOC  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0039
2 CA-CV 2008-0051  ELECTRICAL DISTRICT NO. 3 OF PINAL COUNTY v. 3-F CONTRACTING INCORPORATED  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0051
2 CA-CV 2008-0067  DANIEL WILLIAM PARTIN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0067
2 CA-CV 2008-0069  ANANT K. TRIPATI v. YARBROUGH, VILLACANA, BALDENEGRO  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0069
2 CA-CV 2008-0095  VALLEY FORGE INSURANCE CO. v. SAM'S PLUMBING; THOMAS, THOMAS  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0095
Issues Summary: Are tort claims available against a company that contracted to perform gas-line work in a building, negligently performed that work, and caused an explosion that damaged the building itself but resulted in no personal injury or damage to personal property?


2 CA-CV 2008-0109  JEANETTE ELLEN WILLIAMS v. CLARENCE KELVIN WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0109
Issues Summary: 1) When an award of costs, expenses, and attorney fees is requested pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-324(A), may a court consider the subjective intent of a party when determining the “reasonableness” of the positions the party has taken?

2) May a court disregard the financial resources of a party who seeks an award of costs, expenses, and attorney fees under A.R.S. § 25-324(A) and consider only the financial resources of the party who would be paying the fee award?


2 CA-CV 2008-0121  MIKAL A. SILVERS v. MIMI SILVERS, nka MIMI DANIEL  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0121
2 CA-CV 2008-0151  JOHNSON UTILITIES COMPANY v. PECAN CREEK COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0151
2 CA-CV 2008-0152  KATHLEEN ARNOLD LANGDON v. ELLA MAUREEN ARNOLD  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0152
2 CA-CV 2008-0161  CARDI AMERICAN CORP.; ALL AMERICAN HOUSE & APARTMENT MOVERS  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0161
Issues Summary: When a landlord has the option to terminate a lease when property is “taken by eminent domain,” does the exercise of this option extinguish a tenant's right to receive compensation?


2 CA-CV 2008-0163  HOWELL v. PALMER  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0163
2 CA-CV 2008-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA; GRAMMAR v. KAKAR  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0167
2 CA-CV 2008-0189  FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE v. TOWN OF MARANA; BRONSON; NESSINGER  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0189
Issues Summary: When challenging a rezoning ordinance by referendum, what is the event that triggers the running of the thirty-day time limit within which to file a referendum petition?


2 CA-CV 2009-0001  HOLT, nka TRUED v. HOLT  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0001
2 CA-CV 2009-0015  UPS SUPPLY CHAIN v. PARTIDA BROKERAGE  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0015
2 CA-CV 2009-0017  STANTEC CONSULTING v. SAGUARO RESERVE  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0017
2 CA-CV 2009-0042  MM&A PRODUCTIONS v. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION...  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0042
2 CA-CV 2009-0049  YODER v. LACHEMANN  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0049
2 CA-CV 2009-0063  MARANA POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION v. TOWN OF MARANA...  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0063
2 CA-CV 2009-0087  LEVI and KINGDOM INVESTORS, LLC v. KORN  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0087
2 CA-CV 2009-0099  SHARKOZY v. WALKER  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0099
2 CA-CV 2009-0135  In re the MCCUNE REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST DATED JUNE 6, 1989  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0135
2 CA-CV 2009-0153  SALICA v. TUCSON HEART HOSPITAL - CARONDELET, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0153
Issues Summary: In this wrongful death action, did the trial court correctly determine that sufficient evidence of causation existed to support the jury’s verdict against the defendant hospital?


2 CA-CV 2009-0159  MILLER v. KRAMBER; KRAMBER PROPERTIES  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0159
2 CA-CV 2009-0161  SHEEHAN v. SHEEHAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0161
2 CA-CV 2009-0172  HOWARD v. RAMER  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0172
2 CA-CV 2009-0175  SMITH v. BEESLEY; BOOTH  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0175
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in concluding the appellee had a right to enter and alter land within a subdivision’s drainage easement when the subdivision’s plat specified the land was to be used for “drainage purposes?”

Did the court err in denying appellant relief under A.R.S. § 48-3613, which provides a private right of action for the unauthorized alteration of a watercourse, when the appellee’s driveway and culvert were built without written authorization from the flood control district board, diverted a watercourse, and risked causing damage to the appellant’s property?

Did the court err in awarding attorney fees to the appellee and denying appellant’s fee request?


2 CA-CV 2009-0187  BELLINFANTE v. FALCONER  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0187
2 CA-CV 2010-0013  CRUZ v. SMITH-FRAZIER, fka CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0013
2 CA-CV 2010-0015  HOMEQ, LLC v. DEL TURCO  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0015
2 CA-CV 2010-0029  THE FUNDING GROUP v. THE ESTATE OF FREDDY JO DEEN  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0029
2 CA-CV 2010-0039  LEVY v. LEVY  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0039
2 CA-CV 2010-0041  DAUENHAUER v. FEATHERMAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0041
2 CA-CV 2010-0053  LA PALOMA v. CATALINA FOOTHILLS UNIF. SCH. DIST. #16  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0053
2 CA-CV 2010-0070  WOOD v. FITZ-SIMMONS  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0070
2 CA-CV 2010-0071  CORTEZ; THE ESTATE OF FRANCES CORTEZ v. AVALON CARE CENTER, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0071
Issues Summary: Did the appellee waive the right to compel arbitration by answering the appellant’s complaint and proceeding with litigation for nearly a year?


2 CA-CV 2010-0093  JEFFREY MILLER and ALLYSON MILLER v. KITTY L. WAYNE  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0093
2 CA-CV 2010-0103  SUNFED PRODUCE v. CONECCIONES AGRICOLAS, S. de R.L. de C.V.   Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0103
2 CA-CV 2010-0117  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP, PARAGON HOTEL CORP. v. CASA GRANDE RESORT LIVING, PINSONNEAULT, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0117
2 CA-CV 2010-0118  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP, PARAGON HOTEL CORP. v. JOE PINSONNEAULT, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0118
2 CA-CV 2010-0149  IN THE ESTATE OF MARY A. RILEY, aka MARY AGNES RILEY, aka MARY AGNES REILLY  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0149
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err pursuant to A.R.S. § 14-3952 when it approved compromises between an estate’s personal representative and some, but not all, of the beneficiaries of the estate and not all of the beneficiaries signed the compromise?


2 CA-CV 2010-0161  In re ONE RESIDENCE LOCATED AT 3225 W. SWEETWATER DR.  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0161
2 CA-CV 2010-0171  COLWELL v. OUTENREATH  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0171
2 CA-CV 2010-0175  HAGER v. M. VISTA INVESTORS, LLC  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0175
2 CA-CV 2010-0181  LANGLEY v. SACKRIDER   Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0181
2 CA-CV 2010-0188  DELMASTRO & EELLS v. TACO BELL CORP.  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0188
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding appellant’s mechanic’s lien invalid and dismissing its foreclosure count on summary judgment? 2. Assuming appellant’s mechanic’s lien was invalid, did appellant’s knowledge or “reason to know” of the invalidity present a factual question that precluded entry of summary judgment on appellee’s counterclaim under A.R.S. § 33-420(A)?


2 CA-CV 2010-0191  PAPALIOLIOS v. DAVIDSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0191
2 CA-CV 2010-0213  IN RE ROBERT EARL KRONCKE  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0213
2 CA-CV 2011-0013  PINAL COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT v. CARDEST JAMES  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0013
2 CA-CV 2011-0026  INTER K N.V. v. UPS SUPPLY CHAIN SOLUTIONS, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0026
2 CA-CV 2011-0042  RIEMAN v. RIEMAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0042
2 CA-CV 2011-0094  PALMER v. HOWELL  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0094
2 CA-CV 2011-0106  FLORES v. MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0106
2 CA-CV 2011-0128  ROGERS v. BOARD OF REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0128
2 CA-CV 2011-0136  MARANA 670 HOLDINGS, LLC v. SPIRIT UNDERGROUND, LLC  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0136
2 CA-CV 2011-0138  NOBLES v. OGLESBY  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0138
2 CA-CV 2011-0182  DOUGALL v. DOUGALL  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0182
2 CA-CV 2011-0186  STAGELINE RANCHES, L.L.C. v. COAWETTE  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0186
2 CA-CV 2011-0187  In re the ESTATE OF WILLIAM H. ANDRESON  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0187
2 CA-CV 2012-0004  KONDAUR CAPITAL CORPORATION v. PINAL COUNTY, BABEU  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0004
2 CA-CV 2012-0014  DOMINGUEZ v. MERITAGE HOMES ARIZONA, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0014
2 CA-CV 2012-0016  BFD INVESTMENTS, LLC v. BARNYARD HERITAGE, LLC  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0016
2 CA-CV 2012-0038  SALVATIERRA v. TROJANOVICH  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0038
2 CA-CV 2012-0056  U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION v. DUNN  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0056
2 CA-CV 2012-0059  MOORE v. MOORE  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0059
2 CA-CV 2012-0072  KELLY v. KINO SPRINGS GOLF, LLC and KINO SPRINGS RANCH, LLC  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0072
2 CA-CV 2012-0074  QUINN v. SHERMAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0074
2 CA-CV 2012-0104  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF FEATHERSTONE  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0104
2 CA-CV 2012-0126  PFEIFER v. PFEIFER  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0126
2 CA-CV 2012-0140  KING v. KING  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0140
2 CA-CV 2012-0160  DESMARAIS v. ANDERSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0160
2 CA-CV 2013-0017  LOCKERBY v. CITY OF TUCSON, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0017
2 CA-CV 2013-0079  TAYLOR-BERTLING v. FOLEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0079
2 CA-CV 2013-0081  ORTIZ v. ESPINOZA  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0081
2 CA-CV 2013-0091  SAKS v. SANTA CRUZ VALLEY UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT #840  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0091
2 CA-CV 2013-0141  F & C HOLDINGS v. SNOW  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0141
2 CA-CV 2013-0147  DONALD RAY PALMER v. BANK OF AMERICA  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0147
2 CA-CV 2013-0165  CRAIG R. EHRHORN v. THOMAS E. HIGGINS  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0165
2 CA-IC 2007-0001  RONALD HULL v. ABLE REFRIGERATION, INC., STATE COMP. FUND   Author 2 CA-IC 2007-0001
2 CA-IC 2008-0005  PESQUEIRA v. GILBERT ELECTRIC CO.; SCF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-IC 2008-0005
2 CA-IC 2010-0007  DEBORAH PHOENIX v. PRECISION SHOOTING EQUIPMENT and SCF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-IC 2010-0007
2 CA-IC 2010-0009  BEVERLY G. JONES v. RAYTHEON CO. and LIBERTY MUTUAL INS.  Author 2 CA-IC 2010-0009
2 CA-IC 2010-0011  MARVIN O. RAMBEL v. MNI ENTERPRISES, AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE  Author 2 CA-IC 2010-0011
2 CA-IC 2011-0006  JOSEPH R. TAYLOR v. DOLLAR GENERAL MISSON RDG. and NEW HAMPSHIRE INSURANCE CO./AVIZENT  Author 2 CA-IC 2011-0006
2 CA-IC 2011-0024  SANDRA R. SARTIN v. BASHAS' INC.  Author 2 CA-IC 2011-0024
2 CA-IC 2012-0004  CARLETON J. FULLER v. EAGLE EXPRESS LINES, INC. and LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE GROUP  Author 2 CA-IC 2012-0004
2 CA-IC 2012-0008  ROBINSON v. YOUTH DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE and SCF WESTERN INSURANCE COMPANY  Author 2 CA-IC 2012-0008
2 CA-JV 2006-0041  CYNTHIAANNE F. v. ADES & HESREAL F.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0041
2 CA-JV 2006-0047  SUZANNE S. v. ADES., BRITTANY S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0047
2 CA-JV 2006-0049  IN RE NATALIE Z.   Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0049
Issues Summary: Are A.R.S. § 13-502(A) and (C), which set forth the legal test for insanity and assign a clear and convincing burden of proof to the person asserting a defense of guilty except insane, applicable to a delinquency proceeding when a juvenile asserts an insanity defense?


2 CA-JV 2006-0051  ALICIA L. v. ADES, HENRY L., LEVI L., JACKIE L., DESTINY L.   Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0051
2 CA-JV 2006-0053  ADRIAN E. v. ADES, NAINOA E.   Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0053
Issues Summary: If a parent fails to appear without good cause at a status conference in a termination of parental rights proceeding conducted pursuant to chapter 10, article 4 of title 8, A.R.S., may the juvenile court proceed to terminate the parent’s rights by default?


2 CA-JV 2007-0013  VERONICA B. v. ADES, TRESSA M., KAYLA D.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0013
2 CA-JV 2007-0019  MARK G. v. ADES, MARISABEL G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0019
2 CA-JV 2007-0037  CYNTHIA W. v. ADES, SARAH W., DAVID W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0037
2 CA-JV 2007-0039  IN RE JAMES S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0039
2 CA-JV 2007-0053  RUTH H. v. ADES & KRISTEN H.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0053
2 CA-JV 2007-0062  DINORA G. v. ADES, SIPRIANO G., DINORA G., JESUS G., GLORIA G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0062
2 CA-JV 2007-0063  IN RE EDREI O.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0063
2 CA-JV 2007-0071  MANUEL M. v. ADES, LEILA M., ALAYENA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0071
Issues Summary: In this parental severance case wherein the father failed to personally appear at a termination hearing and the trial court proceeded to adjudicate the state’s motion to terminate his parental rights, did the juvenile court abuse its discretion when it considered only documentary evidence, admitted without testimony, and denied the request of father’s counsel to examine adverse witnesses?


2 CA-JV 2007-0085  IN RE EMMANUEL P.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0085
2 CA-JV 2008-0003  CRAIG B. v. ADES, WESTON B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0003
2 CA-JV 2008-0021  RAMONA M. v. ADES, JOB O., JASMINE O., ABIGAIL O. & JAZELLE O.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0021
2 CA-JV 2008-0035  JONAS P. v. KATHRYN R. & BRANDON R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0035
2 CA-JV 2008-0067  MICAH D. v. ADES, SAMANTHA D., KC D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0067
2 CA-JV 2008-0083  IN RE GADN R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0083
2 CA-JV 2008-0097  BETSAIRA G. v. ADES, CHRISTOPHER G. and EDGARDO G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0097
2 CA-JV 2008-0107  IN RE BENNY H.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0107
2 CA-JV 2008-0111  REBECCA W. v. ADES and ISABELLE W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0111
2 CA-JV 2008-0117  JESSE P. v. ADES and SHELBI P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0117
2 CA-JV 2008-0121  IN RE HILLARY C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0121
Issues Summary: Whether the juvenile court is statutorily required to notify the Arizona Department of Transportation that a juvenile has been adjudicated delinquent for violating A.R.S. § 4-244(33), which prohibits a person under the age of twenty-one from driving or being in physical control of a motor vehicle while there is any alcohol in his or her body.


2 CA-JV 2008-0129  IN RE GUSTAVO S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0129
2 CA-JV 2009-0003  DENISE R. v. ADES, DRAVEN R. and LARSEN R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0003
Issues Summary: What standard of appellate review applies to a claim that the evidence was insufficient to support a juvenile court’s order terminating parental rights? Was the evidence sufficient to establish that the mother was unable to discharge her parental responsibilities as the result of her chronic alcohol abuse, which she acknowledged could be expected to continue indefinitely?


2 CA-JV 2009-0009  ARLENE I. v. ADES and ANGEL I.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0009
2 CA-JV 2009-0031  IN RE EZRA B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0031
2 CA-JV 2009-0043  BRUCE T. v. CHRISTENE N. and DEVON T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0043
2 CA-JV 2009-0047  CHESTER F. v. ADES, DANEA F. MARCUS F. KEVON F. and TYREE F  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0047
2 CA-JV 2009-0051  IN RE ISAAC U.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0051
2 CA-JV 2009-0067  RAFIEL L.-B. v. ADES and LEILANI L.-B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0067
2 CA-JV 2009-0083  PRISCILLA G. v. ADES, NATHANIEL S.-M. and NATALIE S.-M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0083
2 CA-JV 2009-0091  IN RE JESUS M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0091
2 CA-JV 2009-0093  ERIC H. v. ADES, KAMARIA S., ZINAYAH S. and CHRISTIAN S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0093
2 CA-JV 2009-0099  JACQUES C. v. ADES, MATTHEW C., ACACIA C., JACOB C., SAMUEL C. and DYLAN N.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0099
2 CA-JV 2009-0111  IN RE NICKOLAS T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0111
Issues Summary: Did the juvenile court have the authority, based on A.R.S. § 13-3821(D) and A.R.S. § 8-202(G), to vacate a previously imposed order requiring the juvenile to register as a sex offender?


2 CA-JV 2009-0132  IN RE TYLER A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0132
2 CA-JV 2009-0135  LORI S. v. ADES and SAMANTHA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0135
2 CA-JV 2010-0021  ROBERT W. v. ADES, SETH W. and ETHAN W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0021
2 CA-JV 2010-0036  ROBERT H. v. ADES and GABRIEL G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0036
2 CA-JV 2010-0051  CHANETTE B. v. ADES, JORDAN T. and JABRIEL T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0051
2 CA-JV 2010-0053  MIRAMONTE T.-S. v. ADES and IZABELLE T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0053
2 CA-JV 2010-0055  CARISSA C. v. ADES and CHANCE C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0055
2 CA-JV 2010-0059  JENNIFER W. v. ADES, TERESA W. and STEVIE W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0059
2 CA-JV 2010-0065  IN RE BRENARD B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0065
2 CA-JV 2010-0071  REBECCA W. v. ADES, CHYANE D., ETHAN W. and SETH W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0071
2 CA-JV 2010-0072  BONNIE M. v. ADES, ANTONIO M. and ALANNIE B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0072
2 CA-JV 2010-0085  IN RE OFIR Z.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0085
2 CA-JV 2010-0103  IN RE MICHELLE Z.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0103
2 CA-JV 2010-0113  IN RE JUSTIN M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0113
2 CA-JV 2010-0119  TRACY H. v. JOHN L. and AISHA L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0119
2 CA-JV 2010-0121  VICTOR N. v. ANA P. and VICTORIA N.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0121
2 CA-JV 2011-0021  ALBERT G. v. KRISTY R., ALBERT G., JR. and MERCEDES G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0021
2 CA-JV 2011-0025  IN RE CHRISTOPHER S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0025
2 CA-JV 2011-0029  IN RE ZACHARY R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0029
2 CA-JV 2011-0036  SAMANTHA H. v. ADES and MICHAEL N.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0036
2 CA-JV 2011-0038  CRYSTAL M. v. ADES and MICHAEL C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0038
2 CA-JV 2011-0046  FRANCISCO F. v. ADES and SHAWN S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0046
Issues Summary: Is a juvenile court’s order that the state need not provide reunification services to a parent in a dependency proceeding, final and appealable?


2 CA-JV 2011-0066  CRYSTAL M. v. ADES and MICHAEL C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0066
2 CA-JV 2011-0068  ASHAH M. v. ADES, DAE'ZHREANA M. and DAIDRIAN M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0068
2 CA-JV 2011-0074  JOSEPH A. III v. ADES, JOSEPH A. IV, ANASELI A., JAZMINE A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0074
2 CA-JV 2011-0080  JOHN A. v. ADES and CHRISTINA A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0080
2 CA-JV 2011-0082  DORITHY C. v. ADES, VORJOLO C., RUTH C., and SOLOMON C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0082
2 CA-JV 2011-0124  JAIME B. v. ADES and DEZIREE B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0124
2 CA-JV 2011-0132  ADRIAN M. v. ADES and ADRIANA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0132
2 CA-JV 2012-0002  KATRINA G. v. ADES and HAILEE K.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0002
2 CA-JV 2012-0014  IN RE CHRISTIAN D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0014
2 CA-JV 2012-0018  MARK H. and LOVASIA H. v. ADES  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0018
2 CA-JV 2012-0048  JASON R. v. ADES and JASON R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0048
2 CA-JV 2012-0054  YOLANDA C. v. ADES, ELENA C., ELI'YANA C., EALIYAH C., ELYSSIA C., AUBRE'YANA C. and ANTHONY C., III  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0054
2 CA-JV 2012-0064  MALACHI W. and ADES v. RICARDO M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0064
2 CA-JV 2012-0074  JESSICA E. v. ADES and ALIVIAH M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0074
2 CA-JV 2012-0086  JOSE L. v. ADES and LORRAYNE M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0086
2 CA-JV 2012-0088  IN RE ALEXIS P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0088
2 CA-JV 2012-0094  ROBIN S. v. ADES, LAYTON S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0094
2 CA-JV 2012-0110  PATRICK A.-S. v. ADES  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0110
2 CA-JV 2013-0017  JAMES F. v. FARIN H., HERBERT H. and KETHAN F.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0017
2 CA-JV 2013-0025  IN RE JESUS G.-C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0025
2 CA-JV 2013-0051  LISA C. v. ADES and J.M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0051
2 CA-JV 2013-0059  SARAH V. v. ADES, E., D., P., and G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0059
2 CA-JV 2013-0071  IN RE RICARDO S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0071
2 CA-JV 2013-0125  I.L., L.L. and A.L. v. ADES, JULIA J., DANIEL L. and GILA RIVER INDIAN COMMUNITY  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0125
2 CA-JV 2014-0021  JAMES L. v. ADES and I.L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2014-0021
2 CA-MH 2006-0009  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-20000649  Author 2 CA-MH 2006-0009
2 CA-MH 2010-0001  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-201000029  Author 2 CA-MH 2010-0001
Issues Summary: Did the two psychiatrists in this case comply with A.R.S. §§ 36-501(14), 36-533(B), and 36-539(B), which require that a proposed patient for court-ordered treatment receive a “complete physical examination” personally conducted by each evaluating physician, when their examinations were limited to interviewing the patient, reviewing his records, and observing his demeanor and physical presentation?


2 CA-MH 2010-0005  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH CASE NO. MH20000209810  Author 2 CA-MH 2010-0005
2 CA-MH 2012-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20100545  Author 2 CA-MH 2012-0002
2 CA-SA 2007-0027  STEVEN PAUL TURNER V. ACUNA; STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0027
2 CA-SA 2007-0067  THE STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA EDWARDS FRYE   Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0067
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by entertaining the defendant’s challenge to the grand jury proceeding, brought more than two years after the grand jury transcript and minutes were filed, well past the time limits in Rule 12.9(b), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and by remanding the case for a new finding of probable cause?


2 CA-SA 2007-0085  DIANA H. v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY  Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0085
Issues Summary: Whether a parent whose child has been adjudicated dependent pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 8-841 through 8-844 has a residual parental right pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-531(5)(c) to exempt the child from immunization for religious reasons.


2 CA-SA 2008-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TODD GLICK  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0013
2 CA-SA 2009-0027  CHRISTOPHER JUDE KAKAR v. VIRGINIA HELENE GRAMMER  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0027
2 CA-SA 2009-0031  JOHN D. KAUFMANN v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0031
Issues Summary: In the absence of statutory authority permitting awards of attorney fees in criminal proceedings, does a criminal trial court have the inherent authority to order defense counsel to pay the state’s attorney fees as a sanction for litigation conduct?


2 CA-SA 2009-0067  LAVELL LITTLETON v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0067
2 CA-SA 2010-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN LEE ROUSSEAU...  Author 2 CA-SA 2010-0087
2 CA-SA 2011-0027  JUNE BURTON v. LAWLEY AUTO SALES, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0027
2 CA-SA 2011-0029  BRENDA A. VARGAS v. LINDA'S LOUNGE LLC  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0029
2 CA-SA 2011-0030  SAMUEL AGUIRRE v. STEVENS; AGUIRRE; RICARDO'S RESTAURANT  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0030
2 CA-SA 2011-0043  ALEX PAUL RASMUSSEN v. STATE OF ARIZONA   Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0043
Issues Summary: May a trial court require a defendant placed on consecutive probation terms to serve, as a condition of probation, two consecutive, one-year jail terms at the beginning of the first probation term?


2 CA-SA 2011-0054  GREGORY TRAINOR v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0054
2 CA-SA 2011-0060  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO MARRUFO ONTIVEROS  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0060
2 CA-SA 2012-0072  GLEN CUSFORD FRANCIS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0072
2 CA-SA 2013-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FULLER WAYNE SMITH  Author 2 CA-SA 2013-0085
2 CA-CR 2004-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS RAFAEL MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2004-0253
2 CA-CR 2005-0047  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS REYNALDO LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0047
2 CA-CR 2005-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0176
2 CA-CR 2005-0219  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CYNTHIA D. JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0219
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant can be convicted of felony murder pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-1105(A)(2) in the absence of evidence that the defendant was either an accomplice to or a participant in the specific offense alleged as the predicate felony.


2 CA-CR 2005-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0319
2 CA-CR 2005-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS NOE MIRAMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0335
2 CA-CR 2005-0353  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EFRAIN MERINO GAMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0353
2 CA-CR 2005-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN BEN BADILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0369
2 CA-CR 2005-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0409
2 CA-CR 2005-0422  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0422
2 CA-CR 2006-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JILL IRENE PARIS-SHELDON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0015
Issues Summary: 1. Before denying the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel, did the trial court conduct a sufficient inquiry under State v. Torres, 208 Ariz. 340, 93 P.3d 1056 (2004)? 2. Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel? 3. Does a criminal defendant waive the attorney-client privilege for purposes of a Torres inquiry? 4. Must a trial court appoint a defendant new counsel for the hearing on the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel? 5. May a defendant properly file a motion to dismiss charges asserting the trial court erred by granting the state’s motion in a previous case, concerning the same defendant and events, to dismiss similar charges without prejudice pursuant to Rule 16.6(a), Ariz. R. Crim. P., 16A A.R.S.? 6. Did the trial court interfere with the defendant’s right to exercise peremptory challenges when, after closing arguments, it excused several jurors for cause after a twelve-person jury had been inadvertently impaneled instead of the required eight-person jury?


2 CA-CR 2006-0019  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ANTHONY MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0019
2 CA-CR 2006-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0025
2 CA-CR 2006-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD MICHAEL SWEET  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0029
2 CA-CR 2006-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ALBERTO QUEVEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0031
2 CA-CR 2006-0033  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL CHRISTOPHER MARTINEZ, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0033
2 CA-CR 2006-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EUGENE BARNES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0035
2 CA-CR 2006-0047  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO GUILLERMO SNYDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0047
2 CA-CR 2006-0049  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GREG McCURDY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0049
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding a witness qualified to recite the contents of a business record even though the court had precluded admission of the actual document under Rule 403, Ariz. R. Evid.?

2. Was the evidence sufficient to permit the jury to find that the defendant was the same person previously convicted in another jurisdiction?

3. Was the trial court required to amend the presentence report pursuant to Rule 26.8(c), Ariz. R. Crim. P., based on the defendant’s allegations that it contained incorrect information?


2 CA-CR 2006-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER JOSEPH VISCONTI, IV  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0059
2 CA-CR 2006-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY NOEM VETA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNIE CHANDLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0071
2 CA-CR 2006-0075-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TROY ALEXANDER BERTLING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0075-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEMON MONTREA JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0079
Issues Summary: 1. Did a police officer conducting a traffic stop reasonably suspect a passenger was armed and dangerous, thereby allowing the officer to perform a pat-down search of that passenger under the rule announced in Arizona v. Johnson, ___ U.S. ___, 129 S. Ct. 781, 788 (2009)? 2. Does article II, § 8 of the Arizona Constitution provide greater protection to automobile passengers than does the United States Constitution so that an officer conducting a traffic stop may not question a passenger about matters unrelated to the stop and may not perform a pat-down search of a passenger absent a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity and reason to suspect that the passenger is armed and dangerous? 3. Did the trial court commit structural error when it gave the reasonable doubt jury instruction mandated by State v. Portillo, 182 Ariz. 592, 898 P.2d 970 (1995)? 4. Was the defendant entitled to have a jury determine whether he had prior felony convictions that were alleged to enhance his sentences?


2 CA-CR 2006-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MARCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0083
2 CA-CR 2006-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN LAGRON PENNINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0087
2 CA-CR 2006-0095  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GILES CONNOLLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0095
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 12-116, which imposes a time-payment fee on those who pay a court-ordered “penalty, fine, or sanction” on an installment basis, apply to a defendant who is ordered to reimburse the county for the costs of attorney fees?


2 CA-CR 2006-0104  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL DEAN SCHLOBOM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0104
2 CA-CR 2006-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUANITA ROSARIO MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0107
2 CA-CR 2006-0113  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEBRA LYNN VENABLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0113
2 CA-CR 2006-0115  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOEL ALEJANDRO ALCAREZ-GUERRERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0115
2 CA-CR 2006-0117  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY CARLOS MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0117
2 CA-CR 2006-0121  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEY DOMINIC WILLCUTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0121
2 CA-CR 2006-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO CUEVAS GALLEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0133
2 CA-CR 2006-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL WAYNE MULLICAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0148
2 CA-CR 2006-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER CRUZ CUEVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0157
Issues Summary: In granting a defendant’s motion to suppress evidence stemming from a traffic stop, did the trial court err in determining A.R.S. § 28-751(2), which requires a driver turning left to turn, “[i]f practicable,” into the “left lane immediately available” in the street onto which he or she is turning, means the turn need not be made to the median lane?


2 CA-CR 2006-0159-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0159-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0167-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERNIE LEE DURAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0167-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0173-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOSEPH BENGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0173-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0175-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BEATRIZ AURORA BLACKWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0175-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE WILLIAM McLEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0177
2 CA-CR 2006-0179  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE BRIAN CARR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0179
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in admitting urine test evidence at appellant’s probation revocation proceeding over his objections based on reliability and chain of custody?

2. Did the admission of written urinalysis results without requiring a laboratory employee to testify and be cross-examined violate appellant’s Sixth Amendment confrontation rights as interpreted in Crawford v. Washington?


2 CA-CR 2006-0183  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DEAN McCOY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0183
2 CA-CR 2006-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANNON JANE PARKS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0187
2 CA-CR 2006-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY COLMENERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0189
2 CA-CR 2006-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE Y. SPERLE; ROBERT BRYAN CLEERE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0197
2 CA-CR 2006-0203  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL MANUEL DIXON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0203
Issues Summary: Is evidence of accidental loss or inadvertence by a property owner required to support a conviction for theft of lost or misdelivered property in violation of A.R.S. § 13-1814(A)(4)?


2 CA-CR 2006-0207-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEE McCLAIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0207-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER OSWALDO COOPER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0211
2 CA-CR 2006-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADLEY ALAN SCHWARTZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0213
2 CA-CR 2006-0217  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHON JOEL MICHITSCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0217
2 CA-CR 2006-0225-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY DALE INGMIRE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0225-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDRA PALMA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0249-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT GAMEZ SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0249-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAYTON LEE HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0253
2 CA-CR 2006-0268  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE CARLOS CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0268
2 CA-CR 2006-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0269
2 CA-CR 2006-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0270
2 CA-CR 2006-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORLANDO J. MENDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0273
2 CA-CR 2006-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG ANTHONY ROHLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0275
2 CA-CR 2006-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME MURIETTA GOMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0285
2 CA-CR 2006-0287-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CLAUDE DANIELS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0287-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK STEPHEN BRASHIER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0307  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMMANUEL ROBLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0307
2 CA-CR 2006-0309-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY S. MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0309-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0310-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERALD RAYMOND WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0310-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0313-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDOLPH CHARLES ARENAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0313-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0321-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERNARD ERNEST COLONNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0321-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0333-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY ALLEN HINES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0333-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR JACQUES ORTIZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0335
2 CA-CR 2006-0337  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOHN MAURER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0337
2 CA-CR 2006-0339-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KUSHAWN LAMONT PITTMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0339-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0349-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCIS JOSEPH FLAHERTY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0349-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER GARDUNO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MASUM JAMES VIJAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADRIAN AGUILAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0365
2 CA-CR 2006-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ADRIAN JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0381
2 CA-CR 2006-0385-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENE WALTER KLINK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0385-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0395-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTOFER ROBIN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0395-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL MORRIS BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0399
2 CA-CR 2006-0405-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEOFFREY CLARK HUNTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0405-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0417-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY WEST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0417-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0421  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY JOE MIRAMONTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0421
2 CA-CR 2006-0423-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES EARL FOX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0423-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0425-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMALE MICHAEL CAREY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0425-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0431-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LACY RIDDELL, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0431-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0439-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EDWARD COX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0439-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0445  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRELL RENNELL STEPHNEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0445
2 CA-CR 2007-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD DINO SHAW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0015-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL JESUS CORDOVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0015-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0019-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARL LOUIS GUILLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0019-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0033-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RADFORD DARRELL SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0033-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LETICIA VILLAREAL GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0036
2 CA-CR 2007-0039-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD PATRICK VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0039-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN AUGUSTA COLLINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0045
2 CA-CR 2007-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXIS GUILLERMO TELLEZ-SUAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0059-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDY T. CISNEROS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0059-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK JOSEPH SARULLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0065
Issues Summary: 1. Whether burglary and theft convictions violated the corpus delicti rule when the only direct evidence was the defendant’s confession but the state presented uncontradicted evidence of closely related crimes. 2. Whether for the purposes of burglary and theft convictions the defendant had the requisite intent to permanently deprive the victim of property when he testified he did not intend to keep the victim’s stolen revolver, but to kill himself in front of her with it. 3. Whether all occupants of a home are victims of a burglary for purposes of Arizona’s Victim Witness Protection Act.


2 CA-CR 2007-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW MICHAEL PERALTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0067
2 CA-CR 2007-0077  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON AMARO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0077
2 CA-CR 2007-0088  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0088
2 CA-CR 2007-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0123-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUPERT RAY DIXON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0123-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0131-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NAOMIS WINFREY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0131-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE SIERRA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0133
2 CA-CR 2007-0136  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY DWAYNE SKAGGS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0136
2 CA-CR 2007-0142-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE EDUVIJES BEJARANO, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0142-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0165-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ERIC STOKES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0165-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0223  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARNEST LEE BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0223
2 CA-CR 2007-0245  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMONA LEE CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0245
2 CA-CR 2007-0255  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE DWAYNE FLEMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0255
2 CA-CR 2007-0257  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0257
2 CA-CR 2007-0281  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL MARIO RIVADENEYRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0281
2 CA-CR 2007-0283  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY KING HUTCHINSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0283
2 CA-CR 2007-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEREK ALBERT CARPENTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0287
2 CA-CR 2007-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BLANCA BATISTA HANS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0289
2 CA-CR 2007-0301  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0301
2 CA-CR 2007-0309  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL DANIEL MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0309
2 CA-CR 2007-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY RUSHING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GIOVANNI ROGERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0347
2 CA-CR 2007-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO ROBERTO ZEPEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0351
2 CA-CR 2007-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL FRANCISCO VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0363
2 CA-CR 2007-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO GALAVIZ FIERRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0369
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court abused its discretion by giving a “deliberate ignorance” jury instruction where the defendant had admitted knowing he was transporting “drugs” but denied knowing his cargo was marijuana and his primary defense at trial was that the state failed to prove the mens rea element for the offense of transporting marijuana for sale under A.R.S. § 13-3405.


2 CA-CR 2007-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABRAAN RENE ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0375
2 CA-CR 2007-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CEDRICK DWAYNE JONES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0381
2 CA-CR 2007-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VLADIMIR GARCIA SOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0383
2 CA-CR 2007-0387  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL MONTOYA TORRES, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0387
2 CA-CR 2007-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS MARTIN SANDOVAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0389
2 CA-CR 2007-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIARON GERMAIN ROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0392
2 CA-CR 2007-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ANGEL ROBLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0393
2 CA-CR 2007-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GALLETLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0395
2 CA-CR 2007-0397  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUILLERMO CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0397
2 CA-CR 2007-0401-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS SCOTT PERRIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0401-PR
Issues Summary: Whether a trial court may use the “catch-all” aggravator in former A.R.S. § 13-702(D)(13) as one of the two aggravating factors necessary to impose a substantially aggravated sentence under former A.R.S. § 13-702.01(A) in light of the supreme court’s opinion in State v. Schmidt, 220 Ariz. 563, 208 P.3d 214 (2009).


2 CA-CR 2007-0403  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ENRIQUE ORTEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0403
Issues Summary: (1) Whether molestation of a child is a lesser included offense of sexual conduct with a minor under fifteen years of age and whether the Double Jeopardy Clauses of the United States and Arizona Constitutions consequently prohibit a defendant from being convicted of both.

(2) Whether the state exerted improper influence over the testimony of a witness.


2 CA-CR 2007-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FREDERICK LEWIS NICHOLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0409
2 CA-CR 2008-0009  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0009
2 CA-CR 2008-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DYLAN CARTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0013
2 CA-CR 2008-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY RAMSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0014
2 CA-CR 2008-0017  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL WESLEY BARBER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0017
2 CA-CR 2008-0020  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY DEAN GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0020
2 CA-CR 2008-0023-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL EDWARD SOUZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0023-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW LEE NEWTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0029
2 CA-CR 2008-0033  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL CORDOVA BALTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0033
2 CA-CR 2008-0043-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT EVANS-GOODIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0043-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0069  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN ROCKY ACUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0069
2 CA-CR 2008-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ANTHONY TEMBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0079
2 CA-CR 2008-0085-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK FILLMORE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0085-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY VEAMATAHAU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0093
2 CA-CR 2008-0099-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY P. VANDERSOMMEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0099-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0100  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA PAUL EUGENE HUFFMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0100
Issues Summary: Whether a third trial, after the two previous trials ended in hung juries, violated defendant’s double jeopardy and due process rights under the United States and Arizona Constitutions.


2 CA-CR 2008-0103  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE GUADALUPE ORANTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0103
2 CA-CR 2008-0105  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEE HOLMAN LACEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0105
2 CA-CR 2008-0125  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALFREDO JIMENEZ-BRACAMONTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0125
2 CA-CR 2008-0130  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS RAFAEL MURO-MONGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0130
2 CA-CR 2008-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GEORGATOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0133
2 CA-CR 2008-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLARENCE NMN HORTON III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0139-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON RAY TYLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0139-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL CARRISOZA RIVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP JAIME ARAGON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0149
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s request for a continuance to allow time for private counsel to be substituted for appointed counsel and prepare for trial?


2 CA-CR 2008-0151  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEOFFREY AARON HOWERTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0151
2 CA-CR 2008-0153  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK CRUZ RUIZ, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0153
2 CA-CR 2008-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINA MARIE LOCKWOOD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0157
Issues Summary: Is a stillborn fetus a “dead human body” for the purposes of A.R.S. § 13-2926, which prohibits the abandonment or concealment of human remains?


2 CA-CR 2008-0163-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH T. DRAYTON II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0163-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0169  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENTE RAYMOND ROSAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0169
2 CA-CR 2008-0173  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STACEE RENE WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0173
2 CA-CR 2008-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ARIEL ZACARIAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0187
2 CA-CR 2008-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ANGEL MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0189
2 CA-CR 2008-0196  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARION L. HAMPTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0196
2 CA-CR 2008-0197-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON ANTONIO BEALE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0197-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0198-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON ANTONIO BEALE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0198-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTHUR FREDRIC GERTH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0203-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL JAMES PORTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0203-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0204  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME MATA BRACAMONTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0204
2 CA-CR 2008-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR ROLANDO TERRAZAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0207
2 CA-CR 2008-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO GONZALEZ-VALDIVIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0211
2 CA-CR 2008-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO IMPERIAL VEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD ABRAN MOLINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0222
2 CA-CR 2008-0224  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RYAN ROBERT BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0224
2 CA-CR 2008-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORVIE ROWLAND STRECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0226
Issues Summary: 1. Is a tractor a means of transportation for purposes of A.R.S. § 13-1814? 2. Are a victim’s travel costs incurred in investigating stolen property compensable expenses?


2 CA-CR 2008-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LYNDALL DWAIN THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0236
2 CA-CR 2008-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY WAYNE SHAW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0237
2 CA-CR 2008-0239  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO ARNULFO TREJO, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0239
2 CA-CR 2008-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ALLEN LEBOVITZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MIGUEL LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0247  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARBARA LYNN WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0247
2 CA-CR 2008-0255  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARLO ALONSO MONTANO-AROCHI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0255
2 CA-CR 2008-0257-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN ALLEN BRUNI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0257-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS PUENTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LEE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ZACKARIAH THOMAS WAGGONER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0275
2 CA-CR 2008-0279  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHAD LUCAS HARRISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0279
2 CA-CR 2008-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO SOTELO ENCINAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0285
2 CA-CR 2008-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER LEE WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0287
2 CA-CR 2008-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICENTE MURRIETA MELENDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0289
2 CA-CR 2008-0295  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DURRELL JAMAL EDWARDS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0295
2 CA-CR 2008-0297  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID WAYNE PATE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0297
2 CA-CR 2008-0299  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY POTTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0299
2 CA-CR 2008-0301-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER J. VAN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0301-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEE MAXIMILLION HUNT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0319-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EUGENE BARNES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0319-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0327  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0327
2 CA-CR 2008-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS ASHTON CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0328
2 CA-CR 2008-0330  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON MICHAEL PATROU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0330
2 CA-CR 2008-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CYNTHIA D. JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0335
2 CA-CR 2008-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS SCOTT BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0338
2 CA-CR 2008-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MAXAMILANO PAREDES-SOLANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0341
Issues Summary: (1) Whether subsections (A)(1) and (A)(2) of A.R.S. § 13-3553 define multiple ways of committing a single offense or distinct offenses that cannot be combined in a single count of an indictment; (2) whether counts one and two of the indictment in this case are duplicitous; (3) whether the jury instructions regarding counts one and two resulted in duplicitous charges by permitting potentially nonunanimous verdicts; and (4) whether the defendant was entitled to an instruction on jury nullification.


2 CA-CR 2008-0343-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONTE EUGENE JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0343-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0351-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0351-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0355-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PARVIS JOHNNARY FIALLOS-RIVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0355-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0363-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY LEE WASHINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0363-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0365-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS RAFAEL MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0365-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER ORTEGA LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0371
2 CA-CR 2008-0373  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUADALUPE GONZALEZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0373
2 CA-CR 2008-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLIVER MICHAEL PRYOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0375
2 CA-CR 2008-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ROLLAND PRITCHARD, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0379
2 CA-CR 2008-0385  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE MIGUEL HARO-ARCE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0385
2 CA-CR 2008-0386  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO AMAYA RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0386
2 CA-CR 2008-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROMAN ALFONSO LOPEZ-VALLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0388
2 CA-CR 2008-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GABRIEL PESQUEIRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0390
2 CA-CR 2008-0391  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES R. PINSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0391
2 CA-CR 2008-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROSARIO CRUZ-SAUCEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0393
2 CA-CR 2008-0408  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS LEE HOSKINSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0408
2 CA-CR 2008-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANFORD LAMAR FERRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0411
2 CA-CR 2008-0415  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CONSALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0415
2 CA-CR 2008-0419  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY LEE NELSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0419
2 CA-CR 2008-0423-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH ANTHONY OCHOA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0423-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0425  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS M. MURPHY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0425
2 CA-CR 2008-0427  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY WAYNE HAMILTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0427
2 CA-CR 2009-0001  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS ANTONIO FELIX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0001
2 CA-CR 2009-0007  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVIN CHESTER HILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0007
2 CA-CR 2009-0012-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEON WAGGONER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0012-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN CONDIDO RIVERA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0015
2 CA-CR 2009-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS ADRIAN CANALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0023
Issues Summary: When a police officer blocks in another vehicle with his patrol car, does this constitute a detention for Fourth Amendment purposes? Is an anonymous tip about “possible” criminal activity sufficiently reliable to support reasonable suspicion to make such a detention?


2 CA-CR 2009-0027  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OCTAVIO MANUEL SANCHEZ LUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0027
2 CA-CR 2009-0029-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KELLY SCOT KLEINSCHMIDT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0029-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0037-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN GAVINO GUZMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0037-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE W. ADAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0038
2 CA-CR 2009-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRENT ALLEN MULVANEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0039
2 CA-CR 2009-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENDA LORRAINE RUMSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0041
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred by not suppressing evidence of blood-test results after concluding the defendant’s right to counsel had been violated at the time the blood draw occurred.


2 CA-CR 2009-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMY LEON ALEXANDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0057  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMIAH NICHOLAS CARLOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0057
2 CA-CR 2009-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN A. CHRISTIAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0061
2 CA-CR 2009-0062  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NETZAHUALCOYOTL G. RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0062
2 CA-CR 2009-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MICHAEL HARPER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYALLEN HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0064
2 CA-CR 2009-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY FIGUEROA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0068
2 CA-CR 2009-0075  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO SAENZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0075
2 CA-CR 2009-0077  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE GERARDO SAAVEDRA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0077
2 CA-CR 2009-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY LEE ARCHIE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0079
2 CA-CR 2009-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL MATA-CAMACHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0087
2 CA-CR 2009-0088-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONAH PARKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARNEST LEE BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0090  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL DAVID WINDSOR, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0090
Issues Summary: Does downloading an image from a remote computer via the Internet constitute “duplicating” it for the purposes of A.R.S. § 13-3553(A)(1), prohibiting the sexual exploitation of minors?


2 CA-CR 2009-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESTEBAN JUAN PRICE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0093
2 CA-CR 2009-0095  STATE OF ARIZONA v. XAVIER ROBERTO ARVIZU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0095
2 CA-CR 2009-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HOWARD NED McMONIGAL III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0099
2 CA-CR 2009-0101  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TAMMI MARIE EDMONDS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0101
2 CA-CR 2009-0103  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IVAN CHAPARRO GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0103
2 CA-CR 2009-0105-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FELIPE GABRIEL SAMANIEGO LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0105-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0110  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CASSIUS CLAYTON WHITEHEAD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0110
2 CA-CR 2009-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR OMAR MELGAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0112
2 CA-CR 2009-0113  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT VINCENT INIGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0113
2 CA-CR 2009-0114  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL DANIEL LEAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0114
2 CA-CR 2009-0125  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DETRICK RAY SIMMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0125
2 CA-CR 2009-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL JAMES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS BERT JORGENSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0135  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS McARTHUR SKINNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0135
2 CA-CR 2009-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTINA MARIE HANLON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0137
2 CA-CR 2009-0138  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MILES L. KAUFMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0138
2 CA-CR 2009-0141  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS ALVIN YOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0141
2 CA-CR 2009-0143  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CIRILO PEDRO MACIAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0143
2 CA-CR 2009-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ALLISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0145-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERALD L. SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0145-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0147-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNEST RUSHING, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0147-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0152-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD I. VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0152-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP JOHN CORTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0157
2 CA-CR 2009-0163  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY PELLICER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0163
2 CA-CR 2009-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW DEAN NORZAGARAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0167
2 CA-CR 2009-0173  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ZACHARY M. WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0173
2 CA-CR 2009-0174-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE HUMBERTO VEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0174-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0175-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMMIE LEVIE POWERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0175-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN MANNIE BLAKLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0176
Issues Summary: Were the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights violated when the police officer entered an area of the driveway not ordinarily accessed by the public in order to conduct his investigation without a warrant?


2 CA-CR 2009-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY FARRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0183  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL SANTAMARIA BONILLAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0183
2 CA-CR 2009-0187-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS BORREGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0187-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LIONEL VALENZUELA PEREIDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0191
2 CA-CR 2009-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD LEE McMAHAN II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0193
2 CA-CR 2009-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0209
2 CA-CR 2009-0211-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER CRUZ FIGUEROA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0211-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0213-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0213-PR
Issues Summary: In a proceeding governed by Rule 32, Ariz. R. Crim. P., did the trial court abuse its discretion in declining to consider claims of ineffective assistance of trial and appellate counsel raised for the first time in the petitioner’s reply brief?


2 CA-CR 2009-0214-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLE ANTOINETTE MOTEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0214-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0221  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN ARTHUR YO-JIMBO RAMIL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0221
2 CA-CR 2009-0227-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANLEY WADE STARR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0227-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0228  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN IGNACIO MARQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0228
2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BURRELL RICO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HANSEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0233
2 CA-CR 2009-0240-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALONZO JAMERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0240-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE MARTINEZ CORELLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0241
2 CA-CR 2009-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRACY SCOTT WEAVER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0249-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MITCHELL NELSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0249-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0251  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DANIEL COMSTOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0251
2 CA-CR 2009-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADALBERTO MURGUIA-RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0253
2 CA-CR 2009-0257-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD PAUL MIGUEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0257-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELBOURNE ROBERT AMES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENNIE CRUZ MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0263
2 CA-CR 2009-0271  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY S. SCROGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0271
2 CA-CR 2009-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. XRISTOS A. MAGOULAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0273
2 CA-CR 2009-0275-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN D. SZPYRKA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0275-PR
Issues Summary: When a defendant’s sentence pursuant to a plea agreement was enhanced by a prior conviction that was subsequently vacated, is the defendant entitled to be resentenced as a nonrepetitive offender? Under such circumstances, where the enhancement was an integral part of the plea, do double jeopardy principles preclude vacating the plea agreement?


2 CA-CR 2009-0277  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES A. ROGERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0277
Issues Summary: (1) Whether the surcharge under A.R.S. § 16-954(C) is mandatory, and (2) whether it is imposed only on the penalty assessments imposed under A.R.S. § 12-116.01 or also on the underlying fine?


2 CA-CR 2009-0283  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON LEE ALMODOVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0283
2 CA-CR 2009-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LESLIE ANN GUARISCO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0285
2 CA-CR 2009-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN JESSIE MUNIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0289
2 CA-CR 2009-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CURTIS SIMMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0295-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERROD ROSS McBRIDE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0295-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0297  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY DAVID TAMPLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0297
2 CA-CR 2009-0301-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY LEE WASHINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0301-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JOSEPH STRINGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0303-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0305-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER MASSINGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0305-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG A. ROHLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN PATRICK KELLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0310
2 CA-CR 2009-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT ALLEN KING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0311
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in 1) admitting in-court and videotaped demonstration evidence; 2) instructing the jury on accomplice liability; and 3) denying King’s motion to dismiss the dangerous-nature allegation?


2 CA-CR 2009-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM DUTCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMILY ROSE ADAPTAR RIOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0319
2 CA-CR 2009-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHEYENNE NATHANIEL BARBER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0329
2 CA-CR 2009-0331  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER ALEXANDER GRAHAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0331
2 CA-CR 2009-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL SOSA MUNIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0335
2 CA-CR 2009-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY ALAN MASON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0341
2 CA-CR 2009-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY JOE LAINHART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0347
2 CA-CR 2009-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD JOSEPH COATES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0351
2 CA-CR 2009-0355  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD ROMERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0355
2 CA-CR 2009-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT R. LOAIZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADRIAN CHRISTOPHER GONZALES, II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0363
2 CA-CR 2009-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO OMAR GALINDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0365
2 CA-CR 2009-0367-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMMY ANTHONY CASTILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0367-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CHARLES TUCCIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0369
2 CA-CR 2009-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIA JESUS AMAVIZCA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0371
2 CA-CR 2009-0373  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIUS KEON BYNUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0373
2 CA-CR 2009-0375-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0375-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0377-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MATTHEWSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0377-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SARAH MELISSA RHINEHART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0379
2 CA-CR 2009-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO VIRGEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0381
2 CA-CR 2009-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROSARIO IGNACIO SOTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0383
2 CA-CR 2009-0385  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD M. SCHERT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0385
2 CA-CR 2009-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN MITCHELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0388-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LEE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0388-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONY MATUL SARAT-ROJOP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0389
2 CA-CR 2009-0393-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL JOAQUIN ALVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0393-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0397  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JAMES POTTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0397
2 CA-CR 2009-0401  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR GARCIA DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0401
2 CA-CR 2009-0403  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMIE MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0403
2 CA-CR 2009-0405-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERESA SOBOTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0405-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0407-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARAMI YELVERTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0407-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0411-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARL LOUIS GUILLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0411-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0003-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO MOLINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0003-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT ARVIZO RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0011  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL C. CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0011
2 CA-CR 2010-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE HECTOR SILVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0015
2 CA-CR 2010-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LEE SANTY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0021
2 CA-CR 2010-0022  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL VALENTE PALOMO YESCAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0022
2 CA-CR 2010-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN ALEX SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0023
2 CA-CR 2010-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NESTOR CRISTOBAL SILVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0025
2 CA-CR 2010-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT W. BANKS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0031
2 CA-CR 2010-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALLEN CULBERTSON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0035
2 CA-CR 2010-0049-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0049-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY G. OSSANA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0057  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE CHURCHWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0057
2 CA-CR 2010-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINDA DARLENE GILES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0059
2 CA-CR 2010-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRED AARON ETHRIDGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0061
2 CA-CR 2010-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN SATATHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE GUADALUPE ORANTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD JOHN GARLICK, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0071
2 CA-CR 2010-0077  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABDULKADIR ABDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0077
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in instructing the jury, pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-419, to presume the victim had acted reasonably in defense of his residence?


2 CA-CR 2010-0081  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO TAMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0081
2 CA-CR 2010-0107-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT EDWARD POWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0107-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND KEITH WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0109
2 CA-CR 2010-0110  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAIGE NICOLE HAMRICK-BRADWAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0110
2 CA-CR 2010-0111-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY CONGRESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0111-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL ANGEL ROSAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ANTHONY FIMBREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUNIES A. JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0127  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRY LEE CRUMRINE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0127
2 CA-CR 2010-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARNELL JOSEPH LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0136  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN DAVID SWIHART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0136
2 CA-CR 2010-0137-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KATRINA MARIEL STRAUT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0137-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0141  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN RICHARD EBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0141
Issues Summary: Does this court have jurisdiction over an appeal from a trial de novo in superior court held after an appeal from a conviction in justice court when the appellant raises no issues enumerated in A.R.S. § 22-375(A)?


2 CA-CR 2010-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN MARCOS MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0149
2 CA-CR 2010-0151-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILIP JOHN CORTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0151-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0157-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WILLIAM CAPES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0157-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0159  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISAAC JAMES MARTINEZ, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0159
2 CA-CR 2010-0165-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IAN MICHAEL DAWKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0165-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0169  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WADE ALLEN DUNNING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0169
2 CA-CR 2010-0171  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE E. BRACEY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0171
2 CA-CR 2010-0175  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO JACOB SULE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0175
2 CA-CR 2010-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN S. HUNTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0177
Issues Summary: Whether, in the context of a defendant’s right to a speedy trial, excluded time under Ariz. R. Crim. P. 8.4 runs from the date a motion is filed, or from the date the trial court rules on the motion.


2 CA-CR 2010-0181  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TITO MARTINEZ CERVANTES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0181
2 CA-CR 2010-0183-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY LEE WASHINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0183-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYNALDO O. OBREGON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0186
2 CA-CR 2010-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRED AARON ETHRIDGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0187
2 CA-CR 2010-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REFUGIO RINCON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0191
2 CA-CR 2010-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX JOSEPH PEDRIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER DALE CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0203  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK A. PAYAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0203
2 CA-CR 2010-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER WILLIAM ROSS, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NESTOR MACIELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0221-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND JEFFERY CONROY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0221-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0223-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FREDERICK RAMON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0223-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0227-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0227-PR
Issues Summary: Does the phrase “any time spent . . . incarcerated” as used in the statutory definition of a historical prior felony include preconviction confinement?


2 CA-CR 2010-0235  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY GRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0235
Issues Summary: Whether a conviction for tampering with a witness under A.R.S. § 13-2804 requires proof that a person had actually unlawfully withheld testimony, testified falsely, or failed to obey a summons as a result of the defendant’s conduct.


2 CA-CR 2010-0237-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD E. NORIEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0237-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BIANCA BURGETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0247-PR
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in relying on the presence of children during the commission of the offense as an aggravating circumstance; and 2) did the trial court err in admitting hearsay at the aggravation/mitigation hearing?


2 CA-CR 2010-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDMUNDO RAMON ANDRADE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0253
2 CA-CR 2010-0260  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELIAS PETE OCHOA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0260
2 CA-CR 2010-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCO ANTONIO CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0263
2 CA-CR 2010-0264-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL PIERCE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0264-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ROY PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0265
2 CA-CR 2010-0271-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS L. WOOD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0271-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0275-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TODD RUSSELL YARNES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0275-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0285-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ENRIQUE RUIZ OROZCO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0285-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MAXAMILLANO SOLANO PAREDES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0286
2 CA-CR 2010-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. INELDA ENIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0287
2 CA-CR 2010-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO LONGORIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0293-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY KEVIN OWENS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0293-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0295  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR STEVEN VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0295
2 CA-CR 2010-0319-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY SCOTT ROBERTS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0319-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0321  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELVIA VARELA RUELAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0321
2 CA-CR 2010-0322  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MURITALA OLAYINKA AJIBOYE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0322
2 CA-CR 2010-0331-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL ANTONIO PARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0331-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0342  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCO ERNESTO ACOSTA-GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0342
2 CA-CR 2010-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CARLOS ALVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0343
2 CA-CR 2010-0344  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES WALTER LOUDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0344
2 CA-CR 2010-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ANGEL RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0346
2 CA-CR 2010-0349-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAYTON DANIEL WILLIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0349-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0351-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY LAMAR SIMMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0351-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0352  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARNELL LENTON CLIFTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0352
2 CA-CR 2010-0355-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY SHARIFF GAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0355-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RON ALLEN VANBROCKLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0358  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MAXAMILIANO PAREDES-SOLANO   Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0358
2 CA-CR 2010-0366  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL LUIS GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0366
2 CA-CR 2010-0367-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON JOHNATHAN LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0367-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0370  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTON GEORGE ADAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0370
2 CA-CR 2010-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0374
2 CA-CR 2010-0377-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM DUTCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0377-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0384  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNIE RAY FRANKS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0384
2 CA-CR 2010-0385-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMIE ROSALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0385-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0394  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WENCESLAO MIGUEL CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0394
2 CA-CR 2010-0399-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLIVER MICHAEL PRYOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0399-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0401-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES MONTE REESE, II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0401-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0406  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH A. MAVERICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0406
2 CA-CR 2010-0409-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL BALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0409-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0416  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM BERNARD HIPP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0416
2 CA-CR 2011-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISMAEL PADILLA-CONTRERAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0004
2 CA-CR 2011-0008  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARELL SCORPIO SMITH, DARRIN NOLAN SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0008
2 CA-CR 2011-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID BERNARD CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0015-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EUGENE YODER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0015-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0019-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNOLD LESTER GEIB  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0019-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0024
2 CA-CR 2011-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO OMAR GALINDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMETRIO LOPEZ-DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0036
2 CA-CR 2011-0041-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0041-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0057-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVIN CHESTER HILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0057-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINDA ANN SIPLIVY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0064
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in failing to place the defendant on mandatory probation pursuant to

A.R.S. § 13-901.01 for the six non-methamphetamine offenses of which she was convicted.


2 CA-CR 2011-0067-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER B. HOWARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0067-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALGER FREDERICK HELLARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0068
2 CA-CR 2011-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD JOHN SANDERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ALAN MIRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0074
2 CA-CR 2011-0082  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICIA JOYCE LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0082
2 CA-CR 2011-0086  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA BARELA MINJARES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0086
2 CA-CR 2011-0087-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID GLEN MILLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0087-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0088-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD LOPEZ DE LA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0092  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SUSAN MICHELLE TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0092
2 CA-CR 2011-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON LIMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0098
Issues Summary: Does this court have jurisdiction over the state’s appeal from the trial court’s order granting a motion to suppress where the state filed its notice of appeal: 1) more than twenty days after the court’s order granting the motion to suppress, 2) less than twenty days after the court’s denial of a motion to reconsider that ruling, and 3) prior to the court’s granting the state’s motion to dismiss the case without prejudice for purposes of appeal?


2 CA-CR 2011-0099-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD E. NORIEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0099-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0100  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN LEVI BLACK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0100
2 CA-CR 2011-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRINIDAD ALBERTO INCLAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0102
2 CA-CR 2011-0108  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SHANE GILES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0108
2 CA-CR 2011-0110  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK LEO EPPLER, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0110
2 CA-CR 2011-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL YSEA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0112
2 CA-CR 2011-0114-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ENRIQUE MONTIJO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0114-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER MASSINGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE NORMAN CALLISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0120-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0121-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GERARDO VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0121-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0122-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUSTAVO ANTONIO SALMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0122-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON RAYMOND FIKES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0124
Issues Summary: May a police officer obtain reasonable suspicion to perform an investigatory stop of an automobile based solely on the fact that one of multiple brake lights is not working?


2 CA-CR 2011-0128  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO C. OCHOA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0128
2 CA-CR 2011-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD JOE GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0130-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE GERARDO GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0130-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0132  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL EDUARDO MEJIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0132
2 CA-CR 2011-0134  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOREN STOECKEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0134
2 CA-CR 2011-0138-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY WAYNE HARMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0138-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0146  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARION AUQUORA PENN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0146
2 CA-CR 2011-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0158
2 CA-CR 2011-0166-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES EDWARD FLOWERS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0166-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0168  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO JOSE CARRILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0168
2 CA-CR 2011-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL EDUARDO CANEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0172
2 CA-CR 2011-0174  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALFRED GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0174
2 CA-CR 2011-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD HUGH WADLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0176
2 CA-CR 2011-0178  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN ARMANDO HERRERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0178
2 CA-CR 2011-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHILOE DOMINIQUE ESPINOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0182
2 CA-CR 2011-0184  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON DELGADO SAGASTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0184
2 CA-CR 2011-0196-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DONNELL DUNLAP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0196-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0200  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY FLYNN WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0200
2 CA-CR 2011-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LUIS DORAME  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0202
2 CA-CR 2011-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RACHEL HENDRICKS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0206
2 CA-CR 2011-0210-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE CHIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0210-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0212-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERICK JAMES SPENCER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0212-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE SANTOS ARTIAGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0230-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS OAKES WATSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0230-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0232-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT ALLEN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0232-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0240  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIN ELIZABETH MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0240
2 CA-CR 2011-0242  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0242
2 CA-CR 2011-0248-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL KEON CURTIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0248-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0250  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL DAVID NUNEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0250
2 CA-CR 2011-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN RANDY PERKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0256
2 CA-CR 2011-0262-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANYELLE DESHAWN CLAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0262-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0266  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EUGENIO JIMENEZ NORZAGARAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0266
2 CA-CR 2011-0268  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PATRICK GUMP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0268
2 CA-CR 2011-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT ROBERT GAXIOLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0270
2 CA-CR 2011-0272  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON RICHARD MARBLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0272
2 CA-CR 2011-0280  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CHRISTOPHER DALE V.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0280
2 CA-CR 2011-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS YANEZ PEYRON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0286
2 CA-CR 2011-0288-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0288-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0292  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO BERNAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0292
2 CA-CR 2011-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN HENRY TYAU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0296-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY ALLEN BEVEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0296-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0300-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0300-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0304  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL LESTER GARRELS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0304
2 CA-CR 2011-0310-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS MOYERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0310-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0312  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SUSAN FINSTERER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0312
2 CA-CR 2011-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICIA LYNNE ROHRSCHNEIDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0314
2 CA-CR 2011-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY CURTIS GIBBINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0324  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NEAL JAMES ROLF  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0324
2 CA-CR 2011-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN PEDRO LEON ABREGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0332
2 CA-CR 2011-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AJELINA LOUISE ROTH LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0334
2 CA-CR 2011-0336  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUSTIN ALLEN BRAMLETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0336
2 CA-CR 2011-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCUS DAVID JARRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0348
2 CA-CR 2011-0350  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK GABRIEL CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0350
2 CA-CR 2011-0352  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH DAVID BROMLEY SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0352
2 CA-CR 2011-0354  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON LEE TUCKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0354
2 CA-CR 2011-0360  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONDRIC D. DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0360
2 CA-CR 2011-0364-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO VASQUEZ CELAYA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0364-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0370  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON LAMONT WILMORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0370
2 CA-CR 2011-0372-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS LEYVA SANTA MARIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0372-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON MENDOZA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0374
2 CA-CR 2011-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMMAR DEAN HALLOUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0380-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARVIZU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0380-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDRE T. LIGHTSEY-COPELAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0389
2 CA-CR 2011-0392-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY HARPER-BURTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0392-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA MICHAEL LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0395
2 CA-CR 2011-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH EDWARD CAMARGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0399
2 CA-CR 2011-0400  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN ANTHONY BONIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0400
2 CA-CR 2011-0402-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO SAENZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0402-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0404-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE TASHQUINTH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0404-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0004-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL MATA-CAMACHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0004-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0008  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON ANTHONY YANCEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0008
2 CA-CR 2012-0010  STATE OF ARIZONA v BILLY WAYNE TOLLISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0010
2 CA-CR 2012-0012  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID O. SOTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0012
2 CA-CR 2012-0018  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON MIGUEL ANGEL MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0018
2 CA-CR 2012-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL HINOJOSA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0026
2 CA-CR 2012-0037  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JENNIFER MICHELLE SNOUFFER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0037
2 CA-CR 2012-0044-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNARY NOP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0044-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0048-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL OQUITA GUTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0048-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0054  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KIMBERLY DIANE DEGEER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0054
2 CA-CR 2012-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIE EDWARD LOWERY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0064
2 CA-CR 2012-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE OWEN PENNINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0070
2 CA-CR 2012-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO MARTIN FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0074
2 CA-CR 2012-0078-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOMINADOR MEJORADA MALIC III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0078-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0080-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC LANOUE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0080-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0082-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERMAN SALAZAR MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0082-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0084  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TONY CRUZ, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0084
2 CA-CR 2012-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANFORD LAMAR FERRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0092-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD ABRAN MOLINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0092-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES DAVID WOMBLE II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0096
2 CA-CR 2012-0106-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT DAVID SERPA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0106-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0112-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA W. POLSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0112-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA ALEXIS REED  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0122
2 CA-CR 2012-0127  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN REY MONTANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0127
2 CA-CR 2012-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN ALLEN BRUNI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0130-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DALE HIGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0130-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0132-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMITY FRANCES ESBROOK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0132-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP WAYNE JORDAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0140-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD LEE CORBIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0140-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0142-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY GRANT TRIMBLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0142-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0150-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEWART BRADLEY GREEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0150-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN VICTOR MELCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0158
2 CA-CR 2012-0162  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTELLA BRANDENBURG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0162
2 CA-CR 2012-0168-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SCOTT KILGORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0168-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0176-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLYDE RAYMOND GABEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0176-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREA JOSEPHINE SIMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0188
2 CA-CR 2012-0193-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON DEJESUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0193-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0198-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0198-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0202-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUSTIN JAY JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0202-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE RAYMAUNDO FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0211
2 CA-CR 2012-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON MICHAEL WILSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0221-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON LAWRENCE SHARP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0221-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0224-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS ELVEN WAY SPEAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0224-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ALBERTO CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0230
2 CA-CR 2012-0238-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN JACKSON COTTRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0238-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0240-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON ANTHONY SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0240-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0252-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GINO SALVATORE GAGLIARDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0252-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESTLEY VANCE HASKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0260-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO MUNOZ RANDALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0260-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0264-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM DUTCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0264-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO MICHAEL TASHQUINTH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0270
2 CA-CR 2012-0278-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VLADIMIR B. RIVERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0278-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0280-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRUCE ALAN WILSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0280-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERMIN ANTONIO DE LA ROSA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0298-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL MICHAEL CAYEROS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0298-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0300
2 CA-CR 2012-0304  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEE MCCLAIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0304
2 CA-CR 2012-0309  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS O. MCCORMICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0309
2 CA-CR 2012-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISAAC CECIL EVANS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0310
2 CA-CR 2012-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALONSO HINOJOSA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0313
2 CA-CR 2012-0319-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WATTERS SOFFEL, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0319-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0321-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0321-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0326-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO GABRIEL VELASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0326-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYRELL KENNETH DEVORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0336  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAREN RENE LAKATOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0336
2 CA-CR 2012-0339-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL COTA MORAGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0339-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0342  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD HERRERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0342
2 CA-CR 2012-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY SHANE DICKEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0346
2 CA-CR 2012-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN CLARK THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0347
2 CA-CR 2012-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ERIC GORMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0351
2 CA-CR 2012-0355  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND JOHN BALLESTEROS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0355
2 CA-CR 2012-0372-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY ROOSEVELT BOLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0372-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0374-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL ANTONIO ACOSTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0374-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY ANDREW KRASSOW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0380
2 CA-CR 2012-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUADALUPE AGUILAR SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0382
2 CA-CR 2012-0384-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL SANTOS SILVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0384-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0390-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL A. ARRIETA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0390-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN NICHOLAS MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0393
2 CA-CR 2012-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE FRANKLIN APOLINAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0395
2 CA-CR 2012-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM ROBERT NUNEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0398
2 CA-CR 2012-0407  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ISMAEL ACOSTA-ALVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0407
2 CA-CR 2012-0423  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY FLYNN WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0423
2 CA-CR 2012-0429  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRYSTAL NADINE GUERRERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0429
2 CA-CR 2012-0432-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANFORD LAMAR FERRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0432-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0435  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEL OSCAR MORANDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0435
2 CA-CR 2012-0441  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMASO ALAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0441
2 CA-CR 2012-0445  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMMY LEE MITCHELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0445
2 CA-CR 2012-0446-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN WILLIAM MANUEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0446-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0462-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENDA LORRAINE RUMSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0462-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0465-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GODOY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0465-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0474-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIA DE LOS ANGELES LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0474-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0481  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMONTE ASKAREE LARUE-FRANKLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0481
2 CA-CR 2012-0486-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHAD LUCAS HARRISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0486-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0488-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS H. SOTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0488-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0493  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALVADOR CELAYA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0493
2 CA-CR 2012-0497  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ASHLEY ELIZABETH LAPPITT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0497
2 CA-CR 2012-0501  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS HAMILTON NEREIM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0501
Issues Summary: Was a police officer’s testimony about a child’s appearance sufficient to sustain the defendant’s convictions of crimes for which the victim’s age was an element of the offense?

Was there sufficient evidence of endangerment to convict the defendant of child abuse when it was established that he had driven with a child in his car while he had a blood alcohol concentration of nearly four times the legal limit, had collided with a police vehicle before being arrested, and had failed three sobriety tests?

Was the jury properly instructed that the crime of child abuse, non-death or serious physical injury, requires the state to prove the “defendant acted under circumstances other than [those] likely to cause death or serious physical injury”?

Were certain of the defendant’s convictions lesser-included offenses of his other convictions and therefore violative of double jeopardy?


2 CA-CR 2012-0511  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELISHA ROBERT EDWARDS III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0511
2 CA-CR 2012-0512-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARY D. RININGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0512-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0514  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW J. SMOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0514
2 CA-CR 2012-0515  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK LYLE BARRICKLOW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0515
2 CA-CR 2012-0516-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REYNALDO LEDESMA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0516-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0019  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA ROSE BEJARANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0019
2 CA-CR 2013-0022-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARBONETTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0022-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BROCK EVERETT ELSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0023
2 CA-CR 2013-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS D. AUSTIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0029
2 CA-CR 2013-0034-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHANITO SALAZAR BACA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0034-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0036-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL JAMES REDDINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0036-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JORDAN FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0042
2 CA-CR 2013-0043  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0043
2 CA-CR 2013-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RASCON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0045
2 CA-CR 2013-0046-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAUL VIRGEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0046-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0050-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON PAUL BIERE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0050-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ALLAN NAIL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0059
2 CA-CR 2013-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL EDUARDO MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0061
2 CA-CR 2013-0075  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD BRIAN SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0075
2 CA-CR 2013-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON MICHAEL KEITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0079
2 CA-CR 2013-0088-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LEON STOKES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0097  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL THOMAS SAABY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0097
2 CA-CR 2013-0104-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN MANUEL REYNOSO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0104-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0113-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNATHON ALLEN STERKESON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0113-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0114-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DANIEL GODINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0114-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS C. RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0122-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LUGO PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0122-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0127-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL ALFARO MERCADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0127-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOB ANTHONY SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0137
2 CA-CR 2013-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE CHAMBERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0139
2 CA-CR 2013-0140-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ULYSSES H. GRANT III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0140-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0145  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO AVILA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0145
2 CA-CR 2013-0151  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY LYNN WATSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0151
2 CA-CR 2013-0153-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD TERRAZAS VILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0153-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0159-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN JESUS LEBARIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0159-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0165  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAMM RUSSELL OLSEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0165
2 CA-CR 2013-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANA CLEMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0173-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SILVA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0173-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0177-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIRIAM MENDIOLA MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0177-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0181-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN MANUEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0181-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0183-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL ANDREW PEREZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0183-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMAR ROSHAUN ATKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0186
2 CA-CR 2013-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH ALONZO MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0187
2 CA-CR 2013-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LESLIE HOLLINGSWORTH, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0203-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH DALE GANN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0203-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LUGO PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MALCOLM FREDDIE RUBIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0207
2 CA-CR 2013-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DONNELL DUNLAP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0217-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO RODRIGUEZ GUTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0217-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SIMON MARTINEZ-ROMERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0223-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MATTHEW EWING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0223-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0229-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMIE LEE FORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0229-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0235-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOELLE SUZANNE WIDDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0235-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CALVIN LAMONT SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0237
2 CA-CR 2013-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0243  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR KYLE LIZARDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0243
2 CA-CR 2013-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS BEVERETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0251-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAREN MARIE HANSEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0251-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0255-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT GALVAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0255-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARY ANN HAAG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN JUNIOR ALVAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0263
2 CA-CR 2013-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTOINNE MAHDI JOLLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0267
2 CA-CR 2013-0271-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAN MONTALVO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0271-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0273-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENITO GIL-MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0273-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0275-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM KENNETH QUALLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0275-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0277-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PERSSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0277-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN BERNARD HORTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0283-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE MICHAEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0283-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0285-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY LEWIS ANGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0285-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM HAYES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0287
2 CA-CR 2013-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0289
2 CA-CR 2013-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CORNELIO BARVA GONZALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0293
2 CA-CR 2013-0297  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE NATALIO JASSO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0297
2 CA-CR 2013-0301-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK DALE CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0301-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0305-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR LINWOOD GILBERT IV  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0305-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0309-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY J. KARPIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0309-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0311-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT E. RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0311-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY MICHAEL GUSTIE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0329-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0329-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0333-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT EDWARD TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0333-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0341-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUALBERTO LOPEZ SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0341-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL HINOJOSA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0343
2 CA-CR 2013-0353-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DELLA LISA VERMUELE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0353-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DWIGHT JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEVERO ANTHONY TORRES, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0363
2 CA-CR 2013-0381-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA MCMURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0381-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0383-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0383-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0385  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD OWEN DOUST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0385
2 CA-CR 2013-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0389-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0389-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LORETO MADUENO-ARCE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0393-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFONSO LOPEZ-MILLAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0393-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0397-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH THOMAS JESSUP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0397-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0401-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ANTONIO GAMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0401-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0421-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERTO GERARDO DELGADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0421-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0423-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EFRIN OSUNA-CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0423-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0425-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID JEROLD SHANK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0425-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0429-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNY ALLEN HALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0429-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0433  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REBECCA SAUCEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0433
2 CA-CR 2013-0439  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMMY-LEE SHANE AMMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0439
2 CA-CR 2013-0443-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0443-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0444-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JAVIER ROMERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0444-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0447-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACKIE L. SCOTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0447-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0449-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN ANTHONY VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0449-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0455-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL LUIS GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0455-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0457-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BRIAN PATTERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0457-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0469-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL EDUARDO GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0469-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0471-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS DELL RADFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0471-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0473-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBY RAY KIRKLAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0473-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0479-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDMUNDO ANDRADE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0479-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0483-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY ESCOBAR,JR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0483-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0489-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JAMES LISKA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0489-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0493-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER RAMON PORTILLO-DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0493-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0497-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARIUS AGBOGHIDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0497-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0499-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO GARZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0499-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0505-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY JOSEPH HAUSNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0505-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0509  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WELLINGTON CURICHIMBA MARIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0509
2 CA-CR 2013-0515  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN ALLEN MCCANN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0515
2 CA-CR 2013-0521  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD RAY SCHULTZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0521
2 CA-CR 2013-0523-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN MATTHEW HELLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0523-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0527-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TONATIHU AGUILAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0527-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0529-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR HUGO HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0529-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0535-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERONICA TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0535-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0539-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARIEL VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0539-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0545-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENT RETURN HOLCOMB  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0545-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0547-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL GREGORY DESKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0547-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0549-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY OWENS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0549-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0555-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAROLD DAVID JONES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0555-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO JOSE CARRILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0003-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0003-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0005  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ARMANDO CORNIDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0005
2 CA-CR 2014-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL BARTON SAMPLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0011-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN KEITH STALLINGS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0011-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NUBIAN TYE HIMBA AMON-RA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0021
2 CA-CR 2014-0023-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM LACKEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0023-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDEE ROBERT VENSOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0049-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAROLD GLEN OVERTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0049-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0057-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CODY LAWRENCE SCOTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0057-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0059-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISIAH ROMONT HILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0059-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL EDUARDO CANEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0071-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0071-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0077-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0077-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0093-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANGELO AMADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0093-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY DELOACH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0155-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD WAYNE HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0155-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0161-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0161-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN DAVID SWIHART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0191-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON MIGUEL ANGEL MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0191-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO MORAGA-PLATT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0213-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES HERBERT BROWN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0213-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMEH BASTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0241-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN MICHAEL PERALTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0241-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0263-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN MATTHEW GILLIAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0263-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0265-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN RAWLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0265-PR
2 CA-CV 2005-0063  BROWN v. McFARLAND  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0063
2 CA-CV 2005-0078  RALPH WILKENS CO., INC. v. DYKES dba PATRICK'S ANTIQUE CARS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0078
2 CA-CV 2005-0093  SAMUEL GEORGE ALVARADO v. SARA JUDITH ALVARADO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0093
2 CA-CV 2005-0134  BEHRENS v. CITY OF CASA GRANDE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0134
2 CA-CV 2005-0155  DEAN v. DEAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0155
2 CA-CV 2006-0017  PAYNE v. ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0017
2 CA-CV 2006-0039  PENNY OSUNA v. WALMART STORES, INC.; SAM'S CLUB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0039
Issues Summary: In an action for breach of employment agreement, where the plaintiff appeals from the trial court grant of defendants’ motion to dismiss claims pled in the original complaint and the denial of her motion to amend her second amended complaint, does this court have jurisdiction over the appeal when the appellant has dismissed without prejudice the only claim pled in her second amended complaint?


2 CA-CV 2006-0051  ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY v. REDLON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0051
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding the State Personnel Board lacked jurisdiction to hear the administrative appeal of a state employee who resigned after being told she would be dismissed if she did not resign immediately?

2. Can the trial court’s dismissal of the employee’s administrative appeal be alternatively upheld on the ground the Personnel Board lacked jurisdiction because the employee’s appeal was untimely?


2 CA-CV 2006-0063  GEHRKE and FINK v. DILLON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0063
2 CA-CV 2006-0075  GORNEY v. MEANEY; RINCON ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES, P.C.   Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0075
Issues Summary: Do the expert opinion requirements of A.R.S. § 12-2603(B) apply to plaintiffs alleging medical malpractice based on lack of informed consent?


2 CA-CV 2006-0095  TWIN PEAKS CONSTRUCTION, INC. v. WEATHERGUARD METAL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0095
Issues Summary: In an administrative action brought by the Registrar of Contractors against a general contractor for failing to pay for services rendered by a subcontractor, does A.R.S. § 32-1153, which bars unlicensed contractors from suing a contracting party, provide the general contractor a defense?


2 CA-CV 2006-0105  EDDY v. STATE OF ARIZONA; DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0105
2 CA-CV 2006-0133  MARTINEZ v. SCHUTT SPORTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0133
2 CA-CV 2006-0136  MACHADO v. MACHADO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0136
2 CA-CV 2006-0149  AIRFREIGHT EXPRESS, LTD. v. EVERGREEN AIR CENTER, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0149
Issues Summary: 1. Where the plaintiff’s claims in a previous action had been dismissed without prejudice, did the trial court err in applying the doctrine of claim preclusion to dismiss those same claims in a subsequent action? 2. Does the doctrine of claim preclusion bar claims based on facts pled as affirmative defenses in a prior action? 3. Did the trial court err in granting the defendant’s motion for summary judgment grounded on a limitation of damages clause in a contract when the plaintiff alleges that clause is unenforceable because the defendant acted in bad faith?


2 CA-CV 2006-0155  COHEN v. FREY, fka COHEN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0155
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court properly dismiss former wife’s partition complaint when the decree dissolving the parties’ marriage permitted husband to “live in the residence for a period of indefinite duration?” 2) Was the language of the decree, incorporating the merged settlement agreement, which permitted the sale of the marital residence for “whatever price” husband desired, susceptible to other than its literal meaning, given other provisions of the decree and the trial court’s duty to divide the property fairly and equitably?


2 CA-CV 2006-0157  HIGGINSON v. CHERNETZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0157
2 CA-CV 2006-0165  G. PUCHI WHOLESALE FOODS CORPORATION and PUCHI v. BOREN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0165
2 CA-CV 2006-0174  COLEMAN v. SLOAN; ALLIANCE IMAGING, INC.; and SIERRA VISTA MEDICAL CENTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0174
2 CA-CV 2006-0178  ARANDA v. CARDENAS, M.D.; NES ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0178
Issues Summary: In an action for the wrongful death of an unborn child, (1) do A.R.S. §§ 25-801 through 25-818, which govern maternity and paternity proceedings, apply to a determination of paternity; and (2) does the plaintiff/putative father or the defendant bear the burden of proving paternity?


2 CA-CV 2006-0185  BOWMAN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS   Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0185
2 CA-CV 2006-0215  WALLACE v. WALLACE nka QUIARAH YUHURU-OHANA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0215
2 CA-CV 2006-0217  CHANCE fka WILES v. WILES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0217
2 CA-CV 2006-0231  FRANCES LOPEZ v. CITY OF ELOY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0231
2 CA-CV 2007-0005  SIMON v. ALBERTSON'S, INC. and COMPASS BANCSHARES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0005
2 CA-CV 2007-0015  LA CHOLLA HILLS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION v. JAMES EDWIN FOARD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0015
2 CA-CV 2007-0033  MEYZLER v. GOROZTHANKINA   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0033
2 CA-CV 2007-0038  ROBERT ALLEN HOKE v. KAROLYN J. MCCONNELL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0038
2 CA-CV 2007-0039  KEN SOZA v. EL JARDIN FLORISTS, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0039
2 CA-CV 2007-0047  MARIA A. KEONJIAN v. TIMOTHY A. OLCOTT, P.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0047
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in holding appellant’s legal malpractice claim barred by the two-year statute of limitations for tort actions and ruling the longer limitations period for contract actions did not apply.


2 CA-CV 2007-0048  NORTHLAND PROMONTORY II, LLC v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0048
2 CA-CV 2007-0055  STEVEN H. SIMON v. SAFEWAY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0055
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying plaintiff’s request to allow additional discovery—functionally a motion under Rule 56(f), Ariz. R. Civ. P.—after finding plaintiff had failed to demonstrate the discovery sought was reasonably likely to yield material evidence?

2) Does a business owner’s nondelegable duty to maintain safe premises encompass the actions of an independent contractor it hires to perform security services on its premises, thus exposing the business owner to vicarious liability?


2 CA-CV 2007-0057  GOODMAN v. CITY OF TUCSON   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0057
2 CA-CV 2007-0069  VERNON WALKER v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0069
2 CA-CV 2007-0077  EQUIFUNDING MICHIGAN, INC. v BETH FORD, PUTZI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0077
2 CA-CV 2007-0080  PIMA COUNTY v. VERNON WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0080
2 CA-CV 2007-0081  PETER WICKRAMASEKERA v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0081
2 CA-CV 2007-0087  LA CEBADILLA ESTATES CORP. v. SISNEROS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0087
2 CA-CV 2007-0095  GLENN HUNTER v. ROSEMARY PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0095
2 CA-CV 2007-0097  CHIQUETTE v. INTERNATIONAL CHURCH OF FOURSQUARE GOSPEL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0097
2 CA-CV 2007-0099  JUNIES JENKINS v. BARBARA ULIBARRI   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0099
2 CA-CV 2007-0115  ALAN W. GILL v. SIERRA FARMING   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0115
2 CA-CV 2007-0117  DENNIS BRODSKY v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0117
Issues Summary: Does the administrative impoundment of a vehicle pursuant to A.R.S. § 28-3511 constitute punishment for double jeopardy purposes, thus barring prosecution of the underlying DUI offense?


2 CA-CV 2007-0121  SHERYL REESE EDWARDS v. ANTHONY A. FUENTES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0121
2 CA-CV 2007-0126  MAYER UNIFIED SCHOOL and GADSEN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL v. WINKLEMAN, AZ STATE LAND DEPT...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0126
Issues Summary: Where plaintiffs argued that highway easements granted without compensation over state trust lands prior to the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Lassen v. Arizona ex rel. Ariz. Highway Dep’t, 385 U.S. 463 (1967), failed to comply with § 28 of the Enabling Act and were therefore void, did the trial court abuse its discretion in finding the claims barred by laches?


2 CA-CV 2007-0141  LUZ MARIA HELLMAN v. MARC RICHARD HELLMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0141
2 CA-CV 2007-0145  NEALE E. SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0145
2 CA-CV 2007-0148  VASQUEZ v. STATE OF AZ.; ST. OF AZ. DEPT. OF PUBLIC SAFETY   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0148
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding insufficient plaintiff’s notice of claim against the state pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-821.01(A) and Deer Valley Unified Sch. Dist. No. 97 v. Houser, 214 Ariz. 293, 152 P.3d 490 (2007)?

2. Did the trial court err in finding neither the state nor the county had any duty to plaintiff, decedent’s mother, to investigate more thoroughly her son’s death or to identify his body before disposing of it?


2 CA-CV 2007-0153  ALVIN S. RATLIFF v. DANIEL M. HARDISON, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0153
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of the plaintiff real estate seller when it found, as a matter of law, that the defendant purchaser anticipatorily repudiated the purchase agreement and did not subsequently retract his repudiation?

2. Does A.R.S. § 33-422 require a seller of real estate to provide an affidavit of disclosure once the buyer has anticipatorily repudiated the purchase agreement?


2 CA-CV 2007-0163  ALTAFFER v. GRAVES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0163
2 CA-CV 2007-0165  McMURRAY v. DREAM CATCHER USA, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0165
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant is a “successful party” and therefore entitled to an award of mandatory attorney fees when a lawsuit brought pursuant to the Purchaser Dwelling Actions Act, A.R.S. §§ 12-1361 through 12-1366, is dismissed without prejudice.


2 CA-CV 2007-0169  RAUL BELTRAN, SR. and ANN BELTRAN v. HARRAH'S ARIZONA CORP.,  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0169
Issues Summary: 1. In a personal injury action against the Ak-Chin Indian Community and its nontribal casino management company, did the superior court err in recognizing for purposes of collateral estoppel a tribal court judgment dismissing plaintiffs’ similar complaint in tribal court despite the judgment’s not having been certified by the superior court clerk under the Arizona Rules of Procedure for Recognition of Tribal Court Civil Judgments? 2. Did the superior court abuse its discretion by recognizing the tribal court judgment as a matter of comity? 3. Could the superior court properly find that issues relating to an indispensable party, sovereign immunity, and the running of the statute of limitations were defensively precluded?


2 CA-CV 2008-0001  GUARDIANSHIP/CONSERVATORSHIP OF ANGELINE SHARKOZY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0001
2 CA-CV 2008-0019  TRIPATI v. MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0019
2 CA-CV 2008-0031  MAUSETH and HOFFMAN; ROSE; TROY v. TUBAC CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0031
2 CA-CV 2008-0041  WOOD v. FITZ-SIMMONS; MEDCHILL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0041
2 CA-CV 2008-0049  WILLIAM ROUSH v. SOUTHERN ARIZONA EAR, NOSE & THROAT...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0049
2 CA-CV 2008-0052  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP v. PACIONI; ESTATE OF KOENIG  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0052
2 CA-CV 2008-0054  GEORGE A. WISE v. BERTRAM POLIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0054
2 CA-CV 2008-0057  ROBERT ANTHONY RUIZ v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0057
2 CA-CV 2008-0059  CHERISE SUZANNE WINDISH v. DAVID KELLOGG WINDISH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0059
2 CA-CV 2008-0063  DEMENT, EDWARDS, EVANS, NORTON v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0063
2 CA-CV 2008-0075  FIA CARD SERVICES v. DOUGLAS B. LEVY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0075
Issues Summary: Whether an arbitration award issued summarily after the defendant failed to timely respond to a notice of arbitration is procured by “undue means,” as contemplated by A.R.S. § 12-1512(A).


2 CA-CV 2008-0076  TADARRYL SMITH v. SITCHEL YEASIN; YELLOW CAB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0076
2 CA-CV 2008-0079  DeSANTIAGO; CASTILLO; SUDDUTH v. PARGAS; DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0079
2 CA-CV 2008-0081  ANTHONY CAMPBELL v. J & T DESERT PROPERTIES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0081
2 CA-CV 2008-0099  JUNIES A. JENKINS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0099
2 CA-CV 2008-0101  ANTANELLE DUWYENIE v. WILLIAM C. MORAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0101
Issues Summary: 1) Under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA), does an Arizona court have jurisdiction to make a custody determination of a child whose home state is Arizona, when an out of state tribal court previously has asserted jurisdiction on grounds not recognized by the UCCJEA and has declined to relinquish such jurisdiction?


2 CA-CV 2008-0103  HUGHES CUSTOM BLDG., LLC; HUGHES and PINERES v. JAMES DAVEY & JAMES DAVEY & ASSOC., INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0103
2 CA-CV 2008-0105  STEPHEN M. SIMI v. NAIMA HANA SIMI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0105
2 CA-CV 2008-0107  JMA INVESTMENTS, LLC v. ALFRED PUCHI; PUCHI PROPERTIES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0107
2 CA-CV 2008-0111  HOLM v. LINCOLN & CONTINENTAL OWNERS CLUB; MATTIX; BLACK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0111
2 CA-CV 2008-0119  ROBERT C. SMITH v. PIMA COUNTY ANIMAL CONTROL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0119
2 CA-CV 2008-0123  SIMONSEN v. ARIZONA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS; STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0123
2 CA-CV 2008-0129  ETZENHOUSER v. BAKER; GJB PROPERTIES; RICHINS; R & M REALTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0129
2 CA-CV 2008-0131  IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF ANGELINE SHARKOZY, DECEASED  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0131
2 CA-CV 2008-0134  ALLAN C. SANCEAU v. DONNA D. SANCEAU  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0134
2 CA-CV 2008-0143  ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY v. PAMELA REDLON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0143
2 CA-CV 2008-0145  JONES, NICHOLS, and HEBERT v. WESTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0145
2 CA-CV 2008-0147  STATE OF ARIZONA ex rel. VANDERVORT v. HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0147
2 CA-CV 2008-0157  MARIPOSA v. LAWYERS TITLE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0157
2 CA-CV 2008-0159  DWAYNE HEAD v. WADE HAYES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0159
2 CA-CV 2008-0166  KUHN v. SMALL; RICHARD M. SMALL FAMILY TRUST; HAUPT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0166
2 CA-CV 2008-0169  CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS v. PAYSON PREMIER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0169
2 CA-CV 2008-0175  AUSTIN v. ARIZONA REGISTRAR OF CONTRACTORS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0175
2 CA-CV 2008-0185  CITY OF SAFFORD v. SEALE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0185
2 CA-CV 2008-0191  ARVIZU v. ARVIZU (MOLINA)  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0191
2 CA-CV 2009-0013  IN RE THE ESTATE OF LOIS A. KNOTT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0013
2 CA-CV 2009-0014  GRAND v. NACCHIO; McMASTER; QWEST COMMUNICATIONS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0014
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in dismissing appellants’ Third Amended Complaint for failure to state a claim of either primary or secondary liability under the Arizona Securities Act?


2 CA-CV 2009-0031  WARD v. CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0031
2 CA-CV 2009-0033  QUINN v. SHERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0033
2 CA-CV 2009-0038  HARRIS v. CITY OF BISBEE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0038
2 CA-CV 2009-0043  HAMMOUDEH, dba CALIFORNIA AUTO MARKET v. JADA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0043
Issues Summary: Whether a party is entitled to an evidentiary hearing before a trial court may strike its pleadings for failure to comply with discovery requests when the party previously has been sanctioned monetarily and personal fault is apparent from the record.


2 CA-CV 2009-0044  ATL, INC. v. A & S PAVING, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0044
2 CA-CV 2009-0047  HERRINGTON; VARGAS v. MINI-SKOOL EARLY LEARNING CENTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0047
2 CA-CV 2009-0057  LEVERAGED LAND, MONTGOMERY v. HODGES; CAIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0057
2 CA-CV 2009-0058  DOUGALL v. DOUGALL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0058
2 CA-CV 2009-0059  BRAILLARD v. MARICOPA COUNTY, MARICOPA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0059
Issues Summary: 1. In a wrongful death and survival action brought by the adult child and estate of a pretrial detainee who died from complications of diabetes which was untreated while she was in custody, did the trial court err in denying defendants’ motion to dismiss the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office as a non-jural entity? 2. Can the violation of an adult child’s right to associate with a parent support a wrongful death claim pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983, absent any official action directed at the parent-child relationship? 3. Did the trial court err in granting defendants’ motions for summary judgment dismissing plaintiff’s § 1983 claims? 4. Do A.R.S. §§ 12-820.04 and 14-3110 preclude awards of punitive damages and damages for pre-death pain and suffering in a § 1983 action? 5. Did the trial court err in denying defendants’ motions for summary judgment dismissing plaintiff’s negligence claims? 6. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in resolving discovery disputes?


2 CA-CV 2009-0061  KASSA v. KASSA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0061
2 CA-CV 2009-0064  JONES v. LUCE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0064
2 CA-CV 2009-0066  SIZER v. SIZER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0066
2 CA-CV 2009-0069  KRUEGER v. DEPT. OF ECONOMIC SECURITY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0069
2 CA-CV 2009-0072  KRASINSKI , JR. v. GOLDSTEIN; GOLDSTEIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0072
2 CA-CV 2009-0081  SOUZA v. SOUZA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0081
2 CA-CV 2009-0082  SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0082
2 CA-CV 2009-0083  PRATT v. PRITZL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0083
2 CA-CV 2009-0089  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP v. FIRST ARIZONA TITLE AGENCY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0089
2 CA-CV 2009-0097  JOY, JR. v. JOY; JOY v. JOY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0097
2 CA-CV 2009-0114  BALLESTEROS v. UNITED AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0114
2 CA-CV 2009-0119  STONERIDGE AT MOUNTAIN VIEW HOMEOWNERS ASSOC. v. THORNTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0119
2 CA-CV 2009-0149  SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON, STATE OF ARIZONA, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0149
2 CA-CV 2009-0158  NATIONAL BANK OF ARIZONA v. LAMB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0158
2 CA-CV 2009-0163  CARDINAL & STACHEL, P.C. v. CURTISS; ESTATE OF LEELA CURTISS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0163
Issues Summary: Whether the attorney fees incurred by one spouse in the course of a dissolution proceeding that does not end in divorce may be characterized as community debt.


2 CA-CV 2009-0171  IN RE SEARCH WARRANT NO. 08 SW 1417  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0171
Issues Summary: A.R.S. § 13-3922 requires a magistrate to “proceed to take testimony” on a motion controverting the grounds of a search warrant, “unless a [forfeiture] proceeding . . . is or has been initiated relating to the same property interest.” Does A.R.S. § 13-3922 divest the court of jurisdiction to decide the motion, or simply preclude the taking of testimony in addressing it?


2 CA-CV 2009-0174  ACOSTA v. PHOENIX INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0174
2 CA-CV 2009-0176  DESERT HERITAGE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0176
2 CA-CV 2009-0178  VAN RAAM v. NICHOLS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0178
2 CA-CV 2009-0183  SAGUARO RESERVE, LLC v. STANTEC CONSULTING, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0183
2 CA-CV 2009-0185  ROBINSON v. KAY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0185
Issues Summary: Does the Court of Appeals have jurisdiction over an appeal from an order certified by the trial court as a final judgment pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., when the order disposes of only one of two legal theories supporting a single claim for relief?


2 CA-CV 2010-0005  In re BOND IN THE AMOUNT OF $75,000  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0005
Issues Summary: When a criminal defendant violates the conditions of a release bond and fails to appear at trial: (1) Does the trial court retain jurisdiction to initiate bond forfeiture proceedings against the surety after the defendant is acquitted of the criminal charges? (2) Is the trial court required to exonerate the bond? (3) Does the trial court’s failure to issue an arrest warrant require reversal of the court’s order forfeiting the bond?


2 CA-CV 2010-0007  BRUMGARD v. RIOS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0007
2 CA-CV 2010-0009  SIMI v. SIMI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0009
2 CA-CV 2010-0028  BLAIR; SOUTHERN VENTURES, INC. v. BURGENER; TIGERLILLY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0028
Issues Summary: (1) Whether the court erred in concluding the plaintiff had demonstrated that personal service was impracticable under Rule 4.1(m), Ariz. R. Civ. P., such that alternate service was appropriate, (2) whether the means of alternate service authorized by the court violated the defendants’ due process rights, and (3) whether the plaintiff sufficiently complied with the court’s order of alternate service.


2 CA-CV 2010-0035  HOLM v. LINCOLN & CONTINENTAL OWNERS CLUB, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0035
2 CA-CV 2010-0051  DISBROW v. DISBROW  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0051
2 CA-CV 2010-0057  JUTRAS v. WOODS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0057
2 CA-CV 2010-0062  In re the Marriage of: A. WINSTANLEY and J. WINSTANLEY   Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0062
2 CA-CV 2010-0065  SAWCHUK v. SAWCHUK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0065
2 CA-CV 2010-0066  HAMBLIN v. PAQUETTE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0066
2 CA-CV 2010-0067  THE PARSONS CO., INC. v. DESERT PLANTS CONSERVANCY; AWD RANCH; LIPIN; PIERRON v. WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0067
2 CA-CV 2010-0073  MIIDAS GREENHOUSES, INVERNADEROS SANTA FE v. GLOBAL HORTICULTURAL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0073
Issues Summary: Whether the economic loss rule bars recovery in tort when peat moss damaged grower’s seeds and resulted in crop failure.


2 CA-CV 2010-0075  U.S. BANK NATL. ASSOC. v. GAGLIARDI, MILLS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0075
2 CA-CV 2010-0077  YODER v. LACHEMANN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0077
2 CA-CV 2010-0081  PATAKI v. LINEHAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0081
2 CA-CV 2010-0087  THOMPSON v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0087
Issues Summary: (1) Whether a cause of action against a public entity or employee can accrue only when a claimant has “facts sufficient” to file a valid notice of claim under A.R.S. § 12-821.01?

(2) Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment based on the claimants’ failure to file a notice of claim within 180 days after they knew or reasonably should have known claimant had been injured after driving over a road defect on a county-maintained road?


2 CA-CV 2010-0097  TEGOWSKI and DIERKING v. CONNOLLY, SACKS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0097
2 CA-CV 2010-0101  KELLER v. KELLER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0101
2 CA-CV 2010-0109  CONTINENTAL LIGHTING & CONTRACTING, INC. v. PREMIER GRADING & UTILITIES, LLC, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0109
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in finding the doctrines of equitable subrogation and replacement did not apply to appellant’s deeds of trust recorded after the refinancing of an original loan secured by appellant’s first position deed of trust and, accordingly, in finding the appellees’ intervening mechanics’ liens had priority over appellant’s deed of trust recorded as part of the loan refinancing.


2 CA-CV 2010-0113  CITIBANK v. COLEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0113
2 CA-CV 2010-0120  GIBBS v. GIBBS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0120
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in determining that claim preclusion barred a mother’s petition to reinstate child-support for her adult disabled daughter under A.R.S. § 25-320(E) and in finding that the adult disabled daughter was not a party to the proceeding?

2. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in ordering the father to pay half of the mother’s attorney fees and in holding him solely responsible for guardian ad litem fees incurred by daughter?


2 CA-CV 2010-0129  In re the Marriage of: ERIC LINDEN and TANYA LINDEN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0129
2 CA-CV 2010-0130  BASHAM v. BASHAM  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0130
2 CA-CV 2010-0131  TETERS v. YEPIZ, FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0131
2 CA-CV 2010-0151  ORINSKI v. ORINSKI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0151
2 CA-CV 2010-0153  WELLS v. HENDERSON, CHANTHARAJ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0153
2 CA-CV 2010-0159  ALI v. BADILLA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0159
2 CA-CV 2010-0160  IN RE ONE RESIDENCE LOCATED AT 5250 W. CAMINO TIERRA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0160
2 CA-CV 2010-0163  KELLEY v. FLOERCHINGER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0163
2 CA-CV 2010-0173  SPARLIN v. BAC HOME LOANS SERVICING, L.P.;RECONTRUST COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0173
2 CA-CV 2010-0189  NICHOLS v. WESTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0189
2 CA-CV 2010-0195  GQR ENTERPRISES, LLC v. ARMEL LAND INVESTORS, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0195
2 CA-CV 2010-0197  NICKERSON, et al v. GREEN VALLEY RECREATION, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0197
Issues Summary: Is a covenant to pay fees and bind a homeowner’s real property as consideration for membership in a community recreational facility a valid servitude that runs with the land?

Is an agreement creating such a covenant an unconscionable contract on the ground that it permits membership fees to be increased at the discretion of the recreational facility’s board of directors?

Is the agreement that creates such a covenant illusory or unilateral on the ground that mutuality of obligation is lacking because the owner of the community recreation facility has the right to modify terms of the agreement but the homeowner does not, except through the facility’s board of directors?


2 CA-CV 2010-0201  NUNEZ v. PROFESSIONAL TRANSIT MANAGEMENT OF TUCSON, INC. ZOELLNER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0201
2 CA-CV 2010-0203  ANEAS v. LOUGHRAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0203
2 CA-CV 2010-0208  KEREGE v. VISCOUNT HOTEL GROUP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0208
2 CA-CV 2010-0214  VANDERBILT MORTGAGE AND FINANCE, INC. v. MANASSA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0214
2 CA-CV 2010-0215  HARRIS v. CITY OF BISBEE, BISBEE CITY CLERK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0215
2 CA-CV 2010-0219  REED v. SCHRIRO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0219
2 CA-CV 2011-0004  FORSBERG v. OSUMI; RADIOLOGY SPECIALIST OF SOUTHERN ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0004
2 CA-CV 2011-0005  IN RE BALLOT PROPOSITION 404 v. CITY OF SIERRA VISTA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0005
2 CA-CV 2011-0015  JONES v. FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE CO.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0015
2 CA-CV 2011-0018  HAYES v. DEXTER CONSTRUCTION; DEXTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0018
2 CA-CV 2011-0024  PARKER v. ARIZONA REGISTRAR OF CONTRACTORS; THE SOLAR STORE, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0024
2 CA-CV 2011-0030  IB PROPERTY HOLDINGS, LLC v. RANCHO DEL MAR APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0030
Issues Summary: In an action over a disputed easement, did the trial court err in finding appellee would suffer irreparable harm and had a strong likelihood of success on the merits and in issuing a preliminary injunction against appellants using the standard established in Shoen v. Shoen, 167 Ariz. 58, 63, 804 P.2d 787, 792 (App. 1990), and in refusing to dissolve the injunction?


2 CA-CV 2011-0032  McKINNEY v. KONDAUR; CHASTAIN; BAI   Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0032
2 CA-CV 2011-0034  BAILEY v. HERMANSON, RAUCH, HERMANSON & EVERROAD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0034
2 CA-CV 2011-0036  NOVOA-BENSON v. VILDOSOLA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0036
2 CA-CV 2011-0040  AUSTIN MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. ALDECOA, DENOGEAN...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0040
2 CA-CV 2011-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA, DEPT. OF ECONOMIC SECURITY v. RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0046
2 CA-CV 2011-0048  BAKER v. CARRILLO; RYAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0048
2 CA-CV 2011-0058  MOORE v. MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0058
2 CA-CV 2011-0062  ROBLES, CITY OF NOGALES v. RIO RICO FIRE DISTRICT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0062
2 CA-CV 2011-0064  BREMER v. GONZALEZ, DU-BROOK DAIRY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0064
2 CA-CV 2011-0066  MOBILITY INSURANCE COVERAGE, INC. v. DEALER INSURANCE GROUP, LLC   Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0066
2 CA-CV 2011-0074  FREEPORT MCMORAN CORPORATION v. LANGLEY EDEN FARMS, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0074
Issues Summary: Were the parties required to utilize administrative remedies before bringing an action in superior court?


2 CA-CV 2011-0076  DAYKA & HACKETT, LLC v. DEL MONTE FRESH PRODUCE, N.A., INC.,  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0076
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment to Dayka & Hackett, LLC (D&H) on its claims of lien priority and conversion regarding crops and their proceeds marketed and sold by Del Monte Fresh Produce, N.A., Inc.? Specifically, did the court err by determining: 1) the growers of crops raised in Mexico were “located” in Washington, D.C., for purposes of perfection pursuant to A.R.S. § 47-9307(C); 2) Del Monte did not have a “right of recoupment” pursuant to A.R.S. § 47-9404; and 3) A.R.S. §§ 47-9610 and 47-9615 did not preclude Del Monte’s liability for conversion?


2 CA-CV 2011-0078  MOTZER dba RLM DESIGNS v. ESCALANTE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0078
Issues Summary: Are expenses for juror notebooks “incurred pursuant to an order,” under A.R.S. § 12-332(A)(6), so as to qualify as taxable costs, when the trial court stated that it “encourages” juror notebooks?


2 CA-CV 2011-0081  GARIBY v. EVENFLO COMPANY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0081
2 CA-CV 2011-0082  DELMASTRO & EELLS v. BANK OF ARIZONA, N.A.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0082
2 CA-CV 2011-0091  HELLER v. HUMPHRIES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0091
2 CA-CV 2011-0100  ARZATE v. ARZATE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0100
2 CA-CV 2011-0110  REA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. v. J.W. FUNERAL SERVICES, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0110
2 CA-CV 2011-0116  BEATTY v. ORO VALLEY HOSPITAL, L.L.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0116
2 CA-CV 2011-0119  TRUITT and ASSOCIATED MEDICAL DEVELOPMENT v. TRUITT and SIERRA VISTA MEDICAL CENTER PARTNERSHIP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0119
2 CA-CV 2011-0130  LANSKY v. LANSKY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0130
2 CA-CV 2011-0135  SANDOVAL v. EICHER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0135
2 CA-CV 2011-0146  In re U.S. CURRENCY IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,900.00  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0146
2 CA-CV 2011-0148  ALDERETE v. ALDERETE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0148
2 CA-CV 2011-0154  LEON v. SECURAPLANE TECHNOLOGIES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0154
2 CA-CV 2011-0158  In re APPROXIMATELY $19,040.00 U.S. CURRENCY (Item no. 12)  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0158
2 CA-CV 2011-0159  NICHOLS v. WESTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0159
2 CA-CV 2011-0160  LEVERAGED LAND COMPANY, MONTGOMERY v. HODGES, CAIN   Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0160
2 CA-CV 2011-0163  KADLEC, HOWELL v. DORSEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0163
2 CA-CV 2011-0164  NATIONAL INDEMNITY COMPANY v. RITTER and RITTER LAW GROUP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0164
2 CA-CV 2011-0170  In Re 2005 NISSAN XTERRA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0170
2 CA-CV 2011-0176  ALLEGRO ACCEPTANCE CORPORATION v. BULLOCK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0176
2 CA-CV 2011-0178  In re THE GUARDIANSHIP/CONSERVATORSHIP OF BESSIE B. GARNER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0178
2 CA-CV 2011-0180  SKY v. BRAVO and CLEARY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0180
2 CA-CV 2011-0188  FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION v. SPARLIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0188
2 CA-CV 2011-0192  ARCHIBALD v. ARCHIBALD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0192
2 CA-CV 2012-0002  LEON v. DANAHER CORP.; PACIFIC SCIENTIFIC; SECURAPLANE TECHNOLOGIES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0002
2 CA-CV 2012-0024  SHUFELT v. CRISWELL, CLARK, FRAIJO, FRAZIER, LONG, et al.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0024
2 CA-CV 2012-0030  CARDINAL & STACHEL, P.C. v. CURTISS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0030
2 CA-CV 2012-0041  MORGAN v. ADAMS, CITY OF SIERRA VISTA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0041
2 CA-CV 2012-0048  MENDOZA, JR. v. BURKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0048
2 CA-CV 2012-0058  IN RE THE GUARDIANSHIP AND CONSERVATORSHIP OF CHRISTINE A. COLEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0058
2 CA-CV 2012-0061  YODER v. LACHEMANN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0061
2 CA-CV 2012-0070  HECTOR ROBLES and CITY OF NOGALES v. RIO RICO FIRE DISTRICT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0070
2 CA-CV 2012-0096  FALKOW v. NEUMAIER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0096
2 CA-CV 2012-0098  BAILEY v. FARLEY, ROBINSON & LARSEN, GREGORY A. ROBINSON, P.C., et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0098
2 CA-CV 2012-0101  JOHNS v. STURM  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0101
2 CA-CV 2012-0102  TRENT v. TRENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0102
2 CA-CV 2012-0106  IN RE THE ESTATE OF JAMES L. LAKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0106
2 CA-CV 2012-0107  IN RE BOND FORFEITURE IN PINAL CAUSE NUMBERS CR201103204, CR201101969 and CR201101968  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0107
2 CA-CV 2012-0122  ROQUET, MARTINEZ v. DORA DEXTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0122
2 CA-CV 2012-0147  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF NOEL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0147
2 CA-CV 2012-0154  IN RE 2003 CHEVROLET 4DSD, REG. AZ/AVK5971  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0154
2 CA-CV 2012-0164  TAPIA v. FETTERS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0164
2 CA-CV 2012-0165  SALERO RANCH LLC v. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0165
2 CA-CV 2012-0169  JUNE BURTON v. LAWLEY AUTO SALES, L.L.C.; LAWLEY MOTORS...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0169
2 CA-CV 2013-0003  McMANUS v. PARRA, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0003
2 CA-CV 2013-0010  BALLARD, et al v. DECONCINI MCDONALD YETWIN & LACY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0010
2 CA-CV 2013-0025  FITZWILLIAMS v. TACK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0025
2 CA-CV 2013-0031  CAMPBELL v. FLORENCE GARDENS MOBILE HOME ASSOCIATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0031
2 CA-CV 2013-0077  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF PIEPER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0077
2 CA-CV 2013-0095  MARTINEZ v. CORRECTIONS CORPORATION OF AMERICA, et al.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0095
2 CA-CV 2013-0101  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF FLORES AND MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0101
2 CA-CV 2013-0103  AH4R-AZ11, LLC v. ALTENES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0103
2 CA-CV 2013-0125  IN RE THE ESTATE OF ROBERT JUNIOR DEMAREE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0125
2 CA-CV 2013-0144  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF WOODSIDE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0144
2 CA-CV 2013-0161  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF YEATTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0161
2 CA-CV 2013-0163  YEKATERINA SHTYRKOVA v. DENIS A. GORBUNOV  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0163
2 CA-CV 2014-0027  McBRIDE v. LINN and KNAAK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0027
2 CA-HC 2009-0001  CARL B. BRANSON v. STATE OF ARIZONA   Participating 2 CA-HC 2009-0001
2 CA-HC 2009-0005  ISIAH HILL v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS  Participating 2 CA-HC 2009-0005
2 CA-HC 2010-0001  JOEL M. COOPER v. CARSON McWILLIAMS, Warden  Participating 2 CA-HC 2010-0001
2 CA-HC 2011-0002  ISIAH HILL v. CHUCK RYAN  Participating 2 CA-HC 2011-0002
2 CA-HC 2012-0002  EDMUND M. ABORDO and CEDRIC AH SING v. WARDEN TODD THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-HC 2012-0002
2 CA-HC 2012-0004  STANLEY D. FRANK v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-HC 2012-0004
2 CA-HC 2012-0010  KEVIN LAWRENCE JONES v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-HC 2012-0010
2 CA-HC 2013-0001  JESUS ESQUER CASTILLO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-HC 2013-0001
2 CA-HC 2013-0007  CARL B. BRANSON v. JOHN GAY, MELVIN THOMAS, WILLIAM WHITE, ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS   Participating 2 CA-HC 2013-0007
2 CA-IC 2006-0013  GLORIA v. BAJA PRODUCTS, EMPLOYERS INSUR. COMPANY OF WAUSAU  Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0013
2 CA-IC 2006-0021  PICKETT v. TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, TRISTAR   Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0021
2 CA-IC 2008-0001  ABEYTA v. CANYON STATE COURIER, SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0001
2 CA-IC 2008-0002  LESSNER v. ADOC; DOA RISK MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0002
2 CA-IC 2008-0003  PIMA COUNTY; PIMA COUNTY RISK MANAGEMENT v. WHITE  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0003
2 CA-IC 2008-0009  WILLIAMS v. BURSTIN' BERRIES SMOOTHIES, FARMERS INSURANCE  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0009
2 CA-IC 2009-0007  MICHAEL S. RHINEHART v. TRULY NOLEN AMERICA and TRULY NOLEN OF AMERICA, INC.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2009-0007
2 CA-IC 2010-0003  WAL-MART ASSOCIATES; CLAIMS MANAGEMENT v. PALAFOX  Participating 2 CA-IC 2010-0003
2 CA-IC 2010-0005  RAUL M. LOPEZ v. US CARPENTRY and AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE CO.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2010-0005
2 CA-IC 2010-0012  STUTZMAN v. ICA, TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, TRISTAR RISK MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2010-0012
2 CA-IC 2010-0015  PAMELA J. POST v. ROYAL PET GROOMING & BOARDING, INC., and TWIN CITY FIRE INSURANCE CO.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2010-0015
2 CA-IC 2011-0010  SPECIAL EVENTS SERVICE, INC. and ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE CO. v. ROBERTO DOMINGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0010
Issues Summary: Did the Administrative Law Judge err in concluding the insurance carrier’s issuance of a form designating the employee’s injury unscheduled and requesting the Industrial Commission to determine benefits was subject to the principle of res judicata?


2 CA-IC 2011-0012  KEITH PIERPONT v. CITY OF TUCSON and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0012
2 CA-IC 2011-0016  GARY R. DITTMANN v. FREEPORT-MCMORAN MORENCI, INC., and GALLAGHER BASSETT SERVICES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0016
2 CA-IC 2011-0018  ALBERT P. DUNN v. TUCSON MEDICAL CENTER and CORVEL CORPORATION  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0018
2 CA-IC 2012-0010  UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA HEALTH NETWORK v. MARY M. SALINAS  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0010
2 CA-IC 2012-0016  JEFFREY D. ZEIDMAN v. PRUDENTIAL OVERALL SUPPLY and TRISTAR RISK MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0016
2 CA-IC 2013-0007  RAYMOND D. CRUM, JR. v. B.J. CECIL TRUCKING, INC. and WAUSAU INS. CO.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0007
2 CA-IC 2013-0009  JEFFREY WHITNEY v. THE HOME DEPOT and HELMSMAN MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0009
2 CA-IC 2013-0018  SUSAN L. DORSEY v. LA POSADA AT PARK CENTRE, INC. and LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS. CO.   Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0018
2 CA-JV 2006-0031  AMY H. v. ADES, EMMA H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0031
2 CA-JV 2006-0035  IN RE NASHON B.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0035
2 CA-JV 2006-0039  IN RE GUILLERMO V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0039
2 CA-JV 2006-0043  IN RE ESAU L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0043
2 CA-JV 2006-0045  IN RE JASEL V.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0045
2 CA-JV 2006-0055  MARGARET G. v. ADES, SIERRA G., CHRISTIAN G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0055
2 CA-JV 2006-0057  IN RE RODGER M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0057
2 CA-JV 2006-0059  IN RE CHAD M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0059
2 CA-JV 2006-0063  MICHAEL K. v. ADES, BAYVIN K.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0063
2 CA-JV 2006-0067  JAMES M. v. ADES, JOSAPHINE M., CODY M., KACEE M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0067
2 CA-JV 2007-0003  VICTORIA D. v. ADES, JOHNATHAN H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0003
2 CA-JV 2007-0005  MANDY S. v. ADES, SEBASTIAN S., JULIAN S.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0005
2 CA-JV 2007-0025  EDWARD S. v. ADES, EDEN S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0025
2 CA-JV 2007-0082  APRIL W. v. ADES, AMBER W. & LUKE W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0082
2 CA-JV 2007-0089  JODI A. v. ADES, DEAN W. & JADE W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0089
2 CA-JV 2007-0097  IN RE TRENELLE G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0097
2 CA-JV 2008-0047  IN RE GREGORY R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0047
2 CA-JV 2008-0065  JESSICA R. v. ADES, SCOTT R., SAMANTHA D., KC D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0065
2 CA-JV 2008-0071  MARIZZA E. v. ADES, TYFFANI E., BIANKA E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0071
2 CA-JV 2008-0073  IN RE VICTOR B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0073
2 CA-JV 2008-0078  IN RE PALMER W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0078
2 CA-JV 2008-0081  IN RE KUSHAWN J.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0081
2 CA-JV 2008-0085  EMILY T. v. ADES, PAYTON G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0085
2 CA-JV 2008-0101  ROBERT B. v. CHRISTINE P. and ROBERT B., II  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0101
2 CA-JV 2008-0103  TAMARA C. v. ADES and HAYLEY C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0103
2 CA-JV 2008-0105  PHILIP C. v. ADES and HAYLEY C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0105
2 CA-JV 2008-0113  JUAN P. v. ADES, JUAN M.-P. and REINA O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0113
2 CA-JV 2008-0119  PAMELA C. v. ADES and MACY C. and KAI C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0119
2 CA-JV 2008-0125  IN RE JACOB Z.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0125
2 CA-JV 2008-0131  YVETTE S. v. ADES and JACQUISE S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0131
2 CA-JV 2008-0133  ANTONIO M. v. ADES and DANIEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0133
Issues Summary: Other than as part of its general consideration of placement possibilities in determining a child’s best interests, is the juvenile court required to consider possible placement of a child with a grandparent pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-538(B), (C), in deciding whether severance is warranted pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-533, or is the placement determination under § 8-538 made after the court finds sufficient grounds for terminating a parent’s rights?

After the juvenile court finds sufficient grounds to terminate a parent’s rights pursuant to § 8-533, does that parent have standing to challenge the child’s placement? Did the juvenile court make sufficient factual findings as required by Michael J. v. Ariz. Dep’t of Econ. Sec., 196 Ariz. 246, 995 P.2d 682 (2000), and A.R.S. § 8-533(B)(4)?


2 CA-JV 2008-0135  IN RE HENRY S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0135
2 CA-JV 2009-0005  IN RE JOSEPH H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0005
2 CA-JV 2009-0011  IN RE JUAN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0011
2 CA-JV 2009-0013  ALONZO M. v. ADES and MARCOS C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0013
2 CA-JV 2009-0019  JORDAN C. , JESSE C., KAILYNN C., MICHELE C. v. ADES  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0019
Issues Summary: Did the juvenile court err in finding by clear and convincing evidence that, despite the Arizona Department of Economic Security’s diligent efforts to provide appropriate reunification services, mother had failed to remedy the circumstances causing her two youngest children to remain in court-ordered, out-of-home care for fifteen months or longer and there was a substantial likelihood she would be unable to effectively parent the children in the near future, warranting termination of her parental rights pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-533(B)(8)(c)?


2 CA-JV 2009-0021  AMBER H. v. GRACIELA G. and JENNA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0021
2 CA-JV 2009-0025  IONA T. v. ADES, VIRGINIA M. and BIANCA T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0025
2 CA-JV 2009-0028  IN RE KALVIN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0028
2 CA-JV 2009-0034  BONNIE G. v. ADES and KARMA F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0034
2 CA-JV 2009-0039  SARAH C. v. ADES, MICHAEL C., ISAAC C. and ADAM C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0039
2 CA-JV 2009-0050  JESUS G. v. ADES and SEBASTIAN D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0050
2 CA-JV 2009-0057  IN RE ANTHONY F.-C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0057
2 CA-JV 2009-0059  HANNAH S. v. ADES, AMETHYST B., NATHAN S. and JONATHON S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0059
2 CA-JV 2009-0064  IN RE MICHAEL N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0064
2 CA-JV 2009-0077  JAY B. v. ADES, and ISABELLA B.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0077
2 CA-JV 2009-0082  MELISSA R. v. WADE T., ANDREW T. and CAMERON T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0082
2 CA-JV 2009-0087  NATASHA P. v. ADES and HAYLIE P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0087
2 CA-JV 2009-0092  IN RE MATHEU I.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0092
2 CA-JV 2009-0097  IN RE STEVEN R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0097
2 CA-JV 2009-0101  DEBORAH B. and DANNY B. v. ALYSSA C.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0101
2 CA-JV 2009-0107  ABDULKADIR A. v. ADES and KAYMAURY F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0107
2 CA-JV 2009-0109  IN RE CASEY G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0109
Issues Summary: Whether a delinquency petition improperly alleged that the delinquent act was a dangerous crime against children as defined in A.R.S. § 13-705(P)(1)(e);


2 CA-JV 2009-0125  IN RE DYLAN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0125
2 CA-JV 2009-0129  CHRISTINE M. v. ADES and LILITH W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0129
2 CA-JV 2009-0133  MARIA A. v. ADES and RUBY M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0133
2 CA-JV 2010-0007  IN RE JESUS L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0007
2 CA-JV 2010-0011  BRIAN S. v. ADES and CARLIE B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0011
2 CA-JV 2010-0015  MATHEW S. v. ADES and MURPHY S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0015
2 CA-JV 2010-0023  ADELAIDE A. v. ADES, MARIAH A., VERONICA A. and HEAVEN A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0023
2 CA-JV 2010-0025  IN RE ISRAEL O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0025
2 CA-JV 2010-0027  JENNIFER M. v. ADES and ZAIDEN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0027
2 CA-JV 2010-0029  GENE M. v. ADES and MATTHEW M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0029
2 CA-JV 2010-0035  KEVIN C. v. ADREANNA G. and KEVIN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0035
2 CA-JV 2010-0037  IN RE ROBERT T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0037
2 CA-JV 2010-0039  JAY B. v. ADES and JASON B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0039
2 CA-JV 2010-0041  MIGUEL M. v. NICOLE S., MIGUEL M. and ANGEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0041
2 CA-JV 2010-0043  DEANNA D. v. ADES, GABRIELLA P., ANTHONY P. and ALEXIA P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0043
2 CA-JV 2010-0061  JUDY D. v. TIMOTHY M., CHARLENE M. and JAKOB O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0061
2 CA-JV 2010-0063  ROBERT S. v. ADES, WAYLAND S. and MICHAEL S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0063
2 CA-JV 2010-0069  KATHRYN C. v. ADES, SHAYLA R. and JAYLEAH C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0069
2 CA-JV 2010-0077  KRISTINE S. v. ADES and BREKELLE S-D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0077
2 CA-JV 2010-0093  RAYMOND B. and SUSAN B. v. ADES, AYTUMN B. and KIERA B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0093
2 CA-JV 2010-0097  IN RE FELIPE O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0097
2 CA-JV 2010-0099  IN RE CHEYANNE G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0099
2 CA-JV 2010-0101  RENEATTA A. v. ADES, ISAIAH A., MARY A., SHANNA N. MATEO A. AND MARCIANO A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0101
2 CA-JV 2010-0105  A. THOMAS S. v. AMANDA S. and JULIAN S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0105
2 CA-JV 2010-0107  FRANK H. v. ADES, and CHLOE C.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0107
2 CA-JV 2010-0109  JOHN M. v. ADES and MICHAEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0109
2 CA-JV 2010-0117  JUSTIN W. v. STEVEN W., ALLISON W. and JUSTIN W., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0117
2 CA-JV 2010-0123  STACEY K. v. ADES, DYLAN K., SABRINA K. and TRISTAN K.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0123
2 CA-JV 2010-0127  IN RE JACOB B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0127
2 CA-JV 2010-0129  IN RE MIRANDA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0129
2 CA-JV 2010-0131  CHRISTOPHER A. v. CHRISTINA M. and TERRY A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0131
2 CA-JV 2010-0133  COURTNEY W. v. ADES and JOEY W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0133
2 CA-JV 2010-0143  IN RE MANUEL S.-R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0143
2 CA-JV 2010-0149  GEORGINE G. v. ADES and ANGELICA R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0149
2 CA-JV 2011-0005  DUANE H. v. ADES, ROBERT H. and ROMAINE H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0005
2 CA-JV 2011-0007  BRANDON C. v. ADES, FIONA C. and AIDEN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0007
2 CA-JV 2011-0024  ESTHER M. v. ADES and SHAWN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0024
2 CA-JV 2011-0039  IN RE DOMINICK B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0039
2 CA-JV 2011-0040  ROBERTO B. v. ADES and ADELCI B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0040
2 CA-JV 2011-0048  ANNA B. v. ADES and JOSEPH B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0048
2 CA-JV 2011-0058  IN RE ISAIAH T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0058
2 CA-JV 2011-0062  CRAYTONIA D., SR. v. ADES and CRAYTONIA D., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0062
2 CA-JV 2011-0084  IN RE ALEXIS E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0084
2 CA-JV 2011-0088  IN RE ANTHONY E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0088
2 CA-JV 2011-0090  ALICIA L. v. ADES and MAYIA L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0090
2 CA-JV 2011-0096  KRISTINA H. v. ADES, MICHELLE H. and RICHARD H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0096
2 CA-JV 2011-0100  IN RE ALEMAN V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0100
2 CA-JV 2011-0108  IN RE DAKOTA L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0108
2 CA-JV 2011-0120  IN RE WYATT H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0120
2 CA-JV 2011-0128  MIGUEL G. v. ADES and DAKOTA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0128
2 CA-JV 2011-0130  IN RE JAHVON S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0130
2 CA-JV 2011-0144  COURTNEY C. v. ADES, EMMA C. and HANNAH F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0144
2 CA-JV 2011-0146  HENRY M. v. ADES and GAGE A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0146
2 CA-JV 2012-0006  STEPHANIE M. v. ADES and ALIZEAH M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0006
2 CA-JV 2012-0010  JOSE I. v. ADES, JOSE M. and FAITH I.-M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0010
2 CA-JV 2012-0015  DUSTIN P. v. ADES; D. P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0015
2 CA-JV 2012-0016  DANIELLE C. v. ADES and JENZ G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0016
2 CA-JV 2012-0044  FREDDIE H. v. ADES and FREDDIE H. JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0044
2 CA-JV 2012-0050  SHANNON S. v. ADES, MICHELLE S. and ARIEL S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0050
2 CA-JV 2012-0058  JONATHON A. v. JOY A., ALEXANDRA A. and JONATHON A., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0058
2 CA-JV 2012-0090  IN RE ALEMAN V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0090
2 CA-JV 2012-0100  MARY W. v. ADES and JADEA W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0100
2 CA-JV 2012-0102  IN RE BRENARD B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0102
2 CA-JV 2012-0108  THOMAS W. v. ADES, WYATT W. and SPENCER W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0108
2 CA-JV 2012-0118  IN RE DARRIAN S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0118
2 CA-JV 2012-0126  AUSTIN S. v. ANDREAS L. and JACOB S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0126
2 CA-JV 2012-0136  JESUS A. v. STEPHEN J., MAGDA J. and EDUARDO S.-M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0136
2 CA-JV 2013-0021  DUSTIN P. v. ADES, A.P. and D.P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0021
2 CA-JV 2013-0028  JUANA M. v. ADES, SELENA R. and LYDIA R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0028
2 CA-JV 2013-0030  ROJELIO B., JR. v. ADES and AMAYA B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0030
2 CA-JV 2013-0036  IN RE ALEXANDREA F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0036
2 CA-JV 2013-0038  IN RE NATHANIEL H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0038
2 CA-JV 2013-0057  IN RE E.M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0057
2 CA-JV 2013-0063  NANCY L. v. ADES and A. L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0063
2 CA-JV 2013-0079  KATRINA S. v. CHRISTOPHER S. and H. S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0079
2 CA-JV 2013-0085  SHELSELAINE F. v. ERNEST & DEANNA L. and K.B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0085
2 CA-JV 2013-0087  HECTOR M. v. AIIESA E. and A.M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0087
2 CA-JV 2013-0113  RACHEL P. v. ADES, H. P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0113
2 CA-JV 2013-0115  IN RE D.K.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0115
2 CA-JV 2013-0117  JESSIE M. v. ADES, A.M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0117
2 CA-JV 2013-0139  IN RE G.Y.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0139
2 CA-JV 2014-0017  KARENA H. v. DCS AND A.G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0017
2 CA-JV 2014-0023  IN RE P.B.-L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0023
2 CA-JV 2014-0037  BRANDON D. v. ADES, E.D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0037
2 CA-JV 2014-0047  IN RE C.S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0047
2 CA-JV 2014-0049  GREGORY T. v. ADES and N.T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0049
2 CA-MH 2008-0007  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-200800072  Participating 2 CA-MH 2008-0007
2 CA-MH 2009-0001-SP  IN RE THE COMMITMENT OF EUGENE LEE CLAY  Participating 2 CA-MH 2009-0001-SP
2 CA-MH 2009-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-20030042-2-09  Participating 2 CA-MH 2009-0002
2 CA-MH 2009-0003-SP  IN RE THE DETENTION OF JOHN C. SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-MH 2009-0003-SP
2 CA-MH 2010-0007  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201000112  Participating 2 CA-MH 2010-0007
2 CA-MH 2010-0008  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201000119  Participating 2 CA-MH 2010-0008
2 CA-MH 2011-0001  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH7256309  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0001
2 CA-MH 2011-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH 20110065  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0002
2 CA-MH 2011-0004  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH3079411  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0004
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding appellant had knowingly and voluntarily waived his right to be present when he failed to appear for a hearing addressing whether he should be compelled to receive mental health treatment?


2 CA-MH 2011-0006  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20110196  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0006
2 CA-MH 2011-0008  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH49361011  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0008
2 CA-MH 2012-0010-SP  IN RE THE COMMITMENT OF DEREK KNOTT  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0010-SP
2 CA-MH 2013-0007  IN RE MENTAL HEALTH CASE NO. MH20000326613  Participating 2 CA-MH 2013-0007
2 CA-SA 2006-0101  GRACE HOWARD ALLEN v. ADES and T.S.A.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2006-0101
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in denying a maternal aunt’s motion to intervene in the juvenile’s dependency proceeding?


2 CA-SA 2007-0061  MARIA LOZA-FELIX v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0061
2 CA-SA 2007-0089  JASON N. v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0089
2 CA-SA 2008-0085  JESSE ALAN GEARHART v. STATE OF ARIZONA; ABBISS  Participating 2 CA-SA 2008-0085
2 CA-SA 2009-0019  CARONDELET HEALTH NETWORK v. ATTEBERRY; NO; TRAVMED USA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0019
Issues Summary: When plaintiff’s decedent shared a hospital room with a fellow patient who witnessed events material to plaintiff’s claims against the hospital and other defendants, did the trial court violate the witness’s physician-patient privilege by ordering the defendant hospital to disclose to plaintiff’s counsel, under seal, the name, address, and telephone number of the witness?


2 CA-SA 2009-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL WILLIAM RITZ  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0029
2 CA-SA 2009-0050  GROSVENOR HOLDINGS v. PINAL COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0050
Issues Summary: Can parties contractually agree that disputes between them are to be resolved in a specified manner by a designated individual or body and that the only means of obtaining judicial review is pursuant to the Administrative Review Act, notwithstanding that the Act otherwise would not apply?


2 CA-SA 2010-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ARTHUR ERGONIS  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0021
Issues Summary: By excluding from its definition of a victim one who is “in custody for an offense,” does the Victims’ Bill of Rights in article II, § 2.1 of the Arizona Constitution deny victims’ rights only to inmates against whom an offense has been committed while the inmate victim is in custody, or does it also exclude victims of crimes who are later taken into custody for an unrelated offense?


2 CA-SA 2010-0037  SANTO VALLARTA LAND PARTNERS v. KAREN BREDESON  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0037
2 CA-SA 2010-0047  CAROL ANN POTTER; DEBRA JOY MERRYMAN v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0047
Issues Summary: After criminal proceedings were transferred from justice court to the superior court pursuant to Rule 11.2(d), Ariz. R. Crim. P., did the respondent judge exceed her authority when she reviewed and rejected the justice court’s reasonable grounds findings pursuant to Rule 11.2(c), found the defendants competent to stand trial, and remanded the matters to the justice court for trial instead of appointing mental health experts to examine the defendants and conduct proceedings in accordance with Rule 11.3 and other provisions of the rule?


2 CA-SA 2010-0065  YVETTE JEANINE TELL v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0065
2 CA-SA 2010-0081  MICHAEL S. LAMONGE v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0081
2 CA-SA 2010-0091  JACOB T. OSTERKAMP v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0091
Issues Summary: Does Rule 32.4(c), Ariz. R. Crim. P., give an indigent pleading defendant the right to appointed counsel in a second, timely filed post-conviction proceeding in which the defendant intends to investigate and possibly raise a claim that counsel who had represented the defendant in the first, of-right proceeding had been ineffective?


2 CA-SA 2011-0009  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK DWAYNE GANNON  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0009
Issues Summary: Whether a victim’s rights under Arizona’s Victim’s Bill of Rights terminate upon the defendant’s placement on probation.


2 CA-SA 2011-0078  MM & A PRODUCTIONS v. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0078
2 CA-SA 2013-0079  M. W. v. ARIZ. DEPT. OF ECONOMIC SECURITY; RICARDO M.   Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0079
2 CA-SA 2014-0026  CARLOS OROZCO v. PINAL COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE  Participating 2 CA-SA 2014-0026

Continue to decisions page.