Decisions by Judge 2007 to Present

Judge Philip Espinosa
Please click on the case number in the "Decision" column to view the complete decision.
Case Number Case Title Role Decision
2 CA-CR 2009-0252  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER PUTZI  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0252
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Whether Tucson City Code § 11-54, which prohibits public urination, is unconstitutionally vague.


2 CA-CR 2010-0088  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD PORTER BOLDING  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0088
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does the application of A.R.S. § 13-4033 to the defendant violate the Arizona Constitution's guarantee of a right to an appeal?


2 CA-CR 2012-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HEULON COLSTON BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0124
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: (1) When the defendant made both pre- and post-arrest statements while hospitalized and on medication, did the trial court err by refusing to suppress those statements on either Fifth or Sixth Amendment grounds?

(2) Did the court err by refusing to provide the jury with duress, “voluntary act,” and “missing witness” instructions?

(3) Was the defendant’s conviction under Arizona’s felony-murder statute unconstitutional and in violation of due process because neither he nor the other participants in the home invasion were directly involved in the killing that occurred?


2 CA-CR 2013-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESGARDO JAVIER NEVAREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0065
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion to suppress evidence based on a police stop of the defendant’s vehicle for lack of a license plate when the officer failed to see a properly displayed temporary license until he had approached the vehicle on foot, at which point he observed evidence of driving under the influence? Did police violate the defendant’s right to counsel by denying his request for an attorney to read to him a warrant they had obtained to draw his blood?


2 CA-CR 2013-0279  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO ARTURO ROJO-VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0279
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in admitting evidence of a pretrial identification of the defendant by a police officer when the “show-up” procedure used on the night of the offense was concededly suggestive and the trial court declined to conduct a due process evaluation?

2. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in admitting, over the defendant’s hearsay objection, testimony about the officer’s identification by a police detective who had observed the suggestive show-up?

3. Did the trial court properly instruct the jury on attempted murder?


2 CA-CR 2013-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID J. WALLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0315
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in denying defendant’s motion to suppress his pretrial statements made prior to and following Miranda advisements on a theory the deputies had conducted a two-stage custodial interrogation prohibited under Missouri v. Seibert, 542 U.S. 600 (2004)?

2. Was it reversible error for the trial court to instruct the jury that it was not required to reach a unanimous verdict on which form of assault, as described by A.R.S. § 13-1203, led to its finding defendant guilty of aggravated assault pursuant to A.R.S. § 13–1204(A)(2)?


2 CA-SA 2010-0074  WILLIAM ALLEN LEAR v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2010-0074
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 12-2203, which pertains to the admission of expert testimony, conflict with Rule 702, Ariz. R. Evid., and violate the separation of power doctrine, rendering it unconstitutional ?


2 CA-SA 2012-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYLER B.   Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0065
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Whether, in a delinquency proceeding for driving under the influence, the juvenile court abused its discretion in granting the juvenile’s motion to suppress the results of a blood test based on the Arizona Parents’ Bill of Rights and the voluntariness of the juvenile’s consent, notwithstanding Arizona’s implied consent statute.


2 CA-CR 2008-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR MONTES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0148
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does Senate Bill 1449, which attempted to make A.R.S. § 13-205(A) retroactively applicable by nullifying our supreme court’s decision in Garcia v. Browning, 214 Ariz. 250, 151 P.3d 533 (2007), violate the separation of powers doctrine?


2 CA-CR 2012-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KWAME ROY LOWERY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0059
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 13-3821, Arizona’s sex offender registration statute, violate a registrant’s right to equal protection under the federal and state constitutions? Did the trial court err in determining sufficient evidence supported Lowery’s conviction under § 13-3821? Did the trial court commit fundamental error by permitting a detective’s testimony interpreting § 13-3821?


2 CA-CR 2012-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL ALEJANDRO DELGADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0287
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Is A.R.S. § 13-1204(B)(1), which provides that a person commits aggravated assault by “imped[ing] the normal breathing or circulation of blood of another person,” unconstitutionally vague? Did the trial court err by denying Delgado’s motion to preclude the testimony of a “strangulation expert” pursuant to Rule 702, Ariz. R. Evid.? Was Delgado deprived of his right to a unanimous jury verdict because of a duplicitous indictment or charge?


2 CA-CR 2012-0305  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN BETZA VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0305
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in denying Vasquez’s motion to sever his trial from that of his codefendant? 2) Did the trial court err in admitting statements made by a non-testifying co-defendant, thereby violating the Confrontation Clause?


2 CA-CR 2013-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD JOHN BRUGGEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0041
** Constitutionality decision
2 CA-CV 2007-0143  CAIN; BAHR; HOLCOMB; AZ ASSOC. OF SCHOOL BUSINESS OFFICIALS; ...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0143
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Do the Arizona Scholarship for Pupils with Disabilities Statute and the Arizona Displaced Pupils Grant Statute violate the Arizona Constitution by providing for state funds to be applied to the cost of tuition and fees for certain categories of students at private, sectarian and nonsectarian, primary and secondary schools at the direction of the students' legal guardians?


2 CA-CV 2012-0019  GROSVENOR HOLDINGS, K. HOVNANIAN GREAT WESTERN HOMES and TOUSA HOMES v. PINAL COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0019
** Constitutionality decision
2 CA-CV 2013-0075  IN RE ESTATE OF RICHARD R. SNURE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0075
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Was Garbareno’s right to notice under the Fourteenth Amendment violated when the estate mailed a notice of claim denial to Garbareno by certified mail, the notice was returned as undeliverable, and the estate took no further steps to notify Garbareno? 2) Did the estate’s sending of the notice by certified mail fulfill the requirements of A.R.S. § 14-3806(A)? 3) If the notice sent by the estate was deficient for any of these reasons, what is Garbareno’s remedy?


2 CA-IC 2006-0025  MONT POLANCO v. ICA; PIMA COUNTY   Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0025
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does the requirement of A.R.S. § 23-1061(H) that a workers’ compensation claim “shall not be reopened because of increased subjective pain if the pain is not accompanied by a change in objective physical findings” violate article XVIII, § 8 of the Arizona Constitution by limiting the means by which an employee can meet the obligation to prove a “new, additional or previously undiscovered temporary or permanent condition” arose out of and in the course of employment?


2 CA-JV 2012-0007  LISA K. v. ADES and JULIAN N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0007
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 8-862 is facially unconstitutional because it permits the same judge who directs the Department of Economic Security to file a motion to terminate a parent’s rights to preside over the hearing on that motion and decide whether to grant it?


2 CA-MH 2010-0004  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201000076  Participating 2 CA-MH 2010-0004
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does the strict application of A.R.S. §§ 36-533(B), 36-539(B), and 36-501(14) conflict with Rules 702 and 703, Ariz. R. Evid., and violate the separation of powers doctrine?


2 CA-CR 2011-0249  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS XAVIER ALMAGUER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0249
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err when it denied the defendant’s requests for jury instructions defining “proximate cause” and “voluntary act,” and an instruction explaining the state’s burden to disprove his justification defense to the lesser offenses of manslaughter and negligent homicide?

2. Did the court err by limiting cross-examination relating to a witness’s settled civil lawsuit against the defendant?

3. Did the court abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s motion for mistrial based on a witness’s testimony alluding to his prior acts?


2 CA-CR 2011-0340  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCUS DESHAUN TUCKER, CLIFTON JAMES CUTTLER II and ANDRE LAVELLE ARMSTRONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0340
Issues Summary: (1) Does the test set forth in Waller v. Georgia, 467 U.S. 39 (1984), for a violation of the constitutional right to a public trial apply to a partial closure of a criminal trial in which all members of the public except the press were excluded from the proceedings?

(2) Did the trial court reversibly err by closing Appellants’ trial to all members of the public except the press without making specific findings or considering less restrictive alternatives?

(3) Did the trial court err in denying Appellant Armstrong’s motions for a judgment of acquittal on charges of conspiracy and misuse of body armor?

(4) Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying Armstrong’s motions to sever his trial from that of his codefendants?


2 CA-CR 2012-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT ALAN COLVIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0099
Issues Summary: Whether the defendant’s California convictions for driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI) and driving while having a blood-alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 or above constitute acts that, if committed in Arizona, would be a violation of this state’s DUI and BAC laws such that the California convictions could be used to support aggravated DUI charges under A.R.S. § 28-1383.


2 CA-CR 2012-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELINO PAOLO BUCCHERI-BIANCA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0315
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err by granting the state’s motion to preclude evidence that a victim had applied for a “U-Visa,” issued to noncitizen victims of certain crimes that provides temporary authorization to enter and remain in the United States? 2. Did the prosecutor commit misconduct during his closing argument by asserting repeatedly that the victims had no motive to lie, despite alleged evidence of motive which the prosecution successfully had moved the trial court to exclude? 3. Did the trial court err by denying defendant’s motion to preclude generalized expert testimony regarding child sex abuse victims, not rooted in the facts of the case, on grounds her expertise was based on novel scientific theories, was unhelpful to the trier of fact, and impermissibly bolstered the credibility of the victims?


2 CA-CR 2012-0377  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO PENA, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0377
Issues Summary: Did the state present sufficient evidence that each of the victim’s separately charged injuries caused “temporary but substantial disfigurement” to support the defendant’s multiple convictions for aggravated assault under A.R.S. § 13-1204(A)(3)?


2 CA-CR 2013-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO ANDRES ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0157
2 CA-CR 2013-0233-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND JOHN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0233-PR
Issues Summary: Does the federal Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 16901-16962, preempt Arizona’s jurisdiction to enforce state registration requirements on tribal lands?

Did the trial court err in finding the state could impose upon a member of the Navajo Nation a duty to register as a sex offender based on his residence on tribal land in Arizona?


2 CA-CV 2011-0083  AMANTI ELECTRIC, INC. v. ENGINEERED STRUCTURES, INC., WESTERN SURETY COMPANY  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0083
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying plaintiff’s motion for relief from judgment pursuant to the catch-all provision of Rule 60(c), Ariz. R. Civ. P., when plaintiff’s arguments were based on allegations of fraud and mistake but the motion was untimely under portions of the rule specifically applicable to those arguments?


2 CA-CV 2011-0085  STAGECOACH TRAILS MHC, L.L.C. v. CITY OF BENSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0085
Issues Summary: 1. When a unit is replaced in a mobile-home park, for purposes of zoning enforcement, is the park as a whole entitled to nonconforming-use status or are its individual, constituent spaces separate nonconforming uses for purposes of A.R.S. § 9-462.02(A), which permits continuation of existing uses?

2. Did the presiding judge of the superior court abuse his discretion in overruling the City of Benson’s notice seeking a change of judge?


2 CA-CV 2011-0129  BAC HOME LOANS SERVICING, L.P. v. SEMPER INVESTMENTS, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0129
Issues Summary: (1) Whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment after applying the doctrine of equitable subrogation in favor of a subsequent lender who satisfied primary liens against a property, when an intervening junior lienholder claimed its interest in the property was prejudiced by differences between the terms of the subrogated loan and the original loans. (2) Whether the intervening junior lienholder was prejudiced by lack of notice of the subrogating loan transaction and resulting lien under the doctrine of equitable subrogation.


2 CA-CV 2011-0143  In re U.S. CURRENCY IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,390  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0143
Issues Summary: In an uncontested forfeiture action, must the state provide notice of pending forfeiture to a potential claimant who has no readily ascertainable interest in the property to be forfeited?


2 CA-CV 2011-0153  BELEN LOAN INVESTORS, LLC v. MYERS, BAUMGARDNER, LOS LUNA HIGHLANDS  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0153
Issues Summary: In a professional negligent misrepresentation action, did the trial court err in finding as a matter of law that a property developer’s appraiser owed no duty to third-party lenders who allegedly relied upon the appraisal to make loans for the property’s purchase and development, and in therefore dismissing the lenders’ claims against the appraiser?


2 CA-CV 2011-0166  CATALINA FOOTHILLS UNIF. SCH. DISTR. NO. 16 v. LA PALOMA  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0166
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in certifying a “partial judgment” for appeal pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., when the partial judgment does not dispose of any claim or party? If so, does this court nevertheless have jurisdiction over the appeal from that partial judgment, which incorporates an order of immediate possession, as an interlocutory judgment under A.R.S. § 12-2101(A)(6)?


2 CA-CV 2012-0105  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SUN SURETY INSURANCE COMPANY  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0105
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in exonerating a surety’s appearance bond, notwithstanding the defendant’s failure to appear for a pretrial hearing, on the ground the court had failed to notify the surety, as required by Rule 7.6(c)(1), Ariz. R. Crim. P., that the court had issued a warrant for the defendant's arrest?


2 CA-CV 2012-0125  MACKINNEY v. CITY OF TUCSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0125
Issues Summary: In a negligence action for injuries on a city-owned golf course, did the trial court err in determining that a golf course is not a protected “premises” under Arizona’s recreational-use immunity statute, A.R.S. § 33-1551, and was the plaintiff a recreational user of that golf course as defined by the statute?


2 CA-CV 2012-0129  TOBER v. CIVANO I: NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0129
2 CA-CV 2013-0023  DELONG v. MERRILL  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0023
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred by failing to apply the standards of Rule 36(c), Ariz. R. Civ. P., to a party’s motion to file late responses to requests for admission and by granting summary judgment as a sanction for the party’s failure to provide timely responses.


2 CA-CV 2013-0065  PI'IKEA, LLC v. WILLIAMSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0065
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment for plaintiff who had brought an action on a guarantee when the defendant guarantors asserted the lender had a duty to mitigate its damages by permitting a trustee sale to occur, or to take some other recourse, years earlier when the subject property still had sufficient value to cover the debt?

2. Did the guarantors' express waiver of protections under A.R.S. § 47-3605 and "any similar or analogous other statutory or common law" duty preclude their defense that the lender had a duty to mitigate damages before the property lost significant value?


2 CA-CV 2013-0069  SOUTHWEST NON-PROFIT HOUSING CORPORATION v. NOWAK, KNIFFEN, MARTELL  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0069
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting defendant appraiser’s motion to dismiss a negligence claim based on lack of duty to plaintiff property seller who claimed a negligently prepared appraisal resulted in a lower sale price for its property?

2. In two similar, consolidated cases, did the trial court err by granting defendant appraisers’ motions for summary judgment based on lack of duty to, and reliance by, plaintiff property seller?


2 CA-CV 2014-0001  KONDAUR CAPITAL CORP. v. WHITE; BABEU  Author 2 CA-CV 2014-0001
Issues Summary: On appeal from a declaratory judgment action concerning the procurement and enforcement of writs of restitution:

1) Does the Appellant have standing to seek appellate review of issues that were resolved in its favor?

2) Does any exception to the mootness doctrine apply to Appellant’s claims?


2 CA-CV 2014-0013  IN RE $70,070 IN U.S. CURRENCY  Author 2 CA-CV 2014-0013
Issues Summary: (1) In a forfeiture action, does A.R.S. § 13-4311(H) preclude a claimant from filing a summary judgment motion before a “responsive pleading” is served?

(2) Did the trial court err by holding a probable cause hearing in connection with a Rule 12(b)(6), Ariz. R. Civ. P., motion to dismiss a forfeiture complaint and, as a result, fail to apply the proper standard in ruling on the motion?


2 CA-CV 2014-0029  BOYLE v. FORD MOTOR COMPANY  Author 2 CA-CV 2014-0029
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by imposing sanctions under Rule 68, Ariz. R. Civ. P., when the offer of judgment provided for dismissal of all claims with prejudice, rather than entry of judgment, but the offerees failed to object to the form of offer until after the jury entered its verdict and sanctions were imposed?


2 CA-MH 2011-0011-SP  IN RE THE COMMITMENT OF WILFREDO JARAMILLO  Author 2 CA-MH 2011-0011-SP
Issues Summary: Does the Sexually Violent Persons Act, A.R.S. §§ 36-3701 through 36-3717, authorize a trial court to order the Arizona Community Protection and Treatment Center to implement a specific treatment plan at the request of a person committed to treatment pursuant to that Act?


2 CA-SA 2011-0091  THE SALVATION ARMY; KELLEY v. BENNETT   Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0091
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by ordering the corporate defendant in the underlying personal injury action to produce redacted summaries of investigative interviews conducted, at the direction of counsel, with its employees and volunteers who had been present at the scene of the accident, because the documents were protected by the attorney-client privilege, A.R.S. § 12-2234?


2 CA-SA 2011-0107  SOUTHWEST GAS CORPORATION; TAYLOR v. GRUBB   Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0107
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge err by concluding he lacked jurisdiction to conduct further proceedings in the underlying wrongful death action after the real party in interest filed a notice of appeal from the summary judgment entered in favor of one of multiple defendants and certified as final pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P.?


2 CA-SA 2012-0025  SIERRA TUCSON; CRC HEALTH GROUP v. LOUISE LITWACK  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0025
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in the underlying wrongful death action by granting the real party in interest leave to file a first-amended complaint adding a Pima County resident as a defendant after the defendants had filed an affidavit pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-404(A) requesting that the case be transferred to Pinal County, and real party in interest did not file a controverting affidavit within the five-day period prescribed by the statute?


2 CA-CR 2010-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NELSON IVAN BOTEO-FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0106
Issues Summary: Whether appellant’s admissions after his de facto arrest were sufficiently an act of free will to purge the primary taint of the illegal arrest and whether the state waived this argument by not raising it below.


2 CA-CR 2011-0277  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ANTONIO LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0277
Issues Summary: Does the Fifth Amendment prohibit the state from commenting on a defendant’s pre arrest, pre-Miranda silence where there has been no official compulsion for the defendant to speak?


2 CA-CR 2011-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM PETER MORAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0346
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in finding reasonable suspicion for the defendant’s traffic stop or probable cause for his arrest for suspected driving under the influence of an intoxicant (DUI)? (2) Did the defendant’s two DUI convictions from Nevada for offenses committed in 2005 support his convictions for aggravated DUI pursuant to A.R.S. § 28-1383(A)(2)?


2 CA-CR 2011-0357  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALYSSA MARIE BURR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0357
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by reviewing de novo and then reversing another superior court judge's previous determination in the same case that manifest necessity had existed for a mistrial?


2 CA-CR 2012-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY DURAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0003
Issues Summary: Whether the defendant preserved for appeal his challenge to the trial court’s pretrial ruling allowing the state to impeach him with statements made during change-of-plea proceedings when the defendant did not testify at trial


2 CA-CR 2012-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUILLERMO E. COONEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0061
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in admitting evidence of time spent incarcerated to prove Cooney’s prior DUI convictions occurred within the statutory time period necessary to establish aggravated DUI? 2) Did the use of Cooney’s two prior DUI convictions as elements of aggravated DUI violate double jeopardy?


2 CA-CR 2012-0063  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUILLERMO C. BECERRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0063
Issues Summary: Was the stop of Becerra’s vehicle based on a broken tail lamp constitutional, notwithstanding that A.R.S. § 28-925 requires only one tail lamp function properly, where the officer cited public safety reasons for the stop?

Was Becerra denied his constitutional right to a jury trial as a result of an invalid waiver and, if so, is the proper remedy to remand for limited findings on that issue or to vacate his convictions and remand for a new trial?


2 CA-CR 2012-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH LAWRENCE DIXON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0065
Issues Summary: Did the state have subject matter jurisdiction over appellant’s sexual exploitation of a minor based on his possession of visual depictions where the state did not prove a criminal offense had been committed against a minor during the creation of those depictions? For the same reason, did the trial court err by imposing enhanced sentences for his convictions as dangerous crimes against children pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-705?


2 CA-CR 2012-0153  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT JUNIOR LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0153
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in reducing defendant’s monetary penalties to a criminal restitution order at sentencing and by ordering that “no interest, penalties, or collection fees” would accrue while the defendant was incarcerated?


2 CA-CR 2012-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN DAVID SALAZAR-MERCADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0155
Issues Summary: Does Rule 702, Ariz. R. Evid., require the per se preclusion of an expert witness who intends to provide general testimony without applying her principles and methods to the facts of the case? Did the trial court err in admitting a victim’s prior inconsistent statement to a police detective as substantive evidence?


2 CA-CR 2012-0207-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LEE HESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0207-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in considering the state’s rebuttal evidence in evaluating whether petitioner’s newly discovered evidence probably would result in a different verdict?


2 CA-CR 2012-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY CONNUE SERRANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0215
Issues Summary: (1) Was the trial court authorized to enter a discretionary sex offender registration order more than two weeks after pronouncing the defendant’s judgment and sentence? (2) Does this court have jurisdiction over the defendant’s appeal?


2 CA-CR 2012-0225  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SUSAN IRENE HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0225
Issues Summary: When a presentence report stated a defendant would not be able to successfully participate in sex offender treatment programs or probation because she refused to discuss the offense of conviction, did the trial court violate her Fifth Amendment right to remain silent when it declined to suspend her sentence and place her on probation?


2 CA-CR 2012-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL FRANCISCO INZUNZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0273
Issues Summary: (1) Did the emergency aid exception justify the warrantless entry into and search of the defendant’s apartment where a missing, intellectually disabled adult was last seen? (2) Did the trial court err in precluding evidence of a prior sexual assault committed against the victim? (3) Did the defendant’s prior conviction in Washington for assault with a deadly weapon support the enhanced sentences imposed here?


2 CA-CR 2012-0358  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHILOE DOMINIQUE ESPINOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0358
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in barring the retrial of the defendant for aggravated robbery when a previous jury had convicted her of an improper lesser-included offense, had rendered no verdict on the aggravated robbery count, and the state had not sought the declaration of a mistrial on that count?


2 CA-CR 2012-0405  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CHARLES GLISSENDORF  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0405
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion to dismiss a child molestation charge filed ten years after the victim first reported the offense to the police? (2) Was the defendant entitled to a jury instruction derived from State v. Willits, 96 Ariz. 184, 393 P.2d 274 (1964), due to the state’s destruction of a video recording that documented the victim’s initial allegation of child molestation? (3) Did the trial court commit reversible error in admitting evidence pursuant to Rule 404(c), Ariz. R. Evid., to show the defendant had an aberrant sexual propensity to commit the charged offenses?


2 CA-CR 2012-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARVIN WHIT WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0411
Issues Summary: Does sufficient evidence support the defendant’s conviction for attempted robbery, given that he was acquitted of other related charges?


2 CA-CR 2012-0479  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYNERIAL RAY KINDRED  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0479
Issues Summary: 1) Does inserting a pry bar partially into a door jamb constitute “entry” as defined by A.R.S. § 13-1501(3) for the purpose of determining whether defendant committed second-degree burglary? 2) When the defendant forced entry into an apartment, and there was some evidence suggesting the apartment was visibly empty and unoccupied, was there sufficient evidence the defendant intended to commit a felony upon entry?


2 CA-CR 2012-0505  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS J. TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0505
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in using a verdict form that treated manslaughter upon sudden quarrel or heat of passion as a lesser-included offense of second-degree murder? 2) Did the trial court err in finding the presence of a child as an aggravating factor?


2 CA-CR 2012-0513  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND ANTHONY HALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0513
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in concluding that a set-aside of a conviction pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-907 necessarily includes the restoration of a person’s right to possession of firearms?


2 CA-CR 2013-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON ALBERT SEAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0001-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in declining to award presentence incarceration credit in imposing sentence when the defendant was transferred from prison to a county jail for arraignment, the trial court set no release conditions at arraignment, and the defendant was not returned to prison following arraignment?


2 CA-CR 2013-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERONICA SANCHEZ-EQUIHUA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0003
Issues Summary: Was defendant's constitutional right to compulsory process violated when: her codefendants signed plea agreements stating they had no exculpatory information, the state acknowledged it might seek to withdraw the codefendants' plea agreements if they provided exculpatory testimony, and the codefendants then refused to testify based on a fear of reinstated charges? Did the trial court err by failing to compel the codefendants' testimony?


2 CA-CR 2013-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR CASTILLO MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0083
Issues Summary: 1) Did sufficient evidence support the defendant’s conviction for child molestation when the facts established that he “humped” the victim when they were both clothed, and the victim was under a blanket and did not feel the defendant’s genitals? 2) Did the trial court err in instructing the jury on (a) the elements of child molestation or (b) the defense of lack of sexual motivation?


2 CA-CR 2013-0094-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON ESCARENO MERAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0094-PR
Issues Summary: Does Martinez v. Ryan, ___ U.S. ___, 132 S. Ct. 1309 (2012), constitute a significant change in the law permitting a non-pleading defendant to raise a claim of ineffective assistance of Rule 32 counsel?


2 CA-CR 2013-0116  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADOLFO NOEL RUIZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0116
Issues Summary: (1) Is attempted manslaughter by sudden quarrel or heat of passion a cognizable offense under Arizona law if the person only intended to cause serious physical injury rather than death?

(2) Did the trial court err by instructing the jury pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-401, which bars the use of certain defenses to charged crimes?

(3) Did the trial court err when it declined to further instruct the jury on the relationship of provocation to self-defense?

(4) Did the trial court err by omitting the word “safely” when instructing pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-404(B)(3)(a), which sets forth when the threat or use of physical force against another is not justified?


2 CA-CR 2013-0129  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID GIBBONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0129
2 CA-CR 2013-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONE ALEX GILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0156
Issues Summary: When the defendant admitted to investigating police officers that he had been drinking and driving the truck involved in the recent accident near his house, did the doctrine of corpus delicti prevent him from being convicted of aggravated driving under the influence or criminal damage?


2 CA-CR 2013-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REUBEN RENEE COTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0185
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in conducting a supplemental closing argument in the defendant’s absence without a personal waiver of his right to be present? 2. Did the court err in entering a criminal restitution order at sentencing for (a) the unpaid balance of the court-ordered restitution and (b) other fees and assessments?


2 CA-CR 2013-0368  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID SOTO CECENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0368
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by denying the appellant's request for presentence incarceration credit under A.R.S. § 13-712(B) for time incarcerated in a foreign country while extradition proceeded?


2 CA-CR 2013-0507  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR JACQUES ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0507
2 CA-CV 2011-0027  RICHARD ANDERSON v. VALLEY UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT #22  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0027
Issues Summary: May a teacher appeal a disciplinary decision of a school district’s governing board beyond the superior court?


2 CA-CV 2011-0070  DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF PIMA COUNTY v. BETH FORD; PIMA COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0070
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in denying an award of attorney fees, under A.R.S. § 39 121.02(B), after finding that neither party “substantially prevailed.” Whether the trial court erred in denying an award of costs, under A.R.S. § 12-341, in a special action brought pursuant to title 39, chapter 1, article 2.


2 CA-CV 2011-0107  VAN HEESWYK v. JABIRU AIRCRAFT PTY., LTD.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0107
Issues Summary: In a wrongful death action brought by the surviving family members of a deceased Arizona pilot, did the trial court err by ruling Arizona did not have personal jurisdiction over an Australian aircraft manufacturer, Jabiru Pty., Ltd., when it does not have offices or employees in Arizona but sells its products in the state through its exclusive North American distributors?


2 CA-CV 2011-0117  DESSAROLLO IMMOBILIARIO Y NEGOCIOS INDUSTRIALES DE ALTA TECNOLOGIA DE HERMOSILLO v. KADER HOLDINGS COMPANY LIMITED  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0117
Issues Summary: 1. Whether the trial court erred in exercising personal jurisdiction over appellant based on a forum selection clause in a lease agreement signed by appellant as guarantor when the separate guarantee did not also provide that Arizona was a proper forum for litigation. 2. Whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment against appellant for the tenant’s breach of the underlying lease agreement when the lease had been modified to extend the lease term and to change the payment arrangements under the lease.


2 CA-CV 2011-0133  METZLER v. BCI COCA-COLA BOTTLING COMPANY OF LOS ANGELES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0133
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in awarding prejudgment interest pursuant to Rule 68(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P., from the date of the offer of judgment to the date of a judgment vacated by the grant of a new trial, rather than to the date of the subsequent judgment on mandate?


2 CA-CV 2011-0145  CITY OF SIERRA VISTA v. SIERRA VISTA WARDS SYSTEM VOTING PROJECT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0145
Issues Summary: In this action to enforce the campaign finance reporting requirements of title 16, did the trial court err by granting summary judgment in favor of the City of Sierra Vista, and against the Sierra Vista Wards System Voting Project, based on the Project’s failure to exhaust administrative remedies? Do the applicable statutes authorize two separate civil penalties? Is the civil penalty authorized in § 16-918 capped at $1,000 by § 16-924?


2 CA-CV 2012-0015  BRUINS v. DESERT VILLA ADULT CARE, INC....  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0015
2 CA-CV 2012-0037  GORMAN v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0037
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred by granting summary judgment to Pima County on plaintiffs’ breach of contract and estoppel claims based on its finding that: 1) the parties did not have an enforceable contract for the funding and construction of a county project; and, 2) the county was not estopped from denying any obligation to return the funds the plaintiffs had paid for the design and construction of the project.


2 CA-CV 2012-0063  COHEN v. LOVITT & TOUCHE, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0063
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in determining Arizona public policy categorically bars insurance coverage of restitutionary payments?

2. Did the trial court err in determining payments made in the settlement of a class action were restitutionary in nature?


2 CA-CV 2012-0069  DEVINE and BOSTON v. RANDOLPH; CAMPUS ACQUISITIONS HOLDINGS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0069
2 CA-CV 2012-0073  FLORES v. MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0073
Issues Summary: Whether the court of appeals has jurisdiction over an appeal from the trial court’s order which was entered while this court’s mandate in a prior appeal had not yet issued.


2 CA-CV 2012-0077  TUMACACORI MISSION LAND DEVELOPMENT, LTD. v. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0077
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by denying appellant’s motion to amend its complaint to add alternative easement theories where the motion was filed after summary judgment against appellants on different legal theories had been entered and affirmed on appeal, but before the mandate had issued?


2 CA-CV 2012-0085  DELO v. GMAC MORTGAGE, LLC, U.S. BANK, N.A.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0085
Issues Summary: In this quiet title action, did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee who had obtained a treasurer’s deed to the property following a tax-lien foreclosure lawsuit, where: (1) appellee had neither given notice to or joined appellants as parties in the foreclosure lawsuit; (2) appellant Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. (MERS) had been designated nominee for the lender and lender’s successors and assigns, beneficiary, and legal title holder, under a deed of trust recorded before the foreclosure lawsuit; (3) appellant GMAC’s interest in the property as assignee of the original lender’s interest had not been recorded but was registered on MERS’s electronic records; and, (4) appellee had filed a lis pendens indicating the foreclosure action had been filed?


2 CA-CV 2012-0111  PIMA COUNTY HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH SERVICES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0111
Issues Summary: Did the superior court err in affirming in part and remanding the Arizona Department of Health Services’ denial of the Pima County Human Rights Committee's (PCHRC) request, pursuant to A.R.S. § 41-3804(l), for information regarding deaths of persons enrolled in the mental health system? Did the court err by dismissing PCHRC’s petition for special action because there was an adequate remedy by appeal?


2 CA-CV 2012-0152  WYCKOFF v. MOGOLLON HEALTH ALLIANCE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0152
Issues Summary: 1. Does this court have jurisdiction to consider the trial court’s vacation of a default judgment? 2. Did plaintiff’s failure to timely serve her complaint cause her action to abate? 3. Did the trial court err in finding the default judgment was void, rather than voidable? 4. Under the discovery rule, when does a cause of action for a mold related illness accrue?


2 CA-CV 2012-0161  IN RE BOND FORFEITURE IN COCHISE COUNTY CAUSE NO. CR201100916  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0161
Issues Summary: Did the trial court violate article II, § 22 of the Arizona Constitution by setting bail for a criminal defendant without first determining whether he was on release for another felony offense? Did the state have a duty to notify the court of the defendant’s release status before bond was set? Did the court err in ordering the bond forfeited because it was void ab initio?


2 CA-CV 2012-0167  JOHNSON, JR., dba BUTCH JOHNSON FARMS v. BINKLEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0167
2 CA-CV 2012-0175  GLOBAL MUSIC SUPPLY, LLC v. PRESTINI INTERNATIONAL, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0175
2 CA-CV 2013-0008  PINAL COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE v. PINAL COUNTY EMPLOYEE MERIT COMMISSION; JAMES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0008
2 CA-CV 2013-0015  ROGERS v. BOARD OF REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0015
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining when a quiet title action for an easement by implication accrues against a public entity pursuant to the one-year statute of limitations under A.R.S. § 12-821?


2 CA-CV 2013-0024  YANNI, THOMPSON, GUNDERSON, SAYEGH v. TUCKER PLUMBING, INC., BREWER ENTERPRISES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0024
Issues Summary: Are subcontractors of new home construction subject to suit by homeowners for breach of the implied warranty of workmanship and habitability absent contractual privity with the homeowners?


2 CA-CV 2013-0051  MM&A PRODUCTIONS, LLC v. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0051
Issues Summary: Can the doctrine of apparent authority be applied in a contract action to conclude an Indian Nation’s employee waived the Nation’s sovereign immunity?

Did the trial court err by not allowing further discovery or an evidentiary hearing before ruling it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over appellant’s contract action?


2 CA-CV 2013-0053  TIMMONS v. ROSS DRESS FOR LESS, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0053
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in granting defendant retail store's motion for summary judgment on the basis that it was not the owner or controller of the premises where plaintiff fell? 2) Did the trial court err in denying plaintiff's motion to amend her complaint?


2 CA-CV 2013-0059  LIBBY v. LICHTE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0059
2 CA-CV 2013-0089  STANT v. CITY OF MARICOPA EMPLOYEE MERIT BOARD, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0089
Issues Summary: 1. Does this court have jurisdiction over a discharged law enforcement officer’s appeal under A.R.S. § 38-1004 from the decision of a city or its merit board? 2. If so, does the record here support the decision of the city or board?


2 CA-CV 2013-0105  LOPEZ v. FOOD CITY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0105
Issues Summary: Should this court apply Rule 9(b)(2)(B) of the amended Rules of Civil Appellate Procedure, effective as of January 1, 2014, to our consideration of jurisdiction over this appeal?


2 CA-CV 2013-0113  MUNGER CHADWICK v. FARWEST DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF THE SOUTHWEST, LLC, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0113
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding that a law firm was eligible for an award of attorney fees when representing itself?


2 CA-CV 2013-0139  CAMPOS v. CAMPOS and ARBOLIDA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0139
2 CA-CV 2013-0143  SVENDSEN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0143
Issues Summary: (1) When the suspension of a driver’s license has been appealed to the superior court pursuant to our implied consent statute, A.R.S. § 28-1321, does the Arizona Department of Transportation have a statutory right to appeal the superior court’s decision? (2) If so, did the administrative law judge err in sustaining the suspension here?


2 CA-CV 2013-0145  CANYON COMMUNITY BANK v. ALDERSON, ALDERSON FAMILY TRUST  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0145
2 CA-CV 2014-0019  MYRICK v. MALONEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0019
Issues Summary: (1) In this domestic-relations proceeding, did the trial court abuse its discretion by declining to award the appellant her attorney fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-324(A), given the significant disparity in the parties’ incomes? (2) Are attorney fees available in a final judgment pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-403.08?


2 CA-CV 2014-0022  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF THORN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0022
Issues Summary: 1. Filed more than thirty days after the entry of the judgment, did the untimely portion of the amended notice of appeal bar appellate jurisdiction to address the distribution of community personal property?

2. Did the trial court err in ordering Husband to return certain stocks and bonds to Wife?

3. Was Husband judicially estopped from arguing a contrary position on appeal regarding the equitable distribution of the marital residence; alternatively, did the trial court err in its distribution?

4. Did the trial court err in determining that a loan from Wife to Husband remained unpaid?


2 CA-IC 2012-0001  JOSE A. ESCOBAR v. MARSHALL FOUNDATION and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0001
Issues Summary: Whether, in light of Rodgers v. Industrial Commission, 109 Ariz. 216, 508 P.2d 46 (1973), this court should abrogate its decision in Hoosava v. Industrial Commission, 1 Ariz. App. 6, 398 P.2d 683 (1965), in which we concluded that multiple impairments to one extremity resulting from a single industrial accident are to be compensated as scheduled pursuant to A.R.S. § 23-1044(B).


2 CA-IC 2013-0001  JULIE MUNOZ v. SONIC RESTAURANTS #10 and HARTFORD ACCIDENT & INDEMNITY/GALLAGHER BASSETT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0001
Issues Summary: Did the ALJ properly conclude that Munoz’s concurrent earnings from her horse training business must be excluded from her average monthly wage calculation because her business was not covered employment under the Workers’ Compensation Act?


2 CA-IC 2013-0005  PALOMINAS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DIST. & AZ SCHOOL ALLIANCE v. SPECIAL FUND & MARTHA M. VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0005
2 CA-IC 2013-0015  JOHAHNS B. ANDERSON v. PINNACLE PEAK and SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0015
2 CA-IC 2014-0005  CITY OF TUCSON and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT v. SCOTT WOODWORTH  Participating 2 CA-IC 2014-0005
Issues Summary: 1. Did the ALJ err in finding that petitioner did not experience pain associated with herniation?

2. Did the ALJ err in finding petitioner’s claim compensable under the hernia statute, A.R.S. § 23-1043(2), despite petitioner’s lack of pain associated with herniation?


2 CA-JV 2012-0005  XAVIER R. and ATHENA R. v. ADES and JOSEPH R.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0005
Issues Summary: 1) Whether the notice of appeal filed by the children’s attorney in an appeal from the denial of a motion to sever parental rights complied with Rule 104(B), Ariz. R. Crim. P.

2) Whether the juvenile court abused its discretion in determining ADES had not met its burden to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that severance of the father’s parental rights was in the children’s best interests.


2 CA-JV 2013-0029  BENNIGNO R. v. ADES, S.R. and L.R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0029
Issues Summary: (1) Does the principle of res judicata bar the Arizona Department of Economic Security (ADES) from re-litigating in a proceeding on its second motion to terminate a parent’s rights, the issue of whether termination of the parent’s rights was in a child’s best interest, after the court determined, following a hearing on ADES’s first motion to terminate the parent’s rights, that ADES had not sustained its burden of establishing best interests? Did the juvenile court err in this case by denying the appellant father’s motion for summary judgment based on res judicata under such circumstances?

(2) Did the appellant father waive the right to question in a severance proceeding the reasonableness and propriety of services provided by ADES throughout the dependency, when the father did not request additional services during that time or object to the juvenile court’s periodic reasonable-efforts findings?

(3) Waiver notwithstanding, does the record support the juvenile court’s determination that ADES had made a diligent effort to provide reunification services, and that termination of the father’s rights was in the children’s best interests?


2 CA-MH 2012-0005  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20100837  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0005
2 CA-SA 2011-0095  STAR PUBLISHING CO. v. STATE OF ARIZONA, TIMOTHY LYNN KREUS  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0095
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge err in declining to a hold a hearing on the petitioner’s request made pursuant to Rule 122, Ariz. R. P. Sup. Ct., to permit photographic and electronic coverage of a trial, and did the respondent err in considering, as a basis for denying the request, that it had been filed two working days before the trial was scheduled to begin?


2 CA-SA 2012-0015  JOSEPH M. ARPAIO v. JENNIFER BRAILLARD   Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0015
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court could require defendants against whom a claim for punitive damages had been made to produce financial information and provide it to their own attorneys before the plaintiff had established a prima facie case of liability for punitive damages.


2 CA-SA 2012-0067  CORNERSTONE HOSPITAL OF SOUTHEAST ARIZONA v. ERNEST H. BLACKBURN  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0067
Issues Summary: 1. Did the respondent judge err as a matter of law and thereby abuse his discretion by finding A.R.S. § 12-2604, which prescribes the qualifications for standard-of-care experts in medical malpractice actions, does not apply to an action brought pursuant to the Adult Protective Services Act, A.R.S. §§ 46-451 through 46-459, that is based on allegations of medical negligence?

2. Did the respondent judge err by finding real party in interest’s designated standard-of-care expert, a registered nurse with various nursing degrees, qualified to testify about the standard of care for and conduct of registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, and certified nursing assistants involved in the care of real party in interest’s now-deceased wife at petitioner Cornerstone Hospital, a long-term acute care facility, but not qualified to provide similar testimony and opinions about purely administrative decisions made by Cornerstone’s administrative staff?


2 CA-SA 2013-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN JAMES CHASE  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0025
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in ordering the grand jury to be instructed on two different legal theories as to how the presumption of medical use under the Arizona Medical Marijuana Act applies to protect cardholders from prosecution?


2 CA-SA 2013-0031  PATRICK WHILLOCK v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0031
Issues Summary: Following petitioner’s criminal conviction in justice court, did the respondent judges err in refusing to permit petitioner to file an appellate memorandum pursuant to Rule 8(a), Ariz. Super. Ct. R. App. P.–Crim., after petitioner’s request for a trial de novo was denied?


2 CA-SA 2013-0053  STEVEN LANE FULLER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0053
Issues Summary: 1. Did the state violate the requirement in A.R.S. § 36-3706 that a person alleged to be an SVP must have a trial within 120 days?

2. If the requirement was violated, was Fuller sufficiently prejudiced by the violation to require dismissal of the SVP proceeding?


2 CA-SA 2013-0099  TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT v. GALLAGHER; CORUM  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0099
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in denying defendant's motion for summary judgment in which defendant asserted it was immune to plaintiffs' claims pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-820.05 and that plaintiffs' A.R.S. § 12-821.01 notice of claim was insufficient?


2 CA-SA 2014-0015  KEENAN REED-KALIHER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2014-0015
Issues Summary: When the petitioner was on probation for possession of a narcotic drug for sale, did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying his motion to modify the terms of that probation to allow him to use marijuana pursuant to Arizona's Medical Marijuana Act?


2 CA-CR 2004-0251  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY NOEM VETA  Author 2 CA-CR 2004-0251
2 CA-CR 2004-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS RAFAEL MENDOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2004-0253
2 CA-CR 2005-0047  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS REYNALDO LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0047
2 CA-CR 2005-0219  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CYNTHIA D. JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0219
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant can be convicted of felony murder pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-1105(A)(2) in the absence of evidence that the defendant was either an accomplice to or a participant in the specific offense alleged as the predicate felony.


2 CA-CR 2005-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0319
2 CA-CR 2005-0353  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EFRAIN MERINO GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0353
2 CA-CR 2005-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN BEN BADILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0369
2 CA-CR 2005-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0409
2 CA-CR 2006-0019  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ANTHONY MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0019
2 CA-CR 2006-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0025
2 CA-CR 2006-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD MICHAEL SWEET  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0029
2 CA-CR 2006-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ALBERTO QUEVEDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0031
2 CA-CR 2006-0049  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GREG McCURDY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0049
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding a witness qualified to recite the contents of a business record even though the court had precluded admission of the actual document under Rule 403, Ariz. R. Evid.?

2. Was the evidence sufficient to permit the jury to find that the defendant was the same person previously convicted in another jurisdiction?

3. Was the trial court required to amend the presentence report pursuant to Rule 26.8(c), Ariz. R. Crim. P., based on the defendant’s allegations that it contained incorrect information?


2 CA-CR 2006-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER JOSEPH VISCONTI, IV  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0059
2 CA-CR 2006-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNIE CHANDLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0071
2 CA-CR 2006-0081  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVAN DEON KUHLMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0081
2 CA-CR 2006-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MARCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0083
2 CA-CR 2006-0095  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GILES CONNOLLY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0095
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 12-116, which imposes a time-payment fee on those who pay a court-ordered “penalty, fine, or sanction” on an installment basis, apply to a defendant who is ordered to reimburse the county for the costs of attorney fees?


2 CA-CR 2006-0113  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEBRA LYNN VENABLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0113
2 CA-CR 2006-0115  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOEL ALEJANDRO ALCAREZ-GUERRERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0115
2 CA-CR 2006-0117  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY CARLOS MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0117
2 CA-CR 2006-0135  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG ALLEN BAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0135
2 CA-CR 2006-0167-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERNIE LEE DURAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0167-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0175-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BEATRIZ AURORA BLACKWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0175-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE WILLIAM McLEMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0177
2 CA-CR 2006-0179  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE BRIAN CARR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0179
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in admitting urine test evidence at appellant’s probation revocation proceeding over his objections based on reliability and chain of custody?

2. Did the admission of written urinalysis results without requiring a laboratory employee to testify and be cross-examined violate appellant’s Sixth Amendment confrontation rights as interpreted in Crawford v. Washington?


2 CA-CR 2006-0183  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DEAN McCOY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0183
2 CA-CR 2006-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADRIAN GARCIA PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0186
2 CA-CR 2006-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANNON JANE PARKS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0187
2 CA-CR 2006-0203  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL MANUEL DIXON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0203
Issues Summary: Is evidence of accidental loss or inadvertence by a property owner required to support a conviction for theft of lost or misdelivered property in violation of A.R.S. § 13-1814(A)(4)?


2 CA-CR 2006-0207-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEE McCLAIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0207-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER OSWALDO COOPER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0211
2 CA-CR 2006-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADLEY ALAN SCHWARTZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0213
2 CA-CR 2006-0217  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHON JOEL MICHITSCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0217
2 CA-CR 2006-0225-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY DALE INGMIRE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0225-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN GEORGE AMMON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0237
2 CA-CR 2006-0255  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JANE CHRISTINE LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0255
2 CA-CR 2006-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORLANDO J. MENDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0273
2 CA-CR 2006-0287-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CLAUDE DANIELS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0287-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0307  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMMANUEL ROBLES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0307
2 CA-CR 2006-0313-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDOLPH CHARLES ARENAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0313-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY PETER TULL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0315
2 CA-CR 2006-0321-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERNARD ERNEST COLONNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0321-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0323  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES NORMAN SWANSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0323
2 CA-CR 2006-0327  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESTLEY NAT LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0327
2 CA-CR 2006-0333-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY ALLEN HINES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0333-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR JACQUES ORTIZ, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0335
2 CA-CR 2006-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS BERNARDO GRANILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0343
2 CA-CR 2006-0345  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JAVIER QUINTANA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0345
2 CA-CR 2006-0349-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCIS JOSEPH FLAHERTY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0349-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLEMENT JUSTIN LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0363
2 CA-CR 2006-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADRIAN AGUILAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0365
2 CA-CR 2006-0377  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN RAY WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0377
2 CA-CR 2006-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ADRIAN JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0381
2 CA-CR 2006-0385-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENE WALTER KLINK  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0385-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0391  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA ANTONIA CASTILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0391
2 CA-CR 2006-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL MORRIS BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0399
2 CA-CR 2006-0402  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDY LOYA ROMERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0402
2 CA-CR 2006-0405-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEOFFREY CLARK HUNTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0405-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0415  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAJORNSAK PRASERTPHONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0415
2 CA-CR 2006-0421  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY JOE MIRAMONTEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0421
2 CA-CR 2006-0439-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EDWARD COX  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0439-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0445  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRELL RENNELL STEPHNEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0445
2 CA-CR 2007-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD DINO SHAW  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0015-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL JESUS CORDOVA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0015-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN AUGUSTA COLLINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0045
2 CA-CR 2007-0059-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDY T. CISNEROS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0059-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0065  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK JOSEPH SARULLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0065
Issues Summary: 1. Whether burglary and theft convictions violated the corpus delicti rule when the only direct evidence was the defendant’s confession but the state presented uncontradicted evidence of closely related crimes. 2. Whether for the purposes of burglary and theft convictions the defendant had the requisite intent to permanently deprive the victim of property when he testified he did not intend to keep the victim’s stolen revolver, but to kill himself in front of her with it. 3. Whether all occupants of a home are victims of a burglary for purposes of Arizona’s Victim Witness Protection Act.


2 CA-CR 2007-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW MICHAEL PERALTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0067
2 CA-CR 2007-0075-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO CHAPARRO ROMERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0075-PR
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 13-901.01(A), which requires a court to suspend the imposition of sentence and place on probation a defendant convicted for the first time of personal possession or use of a controlled substance, apply to a conviction for promoting prison contraband in violation of A.R.S. § 13-2505(A)(3)?


2 CA-CR 2007-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX JOSEPH PEDRIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0087
2 CA-CR 2007-0088  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE GONZALEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0088
2 CA-CR 2007-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN MICHAEL TOLAGIAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0099
2 CA-CR 2007-0113  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO AARON LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0113
2 CA-CR 2007-0121  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANGELITO VANNATTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0121
2 CA-CR 2007-0123-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUPERT RAY DIXON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0123-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0127-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LESLIE SAPP  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0127-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0131-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NAOMIS WINFREY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0131-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0165-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ERIC STOKES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0165-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELLA KATHLEEN MCCARTHY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0189
2 CA-CR 2007-0211-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS DUANE WALSH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0211-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0221-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT F. LESKOVSKY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0221-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0229-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARGARITO RUBIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0229-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0245  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMONA LEE CLARK  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0245
2 CA-CR 2007-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFONSO G. FRAGOSO   Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0253-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LUIS SUZARREY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0253-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0255  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE DWAYNE FLEMONS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0255
2 CA-CR 2007-0257  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL RODRIGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0257
2 CA-CR 2007-0271-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NEWTON WRIGHT ARMSTRONG, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0271-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0277-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN MICHAEL PLOOF  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0277-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBY JOSEPH HARRIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0329
2 CA-CR 2007-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO FUENTES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0343
2 CA-CR 2007-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GIOVANNI ROGERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0347
2 CA-CR 2007-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS DWAYNE GAINES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL FRANCISCO VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0363
2 CA-CR 2007-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABRAAN RENE ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0375
2 CA-CR 2007-0387  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL MONTOYA TORRES, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0387
2 CA-CR 2007-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS MARTIN SANDOVAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0389
2 CA-CR 2007-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE CHIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0398
2 CA-CR 2007-0399-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRANCE ANTHONY ALSTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0399-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT A. BONANNO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0411
2 CA-CR 2008-0009  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0009
2 CA-CR 2008-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0024
Issues Summary: Whether probable cause supported the arrest of a passenger when the vehicle in which he was riding, its location, and the manner in which drugs were concealed corresponded to specific information police officers had received from an informant and indicated the passenger and driver were working in concert to transport the drugs.


2 CA-CR 2008-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN WAYNE FOOTE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0041
2 CA-CR 2008-0043-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT EVANS-GOODIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0043-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER LEE AWTREY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0045
2 CA-CR 2008-0047-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARYL EUGENE KILGORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0047-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0052  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GEORGE CORTESE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0052
2 CA-CR 2008-0054  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RENE GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0054
2 CA-CR 2008-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY LAMAR SIMMONS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0056
2 CA-CR 2008-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO LOPEZ SEPULVEDA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0067
2 CA-CR 2008-0069  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN ROCKY ACUNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0069
2 CA-CR 2008-0073  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY SANCHEZ BEJARANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0073
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 13-4032(6), which permits the state to appeal from the granting of a motion to suppress evidence, provides appellate jurisdiction over the state’s appeal of a trial court’s order precluding a witness as a disclosure sanction under Rule 15.7, Ariz. R. Crim. P.


2 CA-CR 2008-0081  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN RUSSEL HENDRIX  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0081
2 CA-CR 2008-0089  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEON DEAN LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0089
2 CA-CR 2008-0092  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAMONI VOLE VEAMATAHAU  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0092
2 CA-CR 2008-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY VEAMATAHAU  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0093
2 CA-CR 2008-0099-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY P. VANDERSOMMEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0099-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0104  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN ALEXANDER McKENNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0104
2 CA-CR 2008-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY CHARLES MONK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0106
2 CA-CR 2008-0114  STATE OF ARIZONA v. J. JESUS BARRIGA ACEVEDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0114
2 CA-CR 2008-0135-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES ALAN AMATOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0135-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0136  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0136
2 CA-CR 2008-0144  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL MARK DURSO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0144
2 CA-CR 2008-0150  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM DENNIS LEE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0150
2 CA-CR 2008-0151  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEOFFREY AARON HOWERTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0151
2 CA-CR 2008-0175  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRITNI KAY KUHFELD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0175
2 CA-CR 2008-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE MENDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0202
2 CA-CR 2008-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LELAND LEWIS HOGAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0206
2 CA-CR 2008-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LAURENCE HARVEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORVIE ROWLAND STRECK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0226
Issues Summary: 1. Is a tractor a means of transportation for purposes of A.R.S. § 13-1814? 2. Are a victim’s travel costs incurred in investigating stolen property compensable expenses?


2 CA-CR 2008-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LYNDALL DWAIN THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0236
2 CA-CR 2008-0238  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERENA MARIE CABALLERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0238
2 CA-CR 2008-0248  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REFUGIO RINCON, aka ARTURO MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0248
2 CA-CR 2008-0250  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMADI SCHALON CANNON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0250
2 CA-CR 2008-0262  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE FLORES LEYVA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0262
2 CA-CR 2008-0264  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE RAMON VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0264
2 CA-CR 2008-0274  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0274
2 CA-CR 2008-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS CHRISTOPHER DALZELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0276
2 CA-CR 2008-0280-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD WAYNE HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0280-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMY DEWAYNE WAYMIRE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0286
2 CA-CR 2008-0302  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0302
2 CA-CR 2008-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE MENDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0306-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CONRAD WHEELOCK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0306-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0308-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK S. BRASHIER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0308-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ANTHONY SALOMON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0310
2 CA-CR 2008-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD CHARLES NOCEO, MICHAEL HARRIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0315
Issues Summary: Whether alleged deficiencies in law enforcement phlebotomy programs rendered particular blood draws conducted in a reasonable manner at the scene of two defendants’ DUI arrests unconstitutional


2 CA-CR 2008-0324  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIKA IRENE OZUNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0324
2 CA-CR 2008-0326  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID PATRICK YOUNG  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0326
2 CA-CR 2008-0330  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON MICHAEL PATROU  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0330
2 CA-CR 2008-0342  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDALL D. WEST and PENNY A. WEST  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0342
2 CA-CR 2008-0354-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTOFER ROBIN BELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0354-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0362  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE EVAN COATES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0362
2 CA-CR 2008-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDEL PAEZ IBARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0392
2 CA-CR 2008-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADRIAN VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0398
2 CA-CR 2008-0410-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WAYNE MARIETTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0410-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0418  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELLISA FINLAYSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0418
2 CA-CR 2008-0424  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NGANG JONKOR NGANG  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0424
2 CA-CR 2008-0428  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO SANCHEZ-NARANJO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0428
2 CA-CR 2009-0006  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON FERNANDO BORBON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0006
2 CA-CR 2009-0010-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOEL ALEJANDRO ALCAREZ-GUERRERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0010-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0012-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEON WAGGONER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0012-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0028  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY AURIGEMMA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0028
2 CA-CR 2009-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE W. ADAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0038
2 CA-CR 2009-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RENE MENDIBLES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0042
2 CA-CR 2009-0044  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP RICHARD SIMMONS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0044
2 CA-CR 2009-0052  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CASSIE MICHELLE CONNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0052
2 CA-CR 2009-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCUS LOUIS WILBORN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0070
2 CA-CR 2009-0076  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ZAID ANDRADE-FELIX  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0076
2 CA-CR 2009-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER JOEL HUERTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0078
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in suppressing evidence in a duffle bag found lying in the street along with other items from the defendant’s truck, when the defendant had claimed the other items but was silent as to the bag?


2 CA-CR 2009-0088-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONAH PARKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0090  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL DAVID WINDSOR, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0090
Issues Summary: Does downloading an image from a remote computer via the Internet constitute “duplicating” it for the purposes of A.R.S. § 13-3553(A)(1), prohibiting the sexual exploitation of minors?


2 CA-CR 2009-0100  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO ESTEBAN RIMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0100
2 CA-CR 2009-0106-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY CORNELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0106-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0108  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ALLEN RICE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0108
2 CA-CR 2009-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES GREG JOHNS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0120-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO VARGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0126
2 CA-CR 2009-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS BERT JORGENSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO DANIEL VERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0140
2 CA-CR 2009-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ALLISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0152-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD I. VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0152-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYRONE LITTLE CISCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0158
2 CA-CR 2009-0164-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEE HOLMEN LACEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0164-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0174-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE HUMBERTO VEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0174-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY RICHARD ENCINAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0182
2 CA-CR 2009-0184-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAY DAVID RAMSEY, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0184-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0194  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON ARREDONDO   Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0194
2 CA-CR 2009-0204-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0204-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0208-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONTE EUGENE JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0208-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0214-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLE ANTOINETTE MOTEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0214-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DEAN DeYOUNG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0232  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0232
2 CA-CR 2009-0235  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIA DE LOS ANGELES LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0235
2 CA-CR 2009-0236-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR LIRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0236-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0238-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRIS WERNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0238-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO ESTRADA, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0246
2 CA-CR 2009-0248-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD GEORGE BROWNE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0248-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW RAYMOND REXACH  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANGELO AMADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0267
2 CA-CR 2009-0284-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANE GERALD MCMILLIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0284-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLEEN JOYCE MONTOYA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0286
2 CA-CR 2009-0288  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN NORMAN MAIKOWSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0288
2 CA-CR 2009-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN SOTO-FONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0296-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LAWRENCE LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0296-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0322-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDEL PAEZ IBARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0322-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0342  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL SANCHEZ-HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0342
2 CA-CR 2009-0344  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD GARDNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0344
2 CA-CR 2009-0370  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTINE ELIZABETH HOWARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0370
2 CA-CR 2009-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD TERRAZAS VILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0372
2 CA-CR 2009-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANITA ELAINA VEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0392
2 CA-CR 2009-0394  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VLADIMIR GARCIA SOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0394
2 CA-CR 2009-0396  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERNON LEE BULLOCK, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0396
2 CA-CR 2009-0410-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK LYLE BARRICKLOW  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0410-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0008  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY D. DELOACH  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0008
2 CA-CR 2010-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH JOHN KAPLINSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0018-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES N. PETTY  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0018-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in dismissing a pleading defendant’s successive notice of post-conviction relief in which the defendant had indicated his desire to pursue a claim that Rule 32 counsel in his first of-right post-conviction proceeding had rendered ineffective assistance?


2 CA-CR 2010-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO JUNIOR MARRUFO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0024
2 CA-CR 2010-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL WILLIE ENOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0026
2 CA-CR 2010-0028  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE UZARGA RODRIGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0028
2 CA-CR 2010-0043  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOE MOODY  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0043
2 CA-CR 2010-0044  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN DICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0044
2 CA-CR 2010-0050  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARRI ANN HANSEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0050
2 CA-CR 2010-0054  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMIE L. WIEDMAIER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0054
2 CA-CR 2010-0062-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WADE DOUGLAS TACKETT, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0062-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0066-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0066-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JAVIER COCOBA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0074
2 CA-CR 2010-0080-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE BENJAMIN MORANDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0080-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0092-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL RAY BUSKE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0092-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0094-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEY ANTHONY VERDUZCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0094-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0100-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD RAY PALMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0100-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0108-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER THOMAS WARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0108-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0114-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME R. ESPINOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0114-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0116  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA WADE KOSATSCHENKO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0116
2 CA-CR 2010-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO MAYORGA RODARTE III  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0126
2 CA-CR 2010-0138-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS EUGENE WAITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0138-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0152-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMMAR DEAN HALLOUM  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0152-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0156-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHON G0RDON SPERBERG II  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0156-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0166-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ALEC KIDWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0166-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT RAY MATHIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0172
2 CA-CR 2010-0178  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFRED MORONES CANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0178
2 CA-CR 2010-0182-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LeROY JAMES MICHAEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0182-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0194-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LOPEZ VALDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0194-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0196  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CLIFTON LIVINGSTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0196
2 CA-CR 2010-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMIN JOEL MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0202
2 CA-CR 2010-0204-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GERARDO VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0204-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD VALENZUELA GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0211
2 CA-CR 2010-0214  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR FERNANDO CAMPAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0214
2 CA-CR 2010-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN EVERADO FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0226
2 CA-CR 2010-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY LAVON KIRK, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0230
2 CA-CR 2010-0232  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DELVIN TROY LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0232
2 CA-CR 2010-0250-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RYAN ROBERT BAKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0250-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE TIBUCIO VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0266  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD D. VILLEGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0266
Issues Summary: Is luring a minor for sexual exploitation, A.R.S. § 13-3554, a dangerous crime against children under § 13-705 when the victim was not a child under the age of fifteen but actually an undercover police officer?


2 CA-CR 2010-0274-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LYNDALL DWAIN THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0274-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0280  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL ALFONSO CARRASCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0280
2 CA-CR 2010-0292  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REYNALDO JESUS LEDESMA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0292
2 CA-CR 2010-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN J. TUCCI  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0296-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMILIO PINEDA SALAZAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0296-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0298-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LEE BAKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0298-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0308  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID WAYNE DROEGEMEIER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0308
2 CA-CR 2010-0312-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT RICHARD NICHOLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0312-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LORENZO REYES FELIX  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0320
2 CA-CR 2010-0326-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS JOSEPH MCGEE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0326-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0328-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RICARDO TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0328-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMIN SHAHEED MUHAMMAD-ALI  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0347
2 CA-CR 2010-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT STEVENSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0348
2 CA-CR 2010-0373  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO RENE MOLINA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0373
2 CA-CR 2010-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM WALTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0376
2 CA-CR 2010-0378-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS CHARLES HENRY   Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0378-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO DAVID PADILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0383
2 CA-CR 2010-0387  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ALLEN HAWKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0387
2 CA-CR 2010-0397  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS BEVERETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0397
2 CA-CR 2010-0398-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN PETER DUGAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0398-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0408-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0408-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINDA LEE CARPENTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0411
2 CA-CR 2011-0002-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRED AARON ETHRIDGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0002-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID GEORGE BOTBYL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0021
2 CA-CR 2011-0039-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE MIGHEL HARO-ARCE  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0039-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0044-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY SCOTT BAILEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0044-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SYDNEY MICHELE VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0045
2 CA-CR 2011-0050-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY MAZEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0050-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0058-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER RAFAEL SOTELO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0058-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0060-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY DEAN GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0060-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0066-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME RENE ESPINOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0066-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0079-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0079-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ORVIL MARTIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0085
2 CA-CR 2011-0101  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN BANARD HORTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0101
2 CA-CR 2011-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS AARON ZAVALA-CANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0109
2 CA-CR 2011-0121-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GERARDO VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0121-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0125  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCO ANTHONY GLASER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0125
2 CA-CR 2011-0139-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT TAYLOR HARDEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0139-PR
Issues Summary: Is a trial court required to appoint defense counsel before summarily dismissing, pursuant to Rule 32.2(b), Ariz. R. Crim. P., a pleading defendant’s first, but untimely, notice of post-conviction relief?


2 CA-CR 2011-0141-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON ROLLAN MARTIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0141-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0145-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYRONE JAMES KESSLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0145-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0151  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ARTHUR VERHULST  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0151
2 CA-CR 2011-0153  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARION L. HAMPTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0153
2 CA-CR 2011-0155-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO ARNULFO TREJO III  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0155-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0159  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MADRID, JR  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0159
2 CA-CR 2011-0161  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK BALLESTEROS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0161
2 CA-CR 2011-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE ALBERT ROSS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0167
2 CA-CR 2011-0173  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRIS RAYMOND LEGGETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0173
2 CA-CR 2011-0181-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER ALEXANDER GRAHAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0181-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0183  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMIE SCOTT FREEMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0183
2 CA-CR 2011-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY ALLEN WOOD  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0193
2 CA-CR 2011-0203  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY ALLEN HOLLIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0203
2 CA-CR 2011-0209-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUBERT WASHINGTON, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0209-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0211-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ALEC KIDWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0211-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0213-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES SCOTT TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0213-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0221  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LORENZO PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0221
2 CA-CR 2011-0231  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER PAUL ROMERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0231
2 CA-CR 2011-0233-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEROY JAMES MICHAEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0233-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL PETER GODOY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK EMILIANO RENTERIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0241
2 CA-CR 2011-0243  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAY SCOTT MCFADDEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0243
2 CA-CR 2011-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE ANTONIO FELIX  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0253-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RICHARDO TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0253-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VIANES JAMES CASIAS, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0265
2 CA-CR 2011-0268  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PATRICK GUMP  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0268
2 CA-CR 2011-0279-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER WAYNE FRANCIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0279-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0299-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL SANTAMARIA BONILLAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0299-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0301  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT AARON EMBRY  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0301
2 CA-CR 2011-0315-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DELL EDWIN BOSWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0315-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0319-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK MICHAEL WESTOVER  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0319-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0321-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON ROLLAN MARTIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0321-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0327  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO SANTAMARIA PARGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0327
2 CA-CR 2011-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD FREDERICK KINNER JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0329
2 CA-CR 2011-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN FRANCISCO VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0339
2 CA-CR 2011-0353  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKA KEHUALANI BLANK  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0353
2 CA-CR 2011-0363-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CHARLES TUCCIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0363-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0367  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY SHAYNE WALLACE  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0367
2 CA-CR 2011-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAUL HERRERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0369
2 CA-CR 2011-0377-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ANGEL TRUJILLO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0377-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR STACY BROOKS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0381
2 CA-CR 2011-0385  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY LYNN KREUS  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0385
2 CA-CR 2011-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDRE T. LIGHTSEY-COPELAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0389
2 CA-CR 2011-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA MICHAEL LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0395
2 CA-CR 2011-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH EDWARD CAMARGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0399
2 CA-CR 2012-0007  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL LYMAN DECKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0007
2 CA-CR 2012-0013-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIO CESAR TAPIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0013-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0019  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON HARRY IRWIN   Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0019
2 CA-CR 2012-0029-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LYNDALL DWAIN THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0029-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID HENRY SHERMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0040
2 CA-CR 2012-0049  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH EDWARD BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0049
2 CA-CR 2012-0060  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0060
2 CA-CR 2012-0071-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RYAN JOSEPH APODACA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0071-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0083-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN CORNELL WORLEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0083-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS CARLOS DORAME-RUIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0091
2 CA-CR 2012-0095  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL OCTAVIO ESTRADA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0095
2 CA-CR 2012-0101  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FEDERICO MARCOS PALAFOX  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0101
2 CA-CR 2012-0103-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC SHAUN NECOECHEA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0103-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0109-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MONYDIT  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0109-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FALISHA NICHOLE LONDON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0125  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD DELANO HOPKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0125
2 CA-CR 2012-0127  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN REY MONTANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0127
2 CA-CR 2012-0135-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN PIZARRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0135-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0139-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COREY JOSEPH BRAXTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0139-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0147-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT KARL HEITZMANN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0147-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0165  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY LON LINEGAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0165
2 CA-CR 2012-0167-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE JESUS CORTEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0167-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNIE RAY FRANKS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0203-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEE FIELDS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0203-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0208-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WILLIAM PARSONS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0208-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0217-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HOWARD NED MCMONIGAL, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0217-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATT JEFFREY MIDED  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0223-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CARLOS SAUCEDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0223-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0229  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORIO PEREZ-GOMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0229
2 CA-CR 2012-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID A. BECKLEIMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0236
2 CA-CR 2012-0237-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN FRANCIS REE, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0237-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL PIERCE  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0251-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL LEE GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0251-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0253-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHAD LUCAS HARRISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0253-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0275
2 CA-CR 2012-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS TAPIA VILLAREAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0289
2 CA-CR 2012-0295-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WILLIAM SCHAAF  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0295-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0302-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0302-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0303  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEREK ALBERT CARPENTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0303
2 CA-CR 2012-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAD KENDALL KNIGHT  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0309  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS O. MCCORMICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0309
2 CA-CR 2012-0319-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WATTERS SOFFEL, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0319-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID WAYNE SROUT  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0327  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ARTHUR ERGONIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0327
2 CA-CR 2012-0337  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAREN RENE LAKATOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0337
2 CA-CR 2012-0345-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY ONA HAYNES  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0345-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN CLARK THOMAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0347
2 CA-CR 2012-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ERIC GORMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0351
2 CA-CR 2012-0355  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND JOHN BALLESTEROS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0355
2 CA-CR 2012-0373-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMY KELLY CONTRERAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0373-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL JESUS TORRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0379
2 CA-CR 2012-0389-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN SARMIENTO ADRIAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0389-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN NICHOLAS MENDOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0393
2 CA-CR 2012-0397-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL BALL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0397-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0399-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL BALL  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0399-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0407  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ISMAEL ACOSTA-ALVAREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0407
2 CA-CR 2012-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARNABUS JOSE GONZALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0409
2 CA-CR 2012-0419-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS BEVERETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0419-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0423  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY FLYNN WALKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0423
2 CA-CR 2012-0465-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GODOY  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0465-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0475-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CARRASCO GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0475-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0485-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARNELL JOSEPH LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0485-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0493  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALVADOR CELAYA  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0493
2 CA-CR 2012-0499  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EVERESTO HARRISON JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0499
2 CA-CR 2012-0501  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS HAMILTON NEREIM  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0501
Issues Summary: Was a police officer’s testimony about a child’s appearance sufficient to sustain the defendant’s convictions of crimes for which the victim’s age was an element of the offense?

Was there sufficient evidence of endangerment to convict the defendant of child abuse when it was established that he had driven with a child in his car while he had a blood alcohol concentration of nearly four times the legal limit, had collided with a police vehicle before being arrested, and had failed three sobriety tests?

Was the jury properly instructed that the crime of child abuse, non-death or serious physical injury, requires the state to prove the “defendant acted under circumstances other than [those] likely to cause death or serious physical injury”?

Were certain of the defendant’s convictions lesser-included offenses of his other convictions and therefore violative of double jeopardy?


2 CA-CR 2012-0511  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELISHA ROBERT EDWARDS III  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0511
2 CA-CR 2013-0005-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN CRAIG BOWMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0005-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0007-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WAYNE MARIETTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0007-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0015-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE PRINCE JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0015-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BROCK EVERETT ELSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0023
2 CA-CR 2013-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK STEVEN RIESGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS D. AUSTIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0029
2 CA-CR 2013-0031-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD M. LONA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0031-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0035-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILBERT SHABIE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0035-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JORDAN FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0042
2 CA-CR 2013-0043  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0043
2 CA-CR 2013-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RASCON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0045
2 CA-CR 2013-0047-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONES JIM  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0047-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL EDUARDO MORALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0061
2 CA-CR 2013-0067-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC WADE HANSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0067-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0071-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ALAN KEITZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0071-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0075  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD BRIAN SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0075
2 CA-CR 2013-0076-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK HUBERT HUMMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0076-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON MICHAEL KEITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0079
2 CA-CR 2013-0097  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL THOMAS SAABY  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0097
2 CA-CR 2013-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO CHAIREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ARTHUR MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOB ANTHONY SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0137
2 CA-CR 2013-0151  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY LYNN WATSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0151
2 CA-CR 2013-0153-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD TERRAZAS VILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0153-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0161-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES GREGORY LAMOREE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0161-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0165  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAMM RUSSELL OLSEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0165
2 CA-CR 2013-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANA CLEMONS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0173-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SILVA CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0173-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH ALONZO MENDOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0187
2 CA-CR 2013-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LESLIE HOLLINGSWORTH, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0203-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH DALE GANN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0203-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LUGO PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MALCOLM FREDDIE RUBIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0207
2 CA-CR 2013-0217-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO RODRIGUEZ GUTIERREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0217-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0223-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MATTHEW EWING  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0223-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0243  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR KYLE LIZARDI  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0243
2 CA-CR 2013-0251-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAREN MARIE HANSEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0251-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0255-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT GALVAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0255-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN JUNIOR ALVAREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0263
2 CA-CR 2013-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN BERNARD HORTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0285-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY LEWIS ANGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0285-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0301-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK DALE CRAWFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0301-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0305-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR LINWOOD GILBERT IV  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0305-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0329-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO MENDOZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0329-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0341-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUALBERTO LOPEZ SALAZAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0341-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEVERO ANTHONY TORRES, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0363
2 CA-CR 2013-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX MELRON GOOLSBY  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0375
2 CA-CR 2013-0383-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0383-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0385  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD OWEN DOUST  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0385
2 CA-CR 2013-0389-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0389-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LORETO MADUENO-ARCE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0401-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ANTONIO GAMEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0401-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0421-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERTO GERARDO DELGADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0421-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0425-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID JEROLD SHANK  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0425-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0439  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMMY-LEE SHANE AMMON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0439
2 CA-CR 2013-0444-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JAVIER ROMERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0444-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0447-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACKIE L. SCOTT  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0447-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0453  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REYNALDO WILLIAM VIDAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0453
2 CA-CR 2013-0455-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL LUIS GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0455-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0457-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BRIAN PATTERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0457-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0469-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL EDUARDO GONZALEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0469-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0471-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS DELL RADFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0471-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0479-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDMUNDO ANDRADE  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0479-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0483-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY ESCOBAR,JR  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0483-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0489-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JAMES LISKA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0489-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0505-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY JOSEPH HAUSNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0505-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0511  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IROQUOIS DANIEL SULLIVAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0511
2 CA-CR 2013-0515  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN ALLEN MCCANN  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0515
2 CA-CR 2013-0521  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD RAY SCHULTZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0521
2 CA-CR 2013-0527-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TONATIHU AGUILAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0527-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0539-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARIEL VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0539-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0545-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENT RETURN HOLCOMB  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0545-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0547-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL GREGORY DESKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0547-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0555-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAROLD DAVID JONES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0555-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO JOSE CARRILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0005  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ARMANDO CORNIDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0005
2 CA-CR 2014-0011-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN KEITH STALLINGS  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0011-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0023-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM LACKEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0023-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0049-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAROLD GLEN OVERTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0049-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0059-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISIAH ROMONT HILL  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0059-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL EDUARDO CANEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0077-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0077-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0097-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MITCHELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0097-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS ROSS TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0109
2 CA-CR 2014-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY DELOACH  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0161-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0161-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0191-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON MIGUEL ANGEL MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0191-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0213-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES HERBERT BROWN, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0213-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0241-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN MICHAEL PERALTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0241-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0263-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN MATTHEW GILLIAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0263-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0265-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN RAWLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0265-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0285-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL PAUL CISNEROZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0285-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HILARIO VASQUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0303-PR
2 CA-CV 2005-0063  BROWN v. McFARLAND  Author 2 CA-CV 2005-0063
2 CA-CV 2005-0093  SAMUEL GEORGE ALVARADO v. SARA JUDITH ALVARADO  Author 2 CA-CV 2005-0093
2 CA-CV 2005-0155  DEAN v. DEAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2005-0155
2 CA-CV 2006-0017  PAYNE v. ANDERSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0017
2 CA-CV 2006-0051  ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY v. REDLON  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0051
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding the State Personnel Board lacked jurisdiction to hear the administrative appeal of a state employee who resigned after being told she would be dismissed if she did not resign immediately?

2. Can the trial court’s dismissal of the employee’s administrative appeal be alternatively upheld on the ground the Personnel Board lacked jurisdiction because the employee’s appeal was untimely?


2 CA-CV 2006-0075  GORNEY v. MEANEY; RINCON ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES, P.C.   Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0075
Issues Summary: Do the expert opinion requirements of A.R.S. § 12-2603(B) apply to plaintiffs alleging medical malpractice based on lack of informed consent?


2 CA-CV 2006-0095  TWIN PEAKS CONSTRUCTION, INC. v. WEATHERGUARD METAL  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0095
Issues Summary: In an administrative action brought by the Registrar of Contractors against a general contractor for failing to pay for services rendered by a subcontractor, does A.R.S. § 32-1153, which bars unlicensed contractors from suing a contracting party, provide the general contractor a defense?


2 CA-CV 2006-0105  EDDY v. STATE OF ARIZONA; DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0105
2 CA-CV 2006-0125  TUCSON IMAGING ASSOCIATES, LLC. v. NORTHWEST HOSPITAL, LLC  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0125
2 CA-CV 2006-0133  MARTINEZ v. SCHUTT SPORTS  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0133
2 CA-CV 2006-0155  COHEN v. FREY, fka COHEN  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0155
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court properly dismiss former wife’s partition complaint when the decree dissolving the parties’ marriage permitted husband to “live in the residence for a period of indefinite duration?” 2) Was the language of the decree, incorporating the merged settlement agreement, which permitted the sale of the marital residence for “whatever price” husband desired, susceptible to other than its literal meaning, given other provisions of the decree and the trial court’s duty to divide the property fairly and equitably?


2 CA-CV 2006-0185  BOWMAN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS   Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0185
2 CA-CV 2006-0215  WALLACE v. WALLACE nka QUIARAH YUHURU-OHANA  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0215
2 CA-CV 2006-0217  CHANCE fka WILES v. WILES  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0217
2 CA-CV 2006-0231  FRANCES LOPEZ v. CITY OF ELOY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0231
2 CA-CV 2007-0003  YUSUPOV v. YUSUPOVA  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0003
2 CA-CV 2007-0005  SIMON v. ALBERTSON'S, INC. and COMPASS BANCSHARES, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0005
2 CA-CV 2007-0069  VERNON WALKER v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0069
2 CA-CV 2007-0077  EQUIFUNDING MICHIGAN, INC. v BETH FORD, PUTZI  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0077
2 CA-CV 2007-0080  PIMA COUNTY v. VERNON WALKER  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0080
2 CA-CV 2007-0081  PETER WICKRAMASEKERA v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0081
2 CA-CV 2007-0087  LA CEBADILLA ESTATES CORP. v. SISNEROS  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0087
2 CA-CV 2007-0095  GLENN HUNTER v. ROSEMARY PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0095
2 CA-CV 2007-0097  CHIQUETTE v. INTERNATIONAL CHURCH OF FOURSQUARE GOSPEL  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0097
2 CA-CV 2007-0115  ALAN W. GILL v. SIERRA FARMING   Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0115
2 CA-CV 2007-0153  ALVIN S. RATLIFF v. DANIEL M. HARDISON, SR.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0153
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of the plaintiff real estate seller when it found, as a matter of law, that the defendant purchaser anticipatorily repudiated the purchase agreement and did not subsequently retract his repudiation?

2. Does A.R.S. § 33-422 require a seller of real estate to provide an affidavit of disclosure once the buyer has anticipatorily repudiated the purchase agreement?


2 CA-CV 2007-0169  RAUL BELTRAN, SR. and ANN BELTRAN v. HARRAH'S ARIZONA CORP.,  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0169
Issues Summary: 1. In a personal injury action against the Ak-Chin Indian Community and its nontribal casino management company, did the superior court err in recognizing for purposes of collateral estoppel a tribal court judgment dismissing plaintiffs’ similar complaint in tribal court despite the judgment’s not having been certified by the superior court clerk under the Arizona Rules of Procedure for Recognition of Tribal Court Civil Judgments? 2. Did the superior court abuse its discretion by recognizing the tribal court judgment as a matter of comity? 3. Could the superior court properly find that issues relating to an indispensable party, sovereign immunity, and the running of the statute of limitations were defensively precluded?


2 CA-CV 2008-0001  GUARDIANSHIP/CONSERVATORSHIP OF ANGELINE SHARKOZY  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0001
2 CA-CV 2008-0019  TRIPATI v. MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0019
2 CA-CV 2008-0059  CHERISE SUZANNE WINDISH v. DAVID KELLOGG WINDISH  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0059
2 CA-CV 2008-0081  ANTHONY CAMPBELL v. J & T DESERT PROPERTIES  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0081
2 CA-CV 2008-0083  JERRY WORTHY v. IRIS WORTHY  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0083
2 CA-CV 2008-0099  JUNIES A. JENKINS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0099
2 CA-CV 2008-0108  JOHN V. DOMMISSE v. JABURG & WILK, PC; MARTON; BOGARD; LAZAROW  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0108
2 CA-CV 2008-0114  MARIE BREI and JASON BREI v. RALPH G. DURAN  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0114
2 CA-CV 2008-0118  MODULAR MINING SYSTEMS, INC. v. JIGSAW TECHNOLOGIES, INC.; OLSON; BLACUTT  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0118
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in determining that appellant’s claim for injunctive relief was moot, where appellant did not contest appellee’s assertion that it had discontinued all use of the computer configuration appellant alleged to be trade secrets? (2) Did the trial court err in granting appellee’s motion for summary judgment on appellant’s claim of trade secret misappropriation? (3) Did the trial court err in awarding appellee its attorney fees under A.R.S. §§ 12-341.01 and 44-404?


2 CA-CV 2008-0120  JAMES A. GREEN v. LISA FRANK, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0120
2 CA-CV 2008-0122  MACIAS, HUIZAR, PEREZ v. CARONDELET ST. MARY'S, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0122
2 CA-CV 2008-0124  STANLEY RIOS v. RICHARD C. BRUMGARD and KAY E. BRUMGARD  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0124
2 CA-CV 2008-0134  ALLAN C. SANCEAU v. DONNA D. SANCEAU  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0134
2 CA-CV 2008-0136  KATHRYN CHAFFIN-HONDA ... v. CHERYL LYNN REYNOLDS  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0136
2 CA-CV 2008-0148  TRIPATI v. TUCKER  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0148
Issues Summary: 1. When a party challenges a previously granted deferral of a filing fee under A.R.S. § 12 302, does the deferral applicant retain the burden of proving he or she is indigent? 2. Does a trial court err in considering evidence that the deferral applicant controls or has access to the resources of third parties?


2 CA-CV 2008-0150  ACTION FINANCIAL IV, LLC v. JOE and JOSIE LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0150
2 CA-CV 2008-0166  KUHN v. SMALL; RICHARD M. SMALL FAMILY TRUST; HAUPT  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0166
2 CA-CV 2008-0176  PIMA COUNTY v. PIMA COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0176
2 CA-CV 2008-0182  BLAIR v. BLAIR  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0182
2 CA-CV 2009-0014  GRAND v. NACCHIO; McMASTER; QWEST COMMUNICATIONS  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0014
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in dismissing appellants’ Third Amended Complaint for failure to state a claim of either primary or secondary liability under the Arizona Securities Act?


2 CA-CV 2009-0018  ZEAGLER v. BUCKLEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0018
Issues Summary: In an action for breach of contract, may the trial court award attorney fees to the prevailing party under A.R.S. § 12-341.01 for legal work performed in connection with a bankruptcy proceeding that was directly related to the contract action?


2 CA-CV 2009-0028  SUTTON v. FLORES  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0028
2 CA-CV 2009-0034  ANS DISTRIBUTING v. VISA INTERNATIONAL SERVICE  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0034
2 CA-CV 2009-0056  KEELING v. TURNEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0056
2 CA-CV 2009-0082  SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0082
2 CA-CV 2009-0090  PRESTON v. CITY OF TUCSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0090
2 CA-CV 2009-0102  OCHOA-FUENTES; FIGUERO-BONILLA v. BLANCHETTE  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0102
2 CA-CV 2009-0104  EMERY v. MISSION VIEW  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0104
2 CA-CV 2009-0106  JEONG; DIAZ v. MUNGUIA, JR.  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0106
2 CA-CV 2009-0120  ELOY LAND AND DEVELOPMENT COMPANY v. 87 & HANNA  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0120
2 CA-CV 2009-0149  SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON, STATE OF ARIZONA, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0149
2 CA-CV 2009-0186  DOS PICOS LAND LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; SHEPARD v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2009-0186
Issues Summary: 1. Whether a trial court may award attorney fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 11-972(B) after finding that a governmental entity, through its administrative decisions and regulations, had effected a taking of private property.

2. Whether the statutory interest rate applicable to a civil judgment or that applicable to a condemnation proceeding applies to an award in an inverse condemnation proceeding.


2 CA-CV 2010-0002  BINIAKOUNOU v. BATEKREZE  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0002
2 CA-CV 2010-0060  WEILER v. GULICK  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0060
2 CA-CV 2010-0064  DENT v. DENT  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0064
2 CA-CV 2010-0076  LOPEZ v. WALGREENS  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0076
2 CA-CV 2010-0079  LITTLE v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0079
Issues Summary: In this medical malpractice action for wrongful death, did the trial court err in granting the state’s motion for summary judgment after concluding appellant had not filed a timely notice of claim pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-820.01? Should the court instead have found the equitable doctrines of estoppel or tolling applicable against the state?


2 CA-CV 2010-0091  IN RE GUARDIANSHIP OF AND CONSERVATORSHIP FOR WILLIE JOE KNIGHT  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0091
2 CA-CV 2010-0100  CENTEX HOMES v. PINAL COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0100
2 CA-CV 2010-0138  LIGHTHOLDER v. STANLEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0138
2 CA-CV 2010-0154  TAIZ v. GREENE  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0154
2 CA-CV 2010-0158  RIVERS v. RIVERS  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0158
2 CA-CV 2010-0182  BEEDE v. CITY OF TUCSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0182
2 CA-CV 2010-0197  NICKERSON, et al v. GREEN VALLEY RECREATION, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0197
Issues Summary: Is a covenant to pay fees and bind a homeowner’s real property as consideration for membership in a community recreational facility a valid servitude that runs with the land?

Is an agreement creating such a covenant an unconscionable contract on the ground that it permits membership fees to be increased at the discretion of the recreational facility’s board of directors?

Is the agreement that creates such a covenant illusory or unilateral on the ground that mutuality of obligation is lacking because the owner of the community recreation facility has the right to modify terms of the agreement but the homeowner does not, except through the facility’s board of directors?


2 CA-CV 2010-0198  PINAL COUNTY V. MILLER  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0198
2 CA-CV 2010-0200  O'BRIEN v. KB HOME TUCSON; KB HOME SALES; KB HOME, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2010-0200
2 CA-CV 2011-0010  TUMACACORI MISSION LAND DEVELOPMENT, LTD. v. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD CO.  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0010
Issues Summary: Does article XV, § 10 of the Arizona Constitution, which declares railways to be public highways, prevent a private party from obtaining a prescriptive easement across a railway?


2 CA-CV 2011-0023  BINNIE v. ORO VALLEY PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0023
2 CA-CV 2011-0037  CLAVOS BUILDING COMPANY, LLC, JACOB v. TONEY, LEIN, SHAFFER  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0037
2 CA-CV 2011-0053  GOODMAN v. PHYSICAL RESOURCE ENGINEERING, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0053
Issues Summary: Did the plaintiff property owner present sufficient evidence for the jury to find an implied contract, either directly or based on agency theory, between the owner and defendant subcontractor, who had been hired by the owner’s general building contractor?


2 CA-CV 2011-0063  IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF WILLIAM BATES  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0063
2 CA-CV 2011-0103  CONTRERAS v. BOURKE  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0103
2 CA-CV 2011-0125  MORIN v. BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.; PERRY & SHAPIRO, LLP  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0125
2 CA-CV 2011-0127  LOPEZ v. TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, THE GOVERNING BOARD, et al  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0127
2 CA-CV 2011-0157  UNITED NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. AMERICAN CASUALTY COMPANY  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0157
2 CA-CV 2011-0159  NICHOLS v. WESTON  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0159
2 CA-CV 2011-0189  TARDY v. MURPHY  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0189
2 CA-CV 2011-0196  HILL v. CATALINA FOOTHILLS UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 16  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0196
2 CA-CV 2012-0039  WRIGHT and ZIA, LLC v. LARGE  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0039
2 CA-CV 2012-0075  McDONALD v. McDONALD  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0075
2 CA-CV 2012-0081  REED v. ARIZONA GAME AND FISH DEPARTMENT and ARIZONA GAME AND FISH COMMISSION  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0081
2 CA-CV 2012-0095  In re the ESTATE OF A.C. MILLER  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0095
2 CA-CV 2012-0107  IN RE BOND FORFEITURE IN PINAL CAUSE NUMBERS CR201103204, CR201101969 and CR201101968  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0107
2 CA-CV 2012-0131  MARTINEZ v. CORRECTIONS CORPORATION OF AMERICA  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0131
2 CA-CV 2012-0137  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF FREDERICK and DiFRANK  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0137
2 CA-CV 2013-0077  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF PIEPER  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0077
2 CA-CV 2013-0123  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF SEYFFERT   Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0123
2 CA-CV 2013-0161  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF YEATTS  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0161
2 CA-CV 2014-0027  McBRIDE v. LINN and KNAAK  Author 2 CA-CV 2014-0027
2 CA-HC 2008-0002  RAYMOND EARL RIGSBY v. ROBERT STEWART, WARDEN; ADOC  Author 2 CA-HC 2008-0002
2 CA-HC 2013-0007  CARL B. BRANSON v. JOHN GAY, MELVIN THOMAS, WILLIAM WHITE, ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS   Author 2 CA-HC 2013-0007
2 CA-IC 2006-0021  PICKETT v. TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, TRISTAR   Author 2 CA-IC 2006-0021
2 CA-IC 2007-0009  McCORMICK v. NBC UNIVERSAL; ELECTRIC INSURANCE COMPANY  Author 2 CA-IC 2007-0009
2 CA-IC 2009-0014  CHRISTINE RAMIREZ PEET v. PIMA COUNTY and PIMA COUNTY c/o PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES  Author 2 CA-IC 2009-0014
2 CA-IC 2010-0010  CARLOS C. CASTRO v. LANDMARK METAL BUILDERS, INC., and SCF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-IC 2010-0010
2 CA-IC 2010-0016  STENZ v. CITY OF TUCSON and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES  Author 2 CA-IC 2010-0016
2 CA-IC 2011-0013  ESCOBAR v. MARSHALL, TOWER INSUR., PINNACLE RISK MGMT.  Author 2 CA-IC 2011-0013
2 CA-IC 2013-0007  RAYMOND D. CRUM, JR. v. B.J. CECIL TRUCKING, INC. and WAUSAU INS. CO.  Author 2 CA-IC 2013-0007
2 CA-IC 2013-0009  JEFFREY WHITNEY v. THE HOME DEPOT and HELMSMAN MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.  Author 2 CA-IC 2013-0009
2 CA-JV 2006-0031  AMY H. v. ADES, EMMA H.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0031
2 CA-JV 2006-0035  IN RE NASHON B.   Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0035
2 CA-JV 2006-0039  IN RE GUILLERMO V.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0039
2 CA-JV 2006-0059  IN RE CHAD M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0059
2 CA-JV 2006-0063  MICHAEL K. v. ADES, BAYVIN K.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0063
2 CA-JV 2007-0003  VICTORIA D. v. ADES, JOHNATHAN H.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0003
2 CA-JV 2007-0005  MANDY S. v. ADES, SEBASTIAN S., JULIAN S.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0005
2 CA-JV 2007-0015  VERONICA M. v. ADES, MAXIMILIANO M., GEMINI M.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0015
2 CA-JV 2007-0049  IN RE: JOVANY L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0049
2 CA-JV 2007-0073  IN RE JOHN V.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0073
2 CA-JV 2007-0075  IN RE EDZEKIEL C.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0075
2 CA-JV 2007-0082  APRIL W. v. ADES, AMBER W. & LUKE W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0082
2 CA-JV 2007-0093  IN RE ALEXIS M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0093
2 CA-JV 2007-0103  TAMMY P. v. ADES, TIFFANIE G., ROBERT G., MATTHEW G. & HAILEIGH P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0103
2 CA-JV 2008-0047  IN RE GREGORY R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0047
2 CA-JV 2008-0049  MARIE P. v. ADES, STARLENE P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0049
2 CA-JV 2008-0065  JESSICA R. v. ADES, SCOTT R., SAMANTHA D., KC D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0065
2 CA-JV 2008-0085  EMILY T. v. ADES, PAYTON G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0085
2 CA-JV 2008-0096  ERIC. S. v. ADES, MICHAEL K., and CATLIN S.   Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0096
2 CA-JV 2008-0098  PAMELA B. v. ADES, KIERRA B. and MALACHI B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0098
2 CA-JV 2008-0108  KATHLEEN C. v. ADES and BRENNAN A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0108
2 CA-JV 2008-0114  IN RE ANTHONY M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0114
2 CA-JV 2008-0118  IN RE DERRICK S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0118
2 CA-JV 2008-0134  BERNADETTE A. v. ADES and Robert A.   Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0134
2 CA-JV 2009-0034  BONNIE G. v. ADES and KARMA F.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0034
2 CA-JV 2009-0036  JOYCE S. v. ADES and MARIAH S. and JEREMIAH S.-S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0036
2 CA-JV 2009-0038  DOREEN J. v. ADES and MICHAEL J.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0038
2 CA-JV 2009-0040  DANNY G. v. ADES and KRISTOFF G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0040
2 CA-JV 2009-0052  BERNARD K. v. ADES and AMORIE S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0052
2 CA-JV 2009-0056  MEGAN R. v. ADES and LIANNA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0056
2 CA-JV 2009-0066  IN RE MELISSA S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0066
2 CA-JV 2009-0074  IN RE JAKE V.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0074
2 CA-JV 2009-0090  IN RE RICARDO F.-C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0090
2 CA-JV 2009-0102  GINA O. v. ADES, ALEJANDRO M., ELYANNA M., and NATHAN M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0102
2 CA-JV 2009-0112  SHAWN R. v. JOHN M.; CATHY M.; and SHAWN R., JR.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0112
2 CA-JV 2009-0130  LOURDES M. v. ADES and JAZMIN M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0130
2 CA-JV 2009-0134  MICHELLE P. v. ADES and MIA P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0134
2 CA-JV 2010-0014  IN RE LAWRENCE I.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0014
2 CA-JV 2010-0016  IN RE DELILAH C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0016
2 CA-JV 2010-0031  HYSON G. v. ADES and SHAMUS J.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0031
2 CA-JV 2010-0052  BRIANNA P. v. ADES, AARON P. and SAMANTHA P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0052
2 CA-JV 2010-0056  LEYLA V. v. ADES and JEFENIA V.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0056
2 CA-JV 2010-0060  MONIQUE C. v. ADES and KYLE W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0060
2 CA-JV 2010-0062  BRANDON B. v. ADES and LETICIA B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0062
2 CA-JV 2010-0066  ADES v. DONNIE D., JAKOB D. and JORDAN D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0066
2 CA-JV 2010-0068  JOSELYN A. v. ADES and SHALANE A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0068
2 CA-JV 2010-0074  ROBERT T. v. ADES, NATHANIEL C. and NEVAHEA C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0074
2 CA-JV 2010-0116  KIMBERLY L. v. ADES and RUBEN L.   Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0116
2 CA-JV 2010-0124  PAUL W. v. ADES and PAUL W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0124
2 CA-JV 2010-0142  IN RE VICENTE V.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0142
2 CA-JV 2010-0149  GEORGINE G. v. ADES and ANGELICA R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2010-0149
2 CA-JV 2011-0004  IN RE SOCHISE F.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0004
2 CA-JV 2011-0023  TERRANCE O. v. ADES and LAYAH G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0023
2 CA-JV 2011-0039  IN RE DOMINICK B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0039
2 CA-JV 2011-0041  DOLORES M. v. ADES, KEVIN M. and RHODRY M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0041
2 CA-JV 2011-0053  AMANDA B. v. ADES and LOTUS M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0053
2 CA-JV 2011-0056  ROBERT P., SR. v. ADES and ROBERT P., JR.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0056
2 CA-JV 2011-0067  GRACE D. v. ADES, MADELINE G. and JASMINE G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0067
2 CA-JV 2011-0079  RILEY F. v. ADES and AMBER B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0079
2 CA-JV 2011-0089  IN RE ALEXANDOR A.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0089
2 CA-JV 2011-0107  MARIA ISABEL S. v. ROBERT S. and MARIA ESPERANZA S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0107
2 CA-JV 2011-0119  ANGELA R. v. ADES and ANGELINA R.; ANTONIO R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0119
2 CA-JV 2011-0123  IN RE JOHN P.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0123
2 CA-JV 2011-0125  JOSE L.v. ADES; JOSE L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0125
2 CA-JV 2011-0133  NORMA M. v. ADES and DAKOTA G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0133
2 CA-JV 2011-0135  KENDRA J. v. ADES, DAKOTA J. and DALLAS J.  Author 2 CA-JV 2011-0135
2 CA-JV 2012-0037  GILBERTO A. v. ADES and RYAN R.   Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0037
2 CA-JV 2012-0069  LARA K. v. DWIGHT K., GABRIEL K. and SAMUEL K.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0069
2 CA-JV 2012-0089  IN RE DAKOTA R.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0089
2 CA-JV 2012-0105  IN RE AARON W.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0105
2 CA-JV 2012-0111  ERIKA A. v. ADES and EDWIN T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0111
2 CA-JV 2012-0129  NATASHA D. v. ADES and AARON D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2012-0129
2 CA-JV 2013-0003  IN RE GISELLE B.   Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0003
2 CA-JV 2013-0057  IN RE E.M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0057
2 CA-JV 2013-0085  SHELSELAINE F. v. ERNEST & DEANNA L. and K.B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0085
2 CA-JV 2013-0115  IN RE D.K.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0115
2 CA-JV 2013-0117  JESSIE M. v. ADES, A.M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2013-0117
2 CA-JV 2014-0023  IN RE P.B.-L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2014-0023
2 CA-JV 2014-0037  BRANDON D. v. ADES, E.D.  Author 2 CA-JV 2014-0037
2 CA-JV 2014-0047  IN RE C.S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2014-0047
2 CA-JV 2014-0049  GREGORY T. v. ADES and N.T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2014-0049
2 CA-MH 2010-0010  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-201000122  Author 2 CA-MH 2010-0010
2 CA-MH 2011-0007  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20040799411  Author 2 CA-MH 2011-0007
2 CA-MH 2012-0006  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201200073  Author 2 CA-MH 2012-0006
2 CA-MH 2013-0007  IN RE MENTAL HEALTH CASE NO. MH20000326613  Author 2 CA-MH 2013-0007
2 CA-SA 2007-0037  HOGAN/DAVIS v. LIFE CARE CENTERS OF AMERICA, INC.   Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0037
2 CA-SA 2007-0061  MARIA LOZA-FELIX v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0061
2 CA-SA 2007-0089  JASON N. v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0089
2 CA-SA 2008-0011  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT DOUGLAS NORDSTROM  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0011
Issues Summary: May a defendant convicted of multiple first-degree felony murders introduce alibi evidence during the aggravation phase of capital sentencing proceedings conducted before a newly empaneled jury when that evidence is offered to rebut the state’s proof of the defendant’s involvement in the murders and/or underlying felonies for purposes of satisfying the requirements of Enmund v. Forida, 458 U.S. 782 (1982), and Tison v. Arizona, 481 U.S. 137 (1987)?


2 CA-SA 2008-0019  ROBERT DOUGLAS SMITH v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0019
2 CA-SA 2008-0063  JOHN O'BRIEN v. HON. RICHARD FIELDS; STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0063
2 CA-SA 2008-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAUGHTERS-WHITE  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0078
Issues Summary: Whether the respondent judge abused her discretion in ordering the state to produce the software configuration code for the Intoxilyzer 8000, the breath testing equipment used by the Tucson Police Department, to defendants charged with driving with an alcohol concentration of .08 or more, after finding the configuration code was not in the possession of the state or any person under the state’s direction or control.


2 CA-SA 2009-0024  GERARDO LOPEZ v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0024
Issues Summary: After having rejected the defendant’s proposed plea agreement in this case and having previously reviewed an unrelated presentence report about the defendant before sentencing him in an earlier case, did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in denying defendant’s motion for an automatic change of judge pursuant to Rule 17.4(g), Ariz. R. Crim. P.?


2 CA-SA 2009-0050  GROSVENOR HOLDINGS v. PINAL COUNTY  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0050
Issues Summary: Can parties contractually agree that disputes between them are to be resolved in a specified manner by a designated individual or body and that the only means of obtaining judicial review is pursuant to the Administrative Review Act, notwithstanding that the Act otherwise would not apply?


2 CA-SA 2009-0062  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERICA LEA DAUGHTERS-WHITE, SEAN AARON JOHNSON, JOHN CLIFTON LIVINGSTON ...   Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0062
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse her discretion in finding the real parties in interest, defendants in consolidated prosecutions for driving with a blood alcohol concentration of .08 or more, established a substantial need under Rule 15.1(g), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and Arizona case law, for the operating system software of the Intoxilyzer 8000 breath-testing equipment and in ordering petitioner State of Arizona to disclose the software to the defendants?


2 CA-SA 2010-0016  ARIZONA CITY SANITARY DIST. v. PINAL COUNTY  Author 2 CA-SA 2010-0016
Issues Summary: (1) After one unsuccessful recall election had already been held, when a political action committee sought a second election to recall the same public officials without paying the costs of the previous election as required by article VIII, part 1, § 5 of the Arizona Constitution and A.R.S. § 19-202(B), did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in ruling that the applicability of the repayment provisions depended on a legal determination that the first recall election had been valid? (2) Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in finding that questions of fact regarding the validity of the previous election barred entry of summary judgment in the underlying action challenging the setting of the second recall election?


2 CA-SA 2010-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORLEANS P. ESTRELLA; JUAN CARLOS HOLGUIN  Author 2 CA-SA 2010-0058
Issues Summary: Whether the respondent judges abused their discretion in precluding under Rule 901, Ariz. R. Evid., a witness whose voice identification testimony was based solely on familiarity with voice recordings of the defendants.


2 CA-SA 2011-0063  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY FLYNN WALKER  Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0063
2 CA-SA 2013-0079  M. W. v. ARIZ. DEPT. OF ECONOMIC SECURITY; RICARDO M.   Author 2 CA-SA 2013-0079
2 CA-SA 2013-0089  PENNY ANN WEST v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2013-0089
2 CA-SA 2014-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATT EDWARD ZANG  Author 2 CA-SA 2014-0029
2 CA-SA 2014-0047  JOHN C. SANCHEZ v. FIELDS  Author 2 CA-SA 2014-0047
2 CA-CR 1995-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKAL OMAR RASUL  Participating 2 CA-CR 1995-0014
Issues Summary: 1. Whether, due to his conduct prior to trial, the defendant forfeited his Sixth Amendment right to the assistance of counsel.

2. Whether the defendant’s prior convictions for arson and conspiracy to commit arson occurred on the “same occasion” for purposes of A.R.S. § 13-604(M).


2 CA-CR 2002-0153  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN WAYNE TALMADGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2002-0153
2 CA-CR 2002-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AUDRA JEAN TALMADGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2002-0155
2 CA-CR 2002-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD IRWIN BACON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2002-0369
2 CA-CR 2004-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MALIK CORNELL PRIOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2004-0059
2 CA-CR 2005-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK FILLMORE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0139
2 CA-CR 2005-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREG CANTUA ORTEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0233
2 CA-CR 2005-0272  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EDWARD COX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0272
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in refusing to give defendant’s requested jury instruction defining prohibited possession even though an identical instruction had been approved in dicta in State v. Tyler, 149 Ariz. 312, 316-17, 718 P.2d 214, 218-19 (App. 1986)?


2 CA-CR 2005-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MANUEL BRACAMONTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0275
2 CA-CR 2005-0333  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NEREA GOITI ANDICOECHEA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0333
2 CA-CR 2005-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS NOE MIRAMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0335
2 CA-CR 2005-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACKIE EUGENE DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0379
2 CA-CR 2005-0422  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0422
2 CA-CR 2006-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JILL IRENE PARIS-SHELDON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0015
Issues Summary: 1. Before denying the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel, did the trial court conduct a sufficient inquiry under State v. Torres, 208 Ariz. 340, 93 P.3d 1056 (2004)? 2. Did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel? 3. Does a criminal defendant waive the attorney-client privilege for purposes of a Torres inquiry? 4. Must a trial court appoint a defendant new counsel for the hearing on the defendant’s motion for substitute counsel? 5. May a defendant properly file a motion to dismiss charges asserting the trial court erred by granting the state’s motion in a previous case, concerning the same defendant and events, to dismiss similar charges without prejudice pursuant to Rule 16.6(a), Ariz. R. Crim. P., 16A A.R.S.? 6. Did the trial court interfere with the defendant’s right to exercise peremptory challenges when, after closing arguments, it excused several jurors for cause after a twelve-person jury had been inadvertently impaneled instead of the required eight-person jury?


2 CA-CR 2006-0033  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL CHRISTOPHER MARTINEZ, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0033
2 CA-CR 2006-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EUGENE BARNES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0035
2 CA-CR 2006-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEARNED O'NEIL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0042
2 CA-CR 2006-0047  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO GUILLERMO SNYDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0047
2 CA-CR 2006-0053  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS VALENZUELA CARRILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0053
2 CA-CR 2006-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENIE VARELA VALENCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0067
2 CA-CR 2006-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY NOEM VETA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0075-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TROY ALEXANDER BERTLING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0075-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEMON MONTREA JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0079
Issues Summary: 1. Did a police officer conducting a traffic stop reasonably suspect a passenger was armed and dangerous, thereby allowing the officer to perform a pat-down search of that passenger under the rule announced in Arizona v. Johnson, ___ U.S. ___, 129 S. Ct. 781, 788 (2009)? 2. Does article II, § 8 of the Arizona Constitution provide greater protection to automobile passengers than does the United States Constitution so that an officer conducting a traffic stop may not question a passenger about matters unrelated to the stop and may not perform a pat-down search of a passenger absent a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity and reason to suspect that the passenger is armed and dangerous? 3. Did the trial court commit structural error when it gave the reasonable doubt jury instruction mandated by State v. Portillo, 182 Ariz. 592, 898 P.2d 970 (1995)? 4. Was the defendant entitled to have a jury determine whether he had prior felony convictions that were alleged to enhance his sentences?


2 CA-CR 2006-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN LAGRON PENNINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0087
2 CA-CR 2006-0103  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO ANGEL GODOY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0103
2 CA-CR 2006-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUANITA ROSARIO MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0107
2 CA-CR 2006-0121  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEY DOMINIC WILLCUTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0121
2 CA-CR 2006-0123  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH BENITEZ LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0123
2 CA-CR 2006-0129  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT EDWARD POWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0129
2 CA-CR 2006-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY BRIAN ABEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0131
2 CA-CR 2006-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO CUEVAS GALLEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0133
2 CA-CR 2006-0137  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN RAY MILLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0137
Issues Summary: In a prosecution for armed robbery, did the trial court err when it admitted, and found relevant, testimony that, after the defendant’s arrest, there had been a cessation of robberies involving the same modus operandi?


2 CA-CR 2006-0143  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIM DALE CALHOUN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0143
2 CA-CR 2006-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL WAYNE MULLICAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0148
2 CA-CR 2006-0149-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISAURA CRUZ CHIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0149-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0151-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PATRICK WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0151-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENE GREG SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0155
2 CA-CR 2006-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER CRUZ CUEVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0157
Issues Summary: In granting a defendant’s motion to suppress evidence stemming from a traffic stop, did the trial court err in determining A.R.S. § 28-751(2), which requires a driver turning left to turn, “[i]f practicable,” into the “left lane immediately available” in the street onto which he or she is turning, means the turn need not be made to the median lane?


2 CA-CR 2006-0159-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0159-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0161-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO ALBERTO ALTAMIRANO, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0161-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0171  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER JOHN PRADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0171
2 CA-CR 2006-0173-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOSEPH BENGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0173-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY EUGENE RHODES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0185
2 CA-CR 2006-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY COLMENERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0189
2 CA-CR 2006-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICIA A. BARNES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0191
Issues Summary: Does an officer transform a lawful warrantless strip search into an intrusion beyond the body’s surface that requires a warrant when he or she handles an object protruding from, and extending into, an arrestee’s body cavity?


2 CA-CR 2006-0193  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY BARAJAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0193
2 CA-CR 2006-0195-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTRON MOROTO FAIRCHILD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0195-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE Y. SPERLE; ROBERT BRYAN CLEERE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0197
2 CA-CR 2006-0199  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO DE LA OSSA MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0199
2 CA-CR 2006-0201  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON JAMERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0201
2 CA-CR 2006-0205  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MITCHELL EUGENE NELSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0205
2 CA-CR 2006-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PRENTISS COGHILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0215
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court commit reversible error in admitting evidence that defendant possessed adult pornography based on its finding the evidence was relevant under Rule 404(b), Ariz. R. Evid., to show the defendant’s intent, knowledge, and opportunity to download child pornography?

2. Did the trial court err in allowing the jury to view portions of the child pornography found in defendant’s residence despite his offer to stipulate that the material was child pornography?

3. Did the trial court violate defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to retain counsel of his choice when it denied the application of defendant’s father, an Illinois attorney, to appear pro hac vice?

4. To be guilty of a dangerous crime against children under A.R.S. § 13-604.01, must a defendant have known that the children depicted in child pornography the defendant possessed were under the age of fifteen?

5. Did the trial court violate Rule 15 of the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure and commit fundamental error by allowing the state, in making its pretrial disclosure, to provide Coghill with copies of his computer hard drives rather than producing the original hard drives?


2 CA-CR 2006-0223  STATE OF ARIZONA v. R.L. ANTHONY ST. CLAIR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0223
2 CA-CR 2006-0231  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY ADDUCI, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0231
2 CA-CR 2006-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HERSHEL ROBERTS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0233
2 CA-CR 2006-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CAROLYN WADDLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0236
2 CA-CR 2006-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT BRION URIAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0241
2 CA-CR 2006-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDRA PALMA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0245  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT ARVIZO RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0245
2 CA-CR 2006-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY JOSEPH DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0249-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT GAMEZ SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0249-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0253  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAYTON LEE HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0253
2 CA-CR 2006-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD L. ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0256
2 CA-CR 2006-0259  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK JONATHAN SALCIDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0259
2 CA-CR 2006-0261  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VIRGIL LEE YOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0261
2 CA-CR 2006-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO FIERRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0265
2 CA-CR 2006-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANE GERALD McMILLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0267
2 CA-CR 2006-0271  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM JAMES NIELSON CORBETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0271
2 CA-CR 2006-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG ANTHONY ROHLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0275
2 CA-CR 2006-0277  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE ALLEN LYMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0277
2 CA-CR 2006-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME MURIETTA GOMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0285
2 CA-CR 2006-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK STEPHEN BRASHIER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. YOLANDA SOTO POBLETE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0293
2 CA-CR 2006-0295-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WARREN FRANK STAFFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0295-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0299-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH G. HEIRONIMUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0299-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0309-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY S. MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0309-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0311-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD A. POTTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0311-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ENIS JOHN CHERAMIE, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0319
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding possession of a dangerous drug is a lesser-included offense of transportation of a dangerous drug for sale?

Was the defendant’s due process right to notice of the charges against him under the Arizona and United States Constitutions violated when the court allowed the amendment of his indictment during trial from transportation of a dangerous drug for sale to possession of a dangerous drug?


2 CA-CR 2006-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN SWARTFIGUER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN DURRELL GALLOWAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0329
2 CA-CR 2006-0331  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM JAMES NIELSON CORBETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0331
2 CA-CR 2006-0337  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOHN MAURER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0337
2 CA-CR 2006-0339-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KUSHAWN LAMONT PITTMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0339-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AGUSTIN CARRENO BUERAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0341
2 CA-CR 2006-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ARMANDO GOMEZ   Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0351
2 CA-CR 2006-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER GARDUNO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MASUM JAMES VIJAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DIEGO MANUEL OQUITA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0369
2 CA-CR 2006-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRACY MARK DUTCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0371
2 CA-CR 2006-0379-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0379-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL DOMINIC LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0383
2 CA-CR 2006-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WEALTHY DAVID THOMAS, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0389
2 CA-CR 2006-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNULFO ENRIQUEZ GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0390
2 CA-CR 2006-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MYRON DALE FERLANTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0393
2 CA-CR 2006-0395-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTOFER ROBIN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0395-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0401  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ANGEL VALDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0401
2 CA-CR 2006-0403  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALAN DOOGAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0403
2 CA-CR 2006-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETRONILO ALVARADO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0409
2 CA-CR 2006-0411-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW ERICH MANZANEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0411-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0417-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY WEST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0417-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0423-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES EARL FOX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0423-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0425-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMALE MICHAEL CAREY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0425-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0427  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID YULO MARTINEZ, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0427
2 CA-CR 2006-0429  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID WARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0429
2 CA-CR 2006-0431-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LACY RIDDELL, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0431-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0433-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KURT WOODBURN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0433-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0437  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN SCHULTZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0437
2 CA-CR 2006-0443  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN ALBERT LEMON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0443
2 CA-CR 2007-0005-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN MICHAEL FERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0005-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEANTONIO MORENO TERAN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0013
2 CA-CR 2007-0019-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARL LOUIS GUILLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0019-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTY GENE GROVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0021
2 CA-CR 2007-0023  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG LANCE ENGLISH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0023
2 CA-CR 2007-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0032-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN PATRICK HOLDEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0032-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0033-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RADFORD DARRELL SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0033-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LETICIA VILLAREAL GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0036
2 CA-CR 2007-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DONALD MALY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0038
2 CA-CR 2007-0043-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PABLO MORENO GONZALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0043-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXIS GUILLERMO TELLEZ-SUAREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0053  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEY RAY HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0053
2 CA-CR 2007-0055  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH JOHN FALCONE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0055
2 CA-CR 2007-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK JAMES SORIANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0061
Issues Summary: Whether a trial court may delay designation of an open-ended offense after the defendant’s probationary term has expired to consider behavior that occurred before the defendant filed a motion to designate his offense.


2 CA-CR 2007-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN WENDELL BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0071
Issues Summary: Under A.R.S. § 13-3408(A)(7), can a defendant be convicted of both “sale” and “transfer” of a narcotic drug for a single transaction? Is such a conviction on both charges a multiple punishment, and barred by the Double Jeopardy Clause, where the defendant receives concurrent sentences and thus no additional term of imprisonment?


2 CA-CR 2007-0077  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON AMARO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0077
2 CA-CR 2007-0083  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER MASSINGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0083
2 CA-CR 2007-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOREECE HADORN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0085
2 CA-CR 2007-0086  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON KEITH CAMPBELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0086
2 CA-CR 2007-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLIE MARIE FORNOF  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0091
Issues Summary: Does a police officer have reasonable suspicion to make a vehicle stop when he or she observes items changing hands between a pedestrian and an occupant of the vehicle, late at night, at a specific intersection known for high levels of drug-related activity, and the pedestrian leaves the scene quickly on seeing the officer?

Did the trial court err in admitting an expert opinion that drugs possessed by the defendant were for sale, rather than personal use?


2 CA-CR 2007-0097-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN G. WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0097-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0101  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CORRALES RIVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0101
2 CA-CR 2007-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD RAYMOND TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0102
2 CA-CR 2007-0103  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MOISES ZELAYA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0103
2 CA-CR 2007-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUCINDA MARIE PIERCE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0107
2 CA-CR 2007-0109  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANE ROBERT ESTILLORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0109
2 CA-CR 2007-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0119  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MORAN G. THINKA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0119
2 CA-CR 2007-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK JUDE MARTINEZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0122
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in admitting evidence of the defendant’s post-arrest statements made to a neighboring jail inmate, based on the court’s finding the inmate had not acted as a state agent in eliciting or reporting the statements? 2) Did defendant lack standing to object on Fourth Amendment grounds to admission into evidence of a letter he wrote from jail to his girlfriend, whose mother intercepted the letter from their shared mailbox and turned it over to the state? 3) Did the trial court err in admitting the letter into evidence when the record supported a finding the girlfriend’s mother had not acted as a state agent in obtaining and producing the letter?


2 CA-CR 2007-0125-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANDY SALCIDO DURAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0125-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL MENDOZA CARRASCO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE SIERRA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0133
2 CA-CR 2007-0135  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER DALE CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0135
2 CA-CR 2007-0141-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINO FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0141-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN LOUIS WRATHALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0145  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE MANUEL PADILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0145
2 CA-CR 2007-0147-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THUC TRI NGUYEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0147-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0155  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER WALLISER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0155
2 CA-CR 2007-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM HALEY FLYTHE, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0157
Issues Summary: Can a defendant’s renewal of a motion to sever trials pursuant to Rule 13.4(c), Ariz. R. Crim. P., preserve the severance issue on appeal for his codefendant when the codefendant did not join in the renewal of that motion or renew his own?


2 CA-CR 2007-0159  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELBOURNE ROBERT AMES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0159
2 CA-CR 2007-0161  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JESUS ALCALA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0161
2 CA-CR 2007-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO FRANCISCO LARRAZOLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0167
2 CA-CR 2007-0169-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARAMI YELVERTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0169-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0171  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL RAY BUSKE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0171
2 CA-CR 2007-0175  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARSHA LYNN STRINGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0175
2 CA-CR 2007-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY STEPHEN PARENTEAU, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0177
2 CA-CR 2007-0179  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALLAN MORRISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0179
2 CA-CR 2007-0183  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO A. ACEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0183
2 CA-CR 2007-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE DALE TRUJILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0185
2 CA-CR 2007-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL MARISCAL CARDENAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0187
2 CA-CR 2007-0191-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVARO GOMEZ CARRILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0191-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0195  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO JIMENEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0195
2 CA-CR 2007-0196-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL RAYMOND MEZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0196-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC DALE JERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0197
2 CA-CR 2007-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LYNN TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0203  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHIL JOSE CISNEROS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0203
2 CA-CR 2007-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT D. CHANDLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0207
2 CA-CR 2007-0209-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARVIN DARYL TABRON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0209-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IAN MICHAEL DAWKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0212
2 CA-CR 2007-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0217  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARNEST LEE BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0217
2 CA-CR 2007-0219  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERVIN ALAN MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0219
2 CA-CR 2007-0223  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARNEST LEE BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0223
2 CA-CR 2007-0225  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD LAMAR WOODS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0225
2 CA-CR 2007-0227  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0227
2 CA-CR 2007-0236  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYON EUGENE MIMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0236
2 CA-CR 2007-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERT JOHN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0237
2 CA-CR 2007-0239  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUADALUPE YOLANDA GOMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0239
2 CA-CR 2007-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRYSTAL LEE EISENSEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0241
2 CA-CR 2007-0243  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COREY LAMONT HOLLEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0243
2 CA-CR 2007-0244  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD BRUCE BIGGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0244
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by denying appellant’s request for a change of venue due to pretrial publicity, admitting testimony offering probability analyses of DNA evidence, and precluding evidence of third-party culpability?


2 CA-CR 2007-0252  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RAY WEEKS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0252
2 CA-CR 2007-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL RICHARD STATON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN KEITH WADE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0263
2 CA-CR 2007-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENE ANTHONY CHECCHI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0269
2 CA-CR 2007-0273-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EUGENE WALTER TUCKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0273-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0275-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT LAMONT BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0275-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT FISHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0276
2 CA-CR 2007-0279  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND ANTHONY BROEKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0279
2 CA-CR 2007-0281  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL MARIO RIVADENEYRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0281
2 CA-CR 2007-0288  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR TAPIA HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0288
2 CA-CR 2007-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BLANCA BATISTA HANS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0289
2 CA-CR 2007-0291-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN LUKE DOITCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0291-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0292  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY S. SIIRTOLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0292
2 CA-CR 2007-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ASCENSION GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0293
2 CA-CR 2007-0295  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL FRANCIS PISCHEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0295
2 CA-CR 2007-0301  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0301
2 CA-CR 2007-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WELLINGTON SPENCER COPPESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0303-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0305  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL PARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0305
2 CA-CR 2007-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS SERRANO SAMANIEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0306
2 CA-CR 2007-0309  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL DANIEL MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0309
2 CA-CR 2007-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT SANCHEZ ESCOBEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0311
2 CA-CR 2007-0313-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEON TIMBERLAKE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0313-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0315-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC ALAN MULKEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0315-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS PAUL PHILLIPS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0320
2 CA-CR 2007-0321  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT SPENCER DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0321
2 CA-CR 2007-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT W. PARKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOELL CHRISTINA SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELE LOUISA VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0332
2 CA-CR 2007-0333  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL CORDOVA BALTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0333
2 CA-CR 2007-0335-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELINDA ELEM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0335-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0337-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOMAS SILVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0337-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOBB LUIS ORNELAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0339
2 CA-CR 2007-0340  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN ANDRES LEYVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0340
Issues Summary: 1. Was a hearing pursuant to State v. Dessureault, 104 Ariz. 380, 453 P.2d 951 (1969), required when the witness failed to identify the defendant in a pretrial photographic line-up, was later told by the prosecutor she had chosen the wrong person, and then identified the defendant for the first time in court?

2. Was there sufficient evidence to support the defendant’s convictions for attempted armed robbery when, while displaying a gun, he asked the victims if they had any money and they replied, “no”?


2 CA-CR 2007-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ARTURO SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0348
2 CA-CR 2007-0355  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOMINIQUE MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0355
2 CA-CR 2007-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO PRECIADO-VEGA, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ALLEN REEVES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0364  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL ALAN KOSCIELSKI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0364
2 CA-CR 2007-0367  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL MIRANDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0367
2 CA-CR 2007-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO GALAVIZ FIERRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0369
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court abused its discretion by giving a “deliberate ignorance” jury instruction where the defendant had admitted knowing he was transporting “drugs” but denied knowing his cargo was marijuana and his primary defense at trial was that the state failed to prove the mens rea element for the offense of transporting marijuana for sale under A.R.S. § 13-3405.


2 CA-CR 2007-0371-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT CARLTON WILLOUGHBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0371-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER THOMAS WARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0376
2 CA-CR 2007-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CEDRICK DWAYNE JONES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0381
2 CA-CR 2007-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VLADIMIR GARCIA SOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0383
2 CA-CR 2007-0385-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN DALE CRONEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0385-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LYNN WESTMILLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GALLETLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0395
2 CA-CR 2007-0396  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAN CAROL RUST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0396
2 CA-CR 2007-0401-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS SCOTT PERRIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0401-PR
Issues Summary: Whether a trial court may use the “catch-all” aggravator in former A.R.S. § 13-702(D)(13) as one of the two aggravating factors necessary to impose a substantially aggravated sentence under former A.R.S. § 13-702.01(A) in light of the supreme court’s opinion in State v. Schmidt, 220 Ariz. 563, 208 P.3d 214 (2009).


2 CA-CR 2007-0403  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ENRIQUE ORTEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0403
Issues Summary: (1) Whether molestation of a child is a lesser included offense of sexual conduct with a minor under fifteen years of age and whether the Double Jeopardy Clauses of the United States and Arizona Constitutions consequently prohibit a defendant from being convicted of both.

(2) Whether the state exerted improper influence over the testimony of a witness.


2 CA-CR 2007-0415-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN WAYNE McMULLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0415-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL NORMAN BAYLISS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DALE HUNTINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0004
2 CA-CR 2008-0011-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER ANDREW RAMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0011-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0015  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MOON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0015
2 CA-CR 2008-0016  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON MARTIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0016
2 CA-CR 2008-0021-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JARED MICHAEL WAGONER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0021-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0023-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL EDWARD SOUZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0023-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RENARD REED III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0026
2 CA-CR 2008-0027  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RENARD REED, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0027
2 CA-CR 2008-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW LEE NEWTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0029
2 CA-CR 2008-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN DURAZO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0031
2 CA-CR 2008-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN DWAYNE SZPYRKA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0035
Issues Summary: Was the statement “I got nothin’ to say” an unambiguous invocation of a suspect’s Fifth Amendment right to remain silent, obliging the detective to cease questioning immediately?


2 CA-CR 2008-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL BRADFORD WOODS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0036
2 CA-CR 2008-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE JOSEPH TUCCI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0040
2 CA-CR 2008-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DAVID LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0046
2 CA-CR 2008-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT MICHAEL HOLLENBACK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN GERARDO GARRIDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0064
2 CA-CR 2008-0065-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNEST JAMES GRIMM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0065-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL ANGEL ZEBADUA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0074
2 CA-CR 2008-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ANTHONY TEMBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0079
2 CA-CR 2008-0085-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK FILLMORE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0085-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0087-PR  THE STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL J. EVANCHYK, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0087-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0088-PR  THE STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DEAN McCOY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0095-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE D.L. CROCKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0095-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE FLORES MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0096
2 CA-CR 2008-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0102
2 CA-CR 2008-0105  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEE HOLMAN LACEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0105
2 CA-CR 2008-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENA ARLIEN BREWER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0107
2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ALCANTAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0109-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COREY DeNEIL BARNUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0109-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0110-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE DAVID DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0110-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH GLENN HUNTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KIM COOK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0120-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0121-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0121-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS NORBERTO FELIX-GRADILLAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0126
2 CA-CR 2008-0128  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELISSA SUE WELCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0128
2 CA-CR 2008-0141  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS M. BORREGO, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0141
2 CA-CR 2008-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL CARRISOZA RIVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0163-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH T. DRAYTON II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0163-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAYNE NELSON DANIELS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0166
Issues Summary: Did the trial court fundamentally err in imposing against the defendants at sentencing a $1,000 prosecution fee pursuant to a Pinal County ordinance?


2 CA-CR 2008-0167  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAUN JERMAINE BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0167
2 CA-CR 2008-0168  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO J. GALAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0168
2 CA-CR 2008-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE TASHQUINTH, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0172
2 CA-CR 2008-0174  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CEDRIC BROGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0174
2 CA-CR 2008-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MATTHEWSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0176
2 CA-CR 2008-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MULHOLLAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WILLIAM STENZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0182
2 CA-CR 2008-0184  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0184
2 CA-CR 2008-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROXANA LEE SALGADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0188
2 CA-CR 2008-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTHUR FREDRIC GERTH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHYRON LEE THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WESLEY HOWARD, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0208
2 CA-CR 2008-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSICA NOEL DEPINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0210
2 CA-CR 2008-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE AMADOR-GALICIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0212
2 CA-CR 2008-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES EARL HUTCHISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0213
2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWIN ANTHONY PELLECIER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO IMPERIAL VEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0228  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RANDALL HALSTEAD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0228
2 CA-CR 2008-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCO LEVONTE WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0230
2 CA-CR 2008-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK MIGUEL LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT ALLEN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0246
2 CA-CR 2008-0254  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY ALEXANDER CONGRESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0254
2 CA-CR 2008-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LACY RIDDELL, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE CALVIN HURSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0265
2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHESTER LEON AXSOM, II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CORRALES RIVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMISON SCOTT WILLETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0278
2 CA-CR 2008-0290-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES E. GRANINGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0290-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN WILDMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0294  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY LOUIS MUSGROVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0294
Issues Summary: Does double jeopardy attach when a trial judge grants a judgment of acquittal and, after continuing discussion, reconsiders, denies the motion and allows the charge to go to the jury?


2 CA-CR 2008-0296  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ELKINS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0296
2 CA-CR 2008-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0314
2 CA-CR 2008-0316  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0316
2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENIE VARELA VALENCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KELVIN JEROME HOUSTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0320
2 CA-CR 2008-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY JAYE WADE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS ASHTON CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0328
2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SILVIA ESTRELLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHMOND OWEN CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0336  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CURT ANDREW RICCI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0336
2 CA-CR 2008-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS SCOTT BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0338
2 CA-CR 2008-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMIAH MARCE FORTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0339
Issues Summary: When a defendant’s probation is revoked and he is sentenced for a felony offense, does a trial court err by conducting the disposition hearing with the defendant appearing only through an interactive audiovisual device and unable to communicate confidentially with counsel?


2 CA-CR 2008-0340  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA ANN MENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0340
2 CA-CR 2008-0344  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANN SINCLAIR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0344
2 CA-CR 2008-0350-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE ARLIEN BREWER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0350-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0355-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PARVIS JOHNNARY FIALLOS-RIVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0355-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE YSIDRO SPERLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON CAMPBELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0364-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON AMARO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0364-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLSIE COLSTON, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0368  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DANIEL VAUGHN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0368
2 CA-CR 2008-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUSTIN ANTHONY ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0372
2 CA-CR 2008-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE JOE BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0374
2 CA-CR 2008-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN WILLIAM DAVID SICARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELVIN STANDISH WOPSCHALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALFREDO PERALTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH EUGENE WOJTSECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0383
2 CA-CR 2008-0384-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY LAMONT LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0384-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO GUARDADO-SOLORIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0389
2 CA-CR 2008-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GABRIEL PESQUEIRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0390
2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL F. CRAGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0402-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER GEORGE KISS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0402-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0406  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS HUMBERTO SOTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0406
2 CA-CR 2008-0409  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MUSGROVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0409
2 CA-CR 2008-0412  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY MICHAEL GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0412
2 CA-CR 2008-0420  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CAMACHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0420
2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL MARIO CASTANEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ROBERT HUGHES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0004
2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE L. TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN FRANCISCO MANRIQUEZ-VIZCARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0014
2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0020  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER WAYNE FRANCIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0020
Issues Summary: Whether the state must specifically allege a defendant is eligible for sentencing under A.R.S. § 13-3419 before he or she may be sentenced pursuant to that statute.


2 CA-CR 2009-0022  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAY NELSON HULL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0022
2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL DAVID RICHARDSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0030  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ALEJANDRO FRASQUILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0030
2 CA-CR 2009-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRUCE TYRONE STOCKER, JR.   Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0031
2 CA-CR 2009-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ERIC HAYES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0034
2 CA-CR 2009-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY JOSEPH TOMASZEWSKI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0036
2 CA-CR 2009-0041  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENDA LORRAINE RUMSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0041
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred by not suppressing evidence of blood-test results after concluding the defendant’s right to counsel had been violated at the time the blood draw occurred.


2 CA-CR 2009-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFRED ALEXANDER LAMADRID  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0046
2 CA-CR 2009-0050-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE HAROLD FLINT, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0050-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AUGUSTINE RUBEN VASQUEZ III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0056
2 CA-CR 2009-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYALLEN HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0064
2 CA-CR 2009-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY FIGUEROA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0068
2 CA-CR 2009-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ALBERTO ORTEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0071
2 CA-CR 2009-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO LOPEZ MADUENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0074
2 CA-CR 2009-0080  STATE OF ARIZONA v.TAMEKA INGRID WRIGHT   Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0080
2 CA-CR 2009-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKE ALLEN SCHOMISCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0096
2 CA-CR 2009-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUBERT WASHINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0098
2 CA-CR 2009-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL NEACE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0102
2 CA-CR 2009-0107-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK ALLEN RUNDHAUG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0107-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0116  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DALE EDWARD CRANFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0116
2 CA-CR 2009-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR SAINZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0122
2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANVILLE JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0130  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RAY LYNAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0130
2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY TERRELL THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0138  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MILES L. KAUFMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0138
2 CA-CR 2009-0142  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN GARCIA-NAVARRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0142
Issues Summary: Does driving at a high rate of speed and almost colliding with another car constitute a breach of the peace sufficient to permit a federal border patrol agent to make a citizen’s arrest pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-3884?


2 CA-CR 2009-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON BUCKLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0148
2 CA-CR 2009-0150  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REBECCA SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0150
2 CA-CR 2009-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESTLEY NAT LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0154-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERMAN SALAZAR MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0156
2 CA-CR 2009-0160  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES BENJAMIN MAPES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0160
2 CA-CR 2009-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACOB MICHAEL AGUILAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0166
2 CA-CR 2009-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE D. SPRANG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0172
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion by instructing the jury on second-degree murder when all the evidence supported a finding of premeditation, and, if so, was the error harmless? When the defendant was acquitted of first-degree murder by the jury and when the appellate court has vacated the defendant’s conviction for the lesser-included crime of second-degree murder, has double jeopardy attached to the second-degree murder charge?


2 CA-CR 2009-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN MICHAEL MAYNES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0177
2 CA-CR 2009-0178-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY WILLIAM COON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0178-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0185-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBIN GULLEDGE-FORGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0185-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID YULO MARTINEZ III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0186
2 CA-CR 2009-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THADDEUS IKOSY'S CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0188
2 CA-CR 2009-0190-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA AGUILERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0190-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0192-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ANTHONY STAPLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0192-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0196  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR ISAAC CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0196
2 CA-CR 2009-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER RUSSELL REEDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0197
2 CA-CR 2009-0198  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARSHALL EARL THOMPSON II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0198
2 CA-CR 2009-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUNIES ALBERRY JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE REFUGIO VALDESPINO GUEVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0212
2 CA-CR 2009-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT EDWIN RIOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE G. SANCHEZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO PARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0222
2 CA-CR 2009-0224  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM FREDRICK YORK, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0224
2 CA-CR 2009-0226-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS OAKES WATSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0226-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BURRELL RICO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0234  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER ADAN ARMENDARIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0234
2 CA-CR 2009-0244-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERVIN ALAN MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0244-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0250-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAURENCE LEE MARCELLUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0250-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDY ALFRED APELT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0256
2 CA-CR 2009-0260  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE DE JESUS ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0260
2 CA-CR 2009-0262  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH THOMAS JESSUP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0262
2 CA-CR 2009-0268-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM BUSTOS RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0268-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0272  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CURTIS LYNN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0272
2 CA-CR 2009-0276-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LEE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0276-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS GRANT GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0278
2 CA-CR 2009-0280  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER L. HINTON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0280
2 CA-CR 2009-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY EUGENE MILLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0287
2 CA-CR 2009-0302-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERONICA TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0302-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL OQUITA GUTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0306-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERALD RAY TIMMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0306-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0308  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SCOTT DECAIRE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0308
2 CA-CR 2009-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS RAY MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0314
2 CA-CR 2009-0318  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE JESUS CORTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0318
2 CA-CR 2009-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANKLYN EDWARD CAIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0324-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID MICHAEL COOK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0324-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTA R. CAMACHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MICHAEL GUTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0332
2 CA-CR 2009-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN BENJAMIN BARRAZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0336-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC THORIN PEELER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0338
2 CA-CR 2009-0340-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL S. LIEVERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0340-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0346-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE ANTHONY LUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0346-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS WESTLEY WILSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0348
2 CA-CR 2009-0350  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT ALPHONSO POWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0350
2 CA-CR 2009-0352  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROLANDO ENCINAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0352
2 CA-CR 2009-0354-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN G. WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0354-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0356  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL MORALES OTERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0356
2 CA-CR 2009-0358  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO LOPEZ MADUENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0358
2 CA-CR 2009-0360  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS ANGELO LAGUNAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0360
2 CA-CR 2009-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS CHRISTOPHER DALZELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0368-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY JAYE WADE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0368-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DALE HIGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0374
2 CA-CR 2009-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0378  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AREN LEE PERRYMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0378
2 CA-CR 2009-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0380
2 CA-CR 2009-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARL ANTHONY MACKEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0382
2 CA-CR 2009-0386-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAJORNSAK PRASERTPHONG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0386-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANTHONY TRUJILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0390
2 CA-CR 2009-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONY MATUL SARAT-ROJOP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0398
2 CA-CR 2009-0400  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT LYNN LARSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0400
2 CA-CR 2009-0404-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN LAMAR BOOKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0404-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0406-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL MERINO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0406-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0408-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCED FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0408-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0002-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE H. SOTELO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0002-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN DOUGLAS KINNEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0004
Issues Summary: Did officers illegally detain defendant when they no longer had reasonable suspicion that he was wanted in connection with an arrest warrant? If so, were defendant’s subsequent statements tainted by the illegal detention, and if they were, did the trial court commit fundamental error in admitting the statements? If it did, was there sufficient evidence to sustain the conviction in the absence of the statements?


2 CA-CR 2010-0006  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LIN GARRISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0006
2 CA-CR 2010-0012  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON EDWARD ERICKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0012
2 CA-CR 2010-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHANIE DAWN RAMIREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0014
2 CA-CR 2010-0020-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE ORLANDO SANTA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0020-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0027-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO ALBERTO ALTAMIRANO, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0027-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0030-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD SZABO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0030-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0032-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD RAYMOND LANE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0032-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0034-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN EUGENE CRAIG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0034-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL MANOLITO PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0039
2 CA-CR 2010-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY IRVIN WEEAST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0040
2 CA-CR 2010-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK OWENS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0042
2 CA-CR 2010-0046-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ROBLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0046-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0048-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL EDWARD RUEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0048-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0052  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES CHARLES RAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0052
Issues Summary: Did the trial court lack authority under A.R.S. § 13-1709 and A.R.S. § 13-804 to require appellant, following his conviction for two counts of reckless burning, to reimburse various state and federal agencies for emergency response expenses the agencies incurred in battling a fire appellant had started? If not, did the trial court violate appellant’s right to due process by ordering him to pay these expenses when sentencing him?


2 CA-CR 2010-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0056
2 CA-CR 2010-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS BANKS LESLIE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0058
2 CA-CR 2010-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO MIGUEL GIBSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0068
2 CA-CR 2010-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0070
2 CA-CR 2010-0072  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL SANCHEZ-HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0072
2 CA-CR 2010-0076-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBY DOMINGUEZ PINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0076-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PERLA LIZABETH CONTRERAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0078
2 CA-CR 2010-0082-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CORY LAMONT HOLLEMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0082-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0083-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH SAMUEL GARFIELD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0083-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0089  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TAMARA V. MAXWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0089
2 CA-CR 2010-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINDA GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN JOSEPH RUHL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0096
2 CA-CR 2010-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL IGNACIO SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0098
2 CA-CR 2010-0102-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID GLENN MILLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0102-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0104-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANGELITO VANNATTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0104-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0105  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN JAMES KING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0105
2 CA-CR 2010-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOA SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0112
2 CA-CR 2010-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RENE BENITEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0120  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM LEIGHTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0120
2 CA-CR 2010-0121  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MANUEL MORAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0121
2 CA-CR 2010-0124-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO RENE MENDIBLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0124-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MODESTO GUILLEN, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0131
2 CA-CR 2010-0134  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROSENDO CRISTOBAL VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0134
2 CA-CR 2010-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT ALPHONSO POWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0139
2 CA-CR 2010-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE HUMBERTO VEGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0146-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL AUGUSTINE VILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0146-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERTO MAZON, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0148
2 CA-CR 2010-0150-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONDRE KAMONIE BELLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0150-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MICHAEL VIVONA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0154-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ANTHONY MATUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0158
2 CA-CR 2010-0162  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL EDWARD LANE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0162
2 CA-CR 2010-0163  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MICHAEL ROSSI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0163
2 CA-CR 2010-0170  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL HAYES NASTIUK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0170
2 CA-CR 2010-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LORENZO RIVERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0176
Issues Summary: 1. Does a jury instruction implicitly amend the indictment when it uses the more expansive language of the statute rather than the more tailored language in the indictment?

2. Was there sufficient evidence to support convictions for endangerment by threat of imminent death when some of the victims may have been in an interior room of the house but the bullets, shot from outside the house, had the capability of penetrating several layers of wall?


2 CA-CR 2010-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN S. HUNTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0177
Issues Summary: Whether, in the context of a defendant’s right to a speedy trial, excluded time under Ariz. R. Crim. P. 8.4 runs from the date a motion is filed, or from the date the trial court rules on the motion.


2 CA-CR 2010-0184-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN ALLEN BRUNI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0184-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN LEON CORRAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0189
2 CA-CR 2010-0195  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADLEY ALAN SCHWARTZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0195
2 CA-CR 2010-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK NORIKI KASIC  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0197
Issues Summary: 1. Whether Graham v. Florida, which held the Eighth Amendment categorically prohibits a life-without-parole prison sentence for juvenile nonhomicide offenders, bars appellant’s consecutively imposed sentences on twenty felony counts committed as a juvenile because the cumulative sentence exceeds his life expectancy.

2. Whether the reasoning of Graham v. Florida extends to the twelve felony counts for crimes appellant committed after he turned eighteen years of age.

3. Did the state fail to establish that two palm trees were “property,” or were worth more than $100, to support two felony arson-of-property convictions?


2 CA-CR 2010-0198-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS JOSE SOTO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0198-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMADI SCHALON CANNON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT EDWARD MORELLI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0206
2 CA-CR 2010-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0207
2 CA-CR 2010-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JU'JUAN MARQUETTE GIBSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0209
2 CA-CR 2010-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO SOLAREZ LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0210
2 CA-CR 2010-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON JOSE DAVIDSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0212
2 CA-CR 2010-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE HURSEY, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR ANTONIO PARSONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0222-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS VEGA CASTILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0222-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0224-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANLEY WADE STARR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0224-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0225  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HORACIO ALBERTO CASTANOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0225
2 CA-CR 2010-0228-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG ALLEN BAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0228-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0229  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN BOWMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0229
2 CA-CR 2010-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AGUSTIN MEDINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0233
2 CA-CR 2010-0236-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL PAUL KECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0236-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0238-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL ELLIOTT, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0238-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ENRIQUE BALLESTEROS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0241
2 CA-CR 2010-0242-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL JESUS CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0242-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0244  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH DANIEL GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0244
2 CA-CR 2010-0246-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABRAAN RENE ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0246-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0248-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUANE WALTON EDWARDS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0248-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0252-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK FERNANDO CASTANEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0252-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0254  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID EDWARD DRAKE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0254
2 CA-CR 2010-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL HARTMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0256
2 CA-CR 2010-0257  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC DEWAYNE HILL   Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0257
2 CA-CR 2010-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL ALFONSO CARRASCO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0270
2 CA-CR 2010-0276-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS ANTHONY TRUJILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0276-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0281  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN CURTIS STEWART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0281
2 CA-CR 2010-0282  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA ASTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0282
2 CA-CR 2010-0283  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME ANTONIO TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0283
2 CA-CR 2010-0288  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PABLO AMAYO CARBAJAL, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0288
2 CA-CR 2010-0295  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR STEVEN VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0295
2 CA-CR 2010-0299  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN CORNELL WORLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0299
2 CA-CR 2010-0300-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0300-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0303  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN WILLIAM MANUEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0303
2 CA-CR 2010-0304  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DWAYNE CHILDS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0304
2 CA-CR 2010-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROLANDO CORTEZ SIERRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0313
2 CA-CR 2010-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN BISHOP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0321  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELVIA VARELA RUELAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0321
2 CA-CR 2010-0323  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY FRANK SHOULTS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0323
2 CA-CR 2010-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL MARIO RIVADENEYRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE C. FLICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. R.W. WOOD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0332
2 CA-CR 2010-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY TERRELL THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0336-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0339  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL ANGEL ORDAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0339
2 CA-CR 2010-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT ACOSTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0341
2 CA-CR 2010-0345  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT REY LEMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0345
2 CA-CR 2010-0354-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETRONILO ALVARADO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0354-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTHUR LEE BRITO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0359  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN JESUS LEBARIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0359
2 CA-CR 2010-0360-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL SOSA MUNIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0360-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0361  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ANTONIO GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0361
2 CA-CR 2010-0362-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL SANTOS SILVAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0362-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0369  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUZ TRINIDAD FIERRO-ANGULO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0369
2 CA-CR 2010-0371  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM JOEL VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0371
2 CA-CR 2010-0375-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL JAMES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0375-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0379  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS RAY REASONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0379
2 CA-CR 2010-0386-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALAN WADE CROWE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0386-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0390-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN OLIVER SWARTZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0390-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC MARK SUTHERLAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0392-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0392-PR
Issues Summary: Whether a pleading defendant is precluded, in his second Rule 32 petition, from asserting ineffective assistance of of-right Rule 32 counsel on the grounds that counsel failed to raise all colorable claims related to his plea proceedings and obtained only partial relief; whether such a claim is premature when raised before the petitioner has been resentenced in accordance with the order granting relief in his first Rule 32 proceeding.


2 CA-CR 2010-0393  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ROBERT KENNEDY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0393
2 CA-CR 2010-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID HILTON BRAMLETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0395
2 CA-CR 2010-0399-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLIVER MICHAEL PRYOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0399-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0400-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LIN GARRISON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0400-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0404-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORDAN CHAVIRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0404-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0405  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MORENO-CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0405
2 CA-CR 2010-0412-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK ALLEN RUNDHAUG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0412-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0413  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE FRANCISCO PERAZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0413
2 CA-CR 2010-0414-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ALEJANDRO FRASQUILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0414-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0415  STATE OF ARIZONA v. UIKIRIFI FRANCISCO LEATIGAGA-LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0415
2 CA-CR 2010-0417  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO MIGUEL GIBSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0417
2 CA-CR 2011-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY LOUIS MUSGROVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PATRICK KELLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0003
2 CA-CR 2011-0005  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN ALBERTO SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0005
2 CA-CR 2011-0010-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY JAMES WARE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0010-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0017-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DION DAVID BRUNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0017-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0018-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD SZABO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0018-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0026-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO CUEVAS GALLEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0026-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0027  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM MICHAEL JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0027
2 CA-CR 2011-0029  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CONSTANTINO RODRIGUEZ ORDUNO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0029
2 CA-CR 2011-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO PERALTA VOLTARES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0031
2 CA-CR 2011-0032-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY PADIAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0032-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0033  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON HUMBERTO CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0033
2 CA-CR 2011-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TAYLOR RYAN FROEBE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0035
2 CA-CR 2011-0038-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERNON MICHAEL LANGLOSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0038-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0040-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRISTINA Z. COTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0040-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0043  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE ANTHONY CASTILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0043
2 CA-CR 2011-0047  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMANUEL PIMENTEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0047
2 CA-CR 2011-0052-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GORDON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0052-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0055  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD PETER PRIVITERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0055
2 CA-CR 2011-0057-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVIN CHESTER HILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0057-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MAURO ACUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0059
2 CA-CR 2011-0061  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEO EUGENE STRANGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0061
2 CA-CR 2011-0063  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT PAUL COLETTI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0063
2 CA-CR 2011-0071  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON ROY MERRIETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0071
2 CA-CR 2011-0077  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD TITUS SPEER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0077
2 CA-CR 2011-0080-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ORLANDO RENTERIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0080-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0081  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS GEORGE VELASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0081
2 CA-CR 2011-0089  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN LEE WARREN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0089
2 CA-CR 2011-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT MICHAEL MAILLOUX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0091
2 CA-CR 2011-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH JOHN FALCONE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0093
2 CA-CR 2011-0095  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SANTIAGO BARELA MINJARES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0095
2 CA-CR 2011-0097  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBIN PAT WILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0097
2 CA-CR 2011-0111  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG S. DAHLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0111
2 CA-CR 2011-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER MASSINGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH JOHN FALCONE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0117-PR
Issues Summary: Was criminal defense counsel ineffective in failing to object when the trial court instructed the jury it was not required to find the defendant had “any knowledge of the age of the alleged victim” in order to find him guilty of sexual conduct with a minor for “knowingly engaging in sexual intercourse . . . with any person who is under eighteen years of age,” A.R.S. § 13-1405?


2 CA-CR 2011-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEITH ROYAL PHILLIPS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0123  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIARON GERMAINE ROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0123
2 CA-CR 2011-0127  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS ELVEN WAY SPEAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0127
2 CA-CR 2011-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD JOE GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMMANUEL DEMITRIUS MCKINNEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0131
2 CA-CR 2011-0133  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER DENNIS BIENIECKI, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0133
2 CA-CR 2011-0137-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABRAAN RENE ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0137-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES CAULDWELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0140
2 CA-CR 2011-0143  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROLAND JAMES SALISBURY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0143
2 CA-CR 2011-0147  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL AYALA KEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0147
2 CA-CR 2011-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELAINE MARIE BLANKENSHIP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0149
2 CA-CR 2011-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROSALIO DELGADO BELTRAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0157
2 CA-CR 2011-0165  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL H. ALMON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0165
2 CA-CR 2011-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM J. MESA JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0175  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ILENE CHRISTINE YBAVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0175
2 CA-CR 2011-0177  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALEJANDRO MEJIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0177
2 CA-CR 2011-0179  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAMONDAI RICHARD YOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0179
2 CA-CR 2011-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNALDO ZEPEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0185
2 CA-CR 2011-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ANTHONY LANOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0187
2 CA-CR 2011-0189-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK RICHARD BLACKWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0189-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0190-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES STUART REICHERT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0190-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRICK JAMAL DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0197
2 CA-CR 2011-0201  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KIRKLAND LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0201
2 CA-CR 2011-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY E. HICKS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0207  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARBARA M. SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0207
2 CA-CR 2011-0215  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JOSE CASTILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0215
2 CA-CR 2011-0216  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ROSS FUNK, JR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0216
2 CA-CR 2011-0217  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIRANDA SUE PADILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0217
2 CA-CR 2011-0223  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CIESLINSKI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0223
2 CA-CR 2011-0225  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANLEY JON LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0225
2 CA-CR 2011-0235-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WELLINGTON SPENCER COPPESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0235-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0237-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERALD E. LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0237-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0251-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL DEWAYNE CAIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0251-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0255-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN CONDIDO RIVERA, JR.,  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0255-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE DE JESUS ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NELSON HOWARD BASS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0263  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROLANDO PARRADO-HERRERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0263
2 CA-CR 2011-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0269
2 CA-CR 2011-0271  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ROSALIO JARROTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0271
2 CA-CR 2011-0273  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK VINCENT SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0273
2 CA-CR 2011-0275  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ELLIOT ROMEO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0275
2 CA-CR 2011-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID SCOTT PAULSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0278
2 CA-CR 2011-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON OMAR BUCKLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0283-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0283-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0284  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE EDWARD MAUCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0284
2 CA-CR 2011-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN JEFFERY MCCALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0285
2 CA-CR 2011-0289-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY JOSEPH RILEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0289-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN PEDRO DeLEON, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0293
2 CA-CR 2011-0295-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT VINCENT INIGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0295-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0297-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESTEBAN MALDONADO ARMENTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0297-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0303  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NARCISO GABRIEL CASILLAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0303
2 CA-CR 2011-0305  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO SOLANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0305
2 CA-CR 2011-0309-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHERMAN LEE RUTLEDGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0309-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN PABLO REYES-VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0313
2 CA-CR 2011-0317-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO LOPEZ MADUENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0317-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LEROY WITT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0320
2 CA-CR 2011-0323  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RON WARRICK SALABARRIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0323
2 CA-CR 2011-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OMAR NAVARRO AMAVISCA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0331-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN BAPTIST CATANIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0331-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0333  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ZACHARY M. WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0333
2 CA-CR 2011-0335-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAY NELSON HULL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0335-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0337-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNOLD LESTER GEIB  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0337-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0341  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESTEBAN JAVIER TERRAZAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0341
2 CA-CR 2011-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO PESQUEIRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0343
2 CA-CR 2011-0345  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID MUNOZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0345
2 CA-CR 2011-0349  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS JOHN FELIX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0349
2 CA-CR 2011-0351  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MANUEL CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0351
2 CA-CR 2011-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERICA LEA WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0365
2 CA-CR 2011-0366  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON WADE SMILEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0366
2 CA-CR 2011-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH DAN-PAUL JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0375
2 CA-CR 2011-0378  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO CABELLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0378
2 CA-CR 2011-0379-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO ESTEBAN RIMER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0379-PR
2 CA-CR 2011-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO ANTONIO VILLA-CARRANZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0383
2 CA-CR 2011-0387  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT DANIEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0387
2 CA-CR 2011-0397  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT F. SNYDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0397
2 CA-CR 2011-0401  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CONRAD SAINZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0401
2 CA-CR 2011-0405  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL RENE LOPEZ-VIDAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0405
2 CA-CR 2012-0001-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEWEY LEE MCBRIDE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0001-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0005-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS BERNARDO GRANILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0005-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0011  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LEONEL PARRA-DEHARO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0011
2 CA-CR 2012-0015-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALBERTO CHAVEZ-PALMA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0015-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0017-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMIE OLIVER BEASLEY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0017-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALAN EUGENE LINEBARGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0021
2 CA-CR 2012-0025  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY RAYMUNDO CORONADO   Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0025
2 CA-CR 2012-0027-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIA ALANIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0027-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0031-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STERLING DEVON MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0031-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0033-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RONALD KUHNS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0033-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0035  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHANNON MORIA SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0035
2 CA-CR 2012-0037  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JENNIFER MICHELLE SNOUFFER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0037
2 CA-CR 2012-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FLOYD BENNETT RIOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0039
2 CA-CR 2012-0045-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EUGENE YODER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0045-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0047-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL PERRY ROBERTSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0047-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0050  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH GABRIEL LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0050
2 CA-CR 2012-0051  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKEL THOMAS DILLON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0051
2 CA-CR 2012-0053  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT EUGENE COBB  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0053
2 CA-CR 2012-0055  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0055
2 CA-CR 2012-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS PEDRO CASTRO MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0067
2 CA-CR 2012-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK DOWLING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0073  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO VINCENT BEJARANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0073
2 CA-CR 2012-0075  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS ANDREW NARCHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0075
2 CA-CR 2012-0077-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE GENE SARTIN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0077-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0079-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM AVERY PATTERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0079-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0081-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC JOSEPH NATZEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0081-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TONY CRUZ, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0085
2 CA-CR 2012-0087  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MORRISTON NEAL CARSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0087
2 CA-CR 2012-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP DAVID MORRIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0093  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN ANTHONY VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0093
2 CA-CR 2012-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY WAYNE NOWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0098
2 CA-CR 2012-0105  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN WARREN ZUNIGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0105
2 CA-CR 2012-0107-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN L. ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0107-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0111-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIFFANY LACHELLE SUTTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0111-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0113-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT MUNOZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0113-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ZACKARIAH ALEXUS SURGICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0123  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RAY WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0123
2 CA-CR 2012-0133-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TROY WILLIAM GIBBONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0133-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0137-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE SAINZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0137-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0141-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEOFFREY PAUL GAGNON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0141-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALLEN WILSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDUARDO VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0145-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GUY GEORGE GETTY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0145-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0149-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADONIS LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0149-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0157  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO QUIJADA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0157
2 CA-CR 2012-0159  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICARWIA JOSEPHINE HUDSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0159
2 CA-CR 2012-0161  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID WARE, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0161
2 CA-CR 2012-0163  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALBERT LEAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0163
2 CA-CR 2012-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE FRANCIS CURTIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0164
2 CA-CR 2012-0169-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN LAMONT BECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0169-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CHARLES LOOMIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0173  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HILARIO AGUIRRE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0173
2 CA-CR 2012-0178  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RYAN ALEXANDER ROMERO-FIMBRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0178
2 CA-CR 2012-0181  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DWAYNE CEDRIC LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0181
2 CA-CR 2012-0185  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE LEYVAS GONZALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0185
2 CA-CR 2012-0187  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WHITNEY BROOKE DRUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0187
2 CA-CR 2012-0191-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEL ESCALERA RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0191-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0195-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES FRANKLIN LONG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0195-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID LANCE ALLEY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0197
2 CA-CR 2012-0199-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MICHAEL MONTARULI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0199-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0201-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP J. MCMULLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0201-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER JAMES VAN JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY ALLEN REED  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0209
2 CA-CR 2012-0211  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE RAYMAUNDO FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0211
2 CA-CR 2012-0213  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH MICHAEL POWERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0213
2 CA-CR 2012-0224-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS ELVEN WAY SPEAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0224-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0227  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ALEJANDRO ORELLANO-TIZNADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0227
2 CA-CR 2012-0231  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO SANTAMARIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0231
2 CA-CR 2012-0232  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CATHERINE ANN MORAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0232
2 CA-CR 2012-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO SANTAMARIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0233
2 CA-CR 2012-0235-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0235-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH CHARLES SCOTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0241-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEE FIELDS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0241-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HEATHER ELIZABETH POLZIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLIVER MICHAEL PRYOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0249-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY WILLIAM COLEMAN JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0249-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0255-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELVIN A. SLINGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0255-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0257-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN EDWARD MAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0257-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME PEREZ MUNOZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEWIS STEVENSON MCDANIEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0263-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDY CHARLES BODIE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0263-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0265-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ANGEL RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0265-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0267-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKEY LEE CAMPBELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0267-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0269  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONAVAN ANTHONY JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0269
2 CA-CR 2012-0271  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DARRIN SLOCUM JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0271
2 CA-CR 2012-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SIOBHAN LYNN PARCELLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0277-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ANTHONY WARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0277-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0279-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE VICENTE MONTIEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0279-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES WARD CHAPMAN III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0283  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JARED LOSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0283
2 CA-CR 2012-0285  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRELL KEITH CROMWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0285
2 CA-CR 2012-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0293-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JAVIER LUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0293-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0297-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVIN STEVENSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0297-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0299  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR ALBERTO FIMBRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0299
2 CA-CR 2012-0301  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIFFANY MARIE PESINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0301
2 CA-CR 2012-0308-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PRENTISS COGHILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0308-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SHAWN ECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0311
2 CA-CR 2012-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALONSO HINOJOSA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0313
2 CA-CR 2012-0317-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BURRELL RICO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0317-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0321-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0321-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0322-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN ALBERTO CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0322-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0328-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN JON PURKERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0328-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0329-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ERNEST HILLYER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0329-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TYRELL KENNETH DEVORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0331-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL CRUZ TRUJILLO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0331-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALLACE ALBERT BEGAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0335  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS GERMAN MENDEZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0335
2 CA-CR 2012-0341-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES STUART REICHERT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0341-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0349  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS ELIAS MACIAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0349
2 CA-CR 2012-0353  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MICHAEL BARCELO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0353
2 CA-CR 2012-0356  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH NELSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0356
2 CA-CR 2012-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH CHANECKA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0360-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS aka GLEN ALLEN HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0360-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FELIX UFRANO RAMIREZ-RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0362-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO RODRIGUEZ-CASTRUITA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0362-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0363-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ALFREDO COCOM-TAX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0363-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0365-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAMELA MARIE WOOD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0365-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLARENCE E. RHODES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0369-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC DEWAYNE PHILLIPS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0369-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0371-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARILEE ELSA GREEN-LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0371-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0375  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELISSA CATHERINE WARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0375
2 CA-CR 2012-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOA SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0381  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO ARVAYO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0381
2 CA-CR 2012-0383  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ARTHER ZUKOWSKI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0383
2 CA-CR 2012-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND ALFRED LATHAM IV  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0388-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID REYES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0388-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0391-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ERNESTO MADUENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0391-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE FRANKLIN APOLINAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0395
2 CA-CR 2012-0417-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THADDEUS IKOSYS CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0417-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0421-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EUGENE VICKREY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0421-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0429  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRYSTAL NADINE GUERRERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0429
2 CA-CR 2012-0431  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN OSHEA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0431
2 CA-CR 2012-0433-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES EDMUND KIVLEHEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0433-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0437-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IGNACIO ESTEBAN RIMER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0437-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0441  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMASO ALAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0441
2 CA-CR 2012-0443-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0443-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0445  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMMY LEE MITCHELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0445
2 CA-CR 2012-0447  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN JOSEPH SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0447
2 CA-CR 2012-0451  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANK K.C. HERTEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0451
2 CA-CR 2012-0453  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MARIA GRIJALVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0453
2 CA-CR 2012-0454-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ODIS AMOS SCHLOSSER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0454-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0456  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM SCHAEFFLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0456
2 CA-CR 2012-0457  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW EDWARD FOSTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0457
2 CA-CR 2012-0461-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JU' JUAN MARQUETE GIBSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0461-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0462-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENDA LORRAINE RUMSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0462-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0463  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LEE PETERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0463
2 CA-CR 2012-0471-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEROY JAMES MICHAEL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0471-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0473-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LORENZO REYES FELIX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0473-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0481  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMONTE ASKAREE LARUE-FRANKLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0481
2 CA-CR 2012-0483  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM LEON CORRAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0483
2 CA-CR 2012-0489  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVARO MAYO GRANADOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0489
2 CA-CR 2012-0491-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP MUSGROVE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0491-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0495  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON BRICE ARNOLDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0495
2 CA-CR 2012-0497  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ASHLEY ELIZABETH LAPPITT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0497
2 CA-CR 2012-0507  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADIYIA SUNDIATA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0507
2 CA-CR 2012-0509-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FELIPE BARRERA PACHECO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0509-PR
2 CA-CR 2012-0515  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK LYLE BARRICKLOW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0515
2 CA-CR 2013-0011-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL BALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0011-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0012  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AARON BRICE ARNOLDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0012
2 CA-CR 2013-0019  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA ROSE BEJARANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0019
2 CA-CR 2013-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL PETER CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0021
2 CA-CR 2013-0033-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD ROBERT ROMAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0033-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0037-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND DOUGLAS ORION CARLTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0037-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD FINCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0039
2 CA-CR 2013-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SARA GOLDEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0040
2 CA-CR 2013-0049-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JUAN OCHOA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0049-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0051-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELINDA GABRIELLA VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0051-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0055-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN SCOTT CHESLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0055-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0057-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL GERARD SCHOTTENBAUER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0057-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0059  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ALLAN NAIL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0059
2 CA-CR 2013-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON EDWARD ERICKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0069-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRANDON JAMES DROUILLARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0069-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0073-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT C. GAMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0073-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0077-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM ALCANTAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0077-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0085-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEROME E. ARNOLDI, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0085-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0087-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER PAUL PETERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0087-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LORRAINE ANNA MARIE CHRISTINA STEDMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0091-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBIE BLAISE STILES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0091-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0093-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRAIG MATTHEW GILBERT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0093-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0099  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL GONZALES MALDONADO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0099
2 CA-CR 2013-0101-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OMAR MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0101-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0103-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARIUS AGBOGHIDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0103-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0105-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE TIBUCIO VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0105-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0111-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HOWARD FRANCES UNDERWOOD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0111-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0113-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNATHON ALLEN STERKESON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0113-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS E. CORRALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0121-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FREDDIE LEE FORD JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0121-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0127-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL ALFARO MERCADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0127-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0131-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFERY S. DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0131-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0135-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THADDEUS IKOSY'S CRAWFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0135-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE CHAMBERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0139
2 CA-CR 2013-0141-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR EDUARDO VISAIZ-RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0141-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0143-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ROBERT TOMLINSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0143-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0145  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO AVILA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0145
2 CA-CR 2013-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY LYNN WATSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0149
2 CA-CR 2013-0159-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN JESUS LEBARIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0159-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0163-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE WASHINGTON MILLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0163-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0175-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0175-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0177-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIRIAM MENDIOLA MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0177-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NICHOLAS BLACKWATER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0181-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN MANUEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0181-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0189  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KATHARINE McMURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0189
2 CA-CR 2013-0191  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIRAM MERAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0191
2 CA-CR 2013-0215-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DONNELL DUNLAP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0215-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEAN FRANKLYN SOARES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0221-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT L. CONRAD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0221-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0225-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIPOLITO CHAVEZ MORENO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0225-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0227-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS MAX BOLDT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0227-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0229-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMIE LEE FORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0229-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0231-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMITRI SHEPHERD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0231-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0235-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOELLE SUZANNE WIDDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0235-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0237  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CALVIN LAMONT SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0237
2 CA-CR 2013-0241  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL RUBEN PENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0241
2 CA-CR 2013-0245-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS BEVERETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0245-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0247-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN KYLE SHEETS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0247-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0249  STATE OF ARIZONA v. COLIN GEORGE GALIPO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0249
2 CA-CR 2013-0256-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY SAMUEL HALULA JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0256-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0259-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL CHRIS BOLTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0259-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARY ANN HAAG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SCOTT KENNETH CAMERON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0265
2 CA-CR 2013-0267  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTOINNE MAHDI JOLLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0267
2 CA-CR 2013-0271-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAN MONTALVO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0271-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0273-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENITO GIL-MENDOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0273-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0275-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM KENNETH QUALLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0275-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0277-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PERSSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0277-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0283-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE MICHAEL RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0283-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0287  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM HAYES, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0287
2 CA-CR 2013-0289  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0289
2 CA-CR 2013-0291  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD HAROLD STEWART, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0291
2 CA-CR 2013-0293  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CORNELIO BARVA GONZALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0293
2 CA-CR 2013-0297  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE NATALIO JASSO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0297
2 CA-CR 2013-0299  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW ABRAHAM SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0299
2 CA-CR 2013-0303-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARIO FRANCISCO MONTES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0303-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0307-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK NORIKI KASIC  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0307-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0309-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY J. KARPIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0309-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0311-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT E. RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0311-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0313  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMARI EUGENE CARTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0313
2 CA-CR 2013-0317  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODNEY GLEN LAW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0317
2 CA-CR 2013-0319  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PATRICK GUNNAR WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0319
2 CA-CR 2013-0325-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY MICHAEL GUSTIE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0325-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0327-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY HULL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0327-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0333-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT EDWARD TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0333-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0343  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABEL HINOJOSA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0343
2 CA-CR 2013-0347-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PHILLIP JOHN CORTEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0347-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0349-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERALD CHARLES SOUCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0349-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0351-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHARON ANN MCCOWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0351-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0353-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DELLA LISA VERMUELE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0353-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0357-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NIKISHA ALANA CALLISTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0357-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DWIGHT JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0361-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PETER SAMANIEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0361-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0365  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARMANDO LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0365
2 CA-CR 2013-0379-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES LOYD WHITE, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0379-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0381-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA MCMURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0381-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0387-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0387-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0393-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFONSO LOPEZ-MILLAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0393-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0395  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE L. MEDINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0395
2 CA-CR 2013-0397-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH THOMAS JESSUP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0397-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0399  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REY DAVID AGUIRRE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0399
2 CA-CR 2013-0407-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ADAM APALATEGUI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0407-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0415  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ADAN AGUAYO-RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0415
2 CA-CR 2013-0417-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL TYRELLANDRE MCWILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0417-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0423-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EFRIN OSUNA-CHAVEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0423-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0429-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNY ALLEN HALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0429-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0433  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REBECCA SAUCEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0433
2 CA-CR 2013-0435  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE BORJON NAVARRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0435
2 CA-CR 2013-0441-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FLORENCIO ROMAN-LIZARRAGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0441-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0443-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0443-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0445-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN NATHAN JENKINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0445-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0449-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIEN ANTHONY VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0449-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0459-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN MICHAEL GRIZZLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0459-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0461-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLTON J. LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0461-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0467-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GREG LAPOINTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0467-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0473-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBY RAY KIRKLAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0473-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0475-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM ARTHUR BORJA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0475-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0477-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIO CESAR MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0477-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0481  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL SKYE BURTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0481
2 CA-CR 2013-0487  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TOAN NGOC TRAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0487
2 CA-CR 2013-0493-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER RAMON PORTILLO-DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0493-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0497-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARIUS AGBOGHIDI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0497-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0499-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO GARZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0499-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0501-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARITY MARIE HILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0501-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0503-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN STEPHEN BRANNOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0503-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0509  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WELLINGTON CURICHIMBA MARIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0509
2 CA-CR 2013-0517-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LYLE HOISINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0517-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0519  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD EUGENE POETHIG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0519
2 CA-CR 2013-0523-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEAN MATTHEW HELLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0523-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0525-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER WALTON HOPTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0525-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0529-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR HUGO HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0529-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0535-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERONICA TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0535-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0537-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS RAMON AGUIAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0537-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0541-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX CRAIG JOHNSTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0541-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0543-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0543-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0549-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY OWENS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0549-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0557-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH DUANE MYERS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0557-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0559-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO LOPEZ-ZAMARRIPA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0559-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0565-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE FERNANDO MCCORMICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0565-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0003-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0003-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0009-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL BARTON SAMPLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0009-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0021  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NUBIAN TYE HIMBA AMON-RA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0021
2 CA-CR 2014-0025-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDEE ROBERT VENSOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0025-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0035-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHERITY ANN COX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0035-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0045-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE JAIME SILVA-ACOSTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0045-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0047-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WONTREL LAWAN SELLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0047-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0055  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL CABALLERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0055
2 CA-CR 2014-0057-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CODY LAWRENCE SCOTT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0057-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0071-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0071-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0075-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELANIE ANNE MOYES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0075-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0079-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAN MILTON ALFONSO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0079-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0089-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEWEY LEE MCBRIDE   Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0089-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ERIC STOKES, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0093-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANGELO AMADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0093-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0095-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM DUTCHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0095-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0101-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TODD EMERY SMITH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0101-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0115-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. QUINN WYATT BISHOP  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0115-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0117-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD CONNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0117-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0123-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANT REY DECKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0123-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0124-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v.DAVID HILTON BRAMLETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0124-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0125-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM WESTLEY DUNCAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0125-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0127-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY BERNARD WALFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0127-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0129-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY DEAN DeYOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0129-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0141  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANNY ROMERO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0141
2 CA-CR 2014-0149  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH PATRICK LOGAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0149
2 CA-CR 2014-0155-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD WAYNE HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0155-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0171-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JONATHAN DAVID SWIHART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0171-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0177-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAY SEGALA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0177-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0179-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL RENE LOPEZ-VIDAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0179-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0205-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO MORAGA-PLATT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0205-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0219-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR VALENZUELA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0219-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY CONNUE SERRANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0233
2 CA-CR 2014-0239-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL EDWARD FINCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0239-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0243-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALVADORE SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0243-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0261-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLY BURTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0261-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0281-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMON PAUL MACK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0281-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0283-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL CONTRERAS-GALDEAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0283-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0299-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS AVELINO CAMACHO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0299-PR
2 CA-CR 2014-0301-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER JEREMIA BROWN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0301-PR
2 CA-CV 2005-0134  BEHRENS v. CITY OF CASA GRANDE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0134
2 CA-CV 2006-0039  PENNY OSUNA v. WALMART STORES, INC.; SAM'S CLUB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0039
Issues Summary: In an action for breach of employment agreement, where the plaintiff appeals from the trial court grant of defendants’ motion to dismiss claims pled in the original complaint and the denial of her motion to amend her second amended complaint, does this court have jurisdiction over the appeal when the appellant has dismissed without prejudice the only claim pled in her second amended complaint?


2 CA-CV 2006-0041  YOST v. YOST  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0041
2 CA-CV 2006-0063  GEHRKE and FINK v. DILLON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0063
2 CA-CV 2006-0069  KIM v.MANSOORI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0069
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion when it granted summary judgment on a claim for attorney fees prior to judgment on the merits and certified the judgment as final pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., 16 A.R.S., Pt. 2?


2 CA-CV 2006-0108  TUCSON GASTROENTEROLOGY v. SIDI, M.D.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0108
2 CA-CV 2006-0136  MACHADO v. MACHADO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0136
2 CA-CV 2006-0141  O'KEEFE v. FINNELL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0141
2 CA-CV 2006-0149  AIRFREIGHT EXPRESS, LTD. v. EVERGREEN AIR CENTER, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0149
Issues Summary: 1. Where the plaintiff’s claims in a previous action had been dismissed without prejudice, did the trial court err in applying the doctrine of claim preclusion to dismiss those same claims in a subsequent action? 2. Does the doctrine of claim preclusion bar claims based on facts pled as affirmative defenses in a prior action? 3. Did the trial court err in granting the defendant’s motion for summary judgment grounded on a limitation of damages clause in a contract when the plaintiff alleges that clause is unenforceable because the defendant acted in bad faith?


2 CA-CV 2006-0156  MACHADO v. WHITFIELD and GAMEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0156
2 CA-CV 2006-0157  HIGGINSON v. CHERNETZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0157
2 CA-CV 2006-0159  LA CANADA HILLS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v. FLORENCE KITE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0159
Issues Summary: In an action where a partnership seeks to enforce its rights under the partnership agreement after one limited partner’s breach of the agreement, which statute of limitations applies, the one governing partnership accounting actions that allows four years from the time the partners wind up their affairs together for a plaintiff to bring an action, or the statute governing breach of contract actions that gives a plaintiff six years from the time of the breach


2 CA-CV 2006-0165  G. PUCHI WHOLESALE FOODS CORPORATION and PUCHI v. BOREN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0165
2 CA-CV 2006-0167  BEISE v. CAPPSCO INTERNATIONAL and PRO-TECH AVIATION, LTD.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0167
2 CA-CV 2006-0169  McGEE v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0169
2 CA-CV 2006-0174  COLEMAN v. SLOAN; ALLIANCE IMAGING, INC.; and SIERRA VISTA MEDICAL CENTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0174
2 CA-CV 2006-0181  DYKES v. GRANDE PROPERTIES and THERMO-TEMP ROOFING  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0181
2 CA-CV 2006-0183  KELLEY ROLLINGS v. THE CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0183
2 CA-CV 2006-0184  IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF WILLIAM D. EVANS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0184
2 CA-CV 2006-0191  POTTER v. WHEELAND, D.O.; DR. CHANG  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0191
2 CA-CV 2006-0193  HARRIS, WILSON, ANGEL TEAM HOME CARE v. COCHISE HEALTH SYSTEMS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0193
Issues Summary: 1. Is a party who has voluntarily dismissed its amended complaint with prejudice an aggrieved party for purposes of establishing appellate court jurisdiction? 2. Can a party raise arguments on appeal that were not raised before the trial court if application of a legal principle would dispose of an action on appeal and correctly explain the law but the issue has not been briefed or argued below? 3. Does a party meet the requirements of A.R.S. § 12-821.01 for individualized notice of a claim when it does nothing more than list the party’s name as the statutory agent for a public entity also named as a defendant?


2 CA-CV 2006-0204  JON SUTTON v. BEATRICE FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0204
2 CA-CV 2006-0207  WHITE v. GREATER ARIZONA BICYCLING ASSOCIATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0207
Issues Summary: Does the holding by Division One of this court in Sedillo v. City of Flagstaff, 153 Ariz. 478, 480, 737 P.2d 1377, 1379 (App. 1987), require reversal of a properly instructed jury’s award of no damages in a wrongful death action when the plaintiff’s evidence of emotional loss is uncontested?


2 CA-CV 2006-0219  LEVERAGED LAND CO., LLC v. CP MANAGEMENT; VEM CORPORATION;   Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0219
2 CA-CV 2006-0221  STREY; BEGURSKI v. MONTOYA; MONTOYA and MARQUEZ PLLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0221
2 CA-CV 2006-0229  JENKINS v. SEDILLO, ULIBERRY, ARIZ. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS   Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0229
2 CA-CV 2007-0009  BERETTA v. TUCSON TRAP & SKEET CLUB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0009
2 CA-CV 2007-0015  LA CHOLLA HILLS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION v. JAMES EDWIN FOARD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0015
2 CA-CV 2007-0017  SMITH v. HUBER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0017
2 CA-CV 2007-0018  JAMES L. CRISSEY v. ELITE PERFORMANCE, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0018
2 CA-CV 2007-0021  SCOTT KASSA v. KAZUMI KASSA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0021
2 CA-CV 2007-0023  GARY BLUEMKE v. UNIV. OF ARIZONA POLICE PENSION BOARD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0023
2 CA-CV 2007-0033  MEYZLER v. GOROZTHANKINA   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0033
2 CA-CV 2007-0038  ROBERT ALLEN HOKE v. KAROLYN J. MCCONNELL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0038
2 CA-CV 2007-0039  KEN SOZA v. EL JARDIN FLORISTS, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0039
2 CA-CV 2007-0043  DENISE PECK v. DAVID WATERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0043
2 CA-CV 2007-0047  MARIA A. KEONJIAN v. TIMOTHY A. OLCOTT, P.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0047
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in holding appellant’s legal malpractice claim barred by the two-year statute of limitations for tort actions and ruling the longer limitations period for contract actions did not apply.


2 CA-CV 2007-0055  STEVEN H. SIMON v. SAFEWAY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0055
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying plaintiff’s request to allow additional discovery—functionally a motion under Rule 56(f), Ariz. R. Civ. P.—after finding plaintiff had failed to demonstrate the discovery sought was reasonably likely to yield material evidence?

2) Does a business owner’s nondelegable duty to maintain safe premises encompass the actions of an independent contractor it hires to perform security services on its premises, thus exposing the business owner to vicarious liability?


2 CA-CV 2007-0057  GOODMAN v. CITY OF TUCSON   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0057
2 CA-CV 2007-0099  JUNIES JENKINS v. BARBARA ULIBARRI   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0099
2 CA-CV 2007-0107  MICHAEL REDHAIR v. KINERK, BEAL, SCHMIDT, DYER & SETHI, P.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0107
Issues Summary: 1. Does the one-year statute of limitations governing actions for breach of an employment contract apply to only those contracts defined by the Arizona Employment Protection Act? 2. Does the one-year statute of limitations of either A.R.S. § 12-541(3) or § 12-541(5) apply to a statutory action for unpaid wages, in which a trial court may award treble damages?


2 CA-CV 2007-0109  MARIA HENNING v. MONTECINI HOSPITALITY, ET AL.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0109
Issues Summary: Does the seller of a bar have a continuing duty of care in dispensing alcohol at that bar when the sale has not closed but the seller has contractually relinquished the right to control, operate, and profit from the bar to the buyer and when the bar is serving alcohol pursuant to the new operator’s liquor license?

Can a seller of a bar be held liable for the negligent training of bar employees when the employees’ allegedly negligent conduct occurs after the seller no longer employs them, when they are employed by the purchaser and new operator of the bar?


2 CA-CV 2007-0113  CATHERINE ANN RODRIGUEZ v. RICHARD RAYMOND RODRIGUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0113
2 CA-CV 2007-0117  DENNIS BRODSKY v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0117
Issues Summary: Does the administrative impoundment of a vehicle pursuant to A.R.S. § 28-3511 constitute punishment for double jeopardy purposes, thus barring prosecution of the underlying DUI offense?


2 CA-CV 2007-0123  DESERT HERITAGE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0123
2 CA-CV 2007-0126  MAYER UNIFIED SCHOOL and GADSEN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL v. WINKLEMAN, AZ STATE LAND DEPT...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0126
Issues Summary: Where plaintiffs argued that highway easements granted without compensation over state trust lands prior to the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Lassen v. Arizona ex rel. Ariz. Highway Dep’t, 385 U.S. 463 (1967), failed to comply with § 28 of the Enabling Act and were therefore void, did the trial court abuse its discretion in finding the claims barred by laches?


2 CA-CV 2007-0129  EVA ANGELINA ENCINAS TREJO v. LAMBERTO ARMENTA TREJO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0129
2 CA-CV 2007-0131  LORENZO SANCHEZ, SR. ET AL v. OLD PUEBLO ANESTHESIA, PC, ET AL.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0131
Issues Summary: When a plaintiff invokes the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur in a medical malpractice action alleging negligence by either a surgeon or anesthesiologist or both, must the plaintiff comply with A.R.S. §§ 12-2603 and 12-2604 by obtaining a preliminary expert opinion affidavit on the relevant standards of care from both an anesthesiologist and a surgeon, or does the res ipsa doctrine create an exception to the requirements of those statutes?


2 CA-CV 2007-0139  HORNBECK v. LUSK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0139
Issues Summary: When a litigant in justice court seeks a peremptory change of judge pursuant to Rule 10.2, Ariz. R. Crim. P., is “the presiding judge” to whom the case must be transferred for reassignment under Rule 10.5, Ariz. R. Crim. P., the justice of the peace of that particular precinct or the presiding justice of the peace for the county in which the precinct is located?


2 CA-CV 2007-0145  NEALE E. SMITH v. DPS OFFICER JOHNSTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0145
2 CA-CV 2007-0149  PINAL COUNTY v. AIRE H. DeJONG and MILKY WAY DAIRY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0149
2 CA-CV 2007-0163  ALTAFFER v. GRAVES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0163
2 CA-CV 2007-0170  LORENZO SANCHEZ, SR. and BERTHA SANCHEZ v. TUCSON ORTHOPAEDIC INSTITUTE; LEVI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0170
Issues Summary: Was summary judgment properly granted in favor of the defendants in a res ipsa loquitur case when the plaintiff failed to establish that the defendant surgeon had exclusive control over the injury-causing instrumentality?


2 CA-CV 2008-0013  ROBERT L. BOUCONI v. RANDALL NEIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0013
2 CA-CV 2008-0018  CHAVEZ v. AVALON CARE CENTER TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0018
2 CA-CV 2008-0023  SWAIN CHAPMAN v. THE WESTERNER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0023
Issues Summary: In an action involving the purchase of one partner’s interest in a limited partnership, where the parties agreed to base the purchase on an appraisal of the partnership’s primary asset, did the trial court err when it concluded, as a matter of law, that the appraiser’s first opinion of value is entitled to the same finality given final arbitration awards?


2 CA-CV 2008-0031  MAUSETH and HOFFMAN; ROSE; TROY v. TUBAC CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0031
2 CA-CV 2008-0035  KENNETH R. BERKEBILE v. NICOLE E. BOESCH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0035
2 CA-CV 2008-0039  RALPH A. PENA, JR. v. ADOC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0039
2 CA-CV 2008-0051  ELECTRICAL DISTRICT NO. 3 OF PINAL COUNTY v. 3-F CONTRACTING INCORPORATED  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0051
2 CA-CV 2008-0067  DANIEL WILLIAM PARTIN v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0067
2 CA-CV 2008-0069  ANANT K. TRIPATI v. YARBROUGH, VILLACANA, BALDENEGRO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0069
2 CA-CV 2008-0074  JAMES J. McMANUS v. TUCSON MEDICAL CENTER FOUNDATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0074
2 CA-CV 2008-0082  BEYNON; BEYNON v. TREZZA dba TREZZA & BRADLEY; THRUSH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0082
Issues Summary: In this attorney malpractice case, did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant/lawyer on the ground that, although the lawyer failed to timely file an action on plaintiffs’ behalf against the state within the one year limitations period prescribed in A.R.S. § 12 821, plaintiffs could not have prevailed on their underlying claim against the state because they failed to strictly comply with the notice of claim statute, A.R.S. § 12 821.01(A), thereby barring any cause of action against the state?


2 CA-CV 2008-0090  RICHARD C. BEALS v. ROBERT L. MOORE, dba KACHINA INSULATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0090
2 CA-CV 2008-0100  LEANNA J. TAYLOR v. BILL BARNETT LIMITED LIABILITY LTD. PARTNERSHIP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0100
2 CA-CV 2008-0104  EDNA N. RUCK v. RALPH CLAY and MARTHA CLAY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0104
2 CA-CV 2008-0106  BECERRA v. TUCSON POLICE DEPT.; CITY OF TUCSON; HAWKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0106
2 CA-CV 2008-0109  JEANETTE ELLEN WILLIAMS v. CLARENCE KELVIN WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0109
Issues Summary: 1) When an award of costs, expenses, and attorney fees is requested pursuant to A.R.S. § 25-324(A), may a court consider the subjective intent of a party when determining the “reasonableness” of the positions the party has taken?

2) May a court disregard the financial resources of a party who seeks an award of costs, expenses, and attorney fees under A.R.S. § 25-324(A) and consider only the financial resources of the party who would be paying the fee award?


2 CA-CV 2008-0116  PANTELE v. ELLIOTT; JARNAGIN; RAY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0116
2 CA-CV 2008-0126  JIMMIE D. HOLLAND v. MICHAEL ANTHONY HURLEY, JANE DOE HURLEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0126
2 CA-CV 2008-0144  SANDRA SPENCER v. JOHN ULREICH, JUDITH ULREICH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0144
2 CA-CV 2008-0146  COUNTY OF COCHISE v. SEBASTIAO FARIA and MARIA FARI dba FARIA DAIRY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0146
Issues Summary: Whether commercial feedlots and “other like businesses” under A.R.S. § 11-821.01(A) are exempt from regulation as uses for agricultural purposes under A.R.S. 11-830(A)(2).


2 CA-CV 2008-0160  MARTIN-MACDONALD v. MACDONALD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0160
2 CA-CV 2008-0163  HOWELL v. PALMER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0163
2 CA-CV 2008-0168  PRATT v. PRITZL; ARIZONA BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0168
2 CA-CV 2008-0188  EICHER v. DIODATI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0188
2 CA-CV 2008-0190  HAROUTUNIAN v. VALUEOPTIONS, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0190
2 CA-CV 2009-0001  HOLT, nka TRUED v. HOLT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0001
2 CA-CV 2009-0002  GOODMAN v. PIMA COUNTY; TDB TUCSON GROUP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0002
2 CA-CV 2009-0020  VILLA; DOMKA; REED v. CITY OF MARICOPA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0020
2 CA-CV 2009-0022  RICHARD E. LAMBERT, LTD. v. CITY OF TUCSON DEPT. OF PROCUREMENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0022
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in overturning, as arbitrary and capricious, the City Director of Procurement’s decision that the City was entitled to assess liquidated damages against a contractor for late performance, and, as a result, in granting partial summary judgment in favor of the contractor?


2 CA-CV 2009-0038  HARRIS v. CITY OF BISBEE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0038
2 CA-CV 2009-0045  BETH FORD v. DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF PIMA COUNTY...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0045
2 CA-CV 2009-0046  BENNETT; JAMES L. BENNETT MONEY PURCHASE PENSION PLAN; MEYERSTEIN v. BAXTER GROUP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0046
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in denying a slander of title claim brought under A.R.S. § 33-420 when the validity of the recorded document was not at issue?

2) Did the trial court err when it awarded attorney fees under A.R.S. § 12-341.01(A) for tort claims that were based on the same set of facts as the underlying breach of contract claims?


2 CA-CV 2009-0054  DEMEURE, M.D. v. STATE OF ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS   Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0054
2 CA-CV 2009-0060  DIMMIG v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0060
2 CA-CV 2009-0063  MARANA POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION v. TOWN OF MARANA...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0063
2 CA-CV 2009-0064  JONES v. LUCE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0064
2 CA-CV 2009-0066  SIZER v. SIZER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0066
2 CA-CV 2009-0070  BAKER v. DAVENPORT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0070
2 CA-CV 2009-0072  KRASINSKI , JR. v. GOLDSTEIN; GOLDSTEIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0072
2 CA-CV 2009-0080  ANDREWS v. CORONA ELECTRIC, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0080
2 CA-CV 2009-0088  GALLEGO, BADILLA, TREJO... v. WHITE, QUILLIAM K.Q. RANCH TRUST...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0088
2 CA-CV 2009-0092  BOUCONI v. NEIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0092
2 CA-CV 2009-0098  SHARKOZY v. WALKER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0098
2 CA-CV 2009-0100  In re REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4720 N. NESTING LANE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0100
2 CA-CV 2009-0108  In re the Marriage of: GINA NOEL AVILA and ALBERT AVILA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0108
2 CA-CV 2009-0110  FOUNTAIN v. FOUNTAIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0110
2 CA-CV 2009-0114  BALLESTEROS v. UNITED AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0114
2 CA-CV 2009-0116  BRYSTAL McCLOUD v. THOMAS MAX KIMBRO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0116
Issues Summary: Whether an employee on out-of-town travel status is within the course and scope of his employment and subjects his employer to vicarious liability while traveling to and from a restaurant for a regular meal.


2 CA-CV 2009-0118  ROMERO v. ROMERO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0118
2 CA-CV 2009-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA, DEPT. OF ECONOMIC SECURITY v. MUNOZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0124
Issues Summary: Whether a child-support enforcement action is barred by former A.R.S. § 25-503(H), when neither the state nor the parent obtained a written judgment within three years of emancipation as required by that statute, but when the three-year limitation period had not yet elapsed when the statute was amended in 2006.


2 CA-CV 2009-0130  MEDEIROS v. HOWARD, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0130
2 CA-CV 2009-0132  SMITH v. BENSON HOSPITAL; MAYBERRY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0132
2 CA-CV 2009-0134  ACTION FINANCIAL IV, LLC v. GROCH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0134
2 CA-CV 2009-0136  BLAISDELL v. CORRECTIONS CORP. OF AMERICA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0136
2 CA-CV 2009-0138  BLAIR v. CIRCLE K STORES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0138
2 CA-CV 2009-0142  REBUILD AMERICA v. THE GOLDEN RAVEN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0142
2 CA-CV 2009-0144  MAERTENS v. CITY OF APACHE JUNCTION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0144
2 CA-CV 2009-0146  BRASLAWSCE v. CRAIG RANCH GOLF COURSE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0146
2 CA-CV 2009-0148  JOHNSON v. PINAL COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0148
2 CA-CV 2009-0154  ZAZUETA v. VAN BEVERHOUDT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0154
2 CA-CV 2009-0156  SIDDLE nka CLASS v. SIDDLE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0156
2 CA-CV 2009-0177  DAMM v. BISCHOFF; DUFFIELD; DUFFIELD YOUNG ADAMSON, P.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0177
2 CA-CV 2009-0184  WEAVER v. ASHFORD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0184
2 CA-CV 2010-0006  In re BOND FORFEITURE IN PINAL CO. CAUSE NO. CR-200800344   Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0006
2 CA-CV 2010-0010  SWETE v. SWETE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0010
2 CA-CV 2010-0018  DENNISON v. AZ. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, CREDIO, WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0018
2 CA-CV 2010-0023  METZLER v. BCI COCA-COLA BOTTLING CO.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0023
2 CA-CV 2010-0024  MARTINEZ v. TUCSON MEDICAL CENTER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0024
2 CA-CV 2010-0026  REA CONSTRUCTION, INC. v. J.W. FUNERAL SERVICES, L.L.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0026
2 CA-CV 2010-0030  SHARKOZY v. ALLISON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0030
2 CA-CV 2010-0037  DELUCA v. DELUCA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0037
2 CA-CV 2010-0040  ROMERO v. TORRES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0040
2 CA-CV 2010-0042  BUTTERFIELD PLAZA BENSON, L.L.C. v. JOHNSON; 4-R ENTERPRISES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0042
2 CA-CV 2010-0044  HAMILL v. MID-CENTURY INSURANCE COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0044
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by granting summary judgment, concluding that a driver is not underinsured when the company providing her automobile liability insurance agrees, prior to judgment, to pay the total judgment or later settlement even if it exceeds the policy limit?


2 CA-CV 2010-0046  MEZA v. AZ. DEPT. OF ECON. SECURITY; WINSTON, LOGAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0046
2 CA-CV 2010-0052  PHELPS v. GILBRAITH; WYSTRACH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0052
2 CA-CV 2010-0053  LA PALOMA v. CATALINA FOOTHILLS UNIF. SCH. DIST. #16  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0053
2 CA-CV 2010-0059  POLACEK v. UNITED FOOD GROUP, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0059
2 CA-CV 2010-0078  KLAIMAN v. SANTA CRUZ COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0078
2 CA-CV 2010-0082  MIDVALE PARK MASTER REVIEW BOARD HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION v. CACTUS COMMUNITY CHURCH OF THE NAZARENE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0082
2 CA-CV 2010-0083  CITY OF TUCSON v. STATE OF ARIZONA; SOUTHERN ARIZONA LEADERSHIP COUNCIL; SENATOR JONATHAN PATON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0083
Issues Summary: Did the trial court correctly find that the 2009 amendments to A.R.S. § 9-821.01, regulating municipal elections, involved statewide concerns, or, rather, does the City of Tucson’s charter supersede the statute because the concerns involved are purely local?


2 CA-CV 2010-0088  CALIK, KAYA, AYDIN v. McDONNELL DOUGLAS CORP., McDONNELL DOUGLAS HELICOPTER CO.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0088
2 CA-CV 2010-0095  SMITH v. CITY OF TUCSON, RANKIN and NAVARRO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0095
2 CA-CV 2010-0096  TOWNSEND, BARNES and MARBLE v. WOODIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0096
2 CA-CV 2010-0098  ANDERSON v. ARIZONA GAME AND FISH DEPARTMENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0098
Issues Summary: Did the Game and Fish Commission lack statutory authority under A.R.S. § 17-340 to deny appellant the right to secure hunting and fishing licenses for a period of ten years that was consecutive to a previously imposed, five-year suspension of that right for an earlier violation of game and fish laws, and to revoke his previously revoked licenses for the same period?


2 CA-CV 2010-0104  VONMENKE v. MENKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0104
2 CA-CV 2010-0108  MAUSETH, HOFFMAN, COME TO TUBAC, LLC. v. VANDERVOET, CULLEN, PHENEGER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0108
2 CA-CV 2010-0112  CHAVEZ v. ARIZONA SCHOOL RISK RETENTION TRUST, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0112
Issues Summary: Are students waiting in line to board a school bus using the vehicle with permission, as defined in A.R.S. § 28-4009(A)(2), thereby requiring a policy’s underinsured motorist insurance provision to cover them pursuant to A.R.S. § 20-259.01(B)?


2 CA-CV 2010-0114  COATES, WIERCINSKI v. SCHEID   Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0114
2 CA-CV 2010-0117  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP, PARAGON HOTEL CORP. v. CASA GRANDE RESORT LIVING, PINSONNEAULT, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0117
2 CA-CV 2010-0118  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP, PARAGON HOTEL CORP. v. JOE PINSONNEAULT, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0118
2 CA-CV 2010-0125  UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD v. D.R. HORTON, INC. - DIETZ-CRANE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0125
2 CA-CV 2010-0126  HERRERA v. ESPINOZA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0126
2 CA-CV 2010-0133  CUTLER v. CUTLER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0133
2 CA-CV 2010-0142  PURSELL v. PURSELL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0142
2 CA-CV 2010-0143  SWEENEY v. ASH; HOUGH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0143
2 CA-CV 2010-0144  AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE GROUP v. BERGESON; WEST FRONTIER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0144
2 CA-CV 2010-0146  In re the ESTATE OF A.C. MILLER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0146
2 CA-CV 2010-0150  RINCON v. RUMSEY, CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0150
2 CA-CV 2010-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA, THE DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY (BASS) v. BASS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0164
2 CA-CV 2010-0167  COLVIN v. GRAHAM COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0167
2 CA-CV 2010-0168  APAGON INDUSTRIES, INC. v. MARTIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0168
2 CA-CV 2010-0176  ORACLE HIGHLANDS, LLC v. FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE AGENCY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0176
2 CA-CV 2010-0180  BRUBAKER v. THE CITY OF TUCSON; STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0180
2 CA-CV 2010-0184  QUINN v. SHERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0184
2 CA-CV 2010-0190  WISE v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0190
2 CA-CV 2010-0199  SHTYRKOVA v. GORBUNOV  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0199
2 CA-CV 2010-0202  GREGORY v. BANGS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0202
2 CA-CV 2010-0207  DAUENHAUER v. FEATHERMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0207
2 CA-CV 2010-0211  KONDAUR CAPITAL CORPORATION v. McKINNEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0211
2 CA-CV 2010-0212  FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORP. v. TIETJEN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0212
2 CA-CV 2010-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA; ARIZONA STATE LAND DEPT. v. ROBINSON CATTLE, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2010-0222
2 CA-CV 2011-0001  JACKSON v. NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0001
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 20-259.01 required an insurer to offer uninsured motorist coverage to a garage owner in connection with a comprehensive general liability policy that included a garage liability endorsement.


2 CA-CV 2011-0005  IN RE BALLOT PROPOSITION 404 v. CITY OF SIERRA VISTA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0005
2 CA-CV 2011-0015  JONES v. FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE CO.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0015
2 CA-CV 2011-0016  SPEARS v. SPEARS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0016
2 CA-CV 2011-0025  TDB TUCSON GROUP, L.L.C. v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0025
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment to the City of Tucson on TDB’s claim that the City was obligated to provide water service to TDB’s Painted Hills subdivision, located outside the City’s corporate boundaries, on the basis of the court’s finding, under A.R.S. § 45-402(31)(a) and case law, that the property was not located within the City’s service area.


2 CA-CV 2011-0039  BROWN v. FRANK, LISA FRANK, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0039
2 CA-CV 2011-0043  EDWARDS v. FUENTES, PETERSON; FUENTES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0043
2 CA-CV 2011-0055  KITCHENS, CROW v. SIPE, SIPE FAMILY TRUST  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0055
2 CA-CV 2011-0059  RS SONGBIRD, LLC v. FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE AGENCY, SONGBIRD 5 LENDER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0059
2 CA-CV 2011-0061  CCSAM FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, MOUSSA v. KING, SILER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0061
2 CA-CV 2011-0071  PRIESSMAN v. PRIESSMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0071
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 25-530, which prohibits courts from considering federal disability benefits awarded pursuant to title 38, chapter 11 of the United States Code when determining the amount of any spousal maintenance award, is applicable to appellant’s Combat-Related Special Compensation authorized in title 10.


2 CA-CV 2011-0073  McDOWELL v. LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0073
2 CA-CV 2011-0087  In re the Marriage of: CHADA and HANUMANDLA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0087
2 CA-CV 2011-0095  STARR v. STARR  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0095
2 CA-CV 2011-0099  In re the ESTATE OF PETRA C. NUNEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0099
2 CA-CV 2011-0101  PINCZEWSKI-FISHER v. CONNELLY; MASON; APACHE JUNCTION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0101
2 CA-CV 2011-0110  REA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. v. J.W. FUNERAL SERVICES, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0110
2 CA-CV 2011-0113  CHRISTENSEN v. CHEVY CHASE BANK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0113
2 CA-CV 2011-0149  BARD v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0149
2 CA-CV 2011-0155  In re ONE 1999 CHEVROLET SUBURBAN...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0155
2 CA-CV 2011-0161  BAILEY v. HERMANSON; RAUCH, HERMANSON & EVERROAD, LTD.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0161
2 CA-CV 2011-0169  In re 2003 JEEP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0169
2 CA-CV 2011-0195  FRICKE v. BRISTOL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0195
2 CA-CV 2012-0007  IN RE THE BOND FORFEITURE OF $25,000  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0007
2 CA-CV 2012-0009  MILAN v. DION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0009
2 CA-CV 2012-0029  BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. v. RUBIN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0029
2 CA-CV 2012-0041  MORGAN v. ADAMS, CITY OF SIERRA VISTA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0041
2 CA-CV 2012-0044  HOPKINS v. STATE OF ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS, RAMIREZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0044
2 CA-CV 2012-0057  IN THE MATTER OF THE WILLIAM & LEOLA F. GOAR TRUST U/A/D FEBRUARY 7, 1991  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0057
2 CA-CV 2012-0078  DENT, DENT v. DENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0078
2 CA-CV 2012-0097  OCHOA-FUENTES v. BLANCHETTE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0097
2 CA-CV 2012-0121  In re the Marriage of: Jani and Jani  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0121
2 CA-CV 2012-0132  DAVIS v. DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0132
2 CA-CV 2012-0133  BARBER v. STUART  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0133
2 CA-CV 2012-0143  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SALERNO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0143
2 CA-CV 2012-0147  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF NOEL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0147
2 CA-CV 2012-0169  JUNE BURTON v. LAWLEY AUTO SALES, L.L.C.; LAWLEY MOTORS...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0169
2 CA-CV 2013-0003  McMANUS v. PARRA, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0003
2 CA-CV 2013-0017  LOCKERBY v. CITY OF TUCSON, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0017
2 CA-CV 2013-0025  FITZWILLIAMS v. TACK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0025
2 CA-CV 2013-0031  CAMPBELL v. FLORENCE GARDENS MOBILE HOME ASSOCIATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0031
2 CA-CV 2013-0079  TAYLOR-BERTLING v. FOLEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0079
2 CA-CV 2013-0081  ORTIZ v. ESPINOZA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0081
2 CA-CV 2013-0091  SAKS v. SANTA CRUZ VALLEY UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT #840  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0091
2 CA-CV 2013-0095  MARTINEZ v. CORRECTIONS CORPORATION OF AMERICA, et al.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0095
2 CA-CV 2013-0101  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF FLORES AND MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0101
2 CA-CV 2013-0103  AH4R-AZ11, LLC v. ALTENES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0103
2 CA-CV 2013-0125  IN RE THE ESTATE OF ROBERT JUNIOR DEMAREE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0125
2 CA-CV 2013-0141  F & C HOLDINGS v. SNOW  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0141
2 CA-CV 2013-0144  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF WOODSIDE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0144
2 CA-CV 2013-0147  DONALD RAY PALMER v. BANK OF AMERICA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0147
2 CA-CV 2013-0165  CRAIG R. EHRHORN v. THOMAS E. HIGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0165
2 CA-CV 2014-0003  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF ROMERO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0003
2 CA-CV 2014-0051  FLACKE v. WILLIAMS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0051
2 CA-HC 2007-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANLEY GENE ESSARY   Participating 2 CA-HC 2007-0003
2 CA-HC 2009-0002  STEPHEN BISHOP v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS  Participating 2 CA-HC 2009-0002
2 CA-HC 2012-0007  THOMAS MICHAEL PIERCE v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-HC 2012-0007
2 CA-HC 2012-0011  MATTHEW A. CLACK v. RONALD CREDIO, WARDEN  Participating 2 CA-HC 2012-0011
2 CA-HC 2013-0001  JESUS ESQUER CASTILLO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-HC 2013-0001
2 CA-IC 2006-0013  GLORIA v. BAJA PRODUCTS, EMPLOYERS INSUR. COMPANY OF WAUSAU  Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0013
2 CA-IC 2007-0001  RONALD HULL v. ABLE REFRIGERATION, INC., STATE COMP. FUND   Participating 2 CA-IC 2007-0001
2 CA-IC 2007-0005  WARNER v. ICA; MATALONE CONSTRUCTION & SFC  Participating 2 CA-IC 2007-0005
2 CA-IC 2007-0007  LANE v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-IC 2007-0007
Issues Summary: Did the administrative law judge err in finding that an off-duty police officer’s gunshot injury in the course of protecting a friend was not compensable because the friend was not actually in danger, even though the officer’s employment rules required him to take action to safeguard life even while off duty?


2 CA-IC 2008-0001  ABEYTA v. CANYON STATE COURIER, SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0001
2 CA-IC 2008-0005  PESQUEIRA v. GILBERT ELECTRIC CO.; SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0005
2 CA-IC 2008-0008  JIM CLICK AUTO MALL; HARCO NATIONAL INS CO. v. ICA; KEVIN LARSON  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0008
2 CA-IC 2009-0002  ROBERTSON (DECEASED);ROBERTSON v. CIRCLE JMR CORP.; SCF ARIZ  Participating 2 CA-IC 2009-0002
2 CA-IC 2009-0008  PIMA COUNTY and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT v. ROBERT HOOKER  Participating 2 CA-IC 2009-0008
2 CA-IC 2009-0016  DAVID RANDALL JENKINS v. AMERICAN ZURICH INS. CO. and NPL CONSTRUCTION CO.  Participating 2 CA-IC 2009-0016
2 CA-IC 2010-0006  JOHN M. PASHAIN v. PIMA CO., PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERV.   Participating 2 CA-IC 2010-0006
2 CA-IC 2011-0005  CHRISTOPHER C. VALVERDE v. TUCSON PROFESSIONAL LANDSCAPING, INC., and SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0005
2 CA-IC 2011-0021  PASSARO v. JEWISH FAMILY & CHILDREN'S SERVICES; SCF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0021
2 CA-IC 2012-0007  PIMA COUNTY and TRISTAR RISK MANAGEMENT v. ERNIE LUNA  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0007
2 CA-IC 2012-0013  JULIE CORRALES v. ESTATE OF LAURA ARONSON and STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0013
2 CA-IC 2012-0015  ALEXANDRINA OCEJO v. TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT and TRISTAR RISK MANAGEMENT  Participating 2 CA-IC 2012-0015
2 CA-JV 2006-0041  CYNTHIAANNE F. v. ADES & HESREAL F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0041
2 CA-JV 2006-0043  IN RE ESAU L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0043
2 CA-JV 2006-0045  IN RE JASEL V.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0045
2 CA-JV 2006-0047  SUZANNE S. v. ADES., BRITTANY S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0047
2 CA-JV 2006-0049  IN RE NATALIE Z.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0049
Issues Summary: Are A.R.S. § 13-502(A) and (C), which set forth the legal test for insanity and assign a clear and convincing burden of proof to the person asserting a defense of guilty except insane, applicable to a delinquency proceeding when a juvenile asserts an insanity defense?


2 CA-JV 2006-0051  ALICIA L. v. ADES, HENRY L., LEVI L., JACKIE L., DESTINY L.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0051
2 CA-JV 2006-0053  ADRIAN E. v. ADES, NAINOA E.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0053
Issues Summary: If a parent fails to appear without good cause at a status conference in a termination of parental rights proceeding conducted pursuant to chapter 10, article 4 of title 8, A.R.S., may the juvenile court proceed to terminate the parent’s rights by default?


2 CA-JV 2006-0055  MARGARET G. v. ADES, SIERRA G., CHRISTIAN G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0055
2 CA-JV 2006-0057  IN RE RODGER M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0057
2 CA-JV 2006-0067  JAMES M. v. ADES, JOSAPHINE M., CODY M., KACEE M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0067
2 CA-JV 2006-0069  EMILIO D. v. ADES, DESTINY D.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0069
2 CA-JV 2007-0004  BILLIE JO M. v. ADES, JOSAPHINE M., CODY M., KACEE M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0004
2 CA-JV 2007-0013  VERONICA B. v. ADES, TRESSA M., KAYLA D.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0013
2 CA-JV 2007-0017  LEANDRA T. v. ADES, RIGOBERTO L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0017
2 CA-JV 2007-0019  MARK G. v. ADES, MARISABEL G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0019
2 CA-JV 2007-0029  JOHN M. v. ADES, SHANNON M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0029
Issues Summary: Does ineffective assistance of counsel justify reversal of a juvenile court’s order terminating parental rights and, if so, under what circumstances?


2 CA-JV 2007-0030  CONRAD P., ANN P. v. ADES, EMMA M., MEGHAN M., SEAN M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0030
2 CA-JV 2007-0032  ASHLEIGH D. v. ADES, BRANDON H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0032
2 CA-JV 2007-0033  JAMES L. v. CARRIE K. and KAYLENA C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0033
2 CA-JV 2007-0035  MICHAELA M. v. ADES., ALEX A., KALEB M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0035
2 CA-JV 2007-0037  CYNTHIA W. v. ADES, SARAH W., DAVID W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0037
2 CA-JV 2007-0039  IN RE JAMES S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0039
2 CA-JV 2007-0043  ANGELINA M. v. ADES, ENEDINA P.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0043
2 CA-JV 2007-0047  CASEY D. v. JENNIFER P., CASEY D.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0047
2 CA-JV 2007-0051  BRUNO R. v. ADES, MARITZA R., BRUNO R.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0051
2 CA-JV 2007-0053  RUTH H. v. ADES & KRISTEN H.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0053
2 CA-JV 2007-0057  IN RE JESUS L.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0057
2 CA-JV 2007-0059  IN RE ANDREW H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0059
2 CA-JV 2007-0062  DINORA G. v. ADES, SIPRIANO G., DINORA G., JESUS G., GLORIA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0062
2 CA-JV 2007-0063  IN RE EDREI O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0063
2 CA-JV 2007-0065  DORA C. v. ADES, MIRIAM J., ARMANDO J., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0065
2 CA-JV 2007-0071  MANUEL M. v. ADES, LEILA M., ALAYENA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0071
Issues Summary: In this parental severance case wherein the father failed to personally appear at a termination hearing and the trial court proceeded to adjudicate the state’s motion to terminate his parental rights, did the juvenile court abuse its discretion when it considered only documentary evidence, admitted without testimony, and denied the request of father’s counsel to examine adverse witnesses?


2 CA-JV 2007-0081  IN RE JAIR V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0081
2 CA-JV 2007-0083  VALERIA G. v. ADES, MARIA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0083
2 CA-JV 2007-0085  IN RE EMMANUEL P.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0085
2 CA-JV 2007-0089  JODI A. v. ADES, DEAN W. & JADE W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0089
2 CA-JV 2007-0091  IN RE IGNACIO F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0091
2 CA-JV 2007-0099  TRACI C. v. ADES, KRISTIAN C. & KURT G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0099
2 CA-JV 2008-0003  CRAIG B. v. ADES, WESTON B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0003
2 CA-JV 2008-0007  MARIA A. v. ADES, MELADIE A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0007
2 CA-JV 2008-0009  BOBBY G. v. ADES & ALLISON G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0009
Issues Summary: After a permanency hearing has commenced in a juvenile dependency proceeding pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-862(A), is a party to that proceeding precluded from filing a petition to terminate parental rights pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-533?


2 CA-JV 2008-0021  RAMONA M. v. ADES, JOB O., JASMINE O., ABIGAIL O. & JAZELLE O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0021
2 CA-JV 2008-0025  LAZARO C. v. ADES & LAZARO C., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0025
2 CA-JV 2008-0027  IN RE OMAR N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0027
2 CA-JV 2008-0035  JONAS P. v. KATHRYN R. & BRANDON R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0035
2 CA-JV 2008-0039  VICTOR S. v. ADES, ALEXANDRA B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0039
2 CA-JV 2008-0045  SHANNON C. v. ADES & CAMERON G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0045
2 CA-JV 2008-0067  MICAH D. v. ADES, SAMANTHA D., KC D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0067
2 CA-JV 2008-0075  DIANA B. v. ADES, MATTHEW B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0075
2 CA-JV 2008-0083  IN RE GADN R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0083
2 CA-JV 2008-0084  IN RE RAMON N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0084
2 CA-JV 2008-0090  SHELLY L. v. ADES, NETERU A., YAZMEEN A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0090
2 CA-JV 2008-0100  RYAN W. v. ADES and DAVID W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0100
2 CA-JV 2008-0104  BERNADETTE L. v. ADES, DANITZA R. and NETANYA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0104
2 CA-JV 2008-0106  IN RE ADRIANA V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0106
2 CA-JV 2008-0110  ROY C. v. ADES and MONROE C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0110
2 CA-JV 2008-0112  IN RE TOBIAS T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0112
2 CA-JV 2008-0121  IN RE HILLARY C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0121
Issues Summary: Whether the juvenile court is statutorily required to notify the Arizona Department of Transportation that a juvenile has been adjudicated delinquent for violating A.R.S. § 4-244(33), which prohibits a person under the age of twenty-one from driving or being in physical control of a motor vehicle while there is any alcohol in his or her body.


2 CA-JV 2008-0122  IN RE ANTHONY C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0122
2 CA-JV 2008-0124  IN RE HENRY N.-F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0124
2 CA-JV 2008-0128  DANIEL O. v. ADES, OLIVIA G. and DANIEL O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0128
2 CA-JV 2008-0132  NUBIAN A.-R. v. ADES and PHYAR A.-R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0132
2 CA-JV 2009-0002  IN RE CHRISTOPHER G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0002
2 CA-JV 2009-0004  BLANCA M. v. ADES; and ESMERALDA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0004
2 CA-JV 2009-0014  DAVID I. v. ADES and ANGEL I.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0014
2 CA-JV 2009-0018  DEON W. v. ADES and ARIANNA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0018
2 CA-JV 2009-0022  JAN P. v. ADES and ANGELA P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0022
2 CA-JV 2009-0024  WANDA R. v. ADES and JAZMIN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0024
2 CA-JV 2009-0026  HILDA A. v. ADES, DAKOTA A. and BOBBIJO A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0026
2 CA-JV 2009-0028  IN RE KALVIN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0028
2 CA-JV 2009-0032  TIMOTHY P. v. ADES and MONET P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0032
2 CA-JV 2009-0042  RAELENE F. v. ADES and ANIYA Z.-F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0042
2 CA-JV 2009-0046  ANGEL G. v. ADES and SELENA G. and CARMEN G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0046
2 CA-JV 2009-0050  JESUS G. v. ADES and SEBASTIAN D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0050
2 CA-JV 2009-0051  IN RE ISAAC U.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0051
2 CA-JV 2009-0058  JOSEPH S. v. ADES, AMETHYST B., NATHAN S and JONATHAN S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0058
2 CA-JV 2009-0061  MARY S. v. ADES and DOUGLAS S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0061
2 CA-JV 2009-0064  IN RE MICHAEL N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0064
2 CA-JV 2009-0076  KATHLEEN T. v. ADES and ALLISON T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0076
2 CA-JV 2009-0078  RICHARD W. v. ADES and ALEXIS F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0078
2 CA-JV 2009-0080  IN RE MARTIN M. and RENE N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0080
2 CA-JV 2009-0092  IN RE MATHEU I.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0092
2 CA-JV 2009-0104  MARIA A. v. ADES and EMILIANO L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0104
2 CA-JV 2009-0110  ARACELY M. v. ADES and JOSHUA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0110
2 CA-JV 2009-0114  AMANDA Z. v. ADES, CHAINING S. and CHASE S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0114
2 CA-JV 2009-0116  KENDRA K. v. ADES and JOHNNY K.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0116
2 CA-JV 2009-0118  MARIA P. v. NATALIE P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0118
2 CA-JV 2009-0122  EBONY M. v. ADES, HAZIAH Z., NEVAYEH Z. and RAEJEAN Z.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0122
2 CA-JV 2009-0124  AUNDRA Z. v. ADES, HAZIAH Z., NEVAYEH Z. and RAEJEAN Z.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0124
2 CA-JV 2009-0126  FRANCES A. v. ADES, PASCUA YAQUI TRIBE, VICTORIA R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0126
2 CA-JV 2010-0006  JERMAINE S. v. ADES and TATUM S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0006
2 CA-JV 2010-0008  CARMEN R. v. ADES, ANGELINA G. and YELENA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0008
2 CA-JV 2010-0010  JAMES L v. ADES, JESSICA E, CRYSTAL E, REBECCA L, TABETHA   Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0010
2 CA-JV 2010-0020  BOBBY J. v. ADES and JESENIA J.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0020
2 CA-JV 2010-0040  IN RE BRIAN P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0040
2 CA-JV 2010-0044  COURTNEY G. v. ADES, STEPHANIE L., NICHOLAS L. and JENNIFER L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0044
2 CA-JV 2010-0046  DON D. v. ADES and BRANDON P.-D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0046
2 CA-JV 2010-0063  ROBERT S. v. ADES, WAYLAND S. and MICHAEL S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0063
2 CA-JV 2010-0064  ESTHER M. v. ADES, SELENA M., WAYLAND S. and MICHAEL S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0064
2 CA-JV 2010-0070  MICHAEL S. v. ADES, RAHSAAD S. and RAHZHON S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0070
2 CA-JV 2010-0075  ARTHUR J. v. ADES, ELIJAH S. and ANAEJAH J.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0075
2 CA-JV 2010-0076  DANIEL C. v. MELISSA A. and BLAINE A-C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0076
2 CA-JV 2010-0084  YOLANDA R. v. ADES and DESTINY R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0084
2 CA-JV 2010-0086  IN RE ANGEL R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0086
2 CA-JV 2010-0088  EDDIE L. v. ADES, JULISSA L. and KYLEENA L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0088
2 CA-JV 2010-0092  MEGAN S. v. ADES, DESTIN C. and ALEXIA C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0092
2 CA-JV 2010-0100  JONATHAN F. v. ADES and SELINA F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0100
2 CA-JV 2010-0102  ADES v. JOSE L. and JOSE L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0102
2 CA-JV 2010-0104  RENA C. v. ADES, SABRINAH S., SOPHIAH R., XAVIER L. and ISAIAH S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0104
2 CA-JV 2010-0106  BOBBY J. v. ADES and BOBBY J., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0106
2 CA-JV 2010-0113  IN RE JUSTIN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0113
2 CA-JV 2010-0130  SHERI L. v. ALEX T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0130
2 CA-JV 2010-0140  JESSICA M. v. ADES and AUTUMN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0140
2 CA-JV 2010-0144  CHRISTOPHER M. v. CHRISTINA O. and MARISABEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0144
2 CA-JV 2010-0148  IN RE BREANNA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2010-0148
2 CA-JV 2011-0008  MATTHEW M. v. ADES and SYDNEY M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0008
2 CA-JV 2011-0015  JOSE L. v. ADES, MARIANA L., and NAVEYA L.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0015
2 CA-JV 2011-0043  LARRY T., JR. v. ADES and LARRY T., III  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0043
2 CA-JV 2011-0044  SAMANTHA E. v. ADES and THOMAS G., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0044
2 CA-JV 2011-0049  IN RE MICHAEL C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0049
2 CA-JV 2011-0051  IN RE GREGORY L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0051
2 CA-JV 2011-0057  IN RE DEREK P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0057
2 CA-JV 2011-0061  SHANNON A. v. ADES and CHRISTIAN N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0061
2 CA-JV 2011-0063  IN RE RYAN Y.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0063
2 CA-JV 2011-0065  ANTENETA H. v. ADES and ELIJAH B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0065
2 CA-JV 2011-0075  AMANDA H. v. ADES, ABREE H., LEONIA H. and DONALD H., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0075
2 CA-JV 2011-0083  TRAVES J. v. ADES and ELI T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0083
2 CA-JV 2011-0099  BRANDY E. v. KIMBERLY T.-S. and ISABELL E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0099
2 CA-JV 2011-0101  RIKKI G. v. ADES, CRYSTAL G. and COURTNEY G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0101
2 CA-JV 2011-0109  IN RE SERGIO G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0109
2 CA-JV 2011-0121  ANGIE G. v. ADES and GABRIEL R.; LILLIANA G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0121
2 CA-JV 2011-0145  LARRY C. v. ADES, and EMMA C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0145
2 CA-JV 2011-0147  BIANCA T. v. ADES and XAVIER T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2011-0147
2 CA-JV 2012-0011  IN RE ALBERTO N.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0011
2 CA-JV 2012-0021  CYNTHIA B. v. ADES, TIMOTHY B., GABRIEL B., CHRISTIAN B. and AUDRIANA B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0021
2 CA-JV 2012-0023  JAIME O. v. ADES, SKYLA O.-S. and STEFEN S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0023
2 CA-JV 2012-0031  DANIELA M. v. ADES, OSCAR O., ESPERANZA O.-M. and EZEKIEL M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0031
2 CA-JV 2012-0045  SYLVIA B. v. ADES and DIEGO B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0045
2 CA-JV 2012-0047  JASON R. v. ADES, YANAHA R. and JAYLA R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0047
2 CA-JV 2012-0048  JASON R. v. ADES and JASON R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0048
2 CA-JV 2012-0050  SHANNON S. v. ADES, MICHELLE S. and ARIEL S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0050
2 CA-JV 2012-0053  IN RE KARL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0053
2 CA-JV 2012-0054  YOLANDA C. v. ADES, ELENA C., ELI'YANA C., EALIYAH C., ELYSSIA C., AUBRE'YANA C. and ANTHONY C., III  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0054
2 CA-JV 2012-0057  MEGAN W. v. ADES and SUMMER W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0057
2 CA-JV 2012-0064  MALACHI W. and ADES v. RICARDO M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0064
2 CA-JV 2012-0071  IN RE BELEN G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0071
2 CA-JV 2012-0075  FELISA M. v. ADES, CAMAI M. and JAMI M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0075
2 CA-JV 2012-0077  IN RE MARIO P. C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0077
2 CA-JV 2012-0080  BRIAN T., JR. v. ADES and DIANA A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0080
2 CA-JV 2012-0093  DZHULYETIA K. v. ADES & YANA K.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0093
2 CA-JV 2012-0095  GILBERTO J. v. ROSA Y., GEORGE Y. and ROMEO Y.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0095
2 CA-JV 2012-0097  IN RE JESUS V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0097
2 CA-JV 2012-0103  RUEBEN T. v. ADES and RUEBEN T., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0103
2 CA-JV 2012-0115  JENNY R. v. ADES, SUZANNA T.-R. and ISAIAH T.-R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0115
2 CA-JV 2012-0119  IN RE JASON S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2012-0119
2 CA-JV 2013-0017  JAMES F. v. FARIN H., HERBERT H. and KETHAN F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0017
2 CA-JV 2013-0021  DUSTIN P. v. ADES, A.P. and D.P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0021
2 CA-JV 2013-0025  IN RE JESUS G.-C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0025
2 CA-JV 2013-0051  LISA C. v. ADES and J.M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0051
2 CA-JV 2013-0059  SARAH V. v. ADES, E., D., P., and G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0059
2 CA-JV 2013-0063  NANCY L. v. ADES and A. L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0063
2 CA-JV 2013-0071  IN RE RICARDO S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0071
2 CA-JV 2013-0079  KATRINA S. v. CHRISTOPHER S. and H. S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0079
2 CA-JV 2013-0087  HECTOR M. v. AIIESA E. and A.M.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0087
2 CA-JV 2013-0113  RACHEL P. v. ADES, H. P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0113
2 CA-JV 2013-0125  I.L., L.L. and A.L. v. ADES, JULIA J., DANIEL L. and GILA RIVER INDIAN COMMUNITY  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0125
2 CA-JV 2013-0139  IN RE G.Y.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0139
2 CA-JV 2014-0017  KARENA H. v. DCS AND A.G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0017
2 CA-MH 2006-0009  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-20000649  Participating 2 CA-MH 2006-0009
2 CA-MH 2007-0003  IN RE: MH-20050999  Participating 2 CA-MH 2007-0003
2 CA-MH 2008-0001  MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH 20000209  Participating 2 CA-MH 2008-0001
2 CA-MH 2008-0006  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-200800068  Participating 2 CA-MH 2008-0006
2 CA-MH 2009-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-20030042-2-09  Participating 2 CA-MH 2009-0002
2 CA-MH 2009-0004  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-200900068  Participating 2 CA-MH 2009-0004
2 CA-MH 2010-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH 7919-7-10  Participating 2 CA-MH 2010-0002
2 CA-MH 2011-0003  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20100047  Participating 2 CA-MH 2011-0003
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in denying appellant’s motion to dismiss the Petition for Continued Treatment of a Persistently or Acutely Disabled Person filed by Community Partnership of Southern Arizona (CPSA) on the ground that appellant was examined less than thirty days before the prior treatment order expired, in violation of R9-21-506(A)(1), Ariz. Admin. Code? (2) Did the trial court err in denying appellant’s motion to dismiss CPSA’s petition and granting the petition on the ground that only one physician examined and evaluated him for purposes of determining whether he continued to require court-ordered treatment, as required by A.R.S. § 36-5434(E), when R9-21-506(B)(2)(c) requires two physicians?


2 CA-MH 2012-0001  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH CASE NO. MH20000209  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0001
2 CA-MH 2012-0003  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH20100752212  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0003
2 CA-MH 2012-0007-SP  IN RE THE COMMITMENT OF CHARLES ALLEN  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0007-SP
2 CA-MH 2012-0009  IN RE GILA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. S0400MH201200015  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0009
2 CA-MH 2012-0011  IN RE GILA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201200020  Participating 2 CA-MH 2012-0011
2 CA-SA 2006-0101  GRACE HOWARD ALLEN v. ADES and T.S.A.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2006-0101
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in denying a maternal aunt’s motion to intervene in the juvenile’s dependency proceeding?


2 CA-SA 2007-0027  STEVEN PAUL TURNER V. ACUNA; STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0027
2 CA-SA 2007-0067  THE STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA EDWARDS FRYE   Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0067
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by entertaining the defendant’s challenge to the grand jury proceeding, brought more than two years after the grand jury transcript and minutes were filed, well past the time limits in Rule 12.9(b), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and by remanding the case for a new finding of probable cause?


2 CA-SA 2007-0081  ASHLEY SKINNER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0081
2 CA-SA 2007-0085  DIANA H. v. ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC SECURITY  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0085
Issues Summary: Whether a parent whose child has been adjudicated dependent pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 8-841 through 8-844 has a residual parental right pursuant to A.R.S. § 8-531(5)(c) to exempt the child from immunization for religious reasons.


2 CA-SA 2008-0013  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TODD GLICK  Participating 2 CA-SA 2008-0013
2 CA-SA 2008-0015  STEPHANIE MARIE LYON v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2008-0015
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion when he concluded the city court magistrate in the underlying DUI case had erred by finding the defendant’s due process rights had not been violated as a result of the state’s failure to comply with applicable Department of Health Services regulations and failure to then provide the defendant with a sample of his breath for independent testing?

Having found the defendant’s due process rights were violated, did the respondent judge err in ordering that the charge under A.R.S. § 28-1381(A)(2) be dismissed but providing no remedy for the violation of the charge under § 28-1381(A(1)?


2 CA-SA 2008-0086  YUMA COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE v. JANE ROE; CITY OF NOGALES  Participating 2 CA-SA 2008-0086
2 CA-SA 2009-0010  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LELAND FLORENCIO CROCKWELL  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0010
Issues Summary: 1. Does Rule 17.4(f), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and/or Rule 410, Ariz. R. Evid., apply to statements a criminal defendant makes to law enforcement in accordance with a cooperation provision in a plea agreement that the state withdraws when the defendant breaches the agreement by making untruthful statements? Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by prohibiting the state from introducing these statements for all but impeachment purposes? 2. Can a defendant waive the protections of Rule 17.4(f), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and Rule 410, Ariz. R. Evid., and agree the state may use against him statements he made in anticipation of, in connection with, and prior to entering into a plea agreement that is later withdrawn based on the defendant’s breach of the agreement?

3. If a defendant can waive the protection of Rule 17.4(f) and Rule 410 for statements made in connection with a breached plea agreement, did the defendant waive those protections here and did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by prohibiting the state from introducing these statements for all but impeachment purposes?


2 CA-SA 2009-0036  IN THE MATTER OF STEVEN PACHECO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0036
2 CA-SA 2009-0052  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO XAVIER GUTIERREZ  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0052
2 CA-SA 2009-0084  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ALLEN KROMKO  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0084
2 CA-SA 2010-0008  PIMA COUNTY v. DOS PICOS LAND LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; SHEPARD, et ux.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0008
Issues Summary: In an inverse condemnation action, did A.R.S. § 12-1127(B) require the county to satisfy the judgment in favor of plaintiffs, notwithstanding Rule 62(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P., while the county’s appeal from the judgment was pending?


2 CA-SA 2010-0032  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ANDREW THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0032
2 CA-SA 2010-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL OLIVERI; MICHAEL JOSEPH NELSON   Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0056
Issues Summary: Does the Revised Arizona Jury Instruction (Criminal) 28.1383(A)(1)-1 correctly state the law in A.R.S. § 28-1381(A)(1)?


2 CA-SA 2010-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID FRANKLIN, SR. & JOHN DAVID FRANKLIN, JR.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0068
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge err in denying the state’s request under Arizona’s Victims’ Bill of Rights, Ariz. Const. art. II, § 2.1(VBR), for a protective order to prohibit the defendants in a civil forfeiture action and a parallel criminal proceeding from deposing in the forfeiture case named victims in the criminal case who had asserted their right under the VBR not to be deposed?


2 CA-SA 2010-0092  ERNESTO DIAZ BROWN RAMSBURGH v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0092
2 CA-SA 2011-0002  DANIEL PAUL RUIZ v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0002
2 CA-SA 2011-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO MARTIN FLORES  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0038
2 CA-SA 2011-0061  THOMAS SACK v. STATE OF ARIZONA   Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0061
2 CA-SA 2011-0079  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELA KOPERSKI  Participating 2 CA-SA 2011-0079
2 CA-SA 2012-0033  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENISE NICOLE PESQUEIRA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0033
2 CA-SA 2012-0039  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN M.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0039
2 CA-SA 2013-0085  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FULLER WAYNE SMITH  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0085
2 CA-SA 2014-0026  CARLOS OROZCO v. PINAL COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE  Participating 2 CA-SA 2014-0026
2 CA-SA 2014-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRON TAYLOR; OZNIE MANHERTZ  Participating 2 CA-SA 2014-0034
2 CA-SA 2014-0055  YOLANDA LAVETTE DIGGS v. STATE OF ARIZONA   Participating 2 CA-SA 2014-0055
Judge John Pelander
Please click on the case number in the "Decision" column to view the complete decision.
Case Number Case Title Role Decision
2 CA-CR 2007-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTO ROSADILLO AGUILAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0126
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding the prosecution time-barred by the statute of limitations, and dismissing the charges against defendant on that basis? Does A.R.S. § 13-107 violate the Ex Post Facto Clause?


2 CA-JV 2007-0096  MARCO C. v. SEAN C. & COLLEEN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0096
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the juvenile court abuse its discretion when it concluded that the consent of the appellant was not required for the appellees’ adoption of appellant’s purported biological child because appellant had failed to register timely with the putative father registry in accordance with A.R.S. § 8-106.01 and had not established circumstances set forth in that statute excusing a putative father from registering within thirty days of the child’s birth? Are A.R.S. §§ 8-106 and 8-106.01 generally unconstitutional?


2 CA-CR 2006-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIGINIO AGUILAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0226
Issues Summary: Whether the state’s request to use an undisclosed scientific report and to have an undisclosed witness testify during Aguilar’s first trial created manifest necessity requiring a mistrial, so that double jeopardy did not bar his retrial.


2 CA-CR 2005-0018  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PONGTHEP NA-AYUDHA PRAMOJ  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0018
2 CA-CR 2005-0066  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL LEE BAKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0066
2 CA-CR 2005-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0176
2 CA-CR 2005-0290  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PEDRO CARRILLO-ROMERO  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0290
2 CA-CR 2005-0330  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EVANS LAFFYATTE PITTMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0330
2 CA-CR 2005-0354  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE MENDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0354
2 CA-CR 2005-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLIE GENE CUMMINGS  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0372
2 CA-CR 2005-0384  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER JAMES MANGUM  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0384
Issues Summary: Was the defendant, charged with prohibited possession of a weapon in violation of A.R.S. §§ 13-3102(A)(4) and 13-3101(A)(6)(d), entitled to dismissal of the charge when another court vacated, on constitutional grounds, the underlying prior conviction on which the weapons charge was based?


2 CA-CR 2005-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN LEON WAGGONER  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0388
2 CA-CR 2005-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STANLEY ERNEST RIMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0392
2 CA-CR 2005-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WAYNE MARIETTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0398
2 CA-CR 2006-0050-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR FRANCISCO RUBIANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0050-PR
Issues Summary: Does the corpus delicti rule apply in the context of a constitutionally valid, in-court guilty plea?


2 CA-CR 2006-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAWN MICHELE WEAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0098
2 CA-CR 2006-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAUL MENDOZA-CARRASCO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0106
2 CA-CR 2006-0120  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY DEAN ARTZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0120
2 CA-CR 2006-0130-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT LEE JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0130-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0136  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN MARTIN GABLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0136
2 CA-CR 2006-0154  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DALLAS SEAN TRENT  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0154
2 CA-CR 2006-0162  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNYS GEOVANNI COLEMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0162
2 CA-CR 2006-0170-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARGARITO URIAS RUBIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0170-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL G. ERVIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0172
2 CA-CR 2006-0174-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL WAYNE SWOOPES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0174-PR
Issues Summary: In defendant’s second Rule 32 proceeding, did his claim that the trial judge, without defendant’s personal presence or waiver of any such right, improperly and erroneously answered a note from jurors during their deliberations implicate a right of “sufficient constitutional magnitude” so as to avoid preclusion of the claim under Rule 32.2(a)(3), Ariz. R. Crim. P.?


2 CA-CR 2006-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRUCE WAYNE GREEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0176
2 CA-CR 2006-0178-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY ALLEN STANHOPE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0178-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0194-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALONZO DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0194-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0196-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS PATRICK PURCELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0196-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0204  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ANTHONY STAPLES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0204
2 CA-CR 2006-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC MANUEL DOMINGUEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0210
2 CA-CR 2006-0228-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY FARRELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0228-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS DWAYNE GAINES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0230
2 CA-CR 2006-0232  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAMELA FRANCESCA CONWAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0232
2 CA-CR 2006-0238  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE TIBUCIO VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0238
2 CA-CR 2006-0240  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC JASON PASTOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0240
2 CA-CR 2006-0244  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN B. SHEPHERD, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0244
2 CA-CR 2006-0252-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERALD RODRIGUEZ DURAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0252-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0254  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JANE CHRISTINE LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0254
2 CA-CR 2006-0266  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SELENA ALICIA CORONADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0266
2 CA-CR 2006-0268  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE CARLOS CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0268
2 CA-CR 2006-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DESEAN ALEXANDER BRUCE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0290  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESTEBAN MALDONADO ARMENTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0290
2 CA-CR 2006-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH FRANKLIN BENNETT, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CONRAD E. SALCIDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0306
2 CA-CR 2006-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL VELASQUEZ SANTA MARIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0320
2 CA-CR 2006-0326  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL RYDER HUNTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0326
2 CA-CR 2006-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFRED CAMPAS GASTELUM  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0328
2 CA-CR 2006-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL GREGORY WHITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RACHEL MARIE VALLEJO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0336-PR
Issues Summary: In post-conviction proceedings, did the trial court err in denying the defendant’s claim that her trial counsel had been ineffective when counsel had failed to ask why defendant had rejected the state’s plea offers, and when the former prosecutor avowed he would have accepted a different counter-offer had defendant made one?


2 CA-CR 2006-0344-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EUGENE HARVEY GLOVER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0344-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LINDA GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0346
2 CA-CR 2006-0352  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LANCE TODD DUNBAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0352
2 CA-CR 2006-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRUCE D. HOFFMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0366  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL OQUITA GUTIERREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0366
2 CA-CR 2006-0370  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL TLALOC QUIROZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0370
2 CA-CR 2006-0386  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN JOHN SHOGREN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0386
2 CA-CR 2006-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE JOE CAMPILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0398
2 CA-CR 2006-0404  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE HUMBERTO VEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0404
2 CA-CR 2006-0406-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ROY NAIL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0406-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0414  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD DALLAS INGRAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0414
2 CA-CR 2006-0432-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH DAVID McCORMICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0432-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0438-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO LONGORIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0438-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0442  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN LEE BABB  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0442
2 CA-CR 2007-0008-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUNIES A. JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0008-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN JOHNSON REITER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0018  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARNELL JOSEPH LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0018
2 CA-CR 2007-0028  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMY LEE HODGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0028
2 CA-CR 2007-0031  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARTURO ANDA CANEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0031
2 CA-CR 2007-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FREDERICK GENE PERKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0042
2 CA-CR 2007-0044  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FELIBERTO BATISTA-DELAPAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0044
2 CA-CR 2007-0052-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELE LEE KELLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0052-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICARDO SARMIENTO ADRIAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0058
2 CA-CR 2007-0063-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLY JOE SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0063-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS ORTEGAS MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0064
2 CA-CR 2007-0068-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL JOSEPH SCARPIGNATO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0068-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR SOZA BELTRAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0070
2 CA-CR 2007-0076  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERARDO ESCARCEGA RUIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0076
2 CA-CR 2007-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD ANTHONY BIERLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0078
2 CA-CR 2007-0080  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS LEONEL BURGOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0080
2 CA-CR 2007-0094-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT O. GOETH, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0094-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0106-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY TERRELL THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0106-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0110  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADOLPH DELGADO-GUTIERREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0110
2 CA-CR 2007-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK JUDE MARTINEZ, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0122
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in admitting evidence of the defendant’s post-arrest statements made to a neighboring jail inmate, based on the court’s finding the inmate had not acted as a state agent in eliciting or reporting the statements? 2) Did defendant lack standing to object on Fourth Amendment grounds to admission into evidence of a letter he wrote from jail to his girlfriend, whose mother intercepted the letter from their shared mailbox and turned it over to the state? 3) Did the trial court err in admitting the letter into evidence when the record supported a finding the girlfriend’s mother had not acted as a state agent in obtaining and producing the letter?


2 CA-CR 2007-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUBERT U. MCCAULEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0124
2 CA-CR 2007-0134  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARY ELIZABETH PAGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0134
2 CA-CR 2007-0146-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ISRAEL ANDREW RIVERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0146-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0168  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL EDWARDO RUEDA, IV  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0168
2 CA-CR 2007-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT RAY ACEVES, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0182
2 CA-CR 2007-0184  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARJORIE ANN JACKSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0184
2 CA-CR 2007-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN MANUEL ALVAREZ-FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0188
2 CA-CR 2007-0194  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT ACOSTA, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0194
2 CA-CR 2007-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT LOPEZ JARAMILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0204  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CAROLE ANN DIXON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0204
2 CA-CR 2007-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. IAN MICHAEL DAWKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0212
2 CA-CR 2007-0214  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARILYN JUNE CARTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0214
2 CA-CR 2007-0224  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RANDLE RAVELICH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0224
2 CA-CR 2007-0248  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANTHONY BROWN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0248
2 CA-CR 2007-0250  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID RAY REED  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0250
2 CA-CR 2007-0252  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RAY WEEKS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0252
2 CA-CR 2007-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS DWAYNE GAINES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0266  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRISTOBAL ASTORGA-HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0266
2 CA-CR 2007-0268  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES DARRELL JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0268
2 CA-CR 2007-0278  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CATHERINE D. LIBERCAJT  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0278
2 CA-CR 2007-0282  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES DAVID CAREY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0282
2 CA-CR 2007-0284  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLIN GENE TAYLOR, JOHN ADRIAN JOHNSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0284
2 CA-CR 2007-0292  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY S. SIIRTOLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0292
2 CA-CR 2007-0296  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER DAVID SHORTMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0296
2 CA-CR 2007-0302-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID MENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0302-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0324-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BENJAMIN EDWARD SATATHITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0324-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0330  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CUAUHTEMOC MARTINEZ-TOVAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0330
2 CA-CR 2007-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELE LOUISA VALENZUELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0332
2 CA-CR 2007-0338-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND AMBROSE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0338-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0340  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN ANDRES LEYVAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0340
Issues Summary: 1. Was a hearing pursuant to State v. Dessureault, 104 Ariz. 380, 453 P.2d 951 (1969), required when the witness failed to identify the defendant in a pretrial photographic line-up, was later told by the prosecutor she had chosen the wrong person, and then identified the defendant for the first time in court?

2. Was there sufficient evidence to support the defendant’s convictions for attempted armed robbery when, while displaying a gun, he asked the victims if they had any money and they replied, “no”?


2 CA-CR 2007-0344-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL JAY NIX  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0344-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0358-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL MCDOWELL SPRAGUE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0358-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0364  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL ALAN KOSCIELSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0364
2 CA-CR 2007-0368  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM HARLOW  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0368
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in modifying the form of verdict shortly after the jurors had retired to deliberate?


2 CA-CR 2007-0370-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA AURORA CASTRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0370-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0378-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BERNARDO DIAZ CARRASCO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0378-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO LUCERO GONZALEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0382
2 CA-CR 2007-0396  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAN CAROL RUST  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0396
2 CA-CR 2008-0008-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELTORNA GANT, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0008-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUSSELL BRADFORD WOODS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0036
2 CA-CR 2008-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE JOSEPH TUCCI  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0040
2 CA-CR 2008-0044-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENNETH SCOTT MACHADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0044-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0062-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN M. HANEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0062-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUBEN GERARDO GARRIDO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0064
2 CA-CR 2008-0070  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM JOHN FIIHR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0070
Issues Summary: Is misdemeanor failure to stop under A.R.S. § 28-1595(A) a lesser-included offense of felony flight from a pursuing law enforcement vehicle under A.R.S. § 28-622.01?


2 CA-CR 2008-0072-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTINA MARIE GEORGE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0072-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0076  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN RICHARD TRAMMEL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0076
2 CA-CR 2008-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE FLORES MORENO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0096
2 CA-CR 2008-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0102
2 CA-CR 2008-0110-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE DAVID DIAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0110-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KIM COOK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0120-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0122-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DEWAYNE GUDE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0122-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS NORBERTO FELIX-GRADILLAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0126
2 CA-CR 2008-0128  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELISSA SUE WELCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0128
2 CA-CR 2008-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLARENCE NMN HORTON III  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0140-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FIDELE BIRAHAGAZE BATEKREZE   Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0140-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0142-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ANTHONY MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0142-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0152-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD OSCAR GRANADOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0152-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CALEB QUIXOTE LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0156
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in ordering the defendant to pay restitution to a victim after he had been acquitted of aggravated assault against her but convicted of drive-by shooting?


2 CA-CR 2008-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAYNE NELSON DANIELS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0166
Issues Summary: Did the trial court fundamentally err in imposing against the defendants at sentencing a $1,000 prosecution fee pursuant to a Pinal County ordinance?


2 CA-CR 2008-0174  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CEDRIC BROGER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0174
2 CA-CR 2008-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES MATTHEWSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0176
2 CA-CR 2008-0184  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DIAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0184
2 CA-CR 2008-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROXANA LEE SALGADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0188
2 CA-CR 2008-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE AMADOR-GALICIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0212
2 CA-CR 2008-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCO LEVONTE WILLIAMS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0230
2 CA-CR 2008-0258-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LACY RIDDELL, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0258-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0260-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN RYAN PUCKETT  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0260-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CORRALES RIVERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0290-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES E. GRANINGER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0290-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0296  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM ELKINS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0296
2 CA-CR 2008-0340  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LISA ANN MENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0340
2 CA-CR 2008-0350-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE ARLIEN BREWER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0350-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0364-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON AMARO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0364-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN WILLIAM DAVID SICARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0384-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY LAMONT LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0384-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0402-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER GEORGE KISS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0402-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0050-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE HAROLD FLINT, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0050-PR
2 CA-CV 2004-0187  JONES, HEBERT, NICHOLS v. WHIPPLE  Author 2 CA-CV 2004-0187
2 CA-CV 2005-0082  HENSON v. TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT; CITY OF TUCSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2005-0082
2 CA-CV 2006-0090  CROM fna BURRIS v. BURRIS  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0090
2 CA-CV 2006-0098  IN RE THE MATTER OF BOND FORFEITURE IN AMOUNT OF $10,000.  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0098
2 CA-CV 2006-0106  CITY OF BISBEE v. ARIZONA WATER COMPANY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0106
Issues Summary: Did the Arizona Corporation Commission have exclusive jurisdiction over the issues raised, divesting the trial court of subject matter jurisdiction, and did the trial court err in granting partial summary judgment in favor of the City on its claims that Arizona Water Co.’s (AWC) reservation of subsurface property rights in certain City streets was void and, therefore, AWC had an obligation to assume any relocation costs associated with the City’s sewer improvement project?


2 CA-CV 2006-0114  RUESGA v. KINDRED NURSING CENTERS WEST, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0114
Issues Summary: 1) Absent any final judgment or Rule 54(b) certification, does this court have subject matter jurisdiction over an appeal from a trial court’s order granting relief pursuant to Rule 60(c) and compelling arbitration?

2) Absent a request for an evidentiary hearing, did the trial court err in summarily finding from undisputed facts and documents presented that a wife had had implied, actual authority to execute an arbitration agreement on behalf of her incapacitated husband in connection with his stay at a nursing home facility?


2 CA-CV 2006-0124  BURKHAMER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0124
Issues Summary: Did appellant’s timely filing of an objection to the trial court’s judgment extend the time for appealing from the judgment under ARCAP 9(b) and, if not, does this court lack jurisdiction because the appeal was untimely?


2 CA-CV 2006-0126  SIGNORELLI v. SIGNORELLI  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0126
2 CA-CV 2006-0132  CORRADO v. DUPNIK; PALMER  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0132
2 CA-CV 2006-0137  HALL v. SMITH  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0137
Issues Summary: Is a party’s communication made to the chief executive officer of a non-party parent corporation during litigation with its subsidiary protected against a defamation claim by the absolute judicial privilege, when the parent company had a close and direct relationship to the underlying litigation?


2 CA-CV 2006-0138  In re the Estate of ELLIOT GOLDMAN, Deceased  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0138
Issues Summary: For purposes of determining abatement under A.R.S. § 14-3902, is the value of estate assets determined as of the date of the testator’s death, or rather, at the time of distribution of estate assets?


2 CA-CV 2006-0150  BUELA VIOLA SMITH TRUST v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0150
2 CA-CV 2006-0154  TATOM and KUZMA v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0154
2 CA-CV 2006-0162  NORWOOD v. FELTNER  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0162
2 CA-CV 2006-0168  LEONETTI v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0168
2 CA-CV 2006-0200  SLINGERLEND v. CRAIG and CENTURY 21 J. PAGEL REALTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0200
2 CA-CV 2006-0212  LOWE v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0212
Issues Summary: In granting summary judgment in favor of Pima County, did the trial court err in refusing to equitably estop the county from enforcing its zoning code against an alleged fence violation when a permit had been issued in 1983 for the fence, and did the court misapply Pleak v. Entrada Property Owners’ Ass’n, 207 Ariz. 418, 87 P.3d 831 (2004), in ruling that a prior deed of dedication had been accepted by the general public, thereby defeating the appellants/property owners’ quiet title/adverse possession claim to the disputed property enclosed by the fence?


2 CA-CV 2006-0216  ZLOTNICK LIVING TRUST v. FINMAN; and SPECIALNEEDS VEHICLES, INC.  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0216
2 CA-CV 2006-0226  MCCAUSLAND v. PIMA COUNTY  Author 2 CA-CV 2006-0226
2 CA-CV 2007-0024  ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY v. CAVCO INDUSTRIES  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0024
2 CA-CV 2007-0032  CUTHBERTSON v. CUTHBERTSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0032
2 CA-CV 2007-0036  JEFFREY ODOM v. FARMERS INSURANCE COMPANY OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0036
Issues Summary: When Farmers’ insured loaned his rental car to a third party, who then caused a one-car accident in which a passenger was injured, was the third party/driver covered for the accident under the insured’s personal automobile insurance policy with Farmers?


2 CA-CV 2007-0044  JOAN TOBER v. CDC REALTY, L.L.C.  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0044
2 CA-CV 2007-0082  ERINEO CANO v. M. IOVINO  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0082
2 CA-CV 2007-0090  HAROUTUNIAN v. VALUEOPTIONS  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0090
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in denying ValueOptions’ motion made pursuant to Rule 9(a), Ariz. R. Civ. App. P., to extend the time to file a notice of appeal? 2. Did the trial court err in denying ValueOptions’ motion made pursuant to Rule 6(b), Ariz. R. Civ. P., to enlarge the time within which to file post-judgment motions? 3. Does this court have jurisdiction over the remaining issues raised by ValueOptions’ appeal or over Haroutunian’s cross-appeal?


2 CA-CV 2007-0098  PINNACLE RESTORATION v. DELIAH CHERRY  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0098
2 CA-CV 2007-0100  IN THE MATTER OF $5,598.00 IN US CURRENCY  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0100
2 CA-CV 2007-0102  ERINEO CANO v. B. VOLK and M. EVANS  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0102
2 CA-CV 2007-0138  PIMA COUNTY PUBLIC FIDUCIARY v. JACK A. RAPPEPORT  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0138
2 CA-CV 2007-0146  PATRICIA W. WATSON v. ROBERT L. WATSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0146
2 CA-CV 2007-0148  VASQUEZ v. STATE OF AZ.; ST. OF AZ. DEPT. OF PUBLIC SAFETY   Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0148
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding insufficient plaintiff’s notice of claim against the state pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-821.01(A) and Deer Valley Unified Sch. Dist. No. 97 v. Houser, 214 Ariz. 293, 152 P.3d 490 (2007)?

2. Did the trial court err in finding neither the state nor the county had any duty to plaintiff, decedent’s mother, to investigate more thoroughly her son’s death or to identify his body before disposing of it?


2 CA-CV 2007-0168  BORDER CITIES LAND CORP. v. CITY OF BISBEE, CITY OF BISBEE BOARD ADJUSTMENT  Author 2 CA-CV 2007-0168
2 CA-CV 2008-0004  STEVEN DAVID MORAN v. THE CITY OF TOMBSTONE, AZ  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0004
2 CA-CV 2008-0008  STEVEN MORNINGTHUNDER v. AUGUSTA RESOURCES CORP., PHELPS DODGE MINING CO., ...  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0008
2 CA-CV 2008-0018  CHAVEZ v. AVALON CARE CENTER TUCSON  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0018
2 CA-CV 2008-0038  THERESA LOUISE McKENNA v. TIMOTHY PAUL McKENNA  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0038
2 CA-CV 2008-0082  BEYNON; BEYNON v. TREZZA dba TREZZA & BRADLEY; THRUSH  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0082
Issues Summary: In this attorney malpractice case, did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant/lawyer on the ground that, although the lawyer failed to timely file an action on plaintiffs’ behalf against the state within the one year limitations period prescribed in A.R.S. § 12 821, plaintiffs could not have prevailed on their underlying claim against the state because they failed to strictly comply with the notice of claim statute, A.R.S. § 12 821.01(A), thereby barring any cause of action against the state?


2 CA-CV 2008-0090  RICHARD C. BEALS v. ROBERT L. MOORE, dba KACHINA INSULATION  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0090
2 CA-CV 2008-0100  LEANNA J. TAYLOR v. BILL BARNETT LIMITED LIABILITY LTD. PARTNERSHIP  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0100
2 CA-CV 2008-0104  EDNA N. RUCK v. RALPH CLAY and MARTHA CLAY  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0104
2 CA-CV 2008-0126  JIMMIE D. HOLLAND v. MICHAEL ANTHONY HURLEY, JANE DOE HURLEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0126
2 CA-CV 2008-0130  GILE E. SIEVERS v. TOWN OF PAYSON, SILVIA SMITH, MAYOR EVANS, ...  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0130
2 CA-CV 2008-0160  MARTIN-MACDONALD v. MACDONALD  Author 2 CA-CV 2008-0160
2 CA-HC 2007-0002  GARY YODER v. WARDEN WALKER; STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-HC 2007-0002
2 CA-HC 2007-0004  BRANSON v. GAY  Author 2 CA-HC 2007-0004
2 CA-IC 2006-0016  TORREON v. AMERICAN HOME, B. BREMER; S. BREMER   Author 2 CA-IC 2006-0016
2 CA-IC 2006-0020  VASQUEZ v. TUCSON CARPENTRY, INC.   Author 2 CA-IC 2006-0020
2 CA-JV 2006-0028  BREANN M. v. ADES, DUNCAN S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0028
2 CA-JV 2006-0050  KARINA C. v. ADES, ARIANNA C., ADRIANNA C.   Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0050
2 CA-JV 2006-0052  IN RE CARLOS M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2006-0052
2 CA-JV 2007-0028  IN THE MATTER OF: ASHTON G.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0028
2 CA-JV 2007-0040  BERNADETTE S. v. ADES, TERESA S., MARIANNA S.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0040
2 CA-JV 2007-0052  IN THE MATTER OF: GUSTAVO C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0052
2 CA-JV 2007-0058  IN RE JOSE H.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0058
2 CA-JV 2007-0060  IN RE JOSE L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0060
2 CA-JV 2007-0068  WILLIAM B. and MAE B. v. ADES, ANJALI B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0068
2 CA-JV 2007-0086  RUBEN L. v. ADES, ADALINA L., ANGELITA L., RUBEN L. & AUDREYANNA L.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0086
2 CA-JV 2007-0104  IN RE JAIRO M.   Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0104
2 CA-JV 2008-0006  MICAH M. v. ADES, RHYAN M., SEBASTIAN M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0006
2 CA-JV 2008-0008  IN RE YVETTE H.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0008
2 CA-JV 2008-0022  IN RE DEREK T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0022
2 CA-JV 2008-0044  PAMELA V. v. ADES & TRINITY M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0044
2 CA-JV 2008-0058  DEWAYNE B. v. ADES, LAYLA B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0058
2 CA-JV 2008-0070  TOMMORIES W. v. ADES, DOMINIC B.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0070
2 CA-JV 2008-0076  IN RE SEAN T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0076
2 CA-JV 2008-0084  IN RE RAMON N.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0084
2 CA-JV 2008-0094  IN RE CODY M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0094
2 CA-JV 2008-0110  ROY C. v. ADES and MONROE C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0110
2 CA-JV 2008-0112  IN RE TOBIAS T.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0112
2 CA-JV 2008-0122  IN RE ANTHONY C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0122
2 CA-JV 2008-0128  DANIEL O. v. ADES, OLIVIA G. and DANIEL O.  Author 2 CA-JV 2008-0128
2 CA-JV 2009-0002  IN RE CHRISTOPHER G.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0002
2 CA-JV 2009-0004  BLANCA M. v. ADES; and ESMERALDA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0004
2 CA-JV 2009-0018  DEON W. v. ADES and ARIANNA M.  Author 2 CA-JV 2009-0018
2 CA-MH 2006-0006-SP  IN RE THE COMMITMENT OF STEVEN CORRALES  Author 2 CA-MH 2006-0006-SP
2 CA-SA 2006-0108  SARTIN v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2006-0108
2 CA-SA 2007-0012  SCOTT DOUGLAS NORDSTROM v. STATE OF ARIZONA   Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0012
Issues Summary: When a defendant has peremptorily removed a judge from the case pursuant to Rule 10.2, Ariz. R. Crim. P., 16A A.R.S., and that judge is later appointed as presiding judge of the court, may that judge, in his role as presiding judge, thereafter rule on the merits of the defendant’s subsequent motion for change of another judge for cause pursuant to Rule 10.1, Ariz. R. Crim. P.?


2 CA-SA 2007-0054  IN RE ANDREW G.  Author 2 CA-SA 2007-0054
Issues Summary: When a juvenile is on probation, does the filing of a subsequent delinquency petition automatically extend the period of the original probation beyond the date it otherwise would have expired?


2 CA-SA 2008-0074  MARK WILLIAMS v. LOURDES HENDRICKSON  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0074
2 CA-SA 2008-0086  YUMA COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE v. JANE ROE; CITY OF NOGALES  Author 2 CA-SA 2008-0086
2 CA-SA 2009-0036  IN THE MATTER OF STEVEN PACHECO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2009-0036
2 CA-CR 2004-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY SHARIFF GAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2004-0306
Issues Summary: 1. Whether, under Illinois v. McArthur, 531 U.S. 326, 121 S. Ct. 946 (2001), and State v. Ault, 150 Ariz. 459, 724 P.2d 545 (1986), exigent circumstances justified a temporary seizure of defendant’s apartment.

2. Whether the trial court erred by concluding the state did not violate Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712 (1986), by exercising peremptory strikes against two African-American prospective jurors.


2 CA-CR 2005-0016  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRAD LEE MONTGOMERY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0016
2 CA-CR 2005-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHANCE RONALD COLLINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0102
2 CA-CR 2005-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MANUEL KEIFNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0152
2 CA-CR 2005-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SEYMOUR JAMEEL ABDULLAH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0212
2 CA-CR 2005-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ZACHARY SAMUEL EGGERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0320
Issues Summary: 1) Does A.R.S. § 13-501, which requires that juveniles charged with certain crimes automatically be tried as adults, violate due process under the Arizona and United States Constitutions? 2) Did the trial court err in failing to suppress the defendant’s confession, made prior to the defendant’s receiving Miranda warnings? 3) Did the trial court err in failing to suppress the defendant’s second confession, made immediately after he received Miranda warnings? 4) Does the imposition of a natural life sentence on a juvenile constitute cruel and usual punishment under the Arizona and United States Constitutions?


2 CA-CR 2005-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CARLOS SAUCEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0334
2 CA-CR 2005-0336  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERNESTO MENDEZ-CANEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0336
2 CA-CR 2005-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PIERRE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2005-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS LUCERO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0382
2 CA-CR 2005-0412  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINALDO GARCIA ALMAZAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0412
2 CA-CR 2005-0414  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMY LEON ALEXANDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0414
2 CA-CR 2005-0428  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT MICHAEL JOLLY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0428
2 CA-CR 2005-0430  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD EDELL WILLIAMS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0430
2 CA-CR 2005-0432  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN BRADLEY RADY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0432
2 CA-CR 2005-0433  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN BRADLEY RADY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2005-0433
2 CA-CR 2006-0002  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT JOSEPH WRIGHT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0002
Issues Summary: Did the trial court improperly exclude defendant’s psychiatric expert witness testimony offered to rebut the mental state element of the offense in violation of his due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and the Supreme Court’s holding in Clark v. Arizona, __ U.S. __, 125 S. Ct. 2709 (2006)?


2 CA-CR 2006-0003  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES DEMPSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0003
2 CA-CR 2006-0018  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LESLIE ZANE POST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0018
2 CA-CR 2006-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL REAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0024
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court violated the Sixth Amendment’s Confrontation Clause, as interpreted in Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36, 124 S. Ct. 1354 (2004), when it permitted a police officer who testified to a complete lack of memory to read from his police report at trial.


2 CA-CR 2006-0032  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON ANTHONY JOYNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0032
Issues Summary: In sentencing a defendant for a first offense of possession of a narcotic drug, marijuana, and drug paraphernalia, did the trial court err in concluding a defendant’s prior convictions for armed robbery and attempted armed robbery were convictions for violent crimes under the definition in A.R.S. § 13-604.04, making him ineligible for mandatory probation under A.R.S. § 13-901.01?


2 CA-CR 2006-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL AARON LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0036
Issues Summary: Whether statements made to a registered nurse performing a sexual assault examination qualify as “[s]tatements made for purposes of medical diagnosis or treatment” under Rule 803(4), Ariz. R. Evid., when the primary purpose of the examination is to look for injury and the nurse uses the victim’s statements to determine where to look for injury.


2 CA-CR 2006-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0046
2 CA-CR 2006-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MATTHEW BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0068
2 CA-CR 2006-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE RUIZ SANTA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0074
2 CA-CR 2006-0080  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ROBLES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0080
2 CA-CR 2006-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN RAUL SOTO-FONG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0091
2 CA-CR 2006-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN MARK KENNEDY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0102
2 CA-CR 2006-0110-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM KENNETH STILLWELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0110-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMINADAB ORDUNO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO RAY LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0122
2 CA-CR 2006-0124  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS FAQUNDO RODRIGUEZ-ZAYA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0124
2 CA-CR 2006-0126-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGELIO SALAZAR GASTELUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0126-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0128  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ELIZABETH MARY SHULKIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0128
2 CA-CR 2006-0132-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMIE LYNN LUCAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0132-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0134-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL PIERCE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0134-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINO DE LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0140
2 CA-CR 2006-0142  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN BENJAMIN BARRAZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0142
2 CA-CR 2006-0144  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN JAY OGG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0144
2 CA-CR 2006-0146  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY TODD WICKHAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0146
2 CA-CR 2006-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY D. HICKLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0152
2 CA-CR 2006-0156-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALLEN WATTERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0156-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN ANDREW VILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0158
2 CA-CR 2006-0180  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODRICK WADE HIGH-ELK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0180
2 CA-CR 2006-0182-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY NIDEZ VALENCIA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0182-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0184-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SELENA ALICIA CORONADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0184-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HARSIMMER SINGH SHERGILL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0188
2 CA-CR 2006-0198  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MATHIEU SALMOND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0198
2 CA-CR 2006-0202-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL VIRAMONTES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0202-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNOLD LONNIE BRODSKY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0206
2 CA-CR 2006-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS CHARLES HENRY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0208
2 CA-CR 2006-0209  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO CAMACHO VALDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0209
2 CA-CR 2006-0212  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES PATRICK SCANNELL, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0212
2 CA-CR 2006-0216  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KELLEY DIANNA TILLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0216
2 CA-CR 2006-0218  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CYNTHIA KAY NORTHCROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0218
2 CA-CR 2006-0222-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH L. SIGNORELLI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0222-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0227  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NORBERTO ACUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0227
2 CA-CR 2006-0234  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL M. DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0234
2 CA-CR 2006-0246-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS MICHAEL JAMES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0246-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0248  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC JOSEPH MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0248
2 CA-CR 2006-0250-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT GRIFFITH HOOVER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0250-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0257  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA EDWARD SYMONETTE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0257
2 CA-CR 2006-0262-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0262-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0264-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEROY GILBERT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0264-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0270
2 CA-CR 2006-0274  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG EUGENE MANKE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0274
2 CA-CR 2006-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY LEE RAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0276
2 CA-CR 2006-0284-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD DE LA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0284-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN DEVONN WHITELOW  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0286
2 CA-CR 2006-0294  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE SANTOS ARTIAGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0294
2 CA-CR 2006-0296  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE GILBERT FIELDER, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0296
2 CA-CR 2006-0298  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FELIPE HURTADO SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0298
2 CA-CR 2006-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS EUGENE WAITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0300
2 CA-CR 2006-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL MARCUS WALTERS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0308-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER MATTHEW TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0308-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0312-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT OTHA JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0312-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL MARTIN-SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0314
2 CA-CR 2006-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY PETER TULL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0315
2 CA-CR 2006-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD FENLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0324  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICAH S. BENNETT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0324
Issues Summary: Whether the admission of an affidavit authenticating a defendant’s prior conviction records, offered without testimony, violates the Sixth Amendment’s confrontation clause under Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36, 124 S. Ct. 1354 (2004).


2 CA-CR 2006-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON SCOTT GUNDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0338-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY PAUL RAMIREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0338-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN EARL MITCHELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0348
2 CA-CR 2006-0350  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN FRANCES GARDNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0350
2 CA-CR 2006-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS ALDANA GUEVARA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0362-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0362-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY GENE GEORGESON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0372
2 CA-CR 2006-0374-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD FISHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0374-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY TYSON CURTIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0376
2 CA-CR 2006-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN EARL MITCHELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0380
2 CA-CR 2006-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERMAYNE DWIGHT GAINOUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0382
2 CA-CR 2006-0384  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SIXTO GERALDO MATUS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0384
2 CA-CR 2006-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM LEE YORK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0388
2 CA-CR 2006-0394-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. UDON McSPADDEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0394-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0396-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES F. WEAVER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0396-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0400  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL MEJIAS MONDESI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0400
2 CA-CR 2006-0408  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADERSON MELRON GOOLSBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0408
2 CA-CR 2006-0410-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL GABRIEL CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0410-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0412  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS LIONEL LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0412
2 CA-CR 2006-0413  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES CHRISTOPHER HODGES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0413
2 CA-CR 2006-0418  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAUDIO VALDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0418
2 CA-CR 2006-0420  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO FIERRO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0420
2 CA-CR 2006-0422  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL L. McALEE, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0422
2 CA-CR 2006-0424  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEQUAUN McLEAN, aka DEQUAN McLEAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0424
2 CA-CR 2006-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WENDY SUE ANDERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0428-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PIERRE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0428-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0430-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN WHEDBEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0430-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0434  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE LEE FRONTERHOUSE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0434
2 CA-CR 2006-0436  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL ANTONIO PARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0436
2 CA-CR 2006-0440  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES SILAS GASTELUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0440
2 CA-CR 2006-0441  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINALDO OCANO MOLINA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0441
2 CA-CR 2006-0446-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIO A. VELASQUEZ-GASTELUM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2006-0446-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0002  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VERNON LEE BULLOCK, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0002
2 CA-CR 2007-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS ALLEN MCCONNELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0004
2 CA-CR 2007-0006-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONALD LESLIE MURRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0006-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0014-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN SERRANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0014-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0020  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO ALONZO RUBIO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0020
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant must use an available peremptory strike to cure the trial court’s alleged error in denying a challenge for cause, or waive the right to raise that error on appeal.


2 CA-CR 2007-0022-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL L. HARRELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0022-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0024-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS TELLEZ POBLETE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0024-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JANELLE SHAELENE FRYER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0026
2 CA-CR 2007-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY JOSEPH STRINGER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0034
2 CA-CR 2007-0039-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD PATRICK VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0039-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0040-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO LAZARO GONZALEZ, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0040-PR
Issues Summary: May a defendant who has been convicted of attempted sexual conduct with an eleven-year-old victim properly be sentenced pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-604.01 for a dangerous crime against children?


2 CA-CR 2007-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY KEVIN OWENS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0046
2 CA-CR 2007-0048  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK WILLIAM HAFFNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0048
2 CA-CR 2007-0054  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BEN GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0054
2 CA-CR 2007-0060-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRYSTAL JEN VINDIOLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0060-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0062  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN RAY PAXTON, SR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0062
2 CA-CR 2007-0066  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VICTOR MANUEL CAMPOY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0066
2 CA-CR 2007-0072  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID WINDHORST  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0072
2 CA-CR 2007-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN DE NEAN EDMISTEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0074
Issues Summary: When a defendant presents evidence of involuntary intoxication in an attempt to negate the culpable mental state for the offenses charged, does the burden of proof shift from the state to the defendant?


2 CA-CR 2007-0081  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALVESTER FORT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0081
2 CA-CR 2007-0082  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MANUEL ROMERO-RABAGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0082
2 CA-CR 2007-0084-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES ALLEN HILLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0084-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0086  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON KEITH CAMPBELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0086
2 CA-CR 2007-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN DANIEL TAYLOR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0092  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHOREI MICHAEL SHEEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0092
2 CA-CR 2007-0100-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD LOPEZ DE LA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0100-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD RAYMOND TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0102
2 CA-CR 2007-0108  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT WILLIAM WHITE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0108
2 CA-CR 2007-0111-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARC EDWARD LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0111-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL PATRICK MOYNIHAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0112
2 CA-CR 2007-0116-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE O. SANTA CRUZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0116-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0118  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD R. PALMER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0118
2 CA-CR 2007-0128-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN GAWLEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0128-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0132  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAGE GRAINGER STUART  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0132
2 CA-CR 2007-0138-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD CARTER CRABTREE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0138-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY MEJIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0140
2 CA-CR 2007-0148-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER GEORGE KISS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0148-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0151-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER EARL YOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0151-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CECIL DELROY BECKFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0152
2 CA-CR 2007-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EUGENE YODER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0154-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT CARLOS GARCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0156
Issues Summary: In a first-degree murder prosecution in which the jury was instructed on the lesser included offenses of second-degree murder and manslaughter, did the trial court commit fundamental error by instructing the jury to consider manslaughter only if it found the defendant not guilty of second-degree murder or could not agree on that offense, instead of instructing it to consider second-degree murder and manslaughter simultaneously?


2 CA-CR 2007-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANVILLE JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0158
2 CA-CR 2007-0160  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE BENJAMIN MORANDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0160
2 CA-CR 2007-0164-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FINN MACCOOL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0164-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LANCE CHRISTIAN HAMBLIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0166
Issues Summary: Does a person commit third-degree burglary as defined in A.R.S. § 13-1506 by entering an unlocked motor vehicle with intent to commit a felony or theft therein?


2 CA-CR 2007-0170  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARDO FRANCISCO AMADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0170
2 CA-CR 2007-0178  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENYA ZANZIBAR TOUSSAINT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0178
2 CA-CR 2007-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN RICHARD PIPER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0186
2 CA-CR 2007-0190-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO JOSE FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0190-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0192  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER DALE TARKINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0192
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant may challenge a search on Fourth Amendment grounds based on his property interest in the item seized even though he has no legitimate expectation of privacy in the premises searched.


2 CA-CR 2007-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ALBERTO MORENO-MEDRANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0202
Issues Summary: 1. Whether the trial court fundamentally erred in failing to make required findings before imposing fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 11-584 and Rule 6.7(d), Ariz. R. Crim. P.

2. Whether the trial court fundamentally erred in reducing indigent defense fees to a criminal restitution order at sentencing.


2 CA-CR 2007-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EMILIO URENA-VILLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0208
2 CA-CR 2007-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAKI DAVID PRICE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0210
Issues Summary: 1. Whether convictions for both aggravated assault and armed robbery violated double jeopardy principles.

2. Whether trial to an eight-person jury constituted fundamental error.


2 CA-CR 2007-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSIE LABRANNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0218  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY CHRISTOPHER HAIGHT-GYURO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0218
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion by admitting into evidence a video recording made by a retail store’s surveillance system when no witness who had been present during the events recorded testified at trial?


2 CA-CR 2007-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO VARGAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCELO PEREZ MUNGUIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0222
2 CA-CR 2007-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER RAFAEL SOTELO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0226
2 CA-CR 2007-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAY BERNARD GILLILLAND  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0233
2 CA-CR 2007-0238  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE MENDOZA HERRERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0238
2 CA-CR 2007-0242-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY FRANCIS HENRY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0242-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTONIO RODRIGUEZ MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0246
2 CA-CR 2007-0254-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MARTIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0254-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO CANO SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0256
2 CA-CR 2007-0260-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY VIRAMONTES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0260-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0262-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MASUM JAMES VIJAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0262-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0264  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW SWEETIE WARRIOR, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0264
2 CA-CR 2007-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY LEE LINDSAY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0270
2 CA-CR 2007-0272-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEX ROBERT BERMUDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0272-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0274-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM FRANCIS ROUSH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0274-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT FISHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0276
2 CA-CR 2007-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT FISHER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0276
2 CA-CR 2007-0280  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY BERNARD ENGEBRETSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0280
2 CA-CR 2007-0286-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL KEVIN BLACKSTOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0286-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0288  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR TAPIA HERNANDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0288
2 CA-CR 2007-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL MENDOZA LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE RENEE LOPER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0300
2 CA-CR 2007-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE SARMIENTO SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS SERRANO SAMANIEGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0306
2 CA-CR 2007-0308  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL A. WELCH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0308
2 CA-CR 2007-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALAN DETRICK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0310
2 CA-CR 2007-0311  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT SANCHEZ ESCOBEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0311
2 CA-CR 2007-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY RUSHING  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS PAUL PHILLIPS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0320
2 CA-CR 2007-0322  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REYNA G. MORALES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0322
2 CA-CR 2007-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN JAY CALAWAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0328
2 CA-CR 2007-0329  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BOBBY JOSEPH HARRIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0329
2 CA-CR 2007-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS RAUL LEON FLORES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0334
2 CA-CR 2007-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY LUGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0336-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0342  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TANYA YVONNE HAMILTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0342
2 CA-CR 2007-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO ARTURO SALAZAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0348
2 CA-CR 2007-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ARNOLD CHACON SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0360-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUSTIN KYLE SHEETS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0360-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0362-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY IAN AARON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0362-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0363  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL FRANCISCO VASQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0363
2 CA-CR 2007-0366  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEREK RUSSELL THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0366
2 CA-CR 2007-0372-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS MICHAEL LEVITSKI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0372-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CASTRO ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0374
2 CA-CR 2007-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER THOMAS WARD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0376
2 CA-CR 2007-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELODY LYNN DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0380
2 CA-CR 2007-0384-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLSIE COLSTON III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0384-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DOUGLAS ELAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0388
2 CA-CR 2007-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS MARTIN SANDOVAL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0390
2 CA-CR 2007-0394-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL MORAGA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0394-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0398  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE CHIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0398
2 CA-CR 2007-0400-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEROME EDWIN ARNOLDI, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0400-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0404  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES LEE HYFIELD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0404
2 CA-CR 2007-0408  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL KEON CURTIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0408
2 CA-CR 2007-0411  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT A. BONANNO, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0411
2 CA-CR 2007-0412  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO PENA, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2007-0412
2 CA-CR 2008-0002  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HECTOR RODRIGUEZ RUIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0002
2 CA-CR 2008-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DALE HUNTINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0004
2 CA-CR 2008-0010-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA HARRISON KITTS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0010-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0012-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PIERRE BAKER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0012-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0016  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON MARTIN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0016
2 CA-CR 2008-0018-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRED WILLIAM ANDREWS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0018-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0022-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES E. COLLINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0022-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0024
Issues Summary: Whether probable cause supported the arrest of a passenger when the vehicle in which he was riding, its location, and the manner in which drugs were concealed corresponded to specific information police officers had received from an informant and indicated the passenger and driver were working in concert to transport the drugs.


2 CA-CR 2008-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RENARD REED III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0026
2 CA-CR 2008-0028-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUHA KIVINEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0028-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0030  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELISSA MARIE ARRINGTON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0030
2 CA-CR 2008-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSIE JAMES ROBINSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0038
2 CA-CR 2008-0042-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRY MICHAEL MILLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0042-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0045  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER LEE AWTREY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0045
2 CA-CR 2008-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DAVID LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0046
2 CA-CR 2008-0048-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE LUIS VELASQUEZ ORDUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0048-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0050  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAUDE RANDALL GEORGE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0050
2 CA-CR 2008-0052  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS GEORGE CORTESE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0052
2 CA-CR 2008-0056  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICKY LAMAR SIMMONS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0056
2 CA-CR 2008-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DON BRYANT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0058
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in modifying an illegally lenient sentence when the state did not appeal the sentence but instead filed a motion for reconsideration after the time for appeal had run?


2 CA-CR 2008-0067  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUMBERTO LOPEZ SEPULVEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0067
2 CA-CR 2008-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL ANGEL ZEBADUA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0074
2 CA-CR 2008-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE JAMES THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0078
2 CA-CR 2008-0082  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHANIE HOLFORD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0082
2 CA-CR 2008-0084-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JASON EDWARD DEAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0084-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0086-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID REY SANTILLANO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0086-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0088-PR  THE STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DEAN McCOY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0088-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0089  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEON DEAN LONG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0089
2 CA-CR 2008-0092  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HAMONI VOLE VEAMATAHAU  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0092
2 CA-CR 2008-0094-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONNELL THOMAS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0094-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0104  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN ALEXANDER McKENNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0104
2 CA-CR 2008-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY CHARLES MONK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0106
2 CA-CR 2008-0107  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENA ARLIEN BREWER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0107
2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ALCANTAR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0114  STATE OF ARIZONA v. J. JESUS BARRIGA ACEVEDO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0114
2 CA-CR 2008-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAMON C. ROSTHENHAUSLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0136  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCADO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0136
2 CA-CR 2008-0138-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FEDERICO AROS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0138-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0144  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL MARK DURSO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0144
2 CA-CR 2008-0150  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM DENNIS LEE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0150
2 CA-CR 2008-0154  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDREW VINCENT BUTTAFUOCO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0154
2 CA-CR 2008-0160-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MEREDITH WAYNE KELLY, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0160-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0162-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM CHAPMAN MACH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0162-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0164-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEMETRIUS MOORE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0164-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0168  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO J. GALAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0168
2 CA-CR 2008-0175  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRITNI KAY KUHFELD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0175
2 CA-CR 2008-0178-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD WILLIAM FARIS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0178-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WILLIAM STENZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0182
2 CA-CR 2008-0190-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY COLMENERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0190-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0192  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM RAMOS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0192
2 CA-CR 2008-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID G. MILLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE MENDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0202
2 CA-CR 2008-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LELAND LEWIS HOGAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0206
2 CA-CR 2008-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WESLEY HOWARD, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0208
2 CA-CR 2008-0214-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLY GENE CUMMINGS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0214-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWIN ANTHONY PELLECIER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0218-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LAURENCE HARVEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0218-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARON SYLVESTER GREEN II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ORVIE ROWLAND STRECK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0226
Issues Summary: 1. Is a tractor a means of transportation for purposes of A.R.S. § 13-1814? 2. Are a victim’s travel costs incurred in investigating stolen property compensable expenses?


2 CA-CR 2008-0228  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RANDALL HALSTEAD  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0228
2 CA-CR 2008-0238  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERENA MARIE CABALLERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0238
2 CA-CR 2008-0240  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER FIMBRES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0240
Issues Summary: When a defendant is indicted under one subsection of a statute, is the trial court’s subject matter jurisdiction implicated when it subsequently instructs the jury on multiple subsections of the same statute?


2 CA-CR 2008-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT ALLEN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0246
2 CA-CR 2008-0248  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REFUGIO RINCON, aka ARTURO MARTINEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0248
2 CA-CR 2008-0250  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMADI SCHALON CANNON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0250
2 CA-CR 2008-0254  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY ALEXANDER CONGRESS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0254
2 CA-CR 2008-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRICE LOOBY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0256
2 CA-CR 2008-0262  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENE FLORES LEYVA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0262
2 CA-CR 2008-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE CALVIN HURSEY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0265
2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHESTER LEON AXSOM, II  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0274  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JULIAN ADRIAN WYATT  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0274
2 CA-CR 2008-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS CHRISTOPHER DALZELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0276
2 CA-CR 2008-0280-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD WAYNE HUGGINS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0280-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN WILDMAN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0302  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL SANCHEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0302
2 CA-CR 2008-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE MENDEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0306-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN CONRAD WHEELOCK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0306-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0308-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK S. BRASHIER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0308-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0314
2 CA-CR 2008-0316  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0316
2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENIE VARELA VALENCIA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0324  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIKA IRENE OZUNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0324
2 CA-CR 2008-0326  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID PATRICK YOUNG  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0326
2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SILVIA ESTRELLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHMOND OWEN CLARK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0344  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANN SINCLAIR  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0344
2 CA-CR 2008-0354-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KRISTOFER ROBIN BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0354-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE YSIDRO SPERLE  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON CAMPBELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0362  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WAYNE EVAN COATES  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0362
2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLSIE COLSTON, III  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0368  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DANIEL VAUGHN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0368
2 CA-CR 2008-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUSTIN ANTHONY ORTIZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0372
2 CA-CR 2008-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE JOE BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0374
2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELVIN STANDISH WOPSCHALL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALFREDO PERALTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDEL PAEZ IBARRA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0392
2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL F. CRAGO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0410-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES WAYNE MARIETTA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0410-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0418  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELLISA FINLAYSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0418
2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL MARIO CASTANEDA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE L. TURNER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0010-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOEL ALEJANDRO ALCAREZ-GUERRERO  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0010-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY BELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL DAVID RICHARDSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0060-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ACENCION LEON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0060-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0072-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0072-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0106-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY CORNELL  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0106-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0119-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODRICK WADE HIGH-ELK  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0119-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANVILLE JACKSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0132-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GILBERT VALENTE BOJORQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0132-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY TERRELL THOMPSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0146-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OMAR GUADALUPE PEREZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0146-PR
2 CA-CV 2005-0078  RALPH WILKENS CO., INC. v. DYKES dba PATRICK'S ANTIQUE CARS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2005-0078
2 CA-CV 2006-0055  GOMEZ v. DAIMLERCHRYSLER MOTORS and JIM CLICK, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0055
2 CA-CV 2006-0064  ALLISON and CREIGHTON v. JOHNSTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0064
2 CA-CV 2006-0065  STEIN v. SONUS USA, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0065
Issues Summary: Whether a hearing aid is an “assistive device” for purposes of A.R.S. §§ 44-1351 through 44-1355, governing assistive device warranties.


2 CA-CV 2006-0081  MACHADO v. MACHADO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0081
2 CA-CV 2006-0082  DANIELS v. CORRECTIONS CORP. OF AMERICA; BENJAMIN, M.D.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0082
2 CA-CV 2006-0086  MARIPOSA ENT., INC. v. LAWYERS TITLE OF ARIZONA, as Trustee,  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0086
2 CA-CV 2006-0092  FLYING DIAMOND AIRPARK, LLC v. MEIENBERG  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0092
Issues Summary: Whether a violation of a restrictive covenant is “intentional,” for purposes of considering the relative hardships to the parties in an action for injunctive relief, when a property owner completes construction of a structure violating the restriction although knowing of the restriction and learning of opposition to the structure during construction.


2 CA-CV 2006-0109  SWIEGART and ABAD v. WASATCH PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0109
2 CA-CV 2006-0110  TAVAREZ v. BRACAMONTE-DAVIS; and DAVIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0110
2 CA-CV 2006-0116  ACOSTA v. PHOENIX INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0116
Issues Summary: Did an insurance company act in bad faith by refusing settlement offers from a plaintiff injured in an automobile accident when: 1) there was a legitimate issue whether its policy covered the claim, and 2) the defendant driver of the vehicle filed a bankruptcy petition before the plaintiff made a second settlement offer?


2 CA-CV 2006-0120  CHALONER v. L & C CONSTRUCTION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0120
2 CA-CV 2006-0122  RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION v. CLIFTON; and LAWYERS TITLE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0122
2 CA-CV 2006-0128  WILLIAMS v. BAUGH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0128
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 13-807 precludes a criminal defendant from raising the affirmative defenses of justification, contributory negligence, and comparative fault in a subsequent civil action.


2 CA-CV 2006-0151  MATZ and SOUTHWEST VETERINARY v. MERIDETH, KLEIN; and VETERINARY INVESTMENTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0151
2 CA-CV 2006-0158  GUTIERREZ v. GUTIERREZ VEGA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0158
2 CA-CV 2006-0164  ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY v. LISA RIDGELY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0164
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err when, relying on the “sham affidavit rule,” it refused to consider on summary judgment deposition testimony that contradicted the deponent’s prior sworn statement?


2 CA-CV 2006-0166  LEPPER and RACUS v. PREBLE-COLLINS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0166
2 CA-CV 2006-0172  HONEYCUTT v. JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0172
2 CA-CV 2006-0176  DUBE v. LIKINS; POWELL; HIXON; BOARD OF REGENTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0176
Issues Summary: I. Whether, for the purposes of stating a claim of tortious interference with a business expectancy, (a) University Officials’ alleged failures constituted intentional, improper conduct; (b) whether the general prospect of employment upon obtaining a graduate degree constitutes an expectancy; and (c) whether the claim was timely filed.

II. Whether a cause of action for defamation—based on letters sent to third parties—accrues on the date the letters are published or the date the plaintiff discovered or reasonably should have discovered the existence of the letters.

III. Whether communications between two agents of the same principal constitute “publication” for defamation purposes.


2 CA-CV 2006-0177  KAMAN AEROSPACE CORP. v. ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0177
Issues Summary: In a dispute between the Arizona Board of Regents (“ABOR”) and Kaman involving competing breach of contract claims: 1) Did the trial court err in denying ABOR’s motions for summary judgment and judgment as a matter of law on Kaman’s claim because Kaman had failed to prove an authorized signatory had executed contract modifications on ABOR’s behalf? 2) Would reversal of the judgment in favor of Kaman on its breach of contract claim mandate a reversal of the judgment in favor of Kaman on ABOR’s counterclaim? 3) On Kaman’s cross-appeal, did the court err when it declined to award Kaman attorney fees?


2 CA-CV 2006-0180  ANTONE v. GREATER ARIZONA AUTO AUCTION, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0180
Issues Summary: Is a commercial car auctioneer a seller under A.R.S. § 12-681(9) and therefore subject to strict product liability under Arizona law?


2 CA-CV 2006-0182  MILLS; DELLA SANTA v. WOODLOCK; LITTLE & LITTLE, P.C.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0182
2 CA-CV 2006-0188  HOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION v. CITY OF MARICOPA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0188
Issues Summary: Whether Pinal County had the statutory authority to enter into development agreements providing no development fees would be imposed on the developments and whether subsequently incorporated City of Maricopa is bound by those agreements.


2 CA-CV 2006-0206  ROBSON RANCH QUAIL CREEK, LLC v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0206
Issues Summary: 1) Whether Pima County’s sewer connection fee ordinance, as amended in 2005, is subject to the reasonable relationship requirement of A.R.S. § 11-821.

2) Whether the 2005 amendment to Pima County’s sewer connection fee ordinance unconstitutionally impaired an existing sewer fee agreement between Pima County and Robson Ranch Quail Creek, LLC.


2 CA-CV 2006-0208  GALLEGOS v. TALALAEV, M.D.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0208
2 CA-CV 2006-0210  LEVERAGED LAND CO.; and MONTGOMERY v. HODGES, et al.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0210
2 CA-CV 2006-0232  CANALES v. MENDEZ, ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2006-0232
2 CA-CV 2007-0006  MCCLOUD v. STATE OF ARIZONA; DEPT. OF PUBLIC SAFETY; and KIMBRO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0006
Issues Summary: Plaintiff was injured when a state employee’s vehicle collided with hers, and the trial court granted the state’s motion to dismiss the plaintiff’s complaint, filed after the one-year limitations period applicable to suits against the state had expired. 1. Did the trial court err by declining to apply the doctrine of equitable tolling to the complaint when the plaintiff’s attorney suffered various illnesses and family misfortunes, as did his backup attorney? 2. Did the trial court err by dismissing the plaintiff’s complaint against the state employee in his individual, private capacity, to which the two-year limitations period applied?


2 CA-CV 2007-0010  CARROLL MICHAEL v. CLINT EVAN MCGEE   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0010
2 CA-CV 2007-0016  CAROL M. JONES v. JAYSON JONES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0016
2 CA-CV 2007-0018  JAMES L. CRISSEY v. ELITE PERFORMANCE, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0018
2 CA-CV 2007-0020  CULLEN v. KOTY-LEAVITT INSURANCE AGENCY, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0020
Issues Summary: Where plaintiff’s complaint alleged he had a reasonable expectation of underinsured motorist insurance coverage under a policy issued by defendant to an entity that provided a vehicle to the plaintiff’s family for its private use, and the plaintiff was not injured while occupying that vehicle, but instead while riding in a vehicle not covered by the insurance policy, did the trial court err in granting the defendant’s motion to dismiss made pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6), Ariz. R. Civ. P., 16A A.R.S., Pt. 1, plaintiff’s complaint for breach of contract and bad faith failure to pay a valid insurance claim?


2 CA-CV 2007-0022  GASTON P. JENNETT III v. REBECCA TICE JENNETT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0022
2 CA-CV 2007-0030  RANCHO CANCION EAST HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION v. FETZER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0030
2 CA-CV 2007-0034  JACQUELINE PYRDECK v. FRANK S. PYRDECK, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0034
2 CA-CV 2007-0041  CATHERINE E. WARNER v. SOUTHWEST DESERT IMAGES, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0041
Issues Summary: In plaintiff’s negligence action, did the trial court err by: 1. Granting a directed verdict in favor of an employee defendant after granting the plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment on the issue of that employee’s negligence and the corresponding vicarious liability of his employer? 2. Dismissing plaintiff’s claims against two parties for failure to file an expert opinion affidavit as required by A.R.S. § 12-2602? 3. Denying plaintiff’s request for a punitive damages jury instruction? 4. Excluding evidence of the plaintiff’s workers’ compensation benefits and her workers’ compensation carrier’s § 23-1023 lien against her recovery? 5. Declining to answer juror questions asked during trial? 6. Granting the appellees’ sanctions pursuant to Rule 68, Ariz. R. Civ. P., when plaintiff was unable to accept appellees’ offer of judgment without her workers’ compensation carrier’s approval?


2 CA-CV 2007-0048  NORTHLAND PROMONTORY II, LLC v. CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0048
2 CA-CV 2007-0052  BUCHANAN v. PINAL COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0052
2 CA-CV 2007-0054  MICHAEL W. TONEY v. THE CITY OF TUCSON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0054
2 CA-CV 2007-0056  CRAIG MORTON v. SHERRI MORTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0056
2 CA-CV 2007-0064  IN THE MATTER OF: ONE RESIDENCE LOCATED AT 8444 E. Agape Dr.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0064
2 CA-CV 2007-0070  HARTER v. COCHISE COUNTY   Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0070
2 CA-CV 2007-0072  IN THE MATTER OF BOND FORFEITURE IN THE AMOUNT OF $15,000  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0072
2 CA-CV 2007-0084  MANU DUBE v. CHANDRA S. DESAI and PATRICIA DESAI  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0084
Issues Summary: Whether trial court was correct in granting summary judgment to appellee based on its conclusions that appellee acted within scope of employment as a public employee when committing the alleged tortious acts and that therefore appellant’s failure to comply with notice requirements of A.R.S. § 12-821.01 required dismissal of the complaint.


2 CA-CV 2007-0094  In the Matter of the Estate of: WILLIAM NATHAN SPENCER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0094
2 CA-CV 2007-0096  JERRY BINKLEY v. PINAL COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0096
2 CA-CV 2007-0104  CITY OF TUCSON v. CLEAR CHANNEL OUTDOOR, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0104
Issues Summary: 1. Whether the statute of limitations period contained in A.R.S. § 9-462.02 includes a due diligence element. 2. Whether billboards built or maintained in violation of repealed sign ordinances at the time of their repeal can be regulated under the current sign ordinances. 3. Whether the addition of a second face to certain billboards caused those billboards to lose their legal nonconforming status. 4. Whether the trial court has the discretion to order removal, remediation, or no relief at all with respect to billboards found in violation of the current code; and whether it abused that discretion.


2 CA-CV 2007-0108  PAT SPAULDING v. MICHAEL POULIOT, ET AL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0108
Issues Summary: 1. When a party claimed to have acquired property rights by prescriptive easement and adverse possession, did the trial court err in utilizing a presumption that such use is with the property owner’s permission?

2. When the property owner did not dispute that the claimant and his predecessor in interest had used the property openly, notoriously, and without interference for nearly forty years, did the evidence in this quiet title action support the trial court’s ruling that the claimant had failed to prove he had acquired rights to the property by prescriptive easement and adverse possession?


2 CA-CV 2007-0118  RONALD G. MORALES v. ROGER BARNETT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0118
2 CA-CV 2007-0120  KINO MEADOWS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION v. KASHMAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0120
2 CA-CV 2007-0132  JAMES COLT JONES, ET AL. v. COCHISE COUNTY, ET AL.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0132
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of Cochise County on the Joneses’ tort claims on the ground that their notice of claim, filed pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-821.01, was insufficient?


2 CA-CV 2007-0136  ALISA SALVESTRINI v. TIMOTHY PORTIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0136
2 CA-CV 2007-0142  MANU DUBE v C. DESAI, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0142
2 CA-CV 2007-0152  TADAYON v. MACKENZIE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0152
2 CA-CV 2007-0156  CALMAT CO. dba VULCAN MATERIALS CO. v. WESTFALL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0156
2 CA-CV 2007-0160  JEFFERY HARRIS v. CITY OF BISBEE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0160
Issues Summary: When the Bisbee city clerk refused to process referendum petitions and invalidated entire pages of signatures because it appeared the circulator had altered some petition signers’ printed names and addresses outside their presence and without their permission, did the trial court err in finding the petitions legally sufficient pursuant to A.R.S. § 19-122(A) and ordering the city clerk to process them?


2 CA-CV 2007-0166  MARTINEZ v. MJKL ENTERPRISES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2007-0166
2 CA-CV 2008-0002  RHONDA DENISE SMITH v. HOWARD EDWARD SMITH, III  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0002
2 CA-CV 2008-0010  DANIEL GARDNER v. STUDIO 6  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0010
2 CA-CV 2008-0012  IN THE MATTER OF $1,034.00 IN U.S. CURRENCY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0012
2 CA-CV 2008-0016  MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT ANTHONY WILLIAMS, JR.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0016
2 CA-CV 2008-0020  KAREN MACKENZIE v. RICHARD J. MANGANIELLO  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0020
2 CA-CV 2008-0028  LISA FRANK v. JAMES A. GREEN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0028
Issues Summary: 1. Does this court have jurisdiction to consider an appeal from a sanctions order entered pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-864? 2. Did the trial court err in sanctioning the appellant’s violations of court orders by dismissing the appellant’s cross-claim against appellee, striking his reply to the appellee’s counterclaim, and entering default judgment in favor of the appellee? 3. Did the trial court err by entering default judgment on appellee’s claims brought pursuant to A.R.S. § 10-809, 18 U.S.C. § 1030, and Title 17 of the United States Code, respectively?


2 CA-CV 2008-0030  EDMUNDO CORDERO v. MICHAEL A. BOSCO, JR., TIFFANY & BOSCO, P.A., ...  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0030
2 CA-CV 2008-0034  JONATHA M. HOPF, LAURA HOFF, VALERIE CRUZ v. DOROTHY J. FIELDS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0034
2 CA-CV 2008-0039  RALPH A. PENA, JR. v. ADOC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0039
2 CA-CV 2008-0052  FIVE POINTS HOTEL PARTNERSHIP v. PACIONI; ESTATE OF KOENIG  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0052
2 CA-CV 2008-0054  GEORGE A. WISE v. BERTRAM POLIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0054
2 CA-CV 2008-0062  JOSEPH M. ARPAIO v. CITIZEN PUBLISHING CO.; MARK KIMBLE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0062
Issues Summary: In a declaratory judgment action, does A.R.S. § 39-121.02(B) permit a trial court to award attorney fees to a party requesting public records against a non-custodian party objecting to the records request?


2 CA-CV 2008-0072  ELTON R. TINGLE v. NEW CENTURY MORTGAGE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0072
2 CA-CV 2008-0074  JAMES J. McMANUS v. TUCSON MEDICAL CENTER FOUNDATION  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0074
2 CA-CV 2008-0076  TADARRYL SMITH v. SITCHEL YEASIN; YELLOW CAB  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0076
2 CA-CV 2008-0080  JAMES J. RUNYON v. THE STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0080
2 CA-CV 2008-0083  JERRY WORTHY v. IRIS WORTHY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0083
2 CA-CV 2008-0091  JOANN AGUILAR. v. R.W. STRUNK EXCAVATING, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0091
2 CA-CV 2008-0096  MILUS v. EL DORADO HOSPITAL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0096
2 CA-CV 2008-0106  BECERRA v. TUCSON POLICE DEPT.; CITY OF TUCSON; HAWKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0106
2 CA-CV 2008-0108  JOHN V. DOMMISSE v. JABURG & WILK, PC; MARTON; BOGARD; LAZAROW  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0108
2 CA-CV 2008-0114  MARIE BREI and JASON BREI v. RALPH G. DURAN  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0114
2 CA-CV 2008-0116  PANTELE v. ELLIOTT; JARNAGIN; RAY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0116
2 CA-CV 2008-0118  MODULAR MINING SYSTEMS, INC. v. JIGSAW TECHNOLOGIES, INC.; OLSON; BLACUTT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0118
Issues Summary: (1) Did the trial court err in determining that appellant’s claim for injunctive relief was moot, where appellant did not contest appellee’s assertion that it had discontinued all use of the computer configuration appellant alleged to be trade secrets? (2) Did the trial court err in granting appellee’s motion for summary judgment on appellant’s claim of trade secret misappropriation? (3) Did the trial court err in awarding appellee its attorney fees under A.R.S. §§ 12-341.01 and 44-404?


2 CA-CV 2008-0120  JAMES A. GREEN v. LISA FRANK, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0120
2 CA-CV 2008-0124  STANLEY RIOS v. RICHARD C. BRUMGARD and KAY E. BRUMGARD  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0124
2 CA-CV 2008-0136  KATHRYN CHAFFIN-HONDA ... v. CHERYL LYNN REYNOLDS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0136
2 CA-CV 2008-0144  SANDRA SPENCER v. JOHN ULREICH, JUDITH ULREICH  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0144
2 CA-CV 2008-0146  COUNTY OF COCHISE v. SEBASTIAO FARIA and MARIA FARI dba FARIA DAIRY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0146
Issues Summary: Whether commercial feedlots and “other like businesses” under A.R.S. § 11-821.01(A) are exempt from regulation as uses for agricultural purposes under A.R.S. 11-830(A)(2).


2 CA-CV 2008-0148  TRIPATI v. TUCKER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0148
Issues Summary: 1. When a party challenges a previously granted deferral of a filing fee under A.R.S. § 12 302, does the deferral applicant retain the burden of proving he or she is indigent? 2. Does a trial court err in considering evidence that the deferral applicant controls or has access to the resources of third parties?


2 CA-CV 2008-0150  ACTION FINANCIAL IV, LLC v. JOE and JOSIE LOPEZ  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0150
2 CA-CV 2008-0168  PRATT v. PRITZL; ARIZONA BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0168
2 CA-CV 2008-0176  PIMA COUNTY v. PIMA COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0176
2 CA-CV 2008-0190  HAROUTUNIAN v. VALUEOPTIONS, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0190
2 CA-CV 2008-0198  ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ADMINSTRATION v. COX  Participating 2 CA-CV 2008-0198
Issues Summary: Whether and to what extent the Arizona Department of Administration may recover, under A.R.S. § 12-962, the cost of medical care provided to participants in the state health insurance plan for injuries sustained as a result of third-party tort liability when the participants received compensation from that third party.


2 CA-CV 2009-0002  GOODMAN v. PIMA COUNTY; TDB TUCSON GROUP  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0002
2 CA-CV 2009-0070  BAKER v. DAVENPORT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2009-0070
2 CA-HC 2006-0002  EDWARD GOLDWATER v. JUDY FREIGO  Participating 2 CA-HC 2006-0002
2 CA-HC 2008-0002  RAYMOND EARL RIGSBY v. ROBERT STEWART, WARDEN; ADOC  Participating 2 CA-HC 2008-0002
2 CA-IC 2006-0022  JAROSLAV HYPL v. CPS FOR LEASED WORKERS TO CORE EXPRESS, CORE EXPRESS   Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0022
2 CA-IC 2006-0024  RICHARDSON v. RINGLER PLUMBING   Participating 2 CA-IC 2006-0024
2 CA-IC 2007-0004  ARTHUR R. OLIVAS v. CITY OF TUCSON c/o PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES   Participating 2 CA-IC 2007-0004
2 CA-IC 2008-0008  JIM CLICK AUTO MALL; HARCO NATIONAL INS CO. v. ICA; KEVIN LARSON  Participating 2 CA-IC 2008-0008
2 CA-IC 2009-0002  ROBERTSON (DECEASED);ROBERTSON v. CIRCLE JMR CORP.; SCF ARIZ  Participating 2 CA-IC 2009-0002
2 CA-JV 2005-0078  BONNIE H., WILLIE G. v. ADES., NYKOLE G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2005-0078
2 CA-JV 2006-0022  LEE ANNE A. v. ADES, ALEAH M., ALYSSE M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0022
2 CA-JV 2006-0030  IN RE LIZBETH C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0030
2 CA-JV 2006-0034  IN RE DEISHA D.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0034
2 CA-JV 2006-0040  DAVID T. v. LAURA E., ARIELLA B.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0040
2 CA-JV 2006-0044  IN RE STEPHEN R.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0044
2 CA-JV 2006-0046  IN RE RICARDO M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0046
2 CA-JV 2006-0056  HEATHER G. v. ADES, GABRIEL A., RAFAEL M.-O., LILIANA M.-O., MARIE M.-O., ANTONIO M.-O.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0056
2 CA-JV 2006-0060  IN RE NICO S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0060
2 CA-JV 2006-0062  IN RE JOHN T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0062
2 CA-JV 2006-0064  IN RE AARON D.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0064
2 CA-JV 2006-0066  TERESA C. v. ADES, CASPARE W., KODY B., BAYVIN K.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0066
2 CA-JV 2006-0070  IN RE LEONARD B.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2006-0070
2 CA-JV 2007-0002  MIRAMONTE T. v. ADES, SAM T.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0002
2 CA-JV 2007-0010  MARY L. v. ADES, NAOMI E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0010
2 CA-JV 2007-0014  IN RE MICHELLE G.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0014
Issues Summary: Did the juvenile court abuse its discretion by awarding restitution to a victim over a year after the juvenile’s disposition hearing, when the disposition order did not address the victim’s right to restitution and, although the victim had timely submitted documentation of his restitution request to the prosecutor, the prosecutor failed to file a restitution claim on the victim’s behalf either before or at the disposition hearing?


2 CA-JV 2007-0020  CANDY B. v. ADES, ANJALI B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0020
2 CA-JV 2007-0022  ANGELA S. v. ADES, BRITTNEY S., JOELLE S., WILLIAM S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0022
2 CA-JV 2007-0024  KASSANDRA K. v. ADES, HERARDO O., IZAC O., JOSHUA O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0024
2 CA-JV 2007-0036  IN RE REYMUNDO F.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0036
Issues Summary: Whether Rule 28(C)(7)(a), Ariz. R. P. Juv. Ct., compels the juvenile court to accept the minor’s admission to a delinquency petition immediately when the minor voluntarily admits the allegations at the advisory hearing.


2 CA-JV 2007-0038  VALERIA G. v. ADES, MARIA V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0038
2 CA-JV 2007-0042  IN RE GABRIEL W.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0042
2 CA-JV 2007-0048  IN RE JORGE R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0048
2 CA-JV 2007-0054  DAWN J. v. ADES & KAYLA J., ASHLEY J.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0054
2 CA-JV 2007-0055  ALBERT R., JR. v. ADES & MAXMILLAN R.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0055
2 CA-JV 2007-0056  IN RE DIANA B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0056
2 CA-JV 2007-0064  IN RE MIRALEM S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0064
2 CA-JV 2007-0066  ARMANDO J. v. ADES, MIRIAM J., ARMANDO J., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0066
2 CA-JV 2007-0070  CHRISTOPHER G., SR. v. ADES, CHRISTOPHER G., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0070
2 CA-JV 2007-0074  IN RE VICENTE R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0074
2 CA-JV 2007-0076  AMY A. v. ADES, PATRICK A., VICTORIA A., & ISABELLA A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0076
2 CA-JV 2007-0077  GUADALUPE A. v. ADES, PATRICK A., VICTORIA A. & ISABELLA A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0077
2 CA-JV 2007-0080  STEVE W. v. ADES & MONICA E.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0080
2 CA-JV 2007-0084  JENNIFER G. v. DAVID Q.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0084
2 CA-JV 2007-0090  LYNDA S. v. ADES, CASSIDY R. & NATHAN R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0090
2 CA-JV 2007-0094  FAWN S. v. ADES, LINDA S., STORMY C., RAIN C., & ORION C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0094
2 CA-JV 2007-0095  ANDREW C. v. ADES, STORMY C., RAIN C. & ORION C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0095
2 CA-JV 2007-0100  ELAINE M. v. ADES & ISAIAH M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2007-0100
2 CA-JV 2008-0010  MELISSA H. v. ADES & CRISTIAN G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0010
2 CA-JV 2008-0014  IN RE PATRICK C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0014
2 CA-JV 2008-0023  DAVID H. v. ADES & KELLI H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0023
2 CA-JV 2008-0024  ANDREA B. v. ADES & KELLI H.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0024
2 CA-JV 2008-0026  VERONICA V. v. ADES & SUNSHINE V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0026
2 CA-JV 2008-0030  FAWN S. v. JACK S. and ROBERT S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0030
2 CA-JV 2008-0032  IN RE ANTHONY M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0032
2 CA-JV 2008-0034  KATHRYN B. v. ADES, JOSHUA B., CHARLES B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0034
2 CA-JV 2008-0042  MARCELLA P. v. ADES, MARINA P., JASMINE P., ALICIA I., ADRIAN I.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0042
2 CA-JV 2008-0046  GERARDO R. v. ADES, GUADALUPE R., GERARDO R., JR.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0046
2 CA-JV 2008-0056  KALEB M. v. GREGORY S., MARTHA S., MICHAEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0056
2 CA-JV 2008-0060  IN RE AUSTIN M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0060
2 CA-JV 2008-0062  MISTY G. v. ADES, JADEN W., DESTINY W., ISAIAH G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0062
2 CA-JV 2008-0064  PATRICIA O. v. ADES, ANNA O., ROBERT O.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0064
2 CA-JV 2008-0066  IN RE MANUEL M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0066
2 CA-JV 2008-0068  PATRICIA D. v. ADES, JAVI H., KESHAYNA S., SAMAJI J.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0068
2 CA-JV 2008-0078  IN RE PALMER W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0078
2 CA-JV 2008-0083  IN RE GADN R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0083
2 CA-JV 2008-0090  SHELLY L. v. ADES, NETERU A., YAZMEEN A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0090
2 CA-JV 2008-0096  ERIC. S. v. ADES, MICHAEL K., and CATLIN S.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0096
2 CA-JV 2008-0098  PAMELA B. v. ADES, KIERRA B. and MALACHI B.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0098
2 CA-JV 2008-0100  RYAN W. v. ADES and DAVID W.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0100
2 CA-JV 2008-0104  BERNADETTE L. v. ADES, DANITZA R. and NETANYA M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0104
2 CA-JV 2008-0106  IN RE ADRIANA V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0106
2 CA-JV 2008-0108  KATHLEEN C. v. ADES and BRENNAN A.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0108
2 CA-JV 2008-0114  IN RE ANTHONY M.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0114
2 CA-JV 2008-0118  IN RE DERRICK S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0118
2 CA-JV 2008-0124  IN RE HENRY N.-F.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0124
2 CA-JV 2008-0132  NUBIAN A.-R. v. ADES and PHYAR A.-R.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0132
2 CA-JV 2008-0134  BERNADETTE A. v. ADES and Robert A.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2008-0134
2 CA-JV 2009-0014  DAVID I. v. ADES and ANGEL I.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0014
2 CA-JV 2009-0022  JAN P. v. ADES and ANGELA P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0022
2 CA-JV 2009-0024  WANDA R. v. ADES and JAZMIN C.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0024
2 CA-JV 2009-0032  TIMOTHY P. v. ADES and MONET P.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0032
2 CA-JV 2009-0036  JOYCE S. v. ADES and MARIAH S. and JEREMIAH S.-S.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0036
2 CA-JV 2009-0040  DANNY G. v. ADES and KRISTOFF G.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0040
2 CA-JV 2009-0060  IN RE SAMANTHA L.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0060
2 CA-JV 2009-0074  IN RE JAKE V.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2009-0074
2 CA-MH 2006-0008  IN RE COCHISE COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-200600032  Participating 2 CA-MH 2006-0008
2 CA-MH 2007-0002-SP  IN RE THE DETENTION OF WILFREDO JARAMILLO   Participating 2 CA-MH 2007-0002-SP
Issues Summary: Whether evidence of prior acts is admissible in proceedings under Arizona’s sexually violent person statutes, A.R.S. §§ 36-3701 through 36-3717, if relevant to prove that the respondent has a mental disorder that makes it likely he will engage in future acts of sexual violence.


2 CA-MH 2008-0002  IN RE PIMA COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH 7496-4-08  Participating 2 CA-MH 2008-0002
2 CA-MH 2008-0006  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH-200800068  Participating 2 CA-MH 2008-0006
2 CA-SA 2007-0056  COCHISE COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER v. HON. IRWIN; STATE OF AZ.  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0056
2 CA-SA 2007-0076  CITY OF TUCSON v. FOX; GOODMAN   Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0076
2 CA-SA 2007-0114  RANDOLPH S. BLOOM v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0114
2 CA-SA 2007-0120  MEREDITH WAYNE KELLY, JR. v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2007-0120
2 CA-SA 2008-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAUGHTERS-WHITE  Participating 2 CA-SA 2008-0078
Issues Summary: Whether the respondent judge abused her discretion in ordering the state to produce the software configuration code for the Intoxilyzer 8000, the breath testing equipment used by the Tucson Police Department, to defendants charged with driving with an alcohol concentration of .08 or more, after finding the configuration code was not in the possession of the state or any person under the state’s direction or control.


2 CA-SA 2009-0010  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LELAND FLORENCIO CROCKWELL  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0010
Issues Summary: 1. Does Rule 17.4(f), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and/or Rule 410, Ariz. R. Evid., apply to statements a criminal defendant makes to law enforcement in accordance with a cooperation provision in a plea agreement that the state withdraws when the defendant breaches the agreement by making untruthful statements? Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by prohibiting the state from introducing these statements for all but impeachment purposes? 2. Can a defendant waive the protections of Rule 17.4(f), Ariz. R. Crim. P., and Rule 410, Ariz. R. Evid., and agree the state may use against him statements he made in anticipation of, in connection with, and prior to entering into a plea agreement that is later withdrawn based on the defendant’s breach of the agreement?

3. If a defendant can waive the protection of Rule 17.4(f) and Rule 410 for statements made in connection with a breached plea agreement, did the defendant waive those protections here and did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by prohibiting the state from introducing these statements for all but impeachment purposes?


2 CA-SA 2009-0024  GERARDO LOPEZ v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2009-0024
Issues Summary: After having rejected the defendant’s proposed plea agreement in this case and having previously reviewed an unrelated presentence report about the defendant before sentencing him in an earlier case, did the respondent judge abuse his discretion in denying defendant’s motion for an automatic change of judge pursuant to Rule 17.4(g), Ariz. R. Crim. P.?


Judge William Druke
Please click on the case number in the "Decision" column to view the complete decision.
Case Number Case Title Role Decision
Judge Joseph Howard
Please click on the case number in the "Decision" column to view the complete decision.
Case Number Case Title Role Decision
ASC CV-10-0092-PR  IN RE NICKOLAS S.  Participating ASC CV-10-0092-PR
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 15-507 violate the constitutional guarantee of freedom of speech?
2 CA-CR 2008-0148  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR MONTES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0148
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does Senate Bill 1449, which attempted to make A.R.S. § 13-205(A) retroactively applicable by nullifying our supreme court’s decision in Garcia v. Browning, 214 Ariz. 250, 151 P.3d 533 (2007), violate the separation of powers doctrine?


2 CA-CR 2012-0392  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHEN VINCENT HAVERSTICK  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0392
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: A.R.S. §§ 13-3821(Q) and 12-116.07 impose assessments on convicted sex offenders without regard to the date of the charged offense. Does applying these statutes to offenders convicted of offenses that predate the statutes’ enactment violate either A.R.S. § 1-246 or the ex post facto clauses of the state or federal constitutions?


2 CA-CV 2011-0080  BAKER v. UNIVERSITY PHYSICIANS HEALTHCARE, WITTMAN, ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0080
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in finding A.R.S. § 12-2604 did not permit a specialist in internal medicine with subspecialties in oncology and hematology to testify as to the standard of care for a specialist in pediatrics with a subspecialty in pediatric hematology/oncology? If not, does § 12-2604 violate the Anti-Abrogation, Equal Protection, or Due Process clauses of the Arizona Constitution?


2 CA-JV 2007-0096  MARCO C. v. SEAN C. & COLLEEN C.  Author 2 CA-JV 2007-0096
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the juvenile court abuse its discretion when it concluded that the consent of the appellant was not required for the appellees’ adoption of appellant’s purported biological child because appellant had failed to register timely with the putative father registry in accordance with A.R.S. § 8-106.01 and had not established circumstances set forth in that statute excusing a putative father from registering within thirty days of the child’s birth? Are A.R.S. §§ 8-106 and 8-106.01 generally unconstitutional?


2 CA-MH 2010-0004  IN RE PINAL COUNTY MENTAL HEALTH NO. MH201000076  Author 2 CA-MH 2010-0004
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does the strict application of A.R.S. §§ 36-533(B), 36-539(B), and 36-501(14) conflict with Rules 702 and 703, Ariz. R. Evid., and violate the separation of powers doctrine?


2 CA-CR 2009-0252  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER PUTZI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2009-0252
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Whether Tucson City Code § 11-54, which prohibits public urination, is unconstitutionally vague.


2 CA-CR 2011-0126  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVE FRANK McPHERSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0126
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: (1) When the defendant possessed seven separate images of child pornography on one DVD, did the imposition of seven consecutive, ten-year terms of imprisonment violate constitutional or statutory prohibitions against multiple punishments?

(2) Did the mandatory consecutive sentences required here by A.R.S. § 13-705 amount to cruel and unusual punishment prohibited by article II, § 15 of the Arizona Constitution?

(3) Does § 13-705 violate constitutional guarantees of equal protection by punishing the possession of child pornography more severely than other dangerous crimes against children that are committed directly against children?


2 CA-CR 2011-0169  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NELSON E. NOTTINGHAM  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0169
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: What effect, if any, does Perry v. New Hampshire, ___U.S.___, 132 S. Ct. (2012), have in modifying Arizona Supreme Court jurisprudence addressing (1) whether a defendant is entitled to a Dessureault hearing when the suggestive pretrial identification procedure occurs at a court proceeding and therefore is not arranged by police, and (2) whether a defendant remains entitled to an identification instruction under such circumstances even if not entitled to a Dessureault hearing?


2 CA-CR 2012-0006  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRADY WHITMAN JR.  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0006
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1) Is a criminal defendant’s notice of appeal timely if it is filed within twenty days of the filing of the minute entry that contains the judgment and sentence? 2) When determining the constitutionality of a traffic stop, may a court consider any observed traffic violation as a basis for the stop, or may the court instead consider only those violations that were cited or relied upon by the police officer who performed the stop?


2 CA-CR 2013-0102-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRAIG MICHAEL STEFANOVICH  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0102-PR
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Do previous convictions for driving under the influence within the previous eighty-four months qualify under A.R.S. § 28-1383(A)(2) when those convictions fell outside the sixty-month window in effect at the time of the defendant’s previous convictions and that sixty-month window had elapsed before the statutory amendment changing the window from sixty months to eighty-four months?

2. Did the trial court err in rejecting defendant’s post-conviction-relief claim that his decision to admit previous convictions was not voluntary because he allegedly had not been informed that admitting his previous convictions could result in an enhanced prison term and that the state was required to prove the fact of those convictions?


2 CA-CR 2013-0296  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS UBALDO GONZALEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0296
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did a police officer conduct an investigatory stop by parking his marked patrol car behind a parked vehicle, blocking its exit, when the occupants of the vehicle did not appear to notice or react to the officer’s presence?


2 CA-CR 2013-0315  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID J. WALLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0315
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in denying defendant’s motion to suppress his pretrial statements made prior to and following Miranda advisements on a theory the deputies had conducted a two-stage custodial interrogation prohibited under Missouri v. Seibert, 542 U.S. 600 (2004)?

2. Was it reversible error for the trial court to instruct the jury that it was not required to reach a unanimous verdict on which form of assault, as described by A.R.S. § 13-1203, led to its finding defendant guilty of aggravated assault pursuant to A.R.S. § 13–1204(A)(2)?


2 CA-CV 2011-0088  DOWNING v. DOWNING  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0088
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining A.R.S. § 25-530 precluded it from including appellee’s disability benefits, awarded pursuant to U.S.C. title 38, chapter 11, in its calculation of appellant’s spousal maintenance award? Does A.R.S. § 25-530 violate the Equal Protection clause?


2 CA-CV 2013-0146  CITY OF TUCSON, CITY OF PHOENIX v. STATE OF ARIZONA; KEN BENNETT  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0146
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Whether charter cities can select election dates independent of statewide election dates pursuant to their authority to structure how their governing officers are elected.


2 CA-SA 2010-0074  WILLIAM ALLEN LEAR v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2010-0074
** Constitutionality decision
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 12-2203, which pertains to the admission of expert testimony, conflict with Rule 702, Ariz. R. Evid., and violate the separation of power doctrine, rendering it unconstitutional ?


2 CA-CR 2006-0226  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HIGINIO AGUILAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0226
Issues Summary: Whether the state’s request to use an undisclosed scientific report and to have an undisclosed witness testify during Aguilar’s first trial created manifest necessity requiring a mistrial, so that double jeopardy did not bar his retrial.


2 CA-CR 2010-0106  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NELSON IVAN BOTEO-FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0106
Issues Summary: Whether appellant’s admissions after his de facto arrest were sufficiently an act of free will to purge the primary taint of the illegal arrest and whether the state waived this argument by not raising it below.


2 CA-CR 2010-0310  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE RAYMOND ALVAREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0310
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by excluding third-party culpability evidence concerning a landscaper present in the yard prior to the burglary when the defendant’s DNA was found in the residence after the burglary?


2 CA-CR 2011-0164  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CURTIS T. BUNTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2011-0164
Issues Summary: Does A.R.S. § 13-4505 require a trial court to permit the state's expert to conduct an additional examination of a defendant in a competency proceeding?


2 CA-CR 2012-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REY DAVID VILLEGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0200-PR
Issues Summary: Where the state, the court, and defendant all erroneously believed he would be eligible for earned release credits against a prison term imposed at sentencing, as reflected in his plea agreement, did the trial court abuse its discretion in finding the plea voluntary, notwithstanding the error, or in fashioning resentencing relief, pursuant to Rule 32, Ariz. R. Crim. P., designed to afford defendant “the benefit of his plea bargain as he understood it”?


2 CA-CR 2012-0228  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL ANTONIO PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0228
Issues Summary: Was the trial court required to hold a hearing on the admissibility of polygraph test results pursuant to Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharms., Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993), in light of the 2012 change in Ariz. R. Evid. 702?


2 CA-CR 2012-0296-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE DEJESUS VILLEGAS-ROJAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0296-PR
Issues Summary: Is the name or exact identity of the victim a necessary element of endangerment, as set forth in A.R.S. § 13-1201(A)?


2 CA-CR 2012-0424  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMY KAY GUSTAFSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2012-0424
Issues Summary: For purposes of sentence enhancement under A.R.S. § 13-704, can a stun gun qualify as a dangerous instrument if evidence of the manner in which it was used shows it was “readily capable of causing death or serious physical injury”? A.R.S. § 13-105(12), (13).


2 CA-CR 2013-0134  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MANUEL JESUS PESQUEIRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0134
Issues Summary: 1) If an expert’s testimony is based on non-admissible facts and data pursuant to Rule 703, Ariz. R. Evid., should challenges to that testimony be focused on whether the facts and data are inherently reliable, or whether the expert’s reliance upon those facts and data is reasonable?

2) Is the state required to re-file allegations of dangerousness when it re-files an indictment after voluntarily remanding that indictment to the grand jury for a new determination of probable cause?


2 CA-CR 2013-0206  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CRISPIN GRANADOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0206
Issues Summary: 1) Whether a defendant is entitled to structural error review when, for the first time on appeal, he alleges the trial judge was biased, or created the appearance of bias, based solely on his judicial rulings in the case.

2) Whether a witness’s testimony as to a third-party’s out-of-court statements constitutes hearsay when used to rebut an improper inference created through defense counsel’s cross-examination of that witness.


2 CA-CR 2013-0346  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GREGORY CHARLES RHOME  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0346
Issues Summary: Whether an appellate court can take judicial notice of a fact, for the first time on appeal, which constitutes an element of the offense when the state presented no evidence of that fact during trial.


2 CA-CR 2013-0440  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL ANTHONY FAVELA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0440
Issues Summary: Is expert testimony on latent palm print evidence still admissible under Rule 702, Ariz. R. Evid., after the rule’s change to conform with Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993)?


2 CA-CR 2013-0442  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ESLYN ADRIAN VILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0442
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in instructing the jury on a new lesser-included offense for the first time during jury deliberations?

2) Did the trial court err in failing to provide the parties additional closing arguments after instructing the jury on a new lesser-included offense when the defendant stated he did not want any additional closing arguments?


2 CA-CR 2013-0506-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN RAY LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0506-PR
Issues Summary: In a post-conviction proceeding brought pursuant to Rule 32, Ariz. R. Crim. P., does Stewart v. Smith, 202 Ariz. 446, 46 P.3d 1067 (2002), permit a defendant to raise a claim that would otherwise be barred as untimely by Rule 32.4(a)?


2 CA-CR 2013-0552  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOMINIC RODOLPHO FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2013-0552
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in sentencing the defendant as a repetitive offender pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-703(B)(1) absent an express jury finding that his offenses had not been committed on the same occasion?


2 CA-CR 2014-0240-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN PAUL ROYALTY  Author 2 CA-CR 2014-0240-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in rejecting defendant’s claim counsel had been ineffective in failing to challenge the imposition of an enhanced sentence under A.R.S. § 13-705(P)(1)(g), for dangerous crimes against children under fifteen years of age, when the defendant had printed images of individuals engaged in sexual acts or exploitive exhibitions who were under the age of fifteen when the images were created, but over fifteen when the defendant printed the images?


2 CA-CV 2011-0072  IN RE THE ESTATE OF FRED N. KIRKES  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0072
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by invalidating a beneficiary designation of more than fifty percent of an individual retirement account, reasoning that appellee was entitled to fifty percent as her share of community property?


2 CA-CV 2011-0140  GRUBB v. DO IT BEST CORPORATION  Author 2 CA-CV 2011-0140
Issues Summary: Does a cooperative qualify as a seller for purposes of product liability when a member store ordered the product directly from the vendor in a drop-ship order, but the vendor sent the bill to the cooperative?


2 CA-CV 2012-0093  ARIZONA MEDICAL BUILDINGS, LLC, TRUITT v. CHASM INVESTMENTS, LLC, TRUITT  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0093
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in determining only one of the quitclaim deeds at issue effectively transferred property?

2) Did the trial court err in determining a contract did not exist for the sale of appellant’s medical practice?

3) Did the trial court err in not granting judgment as a matter of law pursuant to Rule 50, Ariz. R. Civ. P., or vacating the verdict pursuant to Rule 59(a)(8), Ariz. R. Civ. P., on appellant’s wrongful filing of a lis pendens claim?

4) Did the trial court give an erroneous jury instruction on appellant’s lis pendens claim?

5) Did the trial court err in denying appellant attorney fees pursuant to contract or A.R.S. § 12-341.01?

6) Did the trial court abuse its discretion by not admitting the affidavits of a witness offered for impeachment?

7) Did the trial court err by awarding damages on appellee’s quiet title claims, and by quieting title to personal property?

8) Did the trial court abuse its discretion by not offsetting appellant’s costs of maintaining the real property against appellee’s award of damages?

9) Did the trial court err in denying appellee attorney fees pursuant to contract or § 12-341.01?


2 CA-CV 2012-0114  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF KASSA  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0114
Issues Summary: Is a special order after judgment sufficient to vest the Court of Appeals with jurisdiction when it does not resolve all issues raised in the post-decree petition or contain certification of finality pursuant to Rule 78(B), Ariz. R. Fam. Law P.?


2 CA-CV 2012-0118  RICE v. BRAKEL, M.D., CENTER FOR NEUROSCIENCES  Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0118
Issues Summary: 1) May a patient sue for medical battery when his surgeon had an undisclosed drug dependency at the time of surgery?

2) Is a surgeon’s own knowledge of his drug dependency imputed to his employer, and, if so, should that constructive knowledge have precluded the entry of summary judgment on appellant’s claim of negligent supervision?

3) Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee on appellant’s tort claims on the ground that appellant failed to adduce evidence to establish the essential elements of his claims?

4) Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee on appellant’s breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing claim on the ground that appellant failed to adduce evidence to establish the essential elements of his claim?


2 CA-CV 2012-0174  MARTHA EQUIHUA v. CARONDELET HEALTH NETWORK, dba CARONDELET ST. MARY’S HOSPITAL   Author 2 CA-CV 2012-0174
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in finding that alleged negligence in monitoring decedent's tube feeding at an acute care hospital was not actionable abuse under the Adult Protective Services Act ("APSA")? 2) Did the trial court err in finding that the wrongful death claim predicated on the APSA claim also failed?


2 CA-CV 2013-0005  FIRST CREDIT UNION v. COURTNEY  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0005
Issues Summary: 1) Does a lender bring an action for a deficiency judgment under A.R.S. § 33-814 prematurely when it has not exhausted all of its collateral?

2) Does A.R.S. § 33-814(G) prevent a creditor from obtaining a deficiency judgment on residential property when the creditor has not conducted a trustee’s sale of the property and creditor’s loan was not a purchase money loan?

3) Does the extinguishment of the principal borrower’s debt under A.R.S. § 33-814(D) preclude recovery against a guarantor when an action was timely maintained against the guarantor under § 33-814(A)?


2 CA-CV 2013-0045  BERGESON v. WEST FRONTIER CONDOMINIUMS HOA, INC., et al.  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0045
Issues Summary: 1) Did the trial court err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee based on its conclusion that the doctrine of issue preclusion barred appellant’s claims from proceeding? 2) If the court erred in granting summary judgment based on issue preclusion, was summary judgment nonetheless appropriate?


2 CA-CV 2013-0062  RASH v. TOWN OF MAMMOTH  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0062
Issues Summary: (1) Do Rule 7, Ariz. R. P. Spec. Actions, A.R.S. § 12-904, or the common law create a time limit for filing statutory special actions pursuant to A.R.S. § 38-1004?

(2) Did the trial court err in ruling the doctrine of laches barred filing a statutory special action pursuant to A.R.S. § 38-1004 in this case?

(3) Due to the pre-filing procedures, did the trial court lack subject matter jurisdiction to hear the statutory special action filed pursuant to A.R.S. § 38-1004?


2 CA-CV 2013-0108  JOHN MUNIC ENTERPRISES, INC. v. LAOS  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0108
Issues Summary: Did the court err in refusing under Rule 60(C)(5), and based on the Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Act, to offset against a judgment for breach of contract and fraud, the amount of a legal malpractice settlement? If so, may the court’s ruling nonetheless be upheld because of the collateral source rule?


2 CA-CV 2013-0117  IN RE INDENTURE OF TRUST DATED JANUARY 13, 1964  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0117
Issues Summary: 1. Did the trial court err in finding that the beneficiary of a spendthrift trust had no standing to file a petition for accounting when the beneficiary had, twelve years prior, assigned his entire interest in the trust?

2. Did the trial court err in awarding the appellees/cross-appellants attorney fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 14-11004(B)?

3. Did the trial court err in awarding the appellees/cross-appellants a lower amount of attorney fees than what they requested?


2 CA-CV 2013-0148  DON C. ROBERTSON, et al. v. ROBERT E. ALLING and JACQUELINE R. ALLING, et al.  Author 2 CA-CV 2013-0148
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by enforcing a settlement agreement under Rule 80(d), Ariz. R. Civ. P., when one of the parties challenged its attorney’s settlement authority?

If the court erred in finding the agreement enforceable pursuant to Rule 80(d), was the agreement still enforceable under the principles of equitable estoppel?


2 CA-SA 2011-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMENEZ; LLINAS; MEDINA; ROGERS; SIRNIO; TANNER   Author 2 CA-SA 2011-0098
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge abuse his discretion by precluding the state from introducing the results of blood alcohol testing in a DUI case after the state failed to produce the results by the time of a rescheduled case management conference?


2 CA-SA 2012-0032  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOEL AGUSTIN LOPEZ   Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0032
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in concluding defendant’s previous conviction for aggravated assault on a police officer was not, based on the elements of the offense, necessarily a violent crime and therefore that the defendant was eligible for probation under A.R.S. § 13-901.01?


2 CA-SA 2012-0044  MIKEL LO, M.D. and MIKEL W. LO, M.D, INC. v. MILLS  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0044
Issues Summary: In plaintiff’s medical malpractice action, did the respondent judge err in determining that plaintiff’s designated standard-of-care expert met the requirements of A.R.S. § 12-2604(A)(1)?


2 CA-SA 2012-0070  ROOSEVELT ARTHUR WILLIAMS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Author 2 CA-SA 2012-0070
Issues Summary: After a hearing conducted in accordance with A.R.S. § 13-753(G), did the respondent judge err or abuse his discretion in ruling that Williams had failed to establish, by clear and convincing evidence, an intellectual disability that renders him ineligible for the death penalty in his pending prosecution for murder?


2 CA-CR 2010-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES DARRELL JOHNSON  Participating 2 CA-CR 2010-0380
Issues Summary: 1. Was there sufficient evidence supporting the jury’s finding the murder was committed in an especially cruel, heinous, or depraved manner? 2. Did the trial court abuse its discretion in precluding Johnson from presenting diminished capacity evidence pursuant to State v. Mott, 187 Ariz. 536, 931 P.2d 1046 (1997), and A.R.S. § 13-502, when that evidence was relevant to rebut the state’s allegation of aggravating factors?


2 CA-CR 2011-0028  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LEE PALMER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0028
Issues Summary: Was testimony regarding a question about the location of defendant’s backpack, asked by an unavailable witness, inadmissible hearsay?


2 CA-CR 2011-0076  STATE OF ARIZONA v. XAVIER HIPOLITO ESTRELLA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0076
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by denying a motion to suppress evidence obtained from a search of a vehicle driven by Estrella and owned by his employer, following the warrantless placement and monitoring of a GPS tracking device on the vehicle?


2 CA-CR 2011-0214  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAIME RENE ESPINOZA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0214
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court abused its discretion in dismissing with prejudice an indictment alleging defendant’s failure to register as a sex offender on the ground that the order first requiring him to register had been void.


2 CA-CR 2011-0244  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY ALAN NUCKOLS  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0244
Issues Summary: When a trial court has imposed a reasonable deadline for submitting restitution requests and supporting documentation, and when a crime victim subsequently fails to comply with this deadline, may the court then deny the victim’s request based on its untimeliness?


2 CA-CR 2011-0252-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL DIAZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0252-PR
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in dismissing with prejudice defendant’s second proceeding for post-conviction relief when counsel failed to timely file a petition through no fault of the defendant?


2 CA-CR 2011-0264  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROHAN LIVINGSTON BUTLER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0264
Issues Summary: 1. Did sufficient evidence exist to convict the defendant of possessing a deadly weapon during a felony drug offense? 2. When a duplicitous indictment alleges three weapons offenses in one count, and when the defendant neither objects to the indictment before trial nor seeks any curative measures during trial, does the defendant suffer prejudice entitling him to relief under fundamental error review? 3. Did the trial court err by admitting a document from an out-of-state sheriff’s department showing the defendant had possessed a large amount of currency within the dates of his alleged drug-trafficking conspiracy? 4. Does an appeal rejecting a codefendant’s argument under Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), establish the law of the case for a defendant bringing a subsequent appeal? If not, has the appellant here established a Batson violation?


2 CA-CR 2011-0384  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARAMA AZIZI MWANDISHI  Participating 2 CA-CR 2011-0384
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by failing to grant the defendant’s motion for a judgment of acquittal in which he argued the state presented evidence only that he had caused a “typical fracture,” asserting that is not sufficient proof of serious physical injury to permit a finding of aggravated assault pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 13-1204(A)(1) and 13-105(39)?


2 CA-CR 2012-0032  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL ANDREW SNIDER  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0032
Issues Summary: (1) Did the state present sufficient evidence that the defendant used or threatened use of force and was armed with a deadly weapon to support two of the armed robbery convictions? (2) Did the trial court err by sentencing defendant to life imprisonment with the possibility of release after twenty-five years under A.R.S. § 13-706(A), when the defendant had no prior convictions and the multiple offenses committed on different occasions were consolidated for trial? (3) Did the trial court err in reducing defendant’s monetary penalties to a criminal restitution order at sentencing and by ordering that “no interest, penalties, or collection fees” would accrue while the defendant was incarcerated?


2 CA-CR 2012-0094  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDALL SHANNON GRAY  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0094
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in denying appellant’s motion for a judgment of acquittal in reliance on the admissions of appellant’s counsel during opening statements?


2 CA-CR 2012-0184  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT FRANCISCO BORQUEZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0184
Issues Summary: (1) Was there sufficient evidence to support the defendant’s conviction for theft by representation, in violation of A.R.S. § 13-1802(A)(3)?

(2) Does § 13-1802(A)(3) require a material misrepresentation to the person who suffered a loss, or is a misrepresentation to a third party that is instrumental in causing the wrongful act sufficient?


2 CA-CR 2012-0214  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS JOHN FELIX  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0214
Issues Summary: Did sufficient evidence support Appellant’s conviction for kidnapping his girlfriend’s son when the jury did not find him guilty of kidnapping his girlfriend?

Do the mitigation provisions of the kidnapping statute, A.R.S. §13-1304(B), which reduce the felony classification if the victim is released unharmed, apply when the victim is under the age of fifteen?


2 CA-CR 2012-0458  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD LOUIS FIGUEROA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2012-0458
2 CA-CR 2013-0018  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANDRES FERNANDO BUELNA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0018
2 CA-CR 2013-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AGUSTIN GONZALEZ GONGORA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0096
Issues Summary: Under the voyeurism statute, A.R.S. § 13-1424, can a person’s privacy be invaded when the person is in a public place and reasonably expects to be viewed by the public, but the defendant views the person in a manner that captures the person’s genitalia, buttock or female breast, whether clothed or unclothed, that is not otherwise visible to the public, such as an “upskirt” viewing?


2 CA-CR 2013-0120-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VAUGHN MILES DENZ  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0120-PR
Issues Summary: 1) Did counsel render ineffective assistance by failing to consult with a medical expert when medical causation was central to liability? 2) Did the trial court err in finding precluded Denz's claim of actual innocence?


2 CA-CR 2013-0164-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO F. GONZALEZ BARRERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0164-PR
2 CA-CR 2013-0194  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT MICHAEL ALLEN  Participating 2 CA-CR 2013-0194
Issues Summary: Did sufficient evidence support the defendant’s conviction for forgery when the facts established the defendant used a false name when he signed a written warning for trespassing issued by a police officer? Did the trial court commit fundamental, prejudicial error by pronouncing sentence in the defendant’s absence after finding the defendant had voluntarily absented himself by walking out of the courtroom during his sentencing hearing?


2 CA-CR 2014-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE ROY VERA  Participating 2 CA-CR 2014-0154-PR
Issues Summary: Whether a trial court’s order granting relief, pursuant to Miller v. Alabama, ___ U.S. ___, 132 S. Ct. 2455 (2012), to a juvenile sentenced to life imprisonment without release for twenty five-years, should be vacated in light of the legislature’s recent action affording such juveniles an opportunity for parole.


2 CA-CV 2011-0012  SANTEE v. MESA AIRLINES, INC.; AMERICA WEST AIRLINES, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0012
Issues Summary: Is a notice of appeal premature and invalid when it is filed before a trial court rules on a motion for sanctions made pursuant to Rule 68(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P.?


2 CA-CV 2011-0020  In re the ESTATE OF FRANCES B. LEWIS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0020
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion under Rules 16(a) and (f), Ariz. R. Civ. P., in sanctioning an out-of-state appellant—specifically, in dismissing his complaint, entering a default judgment against him, and setting aside his objection to the informal probate of a will—on the grounds that (1) the appellant failed to personally attend a pretrial conference and (2) the appellant failed to file a timely reply to appellees’ counterclaims?


2 CA-CV 2011-0108  KAZ CONSTRUCTION, INC v. SIERRA COBRE ESTATES, LLC  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0108
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining a trust beneficiary was without authority to execute a deed of trust conveying the trust res to appellants and, therefore, it was invalid? Did the court err in determining further that appellee had a valid first-position mechanic’s lien on the property?


2 CA-CV 2011-0126  FETTERS v. STEWART TITLE & TRUST OF PHOENIX, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0126
2 CA-CV 2011-0133  METZLER v. BCI COCA-COLA BOTTLING COMPANY OF LOS ANGELES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0133
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in awarding prejudgment interest pursuant to Rule 68(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P., from the date of the offer of judgment to the date of a judgment vacated by the grant of a new trial, rather than to the date of the subsequent judgment on mandate?


2 CA-CV 2011-0134  PATTERSON v. THE ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS  Participating 2 CA-CV 2011-0134
2 CA-CV 2012-0040  MM&A PRODUCTIONS, L.L.C. V. YAVAPAI-APACHE NATION, YAVAPAI-APACHE NATIONS CLIFF CASTLE CASINO, et al  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0040
2 CA-CV 2012-0060  MAHAR v. ACUNA, II  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0060
Issues Summary: In this protective order proceeding, did the trial court abuse its discretion by prohibiting the defendant from possessing firearms in the absence of any showing that he posed a threat to the physical safety of the plaintiff or any other person?


2 CA-CV 2012-0090  CHAMPLIN; STOPINSKI, SKIPTON AND ASSOC. v. BANK OF AMERICA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0090
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err by refusing to set aside the entry of default, pursuant to Rule 55(c), Ariz. R. Civ. P., even if a copy of the application for the entry of default had not been mailed in a timely fashion?


2 CA-CV 2012-0166  BENNETT BLUM, M.D., INC. v. COWAN; LAW OFFICE OF RAND HADDOCK  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0166
Issues Summary: (1) Whether the trial court’s findings of fact and conclusions of law in this breach-of-contract action are supported by the record; (2) whether the trial court erred by precluding appellants from presenting the affirmative defense of breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing; and (3) whether the trial court erred by awarding appellee attorney fees incurred post-judgment.


2 CA-CV 2012-0168  RAY SAYER and KORI SAYER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0168
2 CA-CV 2012-0173  MARISOL METZLER v. BCI COCA-COLA BOTTLING CO. OF LOS ANGELES  Participating 2 CA-CV 2012-0173
Issues Summary: When applying A.R.S. § 44-1201, did the trial court err in determining that prejudgment interest imposed as a sanction under Rule 68(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P., was interest on an obligation calculated at ten percent per annum pursuant to subsection (A) and not interest on a judgment calculated at one percent plus the prime rate pursuant to subsection (B)?


2 CA-CV 2013-0038  IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF SANFORD M. BOLTON  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0038
Issues Summary: 1. Does A.R.S. § 14-3804 require a claimant with a lawsuit pending against the decedent at the time of the decedent’s death, and who sends notice of the claim to the personal representative, to commence another proceeding or move for probate allowance in order to preserve the claim after the personal representative mailed a notice of disallowance of the claim?

2. Did the probate court err in its determination that a claim was barred because no further proceedings were initiated against the estate after the personal representative disallowed a notice of claim, which incorporated the complaint from an ongoing suit against the decedent?


2 CA-CV 2013-0044  SANDRETTO v. PAYSON HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0044
Issues Summary: 1. In this medical malpractice case, did the trial court err in denying a motion for new trial, which included claims the court made several erroneous evidentiary rulings, improperly denied a motion to continue and a motion for judgment as a matter of law, and improperly approved a co-defendant's settlement agreement?

2. Did the trial court err in denying the motion for new trial on the basis that the verdict was supported by substantial evidence and not the result of improper closing arguments?


2 CA-CV 2013-0047  MONROE v. BASIS SCHOOL, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0047
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in determining a charter school has no duty of care to place a school crossing guard at a controlled intersection when the school did not designate the intersection as a school cross-walk?


2 CA-CV 2013-0056  DOUGALL v. DOUGALL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0056
Issues Summary: Whether A.R.S. § 25-530 precludes a trial court from considering veterans’ disability benefits as income in determining the payment of arrearages on an award of spousal maintenance.


2 CA-CV 2013-0086  THE ESTATE OF JOSEFA U. DeCAMACHO v. LA SOLANA CARE AND REHAB, INC.  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0086
Issues Summary: In ordering arbitration of claims brought by the decedent’s estate and survivors, did the trial court err by finding that: 1) a valid and enforceable contract existed between the decedent and La Solana Care and Rehab, Inc., and 2) the contract’s arbitration clause bound the estate and survivors’ claims brought under Arizona’s Adult Protective Services Act and wrongful death statute?


2 CA-CV 2013-0092  IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF CONTRERAS AND BOURKE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0092
2 CA-CV 2013-0100  POTTERS CLAY REALTY, ET AL. v. KUMMER  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0100
2 CA-CV 2013-0120  PARKER, SPRINGER JR., ANDERSON v. COMMITTEE FOR SUSTAINABLE RETIREMENT IN SUPPORT OF INITIATIVE  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0120
Issues Summary: In this election case, the appeal of which is expedited, did the trial court err by: (1) failing as a matter of law to invalidate signatures for the City of Tucson’s Ballot Initiative 2013-I004 that were challenged by appellants on the grounds the signatures were collected by ineligible circulators and/or the signatures were defective; and (2) ordering that the initiative be placed on the City’s November 5, 2013 election ballot. With respect to the cross-appeal, did the court err by: (1) denying appellee/cross-appellant’s motion to dismiss the complaint pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6), Ariz. R. Civ. P., on August 14, 2013; (2) disqualifying certain initiative petition signatures in favor of appellant/cross-appellees.


2 CA-CV 2013-0126  GONZALES v. HOLLEY  Participating 2 CA-CV 2013-0126
2 CA-CV 2014-0004  LEWIS v. DEBORD and NELSON-DEBORD   Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0004
Issues Summary: Whether a judgment creditor may satisfy his or her judgment by executing on the judgment debtor’s real property that was transferred to a subsequent purchaser after recordation of the judgment pursuant to A.R.S. § 33-961(A) but before attachment of the information statement required under A.R.S. §§ 33-961(C) and 33-967(A).


2 CA-CV 2014-0005  ABEL CUELLAR v. MEGAN G. VETTOREL  Participating 2 CA-CV 2014-0005
Issues Summary: When an offer of judgment made pursuant to Rule 68, Ariz. R. Civ. P., is contingent upon the offeree satisfying his medical liens, did the trial court err by not subtracting the amount of the liens from the offer before comparing it to the final judgment for the purpose of awarding sanctions?


2 CA-IC 2011-0014  GARY D. HACKWORTH v. ATLAS COPCO NORTH AMERICA and LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE GROUP  Participating 2 CA-IC 2011-0014
Issues Summary: When an injured worker’s claim for compensation raises a question of medical causation, is a physician’s testimony regarding the possibility of idiopathic causes sufficient to create a conflict in the evidence and rebut the testimony of another physician establishing industrial causation to a reasonable medical probability?


2 CA-IC 2013-0022  CHARLES W. STENZ v. CITY OF TUCSON and PINNACLE RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES  Participating 2 CA-IC 2013-0022
Issues Summary: Was the petitioner entitled to interest on death benefits pursuant to A.R.S. § 23-1046(A) dating from the date the insurer-carrier received notice of her husband’s death until such benefits were awarded by an administrative law judge four years later?


2 CA-JV 2013-0064  KIMBERLY D.-D. v. ADES, K. D., K. D. and K. D.  Participating 2 CA-JV 2013-0064
Issues Summary: When a dependency hearing was held beyond the time limits prescribed by A.R.S. § 8-842, did the trial court err in concluding extraordinary circumstances justified the delay because the state’s attorney was on unforeseen medical leave and no alternate counsel was available?


2 CA-JV 2014-0008  OSCAR F. v. DCS, E.F., M.F, C. F. G.F. and L.F.   Participating 2 CA-JV 2014-0008
Issues Summary: Whether the juvenile court was authorized by statute to adjudicate the children dependent as to the father, notwithstanding unresolved dependency allegations against the mother, who was participating in an in-home intervention at the time of the adjudication.


2 CA-SA 2012-0006  SUSAN SCHEERER v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0006
Issues Summary: In granting the state relief in its appeal from a sentence imposed on petitioner in justice court, did the respondent judge err by ordering that no credit be given against a jail term ordered on resentencing for any period of time appellant spent in an unauthorized home detention program as ordered by the justice court?


2 CA-SA 2012-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ABIGAIL ALETA ALLIN  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0034
2 CA-SA 2012-0052  ARTURO DURAZO v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0052
2 CA-SA 2012-0060  ELIZABETH W. v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0060
Issues Summary: Did the respondent judge have the authority to order a patient undergoing involuntary, court-ordered treatment to submit to drug testing when the patient admitted she had used marijuana in violation of her treatment plan?


2 CA-SA 2012-0076  CALISTO MARIKO WELLS v. STATE OF ARIZONA  Participating 2 CA-SA 2012-0076
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in ordering a defendant to disclose to the state recordings of interviews with police witnesses, conducted without the prosecutor's knowledge, when he intended to use the material solely for impeachment?


2 CA-SA 2013-0020  PARRISH v. PIMA COUNTY  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0020
2 CA-SA 2013-0078  GARY ABEYTA v. SIERRA TUCSON, INC. AND HEIDI SONNTAG  Participating 2 CA-SA 2013-0078
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion in determining a third-party witness had waived the behavioral health professional-patient privilege and, on that basis, deny the witness’s motion for a protective order relating to his counseling records?


2 CA-CR 1995-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKAL OMAR RASUL  Author 2 CA-CR 1995-0014
Issues Summary: 1. Whether, due to his conduct prior to trial, the defendant forfeited his Sixth Amendment right to the assistance of counsel.

2. Whether the defendant’s prior convictions for arson and conspiracy to commit arson occurred on the “same occasion” for purposes of A.R.S. § 13-604(M).


2 CA-CR 2004-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY SHARIFF GAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2004-0306
Issues Summary: 1. Whether, under Illinois v. McArthur, 531 U.S. 326, 121 S. Ct. 946 (2001), and State v. Ault, 150 Ariz. 459, 724 P.2d 545 (1986), exigent circumstances justified a temporary seizure of defendant’s apartment.

2. Whether the trial court erred by concluding the state did not violate Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712 (1986), by exercising peremptory strikes against two African-American prospective jurors.


2 CA-CR 2005-0016  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRAD LEE MONTGOMERY  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0016
2 CA-CR 2005-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHANCE RONALD COLLINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0102
2 CA-CR 2005-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS MANUEL KEIFNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0152
2 CA-CR 2005-0430  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD EDELL WILLIAMS, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0430
2 CA-CR 2005-0432  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN BRADLEY RADY  Author 2 CA-CR 2005-0432
2 CA-CR 2006-0024  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAFAEL REAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0024
Issues Summary: Whether the trial court violated the Sixth Amendment’s Confrontation Clause, as interpreted in Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36, 124 S. Ct. 1354 (2004), when it permitted a police officer who testified to a complete lack of memory to read from his police report at trial.


2 CA-CR 2006-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARD TURNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0046
2 CA-CR 2006-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE RUIZ SANTA CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0074
2 CA-CR 2006-0080  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ROBLES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0080
2 CA-CR 2006-0091  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN RAUL SOTO-FONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0091
2 CA-CR 2006-0110-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM KENNETH STILLWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0110-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0118-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMINADAB ORDUNO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0118-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FERNANDO RAY LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0122
2 CA-CR 2006-0126-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGELIO SALAZAR GASTELUM  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0126-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0132-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JIMMIE LYNN LUCAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0132-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINO DE LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0140
2 CA-CR 2006-0144  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTIAN JAY OGG  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0144
2 CA-CR 2006-0146  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESLEY TODD WICKHAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0146
2 CA-CR 2006-0152  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEREMY D. HICKLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0152
2 CA-CR 2006-0156-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID ALLEN WATTERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0156-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN ANDREW VILLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0158
2 CA-CR 2006-0180  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RODRICK WADE HIGH-ELK  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0180
2 CA-CR 2006-0184-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SELENA ALICIA CORONADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0184-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0198  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD MATHIEU SALMOND  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0198
2 CA-CR 2006-0202-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL VIRAMONTES  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0202-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS CHARLES HENRY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0208
2 CA-CR 2006-0216  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KELLEY DIANNA TILLEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0216
2 CA-CR 2006-0264-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEROY GILBERT  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0264-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0270
2 CA-CR 2006-0276  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY LEE RAY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0276
2 CA-CR 2006-0286  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN DEVONN WHITELOW  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0286
2 CA-CR 2006-0294  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE SANTOS ARTIAGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0294
2 CA-CR 2006-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THOMAS EUGENE WAITE  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0300
2 CA-CR 2006-0304-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL MARCUS WALTERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0304-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL MARTIN-SANCHEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0314
2 CA-CR 2006-0316-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD FENLEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0316-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0338-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY PAUL RAMIREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0338-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN EARL MITCHELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0348
2 CA-CR 2006-0350  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN FRANCES GARDNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0350
2 CA-CR 2006-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LARRY GENE GEORGESON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0372
2 CA-CR 2006-0374-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD FISHER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0374-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEFFREY TYSON CURTIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0376
2 CA-CR 2006-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAMIAN EARL MITCHELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0380
2 CA-CR 2006-0400  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL MEJIAS MONDESI  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0400
2 CA-CR 2006-0408  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADERSON MELRON GOOLSBY  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0408
2 CA-CR 2006-0418  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAUDIO VALDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0418
2 CA-CR 2006-0422  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL L. McALEE, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0422
2 CA-CR 2006-0424  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DEQUAUN McLEAN, aka DEQUAN McLEAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0424
2 CA-CR 2006-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WENDY SUE ANDERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0428-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PIERRE BAKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0428-PR
2 CA-CR 2006-0436  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SAMUEL ANTONIO PARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0436
2 CA-CR 2006-0441  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REGINALDO OCANO MOLINA  Author 2 CA-CR 2006-0441
2 CA-CR 2007-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS ALLEN MCCONNELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0004
2 CA-CR 2007-0014-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARTIN SERRANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0014-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0020  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SERGIO ALONZO RUBIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0020
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant must use an available peremptory strike to cure the trial court’s alleged error in denying a challenge for cause, or waive the right to raise that error on appeal.


2 CA-CR 2007-0024-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCOS TELLEZ POBLETE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0024-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JANELLE SHAELENE FRYER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0026
2 CA-CR 2007-0040-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANCISCO LAZARO GONZALEZ, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0040-PR
Issues Summary: May a defendant who has been convicted of attempted sexual conduct with an eleven-year-old victim properly be sentenced pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-604.01 for a dangerous crime against children?


2 CA-CR 2007-0062  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLENN RAY PAXTON, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0062
2 CA-CR 2007-0072  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DAVID WINDHORST  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0072
2 CA-CR 2007-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SHAWN DE NEAN EDMISTEN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0074
Issues Summary: When a defendant presents evidence of involuntary intoxication in an attempt to negate the culpable mental state for the offenses charged, does the burden of proof shift from the state to the defendant?


2 CA-CR 2007-0084-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHARLES ALLEN HILLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0084-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0086  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON KEITH CAMPBELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0086
2 CA-CR 2007-0090-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN DANIEL TAYLOR  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0090-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0100-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWARD LOPEZ DE LA CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0100-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0102  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD RAYMOND TURNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0102
2 CA-CR 2007-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL PATRICK MOYNIHAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0112
2 CA-CR 2007-0118  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD R. PALMER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0118
2 CA-CR 2007-0132  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAGE GRAINGER STUART  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0132
2 CA-CR 2007-0142-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE EDUVIJES BEJARANO, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0142-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0148-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEXANDER GEORGE KISS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0148-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0150  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSICA MARIE VASS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0150
2 CA-CR 2007-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GARY EUGENE YODER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0154-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0170  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LEONARDO FRANCISCO AMADO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0170
2 CA-CR 2007-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCUS EUGENE HUNLEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0176
2 CA-CR 2007-0178  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KENYA ZANZIBAR TOUSSAINT  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0178
2 CA-CR 2007-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN RICHARD PIPER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0186
2 CA-CR 2007-0192  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROGER DALE TARKINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0192
Issues Summary: Whether a defendant may challenge a search on Fourth Amendment grounds based on his property interest in the item seized even though he has no legitimate expectation of privacy in the premises searched.


2 CA-CR 2007-0196-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL RAYMOND MEZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0196-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0202  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS ALBERTO MORENO-MEDRANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0202
Issues Summary: 1. Whether the trial court fundamentally erred in failing to make required findings before imposing fees pursuant to A.R.S. § 11-584 and Rule 6.7(d), Ariz. R. Crim. P.

2. Whether the trial court fundamentally erred in reducing indigent defense fees to a criminal restitution order at sentencing.


2 CA-CR 2007-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAKI DAVID PRICE  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0210
Issues Summary: 1. Whether convictions for both aggravated assault and armed robbery violated double jeopardy principles.

2. Whether trial to an eight-person jury constituted fundamental error.


2 CA-CR 2007-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSIE LABRANNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO VARGAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARCELO PEREZ MUNGUIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0222
2 CA-CR 2007-0230  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ALLAN SHANNON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0230
2 CA-CR 2007-0233  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAY BERNARD GILLILLAND  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0233
2 CA-CR 2007-0238  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE MENDOZA HERRERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0238
2 CA-CR 2007-0242-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY FRANCIS HENRY  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0242-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0270  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY LEE LINDSAY, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0270
2 CA-CR 2007-0280  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY BERNARD ENGEBRETSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0280
2 CA-CR 2007-0286-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL KEVIN BLACKSTOCK  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0286-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0288  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CESAR TAPIA HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0288
2 CA-CR 2007-0294-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGEL MENDOZA LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0294-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0300  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE RENEE LOPER  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0300
2 CA-CR 2007-0306  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS SERRANO SAMANIEGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0306
2 CA-CR 2007-0308  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL A. WELCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0308
2 CA-CR 2007-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS PAUL PHILLIPS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0320
2 CA-CR 2007-0334  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS RAUL LEON FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0334
2 CA-CR 2007-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARK ANTHONY LUGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0336-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN CASTRO ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0374
2 CA-CR 2007-0376  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WALTER THOMAS WARD  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0376
2 CA-CR 2007-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELODY LYNN DAVIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0380
2 CA-CR 2007-0388  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DOUGLAS ELAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0388
2 CA-CR 2007-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LUIS MARTIN SANDOVAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0390
2 CA-CR 2007-0400-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JEROME EDWIN ARNOLDI, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0400-PR
2 CA-CR 2007-0408  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHANIEL KEON CURTIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2007-0408
2 CA-CR 2008-0002  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HECTOR RODRIGUEZ RUIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0002
2 CA-CR 2008-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DALE HUNTINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0004
2 CA-CR 2008-0012-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN PIERRE BAKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0012-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0016  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON MARTIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0016
2 CA-CR 2008-0018-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRED WILLIAM ANDREWS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0018-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0022-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES E. COLLINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0022-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0026  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RENARD REED III  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0026
2 CA-CR 2008-0038  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSIE JAMES ROBINSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0038
2 CA-CR 2008-0042-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TERRY MICHAEL MILLER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0042-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESUS DAVID LOPEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0046
2 CA-CR 2008-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JERRY DON BRYANT  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0058
Issues Summary: Did the trial court err in modifying an illegally lenient sentence when the state did not appeal the sentence but instead filed a motion for reconsideration after the time for appeal had run?


2 CA-CR 2008-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL ANGEL ZEBADUA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0074
2 CA-CR 2008-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSE JAMES THOMAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0078
2 CA-CR 2008-0082  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHANIE HOLFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0082
2 CA-CR 2008-0086-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID REY SANTILLANO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0086-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE ALCANTAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0108-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0138-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FEDERICO AROS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0138-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0162-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIAM CHAPMAN MACH  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0162-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0168  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFREDO J. GALAZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0168
2 CA-CR 2008-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE TASHQUINTH, SR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0172
2 CA-CR 2008-0182  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WILLIAM STENZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0182
2 CA-CR 2008-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID G. MILLS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0208  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN WESLEY HOWARD, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0208
2 CA-CR 2008-0210  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JESSICA NOEL DEPINA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0210
2 CA-CR 2008-0214-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BILLY GENE CUMMINGS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0214-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDWIN ANTHONY PELLECIER  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0216-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARON SYLVESTER GREEN II  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0228  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES RANDALL HALSTEAD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0228
2 CA-CR 2008-0240  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAVIER FIMBRES  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0240
Issues Summary: When a defendant is indicted under one subsection of a statute, is the trial court’s subject matter jurisdiction implicated when it subsequently instructs the jury on multiple subsections of the same statute?


2 CA-CR 2008-0246  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRETT ALLEN BELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0246
2 CA-CR 2008-0254  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HENRY ALEXANDER CONGRESS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0254
2 CA-CR 2008-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRICE LOOBY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0256
2 CA-CR 2008-0265  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LAWRENCE CALVIN HURSEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0265
2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHESTER LEON AXSOM, II  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0268-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEVEN WILDMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0292-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0294  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANNY LOUIS MUSGROVE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0294
Issues Summary: Does double jeopardy attach when a trial judge grants a judgment of acquittal and, after continuing discussion, reconsiders, denies the motion and allows the charge to go to the jury?


2 CA-CR 2008-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DONALD ALLEN GUADAGNI  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0314
2 CA-CR 2008-0316  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDGAR TRAVIS CROSS  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0316
2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RENIE VARELA VALENCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0318-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0320  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KELVIN JEROME HOUSTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0320
2 CA-CR 2008-0328  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DENNIS ASHTON CRAWFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0328
2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. SILVIA ESTRELLA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0332-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHMOND OWEN CLARK  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0334-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0336  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CURT ANDREW RICCI  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0336
2 CA-CR 2008-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TRAVIS SCOTT BELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0338
2 CA-CR 2008-0347  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANGELICA MELISSA LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0347
2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARYANNE CHISHOLM  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0356-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE YSIDRO SPERLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0358-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DARRON CAMPBELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0359-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OLSIE COLSTON, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0366-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0368  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN DANIEL VAUGHN  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0368
2 CA-CR 2008-0372  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DUSTIN ANTHONY ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0372
2 CA-CR 2008-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WILLIE JOE BELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0374
2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MELVIN STANDISH WOPSCHALL  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0380-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ALFREDO PERALTA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0382-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0389  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO GUARDADO-SOLORIO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0389
2 CA-CR 2008-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY GABRIEL PESQUEIRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0390
2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EARL F. CRAGO  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0396-PR
2 CA-CR 2008-0412  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RANDY MICHAEL GARCIA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0412
2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL MARIO CASTANEDA  Author 2 CA-CR 2008-0426-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RONNIE L. TURNER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0008-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUAN FRANCISCO MANRIQUEZ-VIZCARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0014
2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY BELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0016-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0022  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CLAY NELSON HULL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0022
2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PAUL DAVID RICHARDSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0026-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0030  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ALEJANDRO FRASQUILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0030
2 CA-CR 2009-0034  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT ERIC HAYES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0034
2 CA-CR 2009-0036  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY JOSEPH TOMASZEWSKI  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0036
2 CA-CR 2009-0046  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALFRED ALEXANDER LAMADRID  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0046
2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANELL McALISTER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0054-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0060-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ACENCION LEON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0060-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0064  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYALLEN HERNANDEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0064
2 CA-CR 2009-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHNNY RAY FIGUEROA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0068
2 CA-CR 2009-0072-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. TIMOTHY PHILLIP PENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0072-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0074  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GENARO LOPEZ MADUENA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0074
2 CA-CR 2009-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIKE ALLEN SCHOMISCH  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0096
2 CA-CR 2009-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. HUBERT WASHINGTON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0098
2 CA-CR 2009-0110  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CASSIUS CLAYTON WHITEHEAD  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0110
2 CA-CR 2009-0114  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MIGUEL DANIEL LEAL  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0114
2 CA-CR 2009-0122  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OSCAR SAINZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0122
2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GRANVILLE JACKSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0124-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0130  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL RAY LYNAM  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0130
2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ANTHONY TERRELL THOMPSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0136-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0138  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MILES L. KAUFMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0138
2 CA-CR 2009-0142  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FABIAN GARCIA-NAVARRO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0142
Issues Summary: Does driving at a high rate of speed and almost colliding with another car constitute a breach of the peace sufficient to permit a federal border patrol agent to make a citizen’s arrest pursuant to A.R.S. § 13-3884?


2 CA-CR 2009-0146-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. OMAR GUADALUPE PEREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0146-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0150  STATE OF ARIZONA v. REBECCA SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0150
2 CA-CR 2009-0154-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. WESTLEY NAT LEWIS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0154-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0156  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GERMAN SALAZAR MORALES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0156
2 CA-CR 2009-0166  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACOB MICHAEL AGUILAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0166
2 CA-CR 2009-0172  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHELLE D. SPRANG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0172
Issues Summary: Did the trial court abuse its discretion by instructing the jury on second-degree murder when all the evidence supported a finding of premeditation, and, if so, was the error harmless? When the defendant was acquitted of first-degree murder by the jury and when the appellate court has vacated the defendant’s conviction for the lesser-included crime of second-degree murder, has double jeopardy attached to the second-degree murder charge?


2 CA-CR 2009-0186  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID YULO MARTINEZ III  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0186
2 CA-CR 2009-0188  STATE OF ARIZONA v. THADDEUS IKOSY'S CRAWFORD  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0188
2 CA-CR 2009-0190-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSHUA AGUILERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0190-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0192-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JAMES ANTHONY STAPLES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0192-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0197  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER RUSSELL REEDER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0197
2 CA-CR 2009-0198  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MARSHALL EARL THOMPSON II  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0198
2 CA-CR 2009-0200-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JUNIES ALBERRY JENKINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0200-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0220-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRAD LEE MONTGOMERY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0220-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0222  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE ARMANDO PARRA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0222
2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT BURRELL RICO, JR.  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0230-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0240-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALONZO JAMERSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0240-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0244-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERVIN ALAN MOORE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0244-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0256  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RUDY ALFRED APELT  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0256
2 CA-CR 2009-0260  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSE DE JESUS ORTIZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0260
2 CA-CR 2009-0262  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RALPH THOMAS JESSUP  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0262
2 CA-CR 2009-0266-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RAYMOND Q. GAITAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0266-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0268-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ADAM BUSTOS RAMOS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0268-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0270-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DIANE CRUZ RIVERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0270-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0308  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER SCOTT DECAIRE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0308
2 CA-CR 2009-0312-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KETTISHA JONES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0312-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0314  STATE OF ARIZONA v. LOUIS RAY MARTINEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0314
2 CA-CR 2009-0318  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JORGE JESUS CORTEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0318
2 CA-CR 2009-0320-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN LEE JUSTIN LONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0320-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0323-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. FRANKLYN EDWARD CAIN  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0323-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0324-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DAVID MICHAEL COOK  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0324-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0330-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERTA R. CAMACHO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0330-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0332  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MICHAEL GUTIERREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0332
2 CA-CR 2009-0336-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRIAN BENJAMIN BARRAZA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0336-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0338  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC THORIN PEELER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0338
2 CA-CR 2009-0340-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL S. LIEVERS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0340-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0346-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOE ANTHONY LUNA  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0346-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0348  STATE OF ARIZONA v. AMOS WESTLEY WILSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0348
2 CA-CR 2009-0368-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BARRY JAYE WADE  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0368-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0374  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROBERT DALE HIGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0374
2 CA-CR 2009-0376-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GLEN ALAN HUGGINS  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0376-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0380  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ERIC SMITH  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0380
2 CA-CR 2009-0382  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KARL ANTHONY MACKEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0382
2 CA-CR 2009-0386-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KAJORNSAK PRASERTPHONG  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0386-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0390  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CHRISTOPHER ANTHONY TRUJILLO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0390
2 CA-CR 2009-0404-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. BRYAN LAMAR BOOKER  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0404-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0406-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL MERINO  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0406-PR
2 CA-CR 2009-0408-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DANIEL MERCED FLORES  Author 2 CA-CR 2009-0408-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0004  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NATHAN DOUGLAS KINNEY  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0004
Issues Summary: Did officers illegally detain defendant when they no longer had reasonable suspicion that he was wanted in connection with an arrest warrant? If so, were defendant’s subsequent statements tainted by the illegal detention, and if they were, did the trial court commit fundamental error in admitting the statements? If it did, was there sufficient evidence to sustain the conviction in the absence of the statements?


2 CA-CR 2010-0006  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD LIN GARRISON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0006
2 CA-CR 2010-0012  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JON EDWARD ERICKSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0012
2 CA-CR 2010-0014  STATE OF ARIZONA v. STEPHANIE DAWN RAMIREZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0014
2 CA-CR 2010-0020-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. EDDIE ORLANDO SANTA CRUZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0020-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0030-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN EDWARD SZABO  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0030-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0032-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. RICHARD RAYMOND LANE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0032-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0034-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN EUGENE CRAIG  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0034-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0040  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ROY IRVIN WEEAST  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0040
2 CA-CR 2010-0042  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JACK OWENS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0042
2 CA-CR 2010-0058  STATE OF ARIZONA v. DOUGLAS BANKS LESLIE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0058
2 CA-CR 2010-0068  STATE OF ARIZONA v. ALEJANDRO MIGUEL GIBSON  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0068
2 CA-CR 2010-0078  STATE OF ARIZONA v. PERLA LIZABETH CONTRERAS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0078
2 CA-CR 2010-0082-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CORY LAMONT HOLLEMAN  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0082-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0083-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOSEPH SAMUEL GARFIELD  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0083-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0096  STATE OF ARIZONA v. KEVIN JOSEPH RUHL  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0096
2 CA-CR 2010-0098  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GABRIEL IGNACIO SALAZAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0098
2 CA-CR 2010-0112  STATE OF ARIZONA v. NOA SALAZAR  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0112
2 CA-CR 2010-0131  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MODESTO GUILLEN, III  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0131
2 CA-CR 2010-0139  STATE OF ARIZONA v. VINCENT ALPHONSO POWELL  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0139
2 CA-CR 2010-0140  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARLOS ENRIQUE NUNEZ  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0140
2 CA-CR 2010-0144-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. GEORGE HUMBERTO VEGA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0144-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0150-PR  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MONDRE KAMONIE BELLE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0150-PR
2 CA-CR 2010-0158  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN ANTHONY MATUS  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0158
2 CA-CR 2010-0162  STATE OF ARIZONA v. CARL EDWARD LANE  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0162
2 CA-CR 2010-0163  STATE OF ARIZONA v. JOHN MICHAEL ROSSI  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0163
2 CA-CR 2010-0170  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL HAYES NASTIUK  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0170
2 CA-CR 2010-0176  STATE OF ARIZONA v. MICHAEL LORENZO RIVERA  Author 2 CA-CR 2010-0176
Issues Summary: 1. Does a jury instruction implicitly amend the indictment when it uses the more expansive language of the statute rather than the more tailored language in the indictment?

2. Was there sufficient evidence to support convictions for endangerment by threat of imminent death when some of the victims may have been in an interior room of the house but the bullets, shot from outside the house, had the capability of penetrating several layers of wall?